Script Writer (10)
Director (9)
Actors/Performances (10+)
Wardrobe Production-Value (10+)
Editing/Cinematography (9)
1st Act (10)
2nd Act (10+)
3rd Act (9)
The Script/Synopsis/Concept is not exactly mind blowing, but the writer and director were able to flesh it out and mould the show into a memorable drama.
Non of the lost memories, time jump, yelling Ajummas, switched at birth, drunkenness, giving all your money to family members, subservient women, weak/feminine men, and other quirky Kdrama tropes.
The acting was great especially the female lead, she portrayed happy, sad, jealousy, anger, suspicion, crazy, so mart, decisive, friction with mom, loving nonna, and so on. It must have been a dream role for the actress.
Every actor & character got there moments to shine, all the main actors are stars in their own respective.The wardrobe was iconic and timeless, the main set (ML’s home) was so good it was an even a tourist attraction in Seoul.
Was this review helpful to you?
100% Rewatch Worthy
I found this Kdrama back in 2018 and oh my god I am so glad I did! It was my first kdrama and since now it has always stuck with me and been my all time favourite no matter how many I’ve watched..I literally have a yearly tradition where I rewatch my love from the star again and it seriously never gets old.
And trust me when I say this, I normally can never stand old kdramas and this is my only exception.
Yes it’s cringy at times, yes there might be small loopholes and things that literally cannot make sense but I honestly think the acting and story make up for this and how story is carried out
(The slight unrealistic/ cringy acting especially from the Fl becomes endearing after some time haha, also considering the style of kdramas back then it’s not so bad)
I found the background storyline somewhat boring at times but it doesn’t take away from the chemistry of the main two leads
You literally find yourself rooting for them later on.
I highly recommend it
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Excellent
This drama portrays romantic comedy in a new light. It is more than a romance between an alien and a human but is a mystery/crime show as well. As you watch to determine how the romance will play out, you are also intrigued by why the obviously socio-pathic character is killing people and whether or not he will be caught.The characters are realistic and funny, while not being campy and the outside scenery is beautiful whether reliving 400 years in the past or modern Seoul.
The drama is an analogy of trust. Each character has to learn to trust and be trusted. Also, to learn that there are those who no matter how much you love them can not be trusted.
From beginning to end, it is well worth watching. The writing, directing and cinematography all excellent which is a rarity for this type of Kdrama.
Personal Rating:
Story: 10
Acting & Cast: 10
Music: 10
Cinematography: 10
Overall: 100/100
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
I'm pretty sure if CRINGE had a face, it would have looked like MY LOVE FROM STAR. Things are getting out of hand with the end of the second episode. I like why, why tf that alien went down to such an extreme, while the gravity of the situation was just mediocre. Maybe that's why I didn't give any star to acting, because there is only overacting, there is no such thing as acting exist out here.
More or less, when i started this, i knew its gonna be hard deal to sit through, but i overlooked by hunches and get started with it.
Was this review helpful to you?
I'm sure it's good..
It was short-lived for me. I just didn't fall in love with it. I was quickly annoyed with the female lead's role. It's not her fault either. It's just written that way. When you see her character in the first episode, you might understand what I'm saying. I initially thought, wow, that's who gets the lead male--what a shame. Please don't let this detour you from watching! You may love every second of it. One day, I might come back to this series. I love the actor, Kim Soo-hyun! He's adorable. He actually is getting better with age as well. HOTT!UPDATE
I did go back to finish it. It ended bittersweet.
Was this review helpful to you?
Un classique, et un de mes dramas préférés. My love from the stars c'est vraiment fou Xd
En general, les drama qui sont le plus populaires et les plus aimé je les adores pas (A quelques exeptions pres comme goblin) Mais la! Ce drama que j'ai vu juste parce que c'est un classique m'a boulversé de debut a la fin!
Deja commencons pas les personnages. Le couple principale, leurs interactions, l'alchimie tout est reel. C'est mon couple préféré de Dramaland. J'ai aussi adoré le frere de Song Yi que je trouvais trop chou
Le drama reussit a melangé fantastique, comedie romantique et drame a la perfection. La comédie est naturelle et n'est pas forcée, de meme pour la romance, les clichés fanatastique sont evités et le drame ne part pas dans le tire larme!
L'histoire est vraiment sympa, et il ne me semble pas avoir remarqué les habituelles longueurs avant le dernier tiers ce qui est assez remarquable pour etre souligné (sahcant que je m'ennuie facilement devant un filme ou un drama)
Je me rapelle vaugement des OST, pas remarquable mais vraiment belle. Et aussi petit assage sur les quelques effets spéciaux qui sont bien gerés rien a dire la dessus
My love from The stars c'est le drama que je conseillerais au nouveau a dramaland (et meme a tout le monde XD)
Was this review helpful to you?
O segundo melhor Dorama que já assisti
Boa história, trilha sonora perfeita. química do casal esplêndida.esse Dorama me surpreendeu muito não esperava que fosse tão bom. A história acontece devagar mas quando engrena não para mais. com certeza voltaria a assistir um dos melhores doramas feitos na Coreia.um dorama antigo (2013) que não conhecia porém ainda assim simplesmente um dos melhores. os personagens secundários incluindo o vilão também não deixam a desejar. o lance de parar o tempo funciona perfeitamente e causa emoção na cena e a insegurança do casal se poderão ou não ficar juntos é uma das melhores partes do drama. porque deixa tudo muito valioso a cada segundo.sensacionalWas this review helpful to you?
Lindo, romântico, atemporal
Um dos primeiros kdramas que assisti e muito especial para mim. Foi aqui que conheci o Kim Soo Hyun e me apaixonei por sua atuação. Lembro que fiquei completamente viciada na história e até hoje, de vez em quando, sinto vontade de assistir novamente, pois de certa forma ele acabou se tornando um dorama de conforto. Sei que para os mais exigentes pode não ser dos melhores, para quem não gosta de clichês também, mas para mim, uma eterna romântica, isso aqui beira a perfeição. Sim, eu sou emocionada e sensível com lindas histórias de amor, e "my love from the star" entrega isso, uma história de amor intensa e inesquecível, do jeito que gosto. Não vou entrar em detalhes sobre roteiro, escrita e esse tipo de coisa, porque pra ser sincera, eu não reparei direito nisso, eu simplesmente me permiti mergulhar fundo na luta dos protagonistas para ficarem juntos ou protegerem um ao outro, do que ficar reparando nessas questões técnicas, fui apenas uma espectadora comum enquanto aproveitava cada episódio e torcia incansavelmente para que tudo desse certo. A única coisinha que achei minimamente incômoda (mas entendi o processo e motivo) foi a demora significativa para o protagonista se render totalmente ao seu amor pela cheong yi. Mas, ainda assim, de certa forma foi algo que depois eu entendi e aceitei tranquilamente. Enfim, eu não consigo ser criteriosa ou crítica demais com esse dorama, eu só amo demais ele e sempre vou defendê-lo. 10/10 <3Was this review helpful to you?
