
dora:
I was thinking about ratings and how I choose them. I never give anything a 10 because to me that’s perfect and nothing is. So my highest rated dramas are a 9.5. Also I never give anything less than a 6.0. I figure if I can sit through it it deserves at least that. But most things I rate between a 7 and a 9. I try to assess the quality as well as my enjoyment. I give an extra .5 points if I really liked it or end up rewatching it more than i expected. But in retrospect I wonder if this is the best way to do it to help myself and others assess a show’s quality. Are my ratings too close to each other? I find it hard to be harsh though because I can find something to like in most shows as long as they’re not boring. I do hate sad endings though. So that could ruin a decent show for me.
How do you decide? What’s most important to you in a good show?
I’m not usually harsh in my reviews because I know everyone puts in a lot of effort to do their best. There’s one show (The Whisperer) that I gave a 4.5 because I was really annoyed. The last episode was missing! I thought that was super disrespectful to the audience. And I was actually enjoying it, even though it’s a horror series, which isn’t really my thing.
For me, the most important factor when rating a show is how much I enjoy it. If it made me laugh, cry, or think, that’s what really matters. Like you, I can usually find something to like in most shows. Maybe that’s not the best way to help others evaluate a show's quality, but I struggle to rate things with other people in mind because taste is so personal. And I know my taste is a bit unconventional. There are popular series that I find mediocre, and others I love that got terrible reviews/ratings.
No matter how bad a show is, I’ll still watch all the episodes. The one thing that can truly ruin a show for me is if it feels, well… sloppy. The budget can be low, the actors can be inexperienced, but if I can see they were really trying to create something interesting, I usually give it a positive rating. Otherwise, it’ll get a low rating (if there's at least something slightly good about it) or won’t even make it onto my list (if I feel like nothing is worth saving).