Quantcast

A Love Other than Yours

너 말고 다른 연애 ‧ Drama ‧ 2026

@MatCap

The contradiction thing is exactly what's been bugging me since the finale, you just put it into words way better than I ever could. If one month with other people was enough to break a 30 year bond, then why is Mi-do still crying over his drawing two years later? And if the bond is really that deep, why didn't either of them fight for it? The show kind of wanted it both ways and never explained either one.

Ep 13 is what makes it worse for me. The stuff about her dad and the guilt finally came out in the open, and it felt like one of the few times they actually talked to each other like adults. I honestly thought ok, now they can start fixing this. And then in the finale it's just "we can't go back" and he says fine. Why not though? What changed after that conversation that made it impossible? We never find out.

Your ep 7 idea would've been so much better. Just break them up for real and then show them trying to move on and not quite managing it. That's still a "love other than yours" story, but we'd actually see the new relationships happen instead of getting them handed to us after a two year time skip with Tae-seung as a voice off screen lol.

And yeah, the "go to him" thing after she literally stood in front of a car... I still can't wrap my head around it. She needed help, not a hall pass. Everything after that felt like it was built on sand.

Also the Endgame comparison made me laugh, but it's kind of true. Imagine Thanos shows up and everyone's like "eh, we can't go back to how things were" and goes home.

There's something I don't understand. I agree that Mido needed help but people forgot that her suicide attempt came after cheating on HO if it had happened before I would have understood what people expect from HO.

People don't understand the fact that HO tells her to go see TEASUNG, neither do i, but you all forget something her suicide attempt comme from her guilt on cheating on the persone that she care the most and the fact that she had feelings for " crazy bastard" like she said herself , this what pushed her in front of the car. If HO had left, and didn't want to see her again after the deception, people would say that he didn't really like Mido. If he stays, what he did for 3 months and but people forget, He is simp for that alone. Already he has to take care of Mido's brother who commits suicide and other members of the depressed family. In addition to him who drowns, he is expected to take care of an adult who does not even know how to communicate or don't Know what she want ?

Whenever HO or even his father or brothers reproached her for something , she had either cried or closed herself on her for days! The right question would be what did you expect from HO? How should he react to Mido's deception and suicide attempt? HO is a horrible partner but Mido is not the victim that people spend their time spending to depict since the end of the series. She's also manipulative asf. She did act like spoiled brat since kid. I don't forger she bullied HO. She found HO acts of kindeness stupid or was like that since the orphelinat, it not just with Mido family. For Mido family he did mix his act kindess with guilt but he is good persone for other's in general.

There's something I don't understand. I agree that Mido needed help but people forgot that her suicide attempt came after cheating on HO if it had happened before I would have understood what people expect from HO.

People don't understand the fact that HO tells her to go see TEASUNG, neither do I, but you all forget something her suicide attempt comme from her guilt on cheating on the person that she care the most and the fact that she had feelings for "crazy bastard" like she said herself, this is what pushed her in front of the car. If HO had left, and didn't want to see her again after the deception, people would say that he didn't really like Mido. If he stays, what he did for 3 months and but people forget, He is simp for that alone. Should he had forced her to psychologist ?

he has to take care of Mido's brother who is also have depression and other members of that depressed family. In addition to himself who drowning, he is expected to take care of an adult who does not even know how to communicate or don't know what she want?

Why should HO be responsible of everyone menlality health ?

Whenever HO or even her father/mother or brothers reproached her ( Mido ) for something, she had either cried or closed herself on her for days! The right question would be what did you expect from HO? How should he react to Mido's deception and suicide attempt? HO is a horrible partner but Mido is not the victim that people are spending their time to depict since the end of the series. She's also manipulative asf. She did act like spoiled brat since kid. I don't forge she bullied him. She found his acts of kindness stupid or was like that since the orphanage, it not just with Mido family. For Mido family he did mix his act kindess with guilt but he is good person for other's in general.

How to communicat with grown up crie baby ? even in the last episode she was still doing the same.

For MIdo's suicide attempt give me a reaction by taking into account his feelings that Mido cheated on him, give me a reaction that he should have had, we will see if he will not fall into the category simp or selfish / horrible according to your reactions that you think are valid ?

The only thing I can say is that the series has dealt with the mental state of all the characters on the surface without deep development The only thing I can say is that the series has dealt with the mental state of all the characters on the surface without deep development!

The fundamental difference between some of us is our expectations of what the show was about. There are many disappointed that a 30 years relationship wasn't put to rights. That it wasn't as story about the restoration of the relationship . That wasn't the story they were aiming for so anyway they ended it was going to be disappointed.

I rewatched the pilot and Mido outright acted that she disliked Ho. I encourage people who feel they should have worked things out to go watch just that episode. As a partner she could barely stand him

A few quotes from @Seymur

"If one month with other people was enough to break a 30 year bond"

If you ignored all the context and focus on the time then yes, 30 years >>> a month. With enough time, you can do as much damage as you can good.

"Ep 13 is what makes it worse for me. The stuff about her dad and the guilt finally came out in the open, and it felt like one of the few times they actually talked to each other like adults. I honestly thought ok, now they can start fixing this. And then in the finale it's just "we can't go back" and he says fine. Why not though?"

Why must they end up/fix things together after they talked through things? I don't get this complaint at all. It can't possibly because they've known each other for 30 years because it ignores all the context and what the individual characters needed for their growth. Ho in particular fixed things. Away. The fact that her brother threw the father's death in his face even once, when stepped out of line justified how he's felt all those years

"And if the bond is really that deep, why didn't either of them fight for it?"

Because it wasn't that deep, and it wasn't worth fighting for. It is tough to swallow but that was the message the show set out to tell and it did so sloppily

@11228

Nah, you're the one missing context here. Pretty blatantly, too.

> Because it wasn't that deep, and it wasn't worth fighting for.

Clearly it was, though. It's all right there for you. In the 'context.'

It's why Mido was still hung up on Namgung after 2 years.

It's why she camped outside of his apartment just to see him.

It's why she agreed to the final trip when he made it clear it would be the last time she would see him. (Why not just move on to Tae Seung, if the bond was so weak?)

It's also why, after she left the restaurant when Namgung told her he regretted meeting her, he just sat there and waited, knowing she would return. And she even came back faster than he expected. Why would she come back after hearing something like that, if the bond was so weak? If the bond wasn't worth fighting for, why, in this very scene, is she clearly fighting for it?

And the final scene, where she's crying over Namgung's drawing, she monologues about 'their spring' and 'loving that spring FOREVER'.

If you see all of that and still come away thinking that their bond was 'weak and not worth fighting for' then you're as guilty of missing context as you claim others are, and there's no point arguing with you. 🙂️

The truth here is that both messages were conveyed throughout this drama. The bond was portrayed as both weak and strong. That inconsistency kept people watching, and that's all that mattered. In the end, there is no deeper meaning behind this story.

It's just a poorly written one.

If I am reading it correctly, it seems you are coming from Mido's perceptive here.

Was the relationship worth fighting for from Mido's perceptive? Probably worth it if the guy shouted from the rooftops I am his life, worshipped the ground I walked on, and was willing to put up with murder, literally. Rewatch the pilot and really see their dynamic from where the story picked up. It was rancid but I digress. If I were Mido, I'll want to hang on to him in any capacity. Not that she did anything to do that, before and after the cheating

And if it was worth it for Mido, what was in it for Ho? d

and there's no point arguing with you. 🙂️

Noted

@MatCap - I think there is more room for nuance here than you are allowing for. Mido & Ho's 30-year relationship was based on an event that they both had misinterpreted, but in different ways. Ho thought Mido's father's death was his fault because her dad died saving him. If that weren't enough guilt to take on, Mido's mom took him into the family when even his own mother abandoned him. Mido thought her father's death was her fault because she goaded him into saving Ho. The mature truth was the father died saving someone because he was a fireman, and that is what he did.

Ho and Mido grew up together. They became lovers almost by default 15 years into their relationship. They loved each other with an inseparable family bond, but they were struggling to make it more than that. In the end, they both realized that it wasn't going to work. Taesung was just the spark that ignited it.

MatCap:

It's why Mido was still hung up on Namgung after 2 years.

It's why she camped outside of his apartment just to see him.

It's why she agreed to the final trip when he made it clear it would be the last time she would see him. (Why not just move on to Tae Seung, if the bond was so weak?)

It's also why, after she left the restaurant when Namgung told her he regretted meeting her, he just sat there and waited, knowing she would return. And she even came back faster than he expected. Why would she come back after hearing something like that, if the bond was so weak? If the bond wasn't worth fighting for, why, in this very scene, is she clearly fighting for it?

Closure. Ho left for 2 years without either of them getting any final closure on their complicated relationship. Ho sat there waiting for Mido return because he knew her so well. He had said something regrettably ugly to her, she left in a huff. They've fought and made up since they were kids. He knew she would return to make sure he didn't get the last word and/or apologized (which he eventually did). Taking the day trip with her to the beach was a final opportunity to take a look back on their relationship and agree that it had been special and that neither regretted it. It gave them an opportunity to shine a light on all that had been good so that they could move on.

MatCap:
And the final scene, where she's crying over Namgung's drawing, she monologues about 'their spring' and 'loving that spring FOREVER'.

In this scene, I think Mido is cherishing the past, not trying to cling to it--a wistful memory, not a longing for what she'd lost.

And I stick to my position that we are still discussing this drama because it had substance, not because the ending was a disappointment to some. Liberation Notes and We Are All Trying Here also elicited strong comments for much the same reasons. This wasn't a brainless lark like the recent Take Charge of My Heart.

@bbchops


Honestly, I think you're mistaking a poorly thought-out story and bad characterization for something with depth and 'nuance'.

> They loved each other with an inseparable family bond, but they were struggling to make it more than that.

Wrong. And I'm stunned at how many people reduce their relationship to a 'family bond' when the story directly contradicts that. All the flashbacks of them smiling, making out, and having sex show that they definitely made it more than a family bond. They weren't 'struggling'. They succeeded.

The 'struggle' only came when Mido's career began to fail and from the burden she was putting on herself from the secrets she was keeping from Namgung. Secrets she didn't feel the need to keep from Tae Seung...


> Closure.

Yeah, I know what was happening in the scene, friend. My point is that it's indicative of how strong their bond was that they both needed that closure from each other after 2 years.


> In this scene, I think Mido is cherishing the past, not trying to cling to it--a wistful memory, not a longing for what she'd lost

Of course she's thinking about the past when she's looking at the picture. However, her monologue is speaking of the future. About something that WILL happen and will last FOREVER. That's not her reminiscing.


>And I stick to my position that we are still discussing this drama because it had substance, not because the ending was a disappointment to some. Liberation Notes and We Are All Trying Here also elicited strong comments for much the same reasons. This wasn't a brainless lark like the recent Take Charge of My Heart.


And just like that other guy, I seriously doubt you and I are going to see eye to eye on this because your idea of 'substance' is miles away from my own. The fact that you are comfortable indirectly invoking the name of Park Hae Young, the screenwriter of My Mister, for Christ's sake, in defense of this drama is baffling. Park Hae Young has repeatedly demonstrated that she has the writing chops to tell thought-provoking and excellent stories. I wasn't blown away by the ending of My Liberation Notes either, but I can't deny that it was extremely well-written. I haven't watched We Are All Trying Here, but I plan to, specifically because Park Hae Young wrote it.

The writer of A Love Other Than Yours has only demonstrated that she is capable of introducing major plot points (like suicide) and then hand-waving them away like they never happened because she doesn't know how to move the story forward otherwise. The poor ending that many people (not 'some') are disappointed by is just another example of her lackluster writing. She doesn't deserve to be spoken of in the same breath as Park Hae Young. Again, the fact that you can shows how forgiving your standards are compared to my own.

You might be continuing this discussion because you found substance in the story. I continue it because I have some free time, I enjoy debate, and notifications keep popping up. But I'm seriously losing interest in the same weak arguments. This drama clearly wasn't meant to be a lark like Take Charge of My Heart, but maybe it should have been, considering the writer's ability.

@11228

Fair points, and I think we actually agree on more than it looks.

I'm not saying they had to end up together. Honestly, I think Namgung is better off, and you're right to ask what was in it for him. Not much, by the end. Walking away was probably the healthiest thing he ever did, and when even her brother threw their dad's death in his face, it kind of confirmed everything he'd been carrying all those years.

And yeah, 30 years can build up as much damage as good. I agree with that too. My problem is that the show never really showed us that damage piling up. We got flashbacks of them happy and in love, and then suddenly we're told the foundation was rotten. If it was a slow buildup of resentment and guilt, I wanted to see it, not just hear about it in the last few episodes.

Same with ep 13. The show set that conversation up like a turning point, the first time they finally got everything out in the open. So my "why not?" wasn't really "why didn't they get back together," it was "why did that breakthrough lead straight to a breakup without the show explaining what changed?" If the answer is that Namgung needed to leave to finally choose himself, I'm totally fine with that. I just wish the show had actually shown him getting there instead of jumping two years ahead.

Something I noticed reading through the last page, and I'm curious if anyone else sees it too.

Even the people defending the ending seem to defend it in the same way. Not "both of them grew and found their own spring," like the show was going for, but "Namgung finally got away." @11228 said that if they were Mi-do they'd hang on to him in any capacity, because he basically worshipped her, but that she never did anything to deserve that, before or after the cheating. @DdDIbi called her manipulative and said she'd acted like a spoiled brat since they were kids.

So whether people hated the ending or liked it, almost everyone ends up in the same place: Namgung leaving is the good part, and Mi-do is the problem he needed to escape.

And honestly, I think that says a lot about how the writing failed her. The show clearly wanted her to have her own growth arc. She confesses about her dad, she makes peace with her friend's success, she lets Namgung go. But if even the people who liked the ending don't buy that she grew, then that arc just didn't land. Instead of "two people who outgrew each other," what most of us saw was one person finally freeing himself and the other left crying over a drawing.

MatCap:
I haven't watched We Are All Trying Here, but I plan to, specifically because Park Hae Young wrote it.

You are in for a treat. It is outstanding.

A Love Other than Yours (2026) poster

Details

Statistics

  • Score: 6.7 (scored by 5,940 users)
  • Ranked: #13004
  • Popularity: #922
  • Watchers: 28,789

Top Contributors

169 edits
80 edits
31 edits
29 edits

Popular Lists

Related lists from users
All Time Favorite Dramas
921 titles 2216 loves 40
My Most Anticipated
1080 titles 224 loves 8

Recently Watched By