DramaQ05

7.5/10 for BoatOat

6/10 for Mark Pakin.

I really like this Naoki, he's not emotionless or rude like the other versions. as for this Kotoko i like her too, she's not stupid or completely useless like the 2010/2013 Kotoko.

Dropped after ML tries to kill FL.

6/10
Great chemistry between the leads but the second half became slow and draggy.

1.5/10 for the theme song and Kimura Takuya.

The ML is so unlikable and doesn't have any attractive quality, i don't understand why everyone kept falling for him. He's such a red flag🚩🚩🚩and i guess the three friends really like to suffer.
the SML however is such a gentleman, the FL is dumb for not choosing him.

I like the chemistry between FM and SML.
The love between ML and FL is not convincing, she just seems to do everything out of pity.

1/10
Unlike the 2008 version the ML in this version doesn't look like he regret what he did to her, which make the happy ending even more disturbing.

Stupid woman
Now she's stuck with her abusive ex forever

Overrated
The ML is very unlikable

One of the worst romance dramas of all time.
he cheated, I wish they added more episodes for his redemption, I wasn't convinced that he actually likes her, it was like he was forced to. and I can't blame him, FL was immature, irresponsible, possessive, and obnoxious.

It's basically "Tokyo Love Story" but with even more unlikable characters and a happy ending.

7/10 for FirstKhaotung

8/10
DaoMingSi and ShanCai have mature romantic chemistry with sexual tension that couples in other versions don't have, even though they were always fighting, I could still tell that they love each other.