While watching this, there was some complaints in the beginning about it not having enough revenge, but after…
I read the novel expecting a similar plot to the drama and to get more moments of ShenRun and YunYa after their marriage, but the novel is very different.
The drama's YunYa is consumed by revenge to the point that she could sacrifice herself for it, but in the novel she only wanted to find the truth after Grandma Xie forcefully brought her into the family. She was not consumed by revenge; instead, the story focused on her surviving in a new environment.
There were no extra layers to the mystery, just a straightforward murder done by First Madam to eliminate the new concubine and blame it on YunYa's mother.
ShenRun - YunYa, and SML - QingRu, aren't childhood friends.
The novel has little going on but has a better structure overall.
Except for SML and maybe QingRu, almost every other character's traits have changed because only those two characters' roles in the drama and the novel were the same.
The drama's QingRu got a happy ending, and the novel's version didn't, as the story's setting and direction were very different.
I like the drama more because it has so much more to offer than the novel. However, the drama also tried to do too many things, lacked budget, and suffered from poor editing and voice dubbing, with disrupted narrative structure at times.
While watching this, there was some complaints in the beginning about it not having enough revenge, but after…
QingRu is a typical bully character who grew up in privilege and was treated as if she were above everyone else. She knows what she did to Li Congxin was wrong, but she only realized and accepted this because she loves him. If it had been anyone else, she wouldn’t have acknowledged her wrongdoing and would have stayed the way she was. Their marriage is official, and she is his legal wife. He could not get a divorce because she hadn't given him any legal grounds for one, and she remains completely devoted to him. Given their situation, she was either going to be ignored for the rest of her life, or Li Congxin was going to accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of person to harbor resentment for a lifetime over such matters. Thanks to her efforts and his father’s dying words, he ultimately chose to accept her. Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes, they get a good one. She also stopped acting like a brat and became entirely devoted to him.
So, I don’t understand why so many people think this ending was the worst possible fate for Li Congxin. He ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Meanwhile, Qingyuan doesn’t love him at all, and the chances of her ever falling for him are zero. Therefore, his ending is actually better than what he was trying to achieve for himself, aside from the tragic death of his father.
Additionally, while the drama failed to portray Li Congxin effectively, he is not entirely innocent either. He does things without caring about the consequences others face due to his actions. Despite knowing that Qingyuan is in love with ShenRun, he still tried to push for a marriage proposal. He didn’t save her a single time and only made things more messy. While he was helpful in securing a meeting with the marquis, that was the extent of his usefulness. If he truly wanted to help her, he could have done so. Instead, he brought up marriage and flaunted its benefits, fully knowing that QingYuan wanted revenge and was already in love with the ShenRun.
Li congxin is introduced as a man who enjoys female attention, but the drama failed to showcase his playboy nature after his initial introduction. As a result, many viewers believe he wouldn't take another wife. However, in the novel, after he got marriage acceptance he didn’t last three months before sleeping with a woman sent by ShenRun. His characterization is the same in both the novel and the drama, the same thing likely would have happened in the show. The drama's wedding simply happened too fast, leaving no time to execute that specific plot point.
I think YunYa started falling for the ML in Ep. 4 after he saved her when she was being punished. She used a trick to ensure he came to her but he not only saved her but also stood up for her very strongly. Even though she acts composed she truly had no one to rely on in the Xie residence with no power of her own to contend against the Xie family. She is like a lone bird struggling in an iron cage but YanRui does not just open the cage door. He breaks the cage itself. What he did that day ensured no one would ever dare mistreat her again. It was the first time she felt a strong shoulder she could lean on.
After everything they went through that night many questions were probably running through her head. What is his true motive? Is he really reliable? Is he just going to use her and abandon her once she loses value in his eyes? And many more.
Surprisingly the next morning YanRui gives her his token and suggests an alliance. However she still cannot bring herself to trust a scheming man she knows nothing about. Eventually she agrees but when she asks about his true motives he shuts her down. He constantly makes moves without giving her a heads up which is troublesome. So when her sisters came to fight her over the SML proposal she used the situation to let the second sister snatch the token. By doing this she learned more about YanRui’s stance toward her while simultaneously getting back at her sisters. She is not looking for love yet she still feels her heart flutter from time to time because of YanRui. Later we are shown that there is another reason behind this reaction as she sees a resemblance to ShenRun whom she misses very much and awaits their reunion. Their love for each other developed properly and was not forced or abrupt.
Why is this getting so much hate? It definitely has issues, but not enough to dismiss all the good things about it. I get that not every drama is for everyone, but it’s disappointing to see dramas with more problems treated as fan favorites and top recommendations while this one gets slammed.
It's not a sudden change, and it was shown and built through each of their interactions. She realizes they are…
They never planned a future together, they both have things to do, and there is even a dialogue telling us that they both have their own secrets and neither is willing to reach out to others. Even after coming out of the village, FL doesn't show her feelings towards him; she is softer and opens up more with him, but that's about it. She only tries to reach out and ask if he is ShenRun because she lost her brother who was good to her and maybe she didn't want to regret it, and when she was about to ask, ML's brother comes and takes him away and ML tells her he will explain everything after coming back. Then the reveal happens, and she already knows what ShenRun's secret is and has been waiting for him. After knowing who YanRui is, there was no more reason for her to hold back her love, but again something happens. I think their relationship dynamics and the transition were shown properly, and I didn't feel confused or feel that it was a sudden shift.
It's not a sudden change, and it was shown and built through each of their interactions. She realizes they are…
I mean, what else does she need in order to show what she is actually feeling? She is already in love before Ep. 14, and after Ep. 14, after going through all of that, she accepts her own feelings for him. Even if we ignore the buildup she had from every confrontation, one moment is enough to fall in love, and she had so many moments in those three episodes. Grandma Chen and her two friends were good and needed support for her, but YanRui's presence gave her the safe space she very much needed in her life, so it's not weird.
idk I don't get FL change of heart in ep 15, she was neutral/hostile to ML entire time and suddenly appreciate…
It's not a sudden change, and it was shown and built through each of their interactions. She realizes they are similar in some ways in Ep. 2, and in the constant struggle of trying to figure out YanRui, she starts to fall for him, but she doesn't realize/acknowledge it because she doesn't want to get entangled in love or any similar emotions before getting her revenge, and she knows nothing about YanRui; what his end goal is, what his next step is going to be, and how it would affect her and her revenge. Her father, who claims to have loved her mother, was the one who killed her. So why would she acknowledge her emotions to a man she doesn't know anything real about? After Ep. 13, she completely realizes what kind of person YanRui is, and her emotions towards him come out when she stops him in the corridor and he hugs her, and later that very night, back to back, she realizes how much she means to him.
Ep 28 is so good, i didn't expect that secret at all. Whatever anyone said about the last 5 eps don't believe…
Same, I didn't understand the excessive hate. The shift was abrupt and it does have some narrative issues, but the last four episodes have some great moments, good twists and the acting was phenomenal. It might not have everything to make it the best, but it has enough to make it a good last 5 episodes.
QingRu is a typical bully character who grew up in privilege and was treated as someone above all else by her mother. She knows what she did to Li Congxin was wrong, but she only realized and accepted that her actions were wrong because she loves him. If it had been for someone else, she wouldn't have realized and accepted that her actions were wrong, and would have stayed the way she was.
Their marriage is done, and she is his official wife. He could not get a divorce because she had not done anything that would grant grounds for one, and she is devoted to him. Even if what she did was wrong, their situation is that she will either be ignored for the rest of her life or Li Congxin will accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of guy who can stay resentful for a lifetime for such a thing. With her efforts and his father’s words before he died, he chose to accept her and if you think about it he was doing what he preached to QingYuan all the time that he believes after marriage his love for her would make her fall for him and accept him. QingRu love for Li Congxin made him accept her and willingly fall for her.
Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes they get a good one. She also stopped being a brat and became devoted to him. So I don’t understand why so many people think the ending Li Congxin and QingRu got was the worst fate for him when he ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Qingyuan doesn’t even love him a bit, and the chances of her falling for him are zero. So his ending is better than what he was trying to get for himself, except for the death of his father.
I don’t know if you will read all of this, but this is just my opinion from what I observed.
During Li Congxin's introduction. He was basking in the attention he got from the women around him, and then he notices Qingyuan, who didn't give him any attention. He approaches her and their conversation literally establishes what kind of person he is. When he fails to get her attention, what he does next is propose marriage, which her family refuses. Then the second marriage proposal comes when Yanrui arrests Second Brother and soldiers surround the Xie house. He uses that situation because this marriage becomes a helping hand to the Xie family, meaning the probability of them rejecting his proposal is low. It means they would be pressured into accepting because of the situation they are in(He knows what he was doing, but he deluded himself into believing it was good for Qingyuan and that he was helping her). Qingyuan gives her grandmother the right to decide because she cannot outright say no when the marriage benefits the family in that situation, and she also believes the Xie family will not let such a good marriage come to her.
Even though no one gave verbal acceptance to his proposal and Qingyuan even rejected him to his face, he kept treating her as if she will become his wife. He did not stop pushing for the marriage even after witnessing Qingyuan's love for Yanrui. The reason? He believed that after getting married she will naturally fall for him because of his love for her. But why does he not think that he will fall for QingRu after marriage, since she loves him so much? That is what finally happened! But he did not even entertain that idea; he just expected Qingyuan to entertain it.
Then he realized Qingyuan was getting her revenge, and he even used her thirst for revenge to try to make her accept his proposal. If he wanted to help her, then help her, so why bring marriage into it? She accepts his proposal and he fully knows that she loves ShenRun and is forcing herself to marry him, and his reaction is happiness? Seriously? That's messed up. If he married her, he would eventually lose its spark because he attained what he wanted. And if he comes across a woman who spikes his interest, the same thing would repeat: he pursues her with everything he has got, tries to marry her.
Just because he said he would give up his status to marry QingYuan does not mean he really meant it, because his parents doted on him very much and he knows they would never let him lose his status as they love him so much and he is the only child. It was an emotional attack to force his parents. There are no differences in his character between the novel and the drama. If you read it, you will understand more that he is not what most people think he is. It's sad that he was deceived by his own mother but he not that innocent. He is a good guy but loves to have fun but doesn't care what his actions causes to others, he is a playboy who just suppressed his nature to pursue a women he fallen in love for. His playboy nature would come out sooner or later, just like in the novel.
QingRu is a typical bully character who grew up in privilege and was treated as someone above all else. She knows what she did to Li Congxin was wrong, but she only realized and accepted that her actions were wrong because she loves him. If it had been for someone else, she wouldn't have realized and accepted that her actions were wrong, and would have stayed the way she was.
Their marriage is done, and she is his official wife. He could not get a divorce because she had not done anything that would grant grounds for one, and she is devoted to him. Even if what she did was wrong, their situation is that she will either be ignored for the rest of her life or Li Congxin will accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of guy who can stay resentful for a lifetime for such a thing. With her efforts and his father’s words before he died, he chose to accept her. Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes they get a good one. She also stopped being a brat and became devoted to him. So I don’t understand why so many people think the ending Li Congxin and QingRu got was the worst fate for him when he ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Qingyuan doesn’t even love him a bit, and the chances of her falling for him are zero. So his ending is better than what he was trying to get for himself, except for the death of his father.
As for the drama itself, it definitely has narrative issues that doesn't give us the satisfying revenge after the buildup it built till ep 24 and the shift was abrupt and things happen too fast.
Before I started watching, I thought this drama would be silly and not to my taste, so I avoided it for a long time. But I finally gave in because I wanted to see how LuYuXiao performed. Now, I’m liking it more and more with each episode.
It’s funny how in the novel, Xie Qingyuan compares SML to her father. But she can’t pull that comparison in the drama because her dad is pure evil in his methods, and she despises him far more than in the novel.
The drama has so much more to offer than the novel, but there are people who like the novel version more than the drama just because ShenRun and Chen Yunya have more intimate scenes.
I'm reading the novel, and I don't know if I should even call this drama a novel adaptation. Except for a few details, almost everything has been changed. The drama focuses on revenge interwoven with political justice, while the novel is not at all revenge focused; it's more focused on the FL's life after she was forcefully taken in by the Xie family. I actually like the drama more because, even with its imperfections, it has layers upon layers. There are so many high moments that I can constantly rewatch and feel the same high. The biggest plus for me is the leads' chemistry and the dynamic between Chen YunYa and ShenRun.
This is the unfulfilled potential drama of the Year! I enjoyed it. This drama has a lot of high moments that made me love it, but if they had edited it properly and planned the reveals, buildup and setting up few things better, it would have been the undisputed drama of the year for me. I just loved every second of Zhou Ye and Xu Kai on screen. From the product we got and the lack of proper promotion, it's clear there were many issues behind the scenes. It's a pity , but anyway, I don’t care if it’s modern or costume; I just hope we get a second collaboration between Zhou Ye and Xu Kai that does their chemistry justice.
The thing is like when he asked her if she had agreed to marry him of her own freewill, I was thinking to myself,…
Yeah, he was seriously trying to coerce her into accepting his marriage proposal. If he genuinely wanted to help FL, he would’ve offered it even without bringing up the marriage. He brings it up almost every single time he's on screen.
I feel bad that ChunZhi’s own mother deceived him, but I just cannot bring myself to like his character. He simply wants to marry her no matter what. I might be wrong but I felt every action he took for her was solely in the hope that the FL or the Xie family would agree to marry him. Even his conversations with her focused entirely on the benefits she would get from marrying him and how she would eventually fall in love with him. He believes that because he loves her so much, she will definitely warm up and fall in love with him. That is what he kept saying. However, this raises the question of why he is not willing to put himself in her shoes. The second daughter of the Xie family also loves him deeply, meaning he could just as easily fall for her after marriage. Why does he not think positively about that scenario, marry her from the start, and stop pursuing a girl who clearly loves someone else? That logic does not apply to him because it works against his own desires. Instead, he keeps trying to marry her without worrying about mutual love and only seeking agreement. He clearly knows she forced herself to accept his proposal for revenge and that she is not happy, yet he still goes forward with the marriage. I did not want to critique this specific point because she was ultimately the one who accepted the proposal, but it is impossible to understand how he can feel happy about an acceptance born out of such circumstances.
I am not saying the FL and ML are blameless, but this comment is specifically about the SML.
Correct me if I’m wrong but that letter just exposed the son rushed a battle that cost his life and the lives…
The emperor's decree was sent out even before the letter was revealed. Once a decree is issued, it must be read; neither Shen Run nor any other official has the right to decide whether to read it or not.
The drama's YunYa is consumed by revenge to the point that she could sacrifice herself for it, but in the novel she only wanted to find the truth after Grandma Xie forcefully brought her into the family. She was not consumed by revenge; instead, the story focused on her surviving in a new environment.
There were no extra layers to the mystery, just a straightforward murder done by First Madam to eliminate the new concubine and blame it on YunYa's mother.
ShenRun - YunYa, and SML - QingRu, aren't childhood friends.
The novel has little going on but has a better structure overall.
Except for SML and maybe QingRu, almost every other character's traits have changed because only those two characters' roles in the drama and the novel were the same.
The drama's QingRu got a happy ending, and the novel's version didn't, as the story's setting and direction were very different.
I like the drama more because it has so much more to offer than the novel. However, the drama also tried to do too many things, lacked budget, and suffered from poor editing and voice dubbing, with disrupted narrative structure at times.
Their marriage is official, and she is his legal wife. He could not get a divorce because she hadn't given him any legal grounds for one, and she remains completely devoted to him. Given their situation, she was either going to be ignored for the rest of her life, or Li Congxin was going to accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of person to harbor resentment for a lifetime over such matters. Thanks to her efforts and his father’s dying words, he ultimately chose to accept her. Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes, they get a good one. She also stopped acting like a brat and became entirely devoted to him.
So, I don’t understand why so many people think this ending was the worst possible fate for Li Congxin. He ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Meanwhile, Qingyuan doesn’t love him at all, and the chances of her ever falling for him are zero. Therefore, his ending is actually better than what he was trying to achieve for himself, aside from the tragic death of his father.
Additionally, while the drama failed to portray Li Congxin effectively, he is not entirely innocent either. He does things without caring about the consequences others face due to his actions. Despite knowing that Qingyuan is in love with ShenRun, he still tried to push for a marriage proposal. He didn’t save her a single time and only made things more messy. While he was helpful in securing a meeting with the marquis, that was the extent of his usefulness. If he truly wanted to help her, he could have done so. Instead, he brought up marriage and flaunted its benefits, fully knowing that QingYuan wanted revenge and was already in love with the ShenRun.
Li congxin is introduced as a man who enjoys female attention, but the drama failed to showcase his playboy nature after his initial introduction. As a result, many viewers believe he wouldn't take another wife. However, in the novel, after he got marriage acceptance he didn’t last three months before sleeping with a woman sent by ShenRun. His characterization is the same in both the novel and the drama, the same thing likely would have happened in the show. The drama's wedding simply happened too fast, leaving no time to execute that specific plot point.
After everything they went through that night many questions were probably running through her head. What is his true motive? Is he really reliable? Is he just going to use her and abandon her once she loses value in his eyes? And many more.
Surprisingly the next morning YanRui gives her his token and suggests an alliance. However she still cannot bring herself to trust a scheming man she knows nothing about. Eventually she agrees but when she asks about his true motives he shuts her down. He constantly makes moves without giving her a heads up which is troublesome. So when her sisters came to fight her over the SML proposal she used the situation to let the second sister snatch the token. By doing this she learned more about YanRui’s stance toward her while simultaneously getting back at her sisters. She is not looking for love yet she still feels her heart flutter from time to time because of YanRui. Later we are shown that there is another reason behind this reaction as she sees a resemblance to ShenRun whom she misses very much and awaits their reunion. Their love for each other developed properly and was not forced or abrupt.
Their marriage is done, and she is his official wife. He could not get a divorce because she had not done anything that would grant grounds for one, and she is devoted to him. Even if what she did was wrong, their situation is that she will either be ignored for the rest of her life or Li Congxin will accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of guy who can stay resentful for a lifetime for such a thing. With her efforts and his father’s words before he died, he chose to accept her and if you think about it he was doing what he preached to QingYuan all the time that he believes after marriage his love for her would make her fall for him and accept him. QingRu love for Li Congxin made him accept her and willingly fall for her.
Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes they get a good one. She also stopped being a brat and became devoted to him. So I don’t understand why so many people think the ending Li Congxin and QingRu got was the worst fate for him when he ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Qingyuan doesn’t even love him a bit, and the chances of her falling for him are zero. So his ending is better than what he was trying to get for himself, except for the death of his father.
During Li Congxin's introduction. He was basking in the attention he got from the women around him, and then he notices Qingyuan, who didn't give him any attention. He approaches her and their conversation literally establishes what kind of person he is. When he fails to get her attention, what he does next is propose marriage, which her family refuses. Then the second marriage proposal comes when Yanrui arrests Second Brother and soldiers surround the Xie house. He uses that situation because this marriage becomes a helping hand to the Xie family, meaning the probability of them rejecting his proposal is low. It means they would be pressured into accepting because of the situation they are in(He knows what he was doing, but he deluded himself into believing it was good for Qingyuan and that he was helping her). Qingyuan gives her grandmother the right to decide because she cannot outright say no when the marriage benefits the family in that situation, and she also believes the Xie family will not let such a good marriage come to her.
Even though no one gave verbal acceptance to his proposal and Qingyuan even rejected him to his face, he kept treating her as if she will become his wife. He did not stop pushing for the marriage even after witnessing Qingyuan's love for Yanrui. The reason? He believed that after getting married she will naturally fall for him because of his love for her. But why does he not think that he will fall for QingRu after marriage, since she loves him so much? That is what finally happened! But he did not even entertain that idea; he just expected Qingyuan to entertain it.
Then he realized Qingyuan was getting her revenge, and he even used her thirst for revenge to try to make her accept his proposal. If he wanted to help her, then help her, so why bring marriage into it? She accepts his proposal and he fully knows that she loves ShenRun and is forcing herself to marry him, and his reaction is happiness? Seriously? That's messed up. If he married her, he would eventually lose its spark because he attained what he wanted. And if he comes across a woman who spikes his interest, the same thing would repeat: he pursues her with everything he has got, tries to marry her.
Just because he said he would give up his status to marry QingYuan does not mean he really meant it, because his parents doted on him very much and he knows they would never let him lose his status as they love him so much and he is the only child. It was an emotional attack to force his parents. There are no differences in his character between the novel and the drama. If you read it, you will understand more that he is not what most people think he is. It's sad that he was deceived by his own mother but he not that innocent. He is a good guy but loves to have fun but doesn't care what his actions causes to others, he is a playboy who just suppressed his nature to pursue a women he fallen in love for. His playboy nature would come out sooner or later, just like in the novel.
QingRu is a typical bully character who grew up in privilege and was treated as someone above all else. She knows what she did to Li Congxin was wrong, but she only realized and accepted that her actions were wrong because she loves him. If it had been for someone else, she wouldn't have realized and accepted that her actions were wrong, and would have stayed the way she was.
Their marriage is done, and she is his official wife. He could not get a divorce because she had not done anything that would grant grounds for one, and she is devoted to him. Even if what she did was wrong, their situation is that she will either be ignored for the rest of her life or Li Congxin will accept her. Li Congxin is not the type of guy who can stay resentful for a lifetime for such a thing. With her efforts and his father’s words before he died, he chose to accept her. Not every bad person gets a bad ending; sometimes they get a good one. She also stopped being a brat and became devoted to him. So I don’t understand why so many people think the ending Li Congxin and QingRu got was the worst fate for him when he ended up with a wife who is solely devoted to him. Qingyuan doesn’t even love him a bit, and the chances of her falling for him are zero. So his ending is better than what he was trying to get for himself, except for the death of his father.
As for the drama itself, it definitely has narrative issues that doesn't give us the satisfying revenge after the buildup it built till ep 24 and the shift was abrupt and things happen too fast.
I'd give:
EP 1-24: 8.9
EP 25: 6.5
EP 26-30: 7.8
I am not saying the FL and ML are blameless, but this comment is specifically about the SML.