Tout ce que nous avons aimé (2023)

Rien de nouveau...

Peut-être que mes 14 ans d'ancienneté y seraient pour quelque chose. Peut-être suis-je devenue plus exigeante. J'avoue devenir un peu plus blasée et avoir un regard moins complaisant. D'où ma critique peut-être sévère.

Le scénario ici n'apporte rien de nouveau, un "triangle amoureux" qui malheureusement sera juste effleuré et dont notre intérêt ne sera jamais titillé à l'extrême. Pour ceux qui ont déjà suivit (avidement) "Reply 1987", le concept y ressemble un tout petit peu. Un bond dans le présent avec un "mystère" planant sur l'adulte que nous avons sous les yeux, jouant avec des indices afin de nous obliger à nous demander "mais qui finit donc avec elle? " nous renoue avec le principe de "Reply 1987" mais sans l'ingéniosité et la beauté de ce dernier. Le protagoniste présenté en 2023 est volontairement brossé comme un portrait de l'un, que cela soit physiquement ou au niveau de l'attitude, avec des indices intentionnellement vagues sur l'identité réel de ce dernier. Le dialogue entre lui et Han So Yeon est aussi volontairement biaisé afin de nous perdre, et cela fonctionne bien, car au bout d'un épisode, je n'avais plus envie d'en savoir plus. Les personnages 2023 n'avaient plus aucune ressemblance avec leur eux de 2006, plus aucun trait physique, plus aucune mimique nous permettant de nous rapprocher des ados qu'ils étaient, plus aucun trait de caractère similaire.... Certes, devenant adultes, nous changeons, c'est indéniable. Pourtant, certains détails devraient nous rappeler vaguement l'ado que nous étions, et ici les adultes sont tellement différent des adolescents, que j'avais l'impression de me retrouver devant des personnages différents. L'année dernière, j'ai pu avoir la chance de retrouver mon premier crush, 35 ans ont pourtant passé, mais impossible pour moi de ne pas retrouver dans sa voix vieillie les intonations bien à lui, sa façon de parler.... 48 ans aujourd'hui, et pourtant, durant notre conversation, j'ai entendu celui qui avait 14 ans.

Et sinon?

Ah oui, revenons à nos moutons. Si l'histoire ne nous transporte pas au nirvana, qu'en est-il des protagonistes? Hé bien, si le début me semblait plutôt sympa, très vite, je soupire d'ennui. Le dynamisme apporté par le trio n'est pas du tout au point. Je ne sais si c'est la faute du jeu des acteurs ou de l'écriture des personnages.
Les personnages n'ont aucune profondeur réelle et bien que l'amitié des deux garçons soit écrite de façon à nous les rendre attachants, j'ai eu du mal à trouver un quelconque intérêt à leur lien. Tout est survolé de manière rapide et superficielle et sans aucune raison logique. La maladie de l'un, l'opération et puis le syndrome de la mémoire du corps (qui ne sert à rien si ce n'est un prétexte à se demander si oui ou non le personnage est réellement amoureux), les liens de la grand mère ou des parents, tout n'est que cliché et mal conté....
Le jeu des acteurs? Si nous n'avons pas à affaire ici au pire, nous sommes très loin d'un bon jeu. Jang Yeo Bin est inexpressive et son jeu est coincé, la rendant effacée. Alors oui, elle est encore jeune, 23 ans... Mais en comparaison, Zhao Lu Si, qui a pratiquement le même âge, manipule les subtilités de la comédie avec grand art.
Ceux des autres ne me laissent pas non plus de forte impression, que cela soit du côté des vétérans ou de la jeune génération.

La romance est placée au second plan, et c'est tant mieux, car il faut avouer qu'elle est aussi sans intérêt. Il n'y a aucune alchimie entre les adolescents et par conséquent, aucune alchimie entre les adultes.
Et la logique? Pourquoi ce retour de l'actrice 17 ans plus tard? Pourquoi cette disparition de l'un? J'ai vraiment dû manquer quelque chose (j'avoue, je me suis un peu endormie...). C'est donc une de ces fois où 8 épisodes sont encore de trop.

Lire davantage

All of me loves Oh Sehun… can’t say the same for the girl these two leads pine for

I came into this show expecting a light-hearted romantic comedy. A love triangle that I honestly would have a hard time watching if it weren't for Oh Sehun. Instead this drama offers much more than the above, in fact it deviates from the typical love-triangle formula to share a story more about youth and the love the young characters have to give towards each other as a whole.

So I'm not going to lie. Oh Sehun is the reason I was interested in this drama in the first place, and outside of that I wasn't planning on watching. To my surprise, right away this drama proved to be interesting- and honestly a whole lot more than I expected in general. Sehun's character Go Yoo fits him so well. The smiles and fun easygoing energy that he has is just perfect. After watching him in that one pirate movie I had no idea what to expect from his acting, but with this role he really fits it so well that I'm impressed and excited to see where his character goes. I think Sehun will do well with the mellow scenes, as this drama will definitely be having more of those. Sehun's scenes with basketball are point blank amazing, peak cinematography. They straight up did a Matrix style scene like where Neo dodges the bullets. Some could say outdated, but honestly genius. Like it is set in 2006, they did the Matrix, its part of the time.

It can be argued that Sehun doesn't look like a high schooler, but come on now. Something about his confidence on the basketball court, he fits being a high school basketball player too well honestly. The guy is all in other players faces like it is the only thing he's good for. So I can see his conflicts of his identity coming to light as he mellows himself to worry about other people. Which can very much so happen considering he ends up giving a kidney to his best friend. (which I also love) Watch the scene where Go Yoo makes the game winning shot and taunts the other players and tell me that isn't a spitting image of a guy in your high school that played basketball and peaked then. (not saying he is going to peak, just getting my point across).

Seeing bullying frustrates me. That is a good thing, why would I feel good watching bullying? Joon He gets bullied and has some issue with his health right away. I can see the whole story happening infant of my eyes and pray and hope that it does it correctly. This drama has a lot of open areas to fail, so that scares me the most. Jo Joon Young plays Joon He, and he plays off of Sehun so well. Their chemistry is so fun, and I love it so much. Watching two people enjoy eachtother that much, it makes me think about them growing old and still ending up as the same stupid teens they once were.. unfortunately I have no idea at this point if that will get to happen at all. I hope this drama focuses on the two of them rather than girl tearing them apart. So far it isn't what I thought it would be, so I hope it continues that path and cuts away romance that doesn't need to happen. The focus should stay on the two best friends, and be about their hardships with realizations about Joon He's health, him opening up, confections with a girl being added to the mix, but he always ends up back to Go Yoo. There is something about the two of them that is so beautiful... as dumb as that sounds. If Joo He is in trouble, Go Yoo will have his back. I love people genuinely enjoying each other without romance being shoved in my face. It is much harder to show a friendship than a romance. Romance can't really be described as to how people fall in love, so in dramas they take advantage of that and it can end up being dumb and heartless. Friendships are earned, they give reasons to why they depend on each other, and that they chose each other to be friends.

What I am saying, is that what is set up is interesting enough that it leaves me impressed. That is because it is executed well, acted well, written well. This drama is just a job well done.

The setup of the story is really good. The cinematography feels outside of the genre I was expecting. I love getting into dramas without knowing much, but its a mixed bag. Either I could love it, or really hate it. Right now I love this drama. What I am worried about is the love triangle, but in the end I think that it will be used to develop the characters rather than make them into a shell of themselves (at least I hope for that to be the case)

Go Yoo and Joon He by far have the best chemistry. Which is so insane to me with the age gaps. Honestly I am just getting so much from this drama that it really didn't have to do. It would have been successful without it being taken in the direction it is because if I watched for Sehun, I bet you many other people have.

Instead this drama serves to lead itself into a bittersweet story. Which it could've gone straight towards the love triangle, it may do that- but it also has a lot of depth beneath that with the first scene coming into play. I am so happy to see another drama that shifts its timeframe away from the present day. A lot can happen with it being set in 2006 compared to 2023. I would say more but I don't want to spoil. What they are doing with the time difference is underdeveloped. The girl character just comes over to drink several times and she’s the same character but not to me.. maybe because there was no defining traits about her to begin with. I don’t get why she comes out of the blue and what they are doing with the whole 2023 story other than to take it to the last episode to show whether Go Yoo is alive or not.

Watch this drama for Sehun, and watch it to get out of the typical love high school plot. I really want this to be great, and hope it stays to focus on the friendships. Then it will get a higher score. For what occurs over the small amount of episodes is a bit confusing. I think they are trying to do a whole jealousy thing with the girl but I can’t buy into it. The girl character isn’t really a character, I can’t find anything interesting about her other than that she is pretty.

Why do they both like her ? Especially Go Yoo? He’s so interesting .. why does he like this boring girl. It’s just oh it’s a new girl so they like her. They look good together… stupid stuff is said to make me buy into it. But I do not at all. Both the male leads like her and there is no depth outside of that, so to have Go Yoo get so jealous because of her makes no sense. It makes sense if he’s jealous she is with his best friend, but as for the latter it straight up does not. He does not know this girl, she is literally just preset and serves no other person. I swear this girl had not thoughts for and is a plot device to have this show be longer. Also she is so laughably bad at basketball .. If they both are mad at eachother for the girl and stop being friends because of it that is straight up criminal. Instead it should be that she is a gap between them and they are upset because of the rift they don’t understand them between them as friends. It does not need the romance but unfortunately that is what this drama is… so I have to live with it

I’m only so picky because they have these things to do and they are ignoring it for the girl. She takes time away but in the end serves no purpose. There is no way I feel bad for her, I don’t know her. She is just new pretty girl and is so annoying to me because I don’t understand why everyone likes her and wants to be her. God it is the worst. Her character is so so so bland… I can’t pick out any trait about her, she just stares and looks and barely talks. Female characters can be good and I don’t hate them by any means, a lot of dramas I love the gamble lead. Here though they really did my girl so bad. She just exists in this school, she’s new, pretty, but she has a secret…. But why- why do they find her interesting? Why is she supposed to be important. She is literally just a thief but why- why is that the thing that makes her not like other girls. Why is it the emotional climax for her- is her family poor? I don’t know they don’t give you that. They give you her crying and suck away anything I love about this show with her just being there. She takes away so many points for me here.


This story should have been done without her entirely.
100% just the two friends and maybe Go Yoo actually being upset he can’t play basketball and starting to blame his friend for that because of the kidney issue. They could have Go Yoo struggle with his identity and friendship and how he feels bad about what was taken away from him but he ultimately gave it away. Give the emotional climax to the friendship that was set up so well. Have it be between the leads and them reconciling and talking about their health issues- lives outside of high school- literally anything but the girl and her being a theif.

This show isn’t going beyond that in a way other than adding a girl to have tension and conflictions. I kid you not she does nothing. I don’t know why suddenly she is some main friend with them? I don’t get it.

Not bad as by any means, just not anything new. Now it’s still good though because of the main friendship, but the girl in the mix is pretty lame to me personally. .. if not aggravating.

It’s a shame. They had this story and a great setup. In the end they dragged out what didn’t need to be a part of it and lost touch of what they wanted to do in the first place. The cellular memory plot is so convoluted and only in the last two episodes.. but barely? So I’m disappointed but not surprised with this one.

Lire davantage