Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 4 hours ago
  • Gender: Male
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: July 24, 2023
On A Love Other than Yours • 23 days ago
For me, my greatest concern is Namgung's secret. The one he has to tell Su A if she can look at him for 10 seconds and get over him. I know it's coming. My hope is that the secret he's keeping is something like Mido's father's last words. A promise that he made Namgung swear to keep or something like that.

However, I keep worrying that the writer is going to make it something bad. Something that assassinates Namgung's character and makes Mido the tragic victim.

I swear to god. If this writer rug pulls me at the last second after making me feel sorry for this guy for the past 6 weeks...
7 5
Replying to MatCap • 23 days ago
> MiDo & TaeSeung share a goodbye kiss The thought crossed my mind. If it happens, the show would be dead…
I've thought about it (had a nice shower 🙂️) and I really don't think a kiss between Mido and Tae Seung is going to happen. Not if they intend for her to go back to Namgung.

Here are my reasons. Think about what this drama has shown us regarding Mido kissing Tae Seung.

The first time she kissed him, it led to the intense clashes between her and Namgung in Episode 7 and her eventual suicide attempt.

The second time, when Tae Seung came close to kissing her in Episode 12, she stopped him because she didn't want to feel even more guilt towards Namgung.

With these scenes, the story has established that kissing Tae Seung is bad for Mido's relationship with Namgung. It simply doesn't make sense for her to do it now if they intend for them to reunite.

...However.

I have been bitching in these comments about the inconsistency of Mido's character, and the times she has contradicted herself in quite meaningful ways. There's no reason why she can't do it again.

But still, another kiss after this would be one HUGE fucking contradiction.
2 2
Replying to MatCap • 23 days ago
> I don’t know if the writer hates womenI'm just curious. If Namgung were the one getting 'trashed', as you…
Sure.
0 0
Replying to TH0121 • 23 days ago
As someone whos firmly team main leads...Idk how id take it if MiDo & TaeSeung share a goodbye kiss only for…
> MiDo & TaeSeung share a goodbye kiss

The thought crossed my mind. If it happens, the show would be dead to me. Lol. Wouldn't feel like I'd won at all.

> They trick us every time.
This is why I'm a quite guarded entering these last two episodes. If I have to, I'll create a proper ending in my head, give this story the rating it deserves, and move on with my life.

But not before making note of everyone who had anything to do with this story, of course. 🙂️
2 4
Replying to changemysoul • 23 days ago
In the end, I think I want Mido to have a happening ending….Because I deserve it. I don’t know if the writer…
> I don’t know if the writer hates women

I'm just curious.

If Namgung were the one getting 'trashed', as you say, instead of Mido, would you conclude that the writer possibly hates men?
10 4
Replying to 16106004 • 23 days ago
Where did you pick up on that?
Sorry. Did I get the names wrong?

I'm talking about the girl he asked out on a date in the earlier episodes. The one he bought roses for, but didn't give them to her because she already had a guy with her.

I remember one of the characters saying that Minjae studied really hard just to get into the same college as her. Am I misremembering?
0 2
On Between Steps • 23 days ago
Can anyone tell me if Seo Hyeon has found out that Minjae had a crush on her, or if it looks like she might find out?

For some reason, that is the only part of this story that I find interesting. Everything else (up to Episode 6) annoys me. 😅️
0 4
Replying to MatCap • 23 days ago
I knew there was a problem with the writing when they had her attempt suicide and then promptly forgot about it…
...🤨️
Jesus. Calm down. You clearly misread something because you're reaction doesn't match the flow of the convo.
1 1
Replying to DdDIbi • 23 days ago
What are your predictions? As a percentage? HO getting back together with Mido, HO moving forward with SUA, HO…
No clue, honestly. Can't tell what this writer is going to do.

- Mido and Tae Seung (aka Gwan U) is the most undesirable outcome to me. It would genuinely piss me off. I hate the 'cheating = happiness' message.

- Su A and Namgung together seems unlikely. I expect the story to make her follow through with the '10 second eye-contact' thing and have her get over Namgung (though I expect her to be lying when she does it).

- Namgung and Mido back together seems kinda likely. If they split in the next episode, I'd pretty much expect them to reunite in the finale.

But maybe the writer will go for the bittersweet 'everybody fucks off in a different direction' ending. Who knows?

Though, I have to admit, I re-watched Episodes 1 & 2 recently and the idea of Namgung and Mido's relationship dying like this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Even though Mido annoys me in many ways. Depending on how they do it, this is one time a cliche 'love conquers all' ending wouldn't bother me that much...

Sue me. 😕️


I dunno. I'm conflicted.
2 0
Replying to MatCap • 23 days ago
I knew there was a problem with the writing when they had her attempt suicide and then promptly forgot about it…
Nope. Instead, he told her to go get laid by the guy she cheated on him with. 🤣️

Thinking about that used to piss me off, but I'm actually starting to find it kinda funny. 😆️
5 3
Replying to infinitestar • 23 days ago
I’m disappointed in what they did with mido’s character. She had potential in the 1st few episodes of being…
I knew there was a problem with the writing when they had her attempt suicide and then promptly forgot about it like it never happened in the following episodes. 🤣️
5 8
Replying to MatCap • 23 days ago
Title A Love Other than Yours Spoiler
I think that, no matter happens in Episode 13, there are going to be a whole lot of people who drop this show…
I may be laughing, but it's really not funny. 😕️
5 0
On A Love Other than Yours • 23 days ago
I think that, no matter happens in Episode 13, there are going to be a whole lot of people who drop this show and give it a 1 star rating for making them waste 7 weeks of their lives. 😂️😂️😂️
5 9
Replying to Stephen Bowman • 23 days ago
I feel I am losing brain cells lol people trying to excuse Mido drunken kiss as not cheating
Still?
God, people really seem to be determined to die on that hill.
4 1
Replying to AA2024 • 23 days ago
Title A Love Other than Yours Spoiler
About that scene: I got the completely opposite foreshadow = TS will intentionally fail the order he got (conning…
I wasn't talking about the villagers. I was talking about his 'alliance' with Su A next episode. I'm hoping that he over steps by trying to split Mido and Namgung up. Possibly by telling Namgung Mido's secret in a way that causes him to spiral.

We'll see, though.
0 1
Replying to DemonSlayer • 24 days ago
just came to comment 7.1 🤣🤣🤣🤭🤭🤭
Down and down and down it goes. Where it stops, nobody knows.
5 0
Replying to 11228 • 24 days ago
Title A Love Other than Yours Spoiler
I just see it as Mido liking the symbolism of her relationship with Namgung rather than the relationship (romantic)…
If I may be so bold, reading your response, it sounds like you've fallen victim to the poor execution of the story and lost sight of the intent. Several of your points don't reflect the content of the story at all.

> [She] was already emotionally checked out by the time the story picked up, asking for a breakup
Checked out, huh? In that first breakup scene, she was clearly forcing herself the entire time and broke down crying immediately after Namgung left.
No. She wasn't 'checked out'. If you listen to her in Episodes 1, 2 & 7, she was actually afraid of a FUTURE where that would eventually happen. And of becoming a burden to him. Breaking up with Namgung was a preemptive move made out of fear.

> She fought with Su A because she sees Namgung as her own.
Agreed. But you're twisting it into something negative. Possessiveness is normal for anyone in a relationship when they feel that relationship is being threatened. Is it hypocritical for Mido to feel that way in that moment? Yup. But she snaps out of it later.

>He can only draw for Mido, you see
Another thing that isn't found anywhere in the story. Unless I'm forgetting something, she placed no such limit on Namgung's drawings.

> she came around and gave Namgung her blessing to see have feelings to Su A. Yet another show of her passiveness over him. She thinks she can dictate how he FEELS.

You need to watch Episode 8 again. Mido is well aware of the influence she has over Namgung and explicitly states that it's a bad thing. Seriously, go watch their fight in the mudflats again and listen to what is said. She told Namgung to not like Su A in Episode 11 out of fear that she was genuinely losing him as an exclusive romantic partner. Then she came to her senses and took it back because she knows that her words hold a lot of weight with Namgung (again, see Episode 8). This pain is what she wanted because it's the same pain she caused him.

> She hasn't done anything to fight for the actual relationship.

???

Everything she has done from Episode 8 forward has been her fighting for the relationship. She's doing it in a strange K-dramaLand way, but she's undeniably doing it.

First, she tried to talk Namgung out of letting her sleep with Tae Seung. When that failed, she started the one-month separation to give Namgung the chance to hurt her back and make everything even. She had no intention of dating Tae Seung seriously. What she said to Tae Seung in Episodes 9 & 10 and her refusal to kiss him in Episode 12 are more evidence of that. If her intent isn't to keep Namgung romantically, why go through all of this when she has already shown earlier in the story that she is more than willing to breakup with him?

To be clear, I'm not saying Mido doesn't have serious problems worthy of heavy criticism. But the execution of the story is making her out to be worse than she is. Especially when it comes to her feelings for Namgung.

But it's true that I might be giving the writer too much credit. As a writer myself, I can't help but look at the story in its entirety and try to see how it all works together because that's exactly how I craft my own stories. And while I strive to do my best, I also understand that what I intend to do with a story doesn't always match my execution of it. I'm also beginning to wonder if the writer had full control over the progression of this story, or if outside parties added things that weren't in her original vision. It would explain a lot.

But this is all just my opinion. I could be wrong. 2 episodes left. Yadda yadda yadda. You know the drill.
1 1
On A Love Other than Yours • 24 days ago
One last thing...

Regarding the scene in Episode 12 where Mido practically begs Tae Seung not to make her regret having feelings for him (🤢️🤮️, btw), I'm hoping this is foreshadowing. I'm hoping that's exactly what he's going to do in the next episode. This might be a faint hope, but it's all I have left after letting myself get roped into this story.

I swear, this might be the last time I watch a drama while it's airing.😅️

The arguments have been fun, though. 🙂️
5 3
On A Love Other than Yours • 24 days ago
I know I'm beating a dead horse here (😅️), but I just had another thought about the 'Tae Seung picture ripping' scene, and it's even worse than I first made it out to be.

In Episode 2, after the break up, Namgung is seen throwing out all the things he owns that represent his relationship with Mido. Later in that same episode, he sees that a homeless person has gotten a hold of them.

Here's the important part. At the end of that episode, Mido is walking on an overpass when she sees the homeless person with all of Namgung's thrown out stuff. She runs to catch up with the homeless person. Desperately. You can see how important these THINGS are to her, and what they represent, from the look on her face. She even risks getting hit by the passing cars just to get closer to these THINGS.

Then, in Episode 7, we see another scene where she painstakingly glues the shattered picture of her and Namgung back together, cutting her fingers in the process.

So we have two clear examples of what the THINGS that represent Mido's relationship with Namgung mean to her. Not just their 28 year bond, but their time as a couple.

...Then we have the picture ripping scene at the restaurant. Where Tae Seung destroys one of those THINGS right in front of her.

In the episodes before this scene, we are shown that Mido is willing to risk her own body to protect these THINGS; walking into traffic and cutting her fingers. But here, she does nothing.

One could argue that this was evidence that her love for Namgung was fading, but the scene in Episode 11 where she physically fights Su A for Namgung's drawing (another THING) directly contradicts that.

To me, this is just another example of one of my criticisms of this drama: the INTENT of the story clashing with the EXECUTION. Even though I know the former is what I'm supposed to be taking away from the story, the latter consistently and repeatedly undermines it.

The EXECUTION of the restaurant scene is meant to make Su A's character look good, but they sacrifice the INTENT behind Mido's character to do it.

I suspect that this messiness, this repeated clashing between the INTENT and EXECUTION of this story, is one of the reasons so many are frustrated with it. The story says one thing and the characters usually agree. But then they'll randomly do something different out of nowhere just for shock value or to push the narrative forward. Sorry if you like that shit, but it's evidence of poor writing/directing.

Mido ending up with Tae Seung would be another example of the story abandoning the INTENT behind her character as shown by her own actions. Something the writer could only explain with a significant time skip. If that happens, I predict the MDL rating for this show will drop below 6.

I know I would personally contribute to that. 🙂️
5 4