Funny, but for me, it's anticlimax when finally Jason reveal his psycho side, rather than scary, he looks…
Bolin Chen being so sticky sweet was the clue that he was the killer! I actually felt he was so much real when his action/killer side kicked in - but it was like he was in another movie entirely. Not the funny rom com the others were in!
Lee Jong Hyun is totally a living sculpture!
yes, what happened to Yoon Jin Yi? she was really great in Gentleman's Dignity.
Lee Min Hyuk, he knows fanservice. he knows how to make a girl's heart beat
just my opinion; honestly, i can't believe you're comparing these two!
Shine or Go Crazy was so boring i dropped it at about ep.5. and it was a time i was so hungry for a K-drama. on the other hand, Scarlet Heart started when i was already very satisfied with 6 Flying Dragons and didn't expect to enjoy a historical anytime soon; much less one with many idols! but Ryeo surprised me. yet i fully enjoyed every single minute of it. specially that one particular episode we all know.
Ha Neul's Smile in the end is just too perfect and dazzling! gosh the memories!! I certainly cannot agree with Jang Hyuk being better than Lee Joon Ki! I'm just that biased over Joon Ki! But I could say the cast of Scarlet Heart Ryeo was really something else! with so many powerful and talented actors and actresses gathered together, you couldn't expect less from them <3 <3
moon lovers would win for me. i love jang hyuk but for me he dint fit as wang so, it was not about acting though. where as lee joon ki was perfect for wang so he started so pathetic and person with no confidence to developing into someone with confidence and who does not give a damn to what people think about him later. sorry to say but even in acting i would give props to lee joon ki in this comparision delivering those expressions with a mask and specially when camera is put two feets away from your face is marvellous. and the sparks of crzy gwangjong that shined through lee joon ki wins
while female lead i would give it to the actress from SOGC its not that IU is bad but she gives some awkward shots which degrades her good acting actually and about chemistry i think both the pairs had wonderful chemistry , its just the character of rouxi or hae soo is presented in the novel as some one who does not fully trust the 4th and there the downfall begin so i can not have any complains about that.
hwangbo yeon hwa definitely would go to SOGC. kang hana was good but she was not given much time to portray.
the rest of the supporting cast of scarlet definitely wins for me
for 8 th prince lim ju hwan wins because ha neul could not make the ambitious side of his character shine as much as his romantic side.
story telling wise i preferd moon lovers, i skipped alot while watching SOGC
i must be in minority but even the ending of moon lovers wins for me its kind of impossible ending but still a hope which leaves you asking more.
actually it felt like there is more to moon lovers because many things were untold and may be were planned to reveal in next season because there were a lot of hints about it in the show that is why i think directing and even editing is genius in moonlovers.
and i agree with jun ki being pegion holed because any one who has seen his king and the clown, two weeks, time between dog and wolf, iljimae and scarlet heart will definetly know that he is A++++ actor but he still has lot of chances to change his image because he still relevant popularity wise and i think its changing. just like jang hyuk was pegion holed but his last project was great even though it dint became popular
To be honest, I did like Scarlet Heart (even against the sickening marry-your-own-sis politics and everything) and hasn't seen Shine or Go Crazy yet...but one thing I can say for IU's part is that it never got me.It looked like the character was going though a bi-polar disorder...
1 
yes, what happened to Yoon Jin Yi? she was really great in Gentleman's Dignity.
Lee Min Hyuk, he knows fanservice. he knows how to make a girl's heart beat
Shine or Go Crazy was so boring i dropped it at about ep.5. and it was a time i was so hungry for a K-drama. on the other hand, Scarlet Heart started when i was already very satisfied with 6 Flying Dragons and didn't expect to enjoy a historical anytime soon; much less one with many idols! but Ryeo surprised me. yet i fully enjoyed every single minute of it. specially that one particular episode we all know.
while female lead i would give it to the actress from SOGC its not that IU is bad but she gives some awkward shots which degrades her good acting actually and about chemistry i think both the pairs had wonderful chemistry , its just the character of rouxi or hae soo is presented in the novel as some one who does not fully trust the 4th and there the downfall begin so i can not have any complains about that.
hwangbo yeon hwa definitely would go to SOGC. kang hana was good but she was not given much time to portray.
the rest of the supporting cast of scarlet definitely wins for me
for 8 th prince lim ju hwan wins because ha neul could not make the ambitious side of his character shine as much as his romantic side.
story telling wise i preferd moon lovers, i skipped alot while watching SOGC
i must be in minority but even the ending of moon lovers wins for me its kind of impossible ending but still a hope which leaves you asking more.
actually it felt like there is more to moon lovers because many things were untold and may be were planned to reveal in next season because there were a lot of hints about it in the show that is why i think directing and even editing is genius in moonlovers.