Quantcast

On the evening of November 16, a 14-year-old girl published a post, saying that she was not yet 13 in early 2025, when she reposted a compilation of controversies surrounding Yu Shu Xin on Weibo. She said she had not insulted anyone and that the post received zero reposts and 24 comments.

Later, the court summons was sent to her home, and the defendants named in the case were her 53-year-old father and 75-year-old grandfather, while she herself, despite being the person who had actually carried out the action, was not named as a defendant. In her post, she mentioned that her grandfather had undergone an amputation, her mother had cancer, and her father was the family's sole breadwinner. She asked, "Why can't responsibility be directed back at the person who actually committed the act?"

In the early hours of November 17, Yu Shu Xin's studio issued a statement:

Regarding the recent online discussions surrounding the reputation rights dispute involving Ms. Yu Shu Xin, we would like to clarify the relevant circumstances as follows:

1. Regarding the defendants in this case.

The defendants currently named in this case do not include the minor who has been mentioned in online reports. According to information lawfully disclosed by the online platform, the Weibo account involved in the case and the mobile phone number linked to it are registered under the names of two different individuals. As we were unable to determine who was actually operating the account, we filed the lawsuit based on the aforementioned information. The action was not taken simply to hold unrelated individuals liable on the basis of their family relationships.

After the court accepted the case, the Weibo user claimed to be the actual operator of the account involved. According to the legal representative, after the presiding judge asked her father whether the user should be added as a co-defendant, her father stated that he did not wish to add her to the case. 

At present, the defendants in this case remain the two individuals registered under their real names. The actual use of the account, the conduct involved in the case, and whether each party bears responsibility should be determined by the people's court in accordance with the law and based on the evidence. 

2. This legal action is not directed at someone for "merely reposting a single Weibo post," nor is it aimed at legitimate criticism or the expression of opinions.

According to the evidence currently available in the case, the account involved in the case published and reposted multiple posts spreading false claims about Ms. Yu Shu Xin. These included, but were not limited to, false allegations that she had "fled during the pandemic", "stolen a staff member's camera", "profited from [others'] suffering", and "paid marketing accounts to promote herself", as well as insulting remarks targeting her personally.

According to information disclosed by Weibo in accordance with the law, the posts involved in the case had accumulated more than 35,000 views. The content had been widely read and circulated, negatively affecting Ms. Yu Shu Xin's reputation and her normal daily life.

We filed the lawsuit in accordance with the law to protect our legitimate rights and interests. Whether the statements in question constitute an infringement and the extent of any liability shall be determined by the People's Court in accordance with the law.

3. We previously agreed to mediation and did not refuse to communicate.

After the court accepted the case, the defendants and the Weibo user involved requested mediation. When the court relayed their willingness to mediate to our legal representative, Ms. Yu Shu Xin took the other party's family circumstances into consideration and chose to agree to mediation.

According to the legal representative, after the defendants changed their legal counsel, effective communication with them could no longer be established. As a result, mediation discussions remained stalled for an extended period, and the court subsequently scheduled a hearing in accordance with the law.

Therefore, the case proceeding to trial should not be interpreted as our side refusing mediation or being unwilling to provide an opportunity for communication.

4. Protecting the legitimate rights and interests of minors does not conflict with upholding the law to protect another person's reputation.

We respect the special legal protections afforded to minors and also hope that every internet user will respect the facts and take responsibility for their words and actions. Any liability involving minors, as well as the responsibility of their guardians, should be handled strictly in accordance with the law.

Regarding any subsequent legal action and settlement arrangements, we will make decisions in accordance with the law, taking into account the specific conduct, the extent of its dissemination, the resulting harm, and any actual corrective measures taken. Communication should be based on respect for the facts and an end to the harm caused, and goodwill should also be treated with due seriousness.

We respect public scrutiny and accept legitimate criticism, but we do not accept the use of false information and insulting remarks to harm others. As the case is still undergoing judicial proceedings, please refrain from spreading unverified identity information or case details. We also urge everyone not to attack, dox, or expose the private information of any individuals involved or their family members.

Thank you for your attention. We will address the relevant disputes through legal proceedings, respond with facts, and abide by the law.

In response, an account called "南风瓜田说法", whose author claimed to have represented the defendants as their lawyer, published a post stating that after conveying the mediation proposal to the plaintiff's lawyer on March 27, he received no response indicating the plaintiff's consent to mediation for five months, until he withdrew from the case in August. This, he said, contradicted the studio's statement.

Source: Jimu News