Melim87

Realised that 11 aka Gabriel isnt related to YJ and his sis. Ah so its a case of hwc bros vs adopted bro rsj.

Qns to ask
Is rsh protecting hwc bro or in cahoots with any?
What else does he know? Does he alr know the identity of the "no 13"?
No 13 is YJ and they say YJ is dead and 12's leg was hurt. So where is 12 now and is 24 really dead?

11 so handsome kid so not hard to guess who the most handsome around haha.

is the wedding hall thin black figure jis specy guy?

Did the fall make him turn violent? Neurological imbalance. And rsh been telling him his life story till he got confused? Poor mixed up kid. Rsh tries to save him coz rsh dont wanna be associated with hwc to maintain neutrality as judge? Still think kinda sadist that rsj suffer so much...when he need not have to. Would ppl target rsj knowing who his mother is? The "ruthless" judge as baek called her that himself. Is someone(or ppl) also taking revenge against rsjs mother by torturing him?

Or maybe fan girl her will come out of nowhere and rescue her crush. Ahhhh

Ah thats why rsh smirked when the mum begged him to save sj in ep 9..coz is biological child? And he knows his place as the adopted son.

Charles 13 not jis 13? Shall watch tmr for clues

When u see ep 10 and what she did was so cringe lol

Ep 10 came along nicely and we see more of jis and ej mother. The theme now: biological/ blood brothers vs adopted bros? Loyalties of no 11

Girl got a fan crush

Wow some of our theories here are true. Well done. (Watching ep 10)

I think ha seok jin acting's is really solid. Very nuanced and layered performance. He finally shows he has repressed emotions

Handsome ha seok jin. Jokes aside she feels he has secrets and got something to hide

My thought is the trailer showed a bit like rsh face and him ambushing her maybe he meant to protect her as he is one upping the killer trying to predict the next move. Jis and rsh know she is going to talk to the nun and get more info and both looking sus...n whose grave did they visit? Yoon jae's, no 24 or the sis? Did the nun tell them about locale

Young kid no. 12 has a mum..in sung's long lost mum is inn owner? How about we turn it such that 12 is in sung and 13 is charles? With split personality? Not much age gap with these two.

Wow i like your thinking and analysis. U analyse better than rsj ! Haha according to relationship chart rsh ath r 35 and the rest below 32

Hi! Just wonder whats your take if rsh is really 11 he should know rsj isnt 13. He does try to protect rsj as a bro and the affection seems genuine. I do think he has many secrets he is unable to reveal and is a tortured soul.

Hi emma i thought he seems more like no 11 given the age and personality. dont think it will be so easy and he is the killer, its half way mark of the show. I felt he portrayed genuine sadness at ath death and the closeness of the pact in the past. Maybe someone copied his shoe style. No 13 could be in sung split personality good boy and psycho? Maybe he hack into his shopping website and knows the kind of shoes rsh bought and wear

He just acting smarty pants with smarmy look throughout the show. Unpardonable sin for being an ass**** and may the poor boi rip

Uncuffing baek alone was the biggest mistake and agree his due punishment for being a spineless puppet

Rsh charles and in sung? 11 12 13 trying to figure out how in sung can get a bloodied lip. Sj - may not be any? I get the sense that rsh feelings for ath were real and he is not the killer. (He isnt acting the tears) while the shot of hisshoes seem a bit red herring, could someone have copied his style? With 6 more episodes doubt it is so easy for him to be the culprit and how he got the drone footage isnt revealed. And who would fly a drone then? The stupidest thing det kang did was to uncuff baek. The culprit(s) is/are getting back at people the law cannot touch- pol chief, baek... vengeful no. 13

Rsh showing a lot of emotions for ath death and also the scene with in sung..a man with secrets. Tot rsh is no 11. For now the director wants us to think he could be the guy who knocked out rsj with tranquilizer given the shoe. Could it be mr choi finally recognized him as boy (my guess is 11) and died of respir shock? Hsj acting is getting better and better. It is a tough role but dude nailed each and every scene so well

Mouse only had that few characters to pick ;). Blind is more like cluedo style or agatha christie's mystery. Actually she had a mystery the twist part was like mouse.