Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo

FL has no morals

This show is basically a korean remake of the hit chinese show Bu Bu Jing Xin, so nothing groundbreaking about the plot. BUT in the first 5 eps the FL basically is openly flirting with her cousin's husband while her cousin is on her deathbed. AND the cousin is supposedly ok with it and gives them her blessing to have a relationship with each other. like what the HELL??? nawwwwww. even if the FL did not end up with the guy in the end i just.... couldn't empathize with the FL anymore after that. so i dropped it. i just can't fathom how anyone can feel for the FL after this.

Read More

Well known doesn't always mean you can't endure the heart ache

You need a stout heart to watch this one, and I barely managed it. As one of over 50k subscribers harassing Viki to get this drama back for viewing, I was determined to see it through. I'm not disappointed to check it off my "must watch" list. But goodness gracious me, it was a bitter journey. Frankly, if Viki didn't limit it to 5 episodes each week, I might have ruined myself. It took about a week to recover after watch each 5 episodes.

Definitely one of the best dramas‼️ The soundtrack was too good. And the choice of cast actors was Directed in an exemplary manner from start to finish. The costumes were beautiful, but some wigs were really terrible distractions. The story was great fantasy but heart rending from beginning to end. And the end was disappointing. Now I understand why so many people have spent years crying for the second season. But too many years have passed.

While I highly recommend it as HIGH quality, not everyone can endure the ultimately sad journey of such wonderfully crafted characters. So in the world of Korean Dramas, this one is definitely a 10⭐️. But in the heart of this viewer, the end didn't satisfy. And as a person who loves a happy ending and can accept well written sad endings - I simply cannot endure ambiguous holes for an ending.

Read More

BE PREPARED

I watched Moonlovers in 2018 and when I reopened my dramatist account I realized it's also my profile pic, so given the fact that I also did a rewatch I need to review this drama.

Also I was very not surprised by seeing that the reviews for Moon Lovers are either a 10/10 or a 4/10, cause this drama is a all in or not, I recommend to not drop it after the few first episodes cause the drama hits in the middle in my opinion.

So Moon Lovers is on my top five of fav dramas and that because it was a really heart wrenching story that literally made me binge watch the whole thing in two days and i could rewatch it again till 6 year later this year, if you don't like historical dramas try it, if you like enemies to lovers try it, if you like obsessed kind of love try it, however if you are not ready to suffer don't do that.
chemistry 10/10, I do believed they loved each other in real life.
music is still engraved in my memory.
The cast is sooo rich and on point.
i recommend this drama I need to share this suffering with more people!

Read More

Best Historical Drama Ever

Story: Scarlet Heart Moon Lovers has one of the most appealing stories that keeps you hooked the whole way through out of any historical k-drama I have ever watched. I am NEVER bored no matter how many times I rewatch it (and I rewatch it a lot). The palace intrigue, the romance, and it is fairly mature considering it is a k-drama.

Acting: Lee Joong Gi and Kang Haneul are masters of their craft, and although this is one of IU's weaker dramas in terms of acting I think she still does an incredible job. She is so capable of making Hae Su's joy, fear, and sorrow come accross. All of the supporting cast also does a great job- BaekHyun and Kim Ji Soo often steal the show.

One of my favorite, if not my favorite drama of all time. Worth a watch 100%

Read More

Tragic, memorable, and sometimes frustrating

Watching this drama for the first time in 2024 made me appreciate how far k-dramas have come in terms of production, costumes, and picture quality in the last several years. I won't judge harshly based on those factors because this show is obviously dated, but, ugly costumes with atrocious color combinations and poor set design are hard to ignore. This is not to mention that a palace, that is supposed to be bustling with activity, looks like a ghost town. There are no maids, eunuchs, or guards anywhere in the courtyard. For such a large production, this is rather odd.

"Moon Lovers" is very well rounded in terms of pacing, storytelling, and character development. The plot is engaging and the pacing is consistent from start to finish. One thing I like is that it does not fixate on one relationship over another. We don't have to sit through a dozen of episodes of Wang Wook and Hue Soo's failed romance while other princes are patiently waiting their turn. Soo's relationship with each prince is uniquely developed from the beginning of the story. So, before the Wang Wook romance arc ends, the writers already give us plenty of meaningful scenes with Wang So and his growing feelings for her. The icing on the cake is Lee Joon Gi's masterful use of facial expressions showing Wang So hopelessly falling in love with her.

Wang So is probably one of the most tragic and misunderstood protagonists in a k-drama. Mysterious and brooding, he looks like he stepped right out of the Phantom of the Opera wearing a mask to cover a face scar. But, under the mask, he is an extremely complex character. The drama relays that complexity rather well through his contentious relationship with his mother, Queen Yoo, giving us a glimpse into his tragic past full of abuse and abandonment, and the man he has become - still a confused and heartbroken kid longing for his mother's love. The most tragic thing about him is that he does not do anything wrong but is forced to make difficult decisions. But despite all that, he is always judged harshly by everyone he cares about who eventually leave him. I don't really understand the point of writing such a tragic character. Tragedy is ok, but Wang So has no hope and nothing to look forward to. He is always alone from the very beginning until the end. Even an opportunity to raise his daughter is unfairly taken away from him.

I liked Hae Soo at the beginning. But, as soon as the drama starts turning into a Shakespearean tragedy, I became extremely disappointed in her. On one hand, she is kind, intelligent, thoughtful, and ridiculously courageous. On the other hand, she is naive, shallow, and judgmental. She accepts So's choice to seek the throne, but never understands the reality of being a king and the responsibilities that come with it. Instead of trusting him with his decisions, she keeps holding on to the unattainable and childish dream of being able to be together if they love each other while judging him for being harsh against the people who seek to harm him. The most tragic and unforgivable thing she does is making no effort to explain to So that her love for Wook was a thing of the past making their last face-to-face encounter filled with resentment and heartbreak.

Some plotlines are poorly thought out and very illogical. Wang So is not stupid, but his complete lack of insight when he rips up King Moo's last decree and leaves it on the floor as evidence is mind boggling. And then there is Prince Yo getting thrown off a cliff then returning in one piece. The writers needed something to move the plot forward, but this type of nonsensical writing makes smart characters look stupid.

The romance is very different from anything I've seen in a k-drama. This is not a typical star crossed lovers or a tragic romance story. The plot takes a rather realistic view of relationships. We all experience bad timing, missed opportunities, and inability to cope with each other's character flaws. This drama paints a harsh picture of what happens when couples go through all that. No matter how much we want it, love is not always enough. Lack of trust, miscommunication, and resentment all play a big part in the main couple's separation leading to loneliness and a lot of regret.

The ending, although tragic, is somewhat open-ended. She says "if we met in another world, at another time, we would have been great together". He says "if you and I are not from the same world, I will find you." These phrases alone are enough to foreshadow a future reunion. But, until there is a sequel, all we can do is resort to writing fanfiction and pretending they have a happy ending 1000 years later.

Read More

Scarlet heart made our heart broken

This drama is another masterpiece for sageuk lovers but with a painful,unforgettable end, i can't bring myself to express my feelings and to say that i have been crying until now, that feeling when you are left alone, when the person you love die while you was ignoring him out of jealousy and hate although his actions were for your sake, your brothers are apart of you, when your mother touched your face tenderly while she was passing away for the first time in your youthful life, when you rised to the glory but lost everything in fact, what does the throne mean for you now? That bloody seat you gained to have everything you desire made you lose everything. A great compassion from me to gyeonjong, that poorly king who was treated like an animal but proved up to everyone his legacy as a king who ruled for 25 years but with a scarred heart, with an harrowing loneliness and grievance. Lee joon ki( as always marvelous)portrayed this character with a great virtue and an awesome grinta,IU also did an amazing job although her character was the time-bomber which shredded the princes to fight each another as go ha jin because the real hae soo wasn't as interactive,curious,energetic as her(as mentioned in the plot).
The cruel screenwriter made our hearts to ache and obliged us not to forget this drama easily keeping the yearning and the emotions floating, i hope they create a happy ending out from many sad moments next time better than making it unhappier and somber for the viewers.

Read More

What makes Moon Lovers special isn't its perfect story, but its powerful emotions. Wang So and Hae Soo's relationship feels like a beautiful yet painful love story.

And honestly, after watching this drama, the OST songs can immediately transport viewers back to their scenes. 😭🌙

Despite my high rating, this drama isn't without its flaws.
Some conflicts feel overly long and full of misunderstandings. There are also some character decisions that might make viewers think

"Why didn't they just talk about it?" 😭

Additionally, since there are quite a lot of princes, at the beginning of the drama it might be a bit difficult to remember who is Wang Wook, Wang Jung, Wang Eun, Wang Yo, and the others.

But as the story progresses, the characters become more distinguishable.

Read More

I love this drama so much, I enjoy it and hopefully there will be season two, made up and put more the issue and dramatic story, just do something a little bit different from SHR season 2 chinese version.. just add more plot so it wont be boring but must relate with the season 1 a little bit, hahah this would be difficult but I believe if the director and PD work well in producing beautiful story line of this drama.

Somehow I feel there's no need for season 2 if the story line are going to be suck. just leave it as melodramatic that left people touched and appreciate this historical drama.
But you will miss the chance and challenge to produce season 2..
Well I do challenge and would like to see how SBS would handle this

Read More