goldenseal50 wrote: LOL you guys are funny... this is called MYDramalist I give my 10's where ever I feel them...I don't care how bad the acting is or the cliched the story if I loved it and remember it fondly it's a 10


LOL, we are a little tortuous, aren't we?
But I too can't lessen a 10, really.
I think a drama is worth a 10 when a few moths after you watched it, you see it somewhere and you feel like watching it again or feel really nostalgic about it because it was so good and now ended. There are many dramas that you're hooked on while you watch them, but afterwards.. not so much anymore. If we're bashing YB now :) I must say I was really hooked on it while watching and I still think it was a really good show, but now when I think about it I can only remember how good Hongki's bus scene was and not much else.
l've watched a least 236 dramas (completed) and I have given only two 10, one is for A Million stars falling from the sky and the other is for Brain.
Cat Street
Hana Yori Dango
Nobuta wo Produce
Scent of a Woman
Secret Garden
Shining Inheritance
Shut Up Flower Boy Band
Smile
Spring Waltz
Tatta Hitotsu no Koi
The Greatest Love
The World that They Live In
You're Beautiful

I'd say that my rating of the drama comes first of all from the wish the drama leaves me with to REWATCH IT AGAIN AND AGAIN!!! The dramas I've listed here, and these are really all the dramas I've rated 10 in my list, I've rewatched like a 100 times (I absolutely remember, I've watched Nobuta for 10 times, HYD... 7 (?), YAB - 4...etc...).
Also for me one of the most important factors is the OST and Score... I just go crazy about good OST... It's been 4 years since I watched Nobuta, and I still can listen to the score like everyday... One of the most heavenly OSTs is Smile's score... Hana Yori Dango...mmm...
And interestingly enough I'm a sucker for a good friendship drama... I always think I'm more romance oriented :P and then go and fall for a friendship drama haha~
the drama I rated 10 is because it has a very good story line and enjoyable to watch again and again: Meteor Garden Sungkyunkwan Scandal You're Beautiful Spring Waltz My Name is Kim Sam Soon Coffee prince or because it made me falling in love with the main lead actor: My girl (Lee dong wok) Hotelier (Bae yoong jon) I like this one, because the character in this drama reminds me of myself :) - Seigi No Mikata
Coffee Prince Secret Garden Only those two deserve to be a 10 in my opinion. Of course, I'm judging based on the drama's that I watched.
I haven't seen many dramas yet, but Coffee Prince, Zettai Kareshi and Sungkyunkwan Scandal got a 10 from me. Vampire Prosecutor got a close 9.
aheheh.. 10 for me are secret garden, coffee prince, greatest love, they kiss again, city hunter, playful kiss, goong, and personal taste,. their all my favorite!.. :)
goldenseal50 wrote: LOL you guys are funny... this is called MYDramalist I give my 10's where ever I feel them...I don't care how bad the acting is or the cliched the story if I loved it and remember it fondly it's a 10


Pretty much agree with that haha :)

i'll give 10 pretty easily so here's some of them:

-Bloody Monday
-Liar game
-JIN
-Rondo
-Hana Yori Dango
-49 Days -My Girlfriend is a Gumiho -Queen Seon Duk -Temptation of an Angel - It was unrealistic, exaggerated, but I liked the ending and the amosphere. I watched it in 2 or 3 days, so I really liked it.
I've just completed and rated 10 Dream High
My ratings usually depend on how much I love the characters and actors, the acting and plot - I just think you can have one without the other. You have to love the characters, actors and the acting and plot has to be solid and convincin to be a favourite. Also how much it's made me laugh or cry or both. The ending is another important element I consider because a bad ending can just ruin a really good series like City Hunter (I couldnt give it a 10 because the ending sucked too much so i had to give it a 8 - tho I might change in to a 9 since I'm rewatching it :)) or Iljimae and its really disappointing and it sucks!!! My top 6 top rated dramas are: Iljimae (the acting and fighting made up for the sucky ending) It Started With A Kiss The Little Fairy - underrated its sooo goood! The Moon That Embraces The Sun They Kissed Again - sequel to ISWAK Warrior Baek Dong Soo - loved the second lead. Did not know I would love a second lead so much! Some other dramas that were in the running for getting a 10: You're Beautiful - didnt like the ending God's Quiz 1&2 - dont know why its not a 10 because it was awesome but just didnt think it was a masterpiece... City Hunter - again with the ending Buzzer Beat - ending again... Secret Garden - ending....pattern starting to form... Operation Proposal - really really wanted to give it a 10 because the acting and the male lead was awesome!!!!!!!!!!! Cannot emphasis it enough but the plot got a little boring during the middle and I had to skip a few episodes (never a good thing) so I couldnt give it a 10. Enjoyed the last few episodes so much tho!!! And the ending - well it was satisfactory but thats as good as any dramas get aha!
I gave a 10 for several reasons: * I liked the story, the players, the chemistry between the lead actors / actresses * I like the OST and even today still remember how the feel when the song played * when watching the drama, my emotions get involved * I could fall in love with the lead actors * without the Fast Forward button pressed during watching the whole episode ;) * I could watch the drama over and over again dramas are: 1. Winter Sonata 2. Coffee Prince 3. Meteor Garden 1 4. You're Beautiful 5. BBF 6. 49 Days 7. Secret Garden 8. Love Rain (though still ongoing) But I gave 9.5 - 9,9 to The Great QSD, Dong Yi, The Princess's Man, City Hunter, TMTETS, The Equator Man
1 litre of tears
great act, great story, great songs..I watched it more than 3 times and I cried harder each time I rewatched..

14 sai no haha
same as 1 litre of tears,,,great act, great story, and great songs.. :D

coffee prince
I really love the story..and the songs too...and who doesn't love Gong Yoo?LOL..
but seriously, the cuteness was so great..

kaseifu no mita
actually, it could be better..but I gave some bonus points for its unexpected story..
the story is too unreasonable, but the mystery bought me..

love shuffle
it was so funny, and light..
although the ending was just what I expected, I still wasn't sure if my expectation would be really happen or not even after the last episode..and YAY PANDA! :D

nobuta wo produce
this drama was the one that turned me into jdrama addict..
I love the story so much...also the ending..
and it's so realistic because nobuta doesn't change 180 degree..in fact, no one can change from shy dark person into a very bright person just in one night..or even 1 year..

shining inheritance
I love that the main girl is not a stupid angel..in most dramas like this,,people usually be a unbelievably kind hearted person that doesn't want to say that bad people do bad thing for particularly no reason..but this one is different.. :)
Current count..I watched 189 drama:-) and those drama that make me cry, laugh and fall in love and got 10 for me are: Korean Drama 1.) Sungkyunkwan Scandal 2.) City Hall 3.) Dalja Spring 4.) 49 Days 5.) My Rosy Life 6.) The Princess' Man 7.) New Heart 8.) Pasta 9.) The Legend 10.) Prosecutor Princess 11.) Queen Seon Deok 12.) Secret Graden 13.) Sorry, I Love You Japanese Drama 1.) Maou 2.) Zettai Kareshi 3.) Yukan 4.) Bara no nai Hanaya 5.) Beautiful Life 6.) Densha Otoko 7.) JIN 2 8.) Koizora 9.) Kurosagi 10.) Tumbling 11.) Love Shuffle 12.) Mr. Brain 13.) My Girl 14.) Nankyoku Tairiku 15.) Nobuta Wo Produce 16.) Nodame Cantabile 17.) Q10 18.) Rookies 19.) Ryusei No Kizuna 20.) Tatta Hitotsu no Koi 21.) Tantei Gakuin Q 22.) Sunao ni Narenakute 23.) 1 Litre of Tears 24.) Liar Game Taiwanese Drama 1.) Fated to Love You 2.) Meteor Garden 3.) Meteor Garden 2 4.) Mysterious Incredible Terminator I don't want to list those drama who almost got 10..cause if i do...it will be a very, very long list:-)