Ok so this is one of my all time favorite novels and I was excited to come across this adaption but... Luo Yun Xi is NOT giving Shizun!😩  I like LYX in other dramas, so don't jump me now🫣 Like his face doesn't give cat. He does give delicate but he looks more dog like IMO, I think it's the long/angular face.  

Arthur Chen seems to be a good fit, he can be playful and is also good at being serious. I don't know who would be a better fit for the Shizun but I just wanted to complain about it lol. I never thought they'd try to adapt this masterpiece. Usually when I come across novel-to-drama adaptions I hear about the drama first so I don't care about the casting. I usually just end up reading the book instead anyways. Having already read and loved the novel is killing this casting choice for me. I don't even know that many Chinese actors to try and head canon a better choice lol. Maybe Xu Kai? He face gives more of a cat vibe to me, him from his As Beautiful As You era would be a good fit. 

What do y'all think?

From 100K+ comments (I followed them since comment 1). You are the 1st one who said so. So let me give you some information how Luo Yunxi was cast for Immortality or how Immortality drama is born BECAUSE of him.

Since novel completed mid-2018, several novel fans made video cuts yet all views were low. The novel has not gained a lot of attention. Summer 2018, Ashes of Love aired and Luo Yunxi Runyu exploded in China. Late 2018 a fan made video cut with Runyu (Lyx) and Leo Wu and overnight it went viral. It was the first time novel fans think there is a person who is worthy to play Chu Wanning.

The next day, the author meatbun received over 500 messages urging her to watch the video and she praised Luo Yunxi as beauty and introduced his name. Since then, meatbun has been praising Lyx several times. After the viral video a producer (from Quantum Entertainment/Otter studio)  bought the IP sold it to Tencent and try to secure both Leo Luo and Leo Wu as CWN & MR. But both refused, most BL actor are unknown with Runyu explosion he has no need to take the role. It took Tencent 8 months persuading him, as they are no other candidate otherwise not filming. At the end, Tencent gave an offer Lyx can’t refused. 3 S&S+ projects if he agreed and he did. And Tencent was willing to wait one year until Lyx has free time to film.

After the news of Immortality drama with Lyx as CWN, the novel exploded big time in new readers. As for Wu Lei he took another Tencent project and CFY really wanted this project. With his dad connection he secured this role just 2 weeks before announcement.

When Luo filmed this, he was the same age as CWN, like CWN he often wears white both in private and official appearance. You might not know, but in his daily demeanors Lyx is def like a cat. LYX is also extremely elegant same as CWN. No offense to Xu Kai, but CWN is extremely difficult to portray without making it facial paralysis or too cold, and Lyx is the perfect cast, he excels in creating highly complex characters.

Most agreed LYX is born to play CWN, and until now there has not been anyone remotely close to be able to play CWN both demeanors, his elegant, beauty, and acting prowess. So, it’s not only just look that matters. The producer themselves is extremely happy with Lyx as CWN as they thanking him for bringing Shizun to life not only with his acting but also his voice acting. 

His first day leaks as CWN broke the record as the most expensive leaks ever sold in C Drama (just as testament how excited people are to see him as CWN).

Idk, the shape of his face and the demeanor don’t match te vibes in the novel imo. He doesn’t look haughty enough at all. But then again according to the description for the drama it seems like they changed the story a lot. Maybe, however they wrote the character for the drama matches him better. I’d prefer a better match looks wise in this instance and sometimes it’s better for lesser known actors to play characters. I just took a look again and it just doesn’t fit. Maybe I’m an anomaly but it looks so incongruent that it prompted me to write this post 😭

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but since you open this tread of discussion. Well the only opinions that matter are 3, starting from the most relevant:

1. Your “Most favorite novel ever” AUTHOR 肉包不吃肉. She endorsed Luo Yunxi as Chu Wanning in more than 1 post, while never did so for Moran actor. CWN creator should know her own character better than any mortal on earth. 

2. Producer: Obviously they waited almost 2yrs between persuading the only actor they want to play CWN and waiting for his free filming time. 

3. 99% people here agreed Luo Yunxi is the perfect cast. 

In fact, your thread can be upsetting for many who has been patiently waiting for this adaptation to air since 2020, watching every single leaks daily during filming and reread the novel many times while waiting for this to be released someday.