1
Foremost, the team of "mad dogs" is ultimately what keeps the series entertaining enough. Especially when the leads were pretty much a perfect cast for their characters. The overall plot itself also has enough twists and turns to keep the viewer intrigued, even if the details don't always make sense and the decisions are sometimes questionable. There's enough fast-paced action here where there really isn't much room to fast-forward on and it thankfully doesn't have any sappy romance.
Although I've dropped other series that have similar flaws, this one was just fun to watch. After all, the focus wasn't meant to be around forensics or detective work but on the woven relationships of the characters. It's like watching a comic book movie of a super-hero team made up of criminals. If it consisted of more than the 11 episodes, then maybe they could have incorporated more depth. The ending felt rushed but still left me wanting to see more of them in action again.
Was this review helpful to you?
This series had its flaws but the specialness of it does a lot to override it and it exceeded expectations. This isn't one of your typical crime/suspense dramas where there are cool dudes or evil villains. In fact, having watched so many action-driven series prior to this, it took a bit to get used to this type of pacing (in a good way). The only way I can describe it is that it is closer to "real-time" pacing, where it gives off a "slice of life" feel despite its darker atmosphere.
The script is done wonderfully and is loaded with insight. I couldn't figure out which male lead I was empathizing with as it kept me switching back and forth until it neared the end when I thought I knew, and then it messed me up again. The female lead felt a bit one-toned for a large portion of the story but boy, was I appreciative of her presence. Almost all of your characters are humanized with realistic gray tones. I won't go into the plot details because I made the mistake of reading what was stated as a minor spoiler, only to realize it ruined quite a bit of what could have been a nice unique surprise.
The negatives for me that hurt the series was they spent too much time on emotional lingering with at least a couple of scenes an episode. I did fast-forward a bit on these sections and some repeated flashbacks but not in the areas of dialogue. The only other negative was the video shots weren't great and took some getting used to.
Don't go into this one expecting gruesome serial killings or exaggerated supernatural powers. This is actually another reason why it was done so well. It didn't need this to build up emotional intensity or suspense. I'm also confused as to why some state this one has no romance. Sure, there wasn't your sappy/tragic type of love story and it wasn't the main focus, but it is most definitely there.
I recommend this series if you are the type who values content over flashy. It isn't episodic in crime-solving but rather a movement across multiple crimes that all gather under one umbrella.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Overhyped and confused
I almost dropped the series multiple times for a number of reasons. But there was just enough of a plot where you felt the need to see it through its conclusion. This should be labeled a romance series that is also trying to imitate drama/comedy/action/politics but just ends up imbalanced.Negatives:
-- The initial premise was intriguing but dwindles rapidly into a full-on love story where the main leads are like high school kids continually flirting with one another.
-- The main male lead is depicted initially as a ruthless leader with a lifelong grudge. Yet they do a slow motion shot of him pretty much falling in love at first sight, which really diminishes his character and his passion from the onset.
-- While I'm all for an intellectual and capable female lead, they went unrealistically overboard with her character. So much so that apparently, the accomplished male leader who led wars and ruled over clans for years suddenly needs constant saving from her.
-- Then the pet peeve of mine that occurs across multiple similar series. When someone is supposed to be a war veteran, etc. who are used to getting wounded and then when they get a paper-cut at some point, a huge deal is made about it. They also didn't budget much on the visual of the wounds.
-- The relationship with the couple is supposed to be unique in the sense that they are enemies, but it's not much different than any other arranged marriages with trust issues. They mush for each other so quickly that it's utterly unconvincing.
-- The series throws in a few graphic scenes of violence and death, lots of lighthearted and fun banter, tons of sappy romance, political manipulation and some war action. It's as if it tried to take little pieces of what made other series successful and forced it together awkwardly.
Positives:
-- The positives also come from the negative listed in the last bullet above. The few graphic scenes does emphasize the seriousness in the grudges, the fun banter between the characters does create chemistry and comradery, and there are some romantic development scenes that are humorous.
-- There are many familiar faces in the series who do a good job in their roles though not at the level of truly seasoned actors. And while Song Zu Er's acting for me was subpar in The Demon Hunter's Romance, she shows a bit more range in this one.
If you're into the romance genre, can definitely see this one being rated on the higher end. But if you're expecting more serious undertones, unpredictability, or action, this is probably not it. There was a lot of potential with this one if they were able to properly balance the different elements or just stayed in one lane. I completed this one with a good amount of fast-forwarding.
Was this review helpful to you?
I appreciate the attempt to bring to light various forms of abuse and its various lasting effects through adulthood no matter how stable one's life turns out. Also appreciate the highlighting that not all victims are saints themselves as everyone has their own type of sin.
However, while I'm not one who minds the slower-paced type of series/movies. This one just felt like a slow-pacing in circles over and over again. The actors were awfully bland even for a somber setting. Making it through over half of the episodes (with lots of fast-forwarding), there is pretty much zero character development. The female lead's character feels so one-note that I've grown annoyed by her screen time. Despite the trauma she's apparently gone through, she is really just selfish and self-righteous underneath her overbearing gentleness and occasional rage. For a child psychologist, she really doesn't have much empathy. It would have been fine if she was given any type of personality growth by now in the series. If the expressions on the majority of the actors didn't feel like permanent Botox, it might have worked better. The only actor that pushed the episodes along was really the main detective.
Was this review helpful to you?
The first few episodes were a bit lackluster as the tragedies were done in an over-simplified and overly dramatic way. But it does start to pick up in quality once the king comes into the picture. What makes this series a bit different from some in this genre is that although there are the usual politics, it doesn't feel quite as heavy. It helps that there are plenty of humorous characters and moments to help break up it up. There is also a unique incorporation of a women-only investigative team, so there is some "detective" aspect to it as well.
The majority of the actors does a great job in their respective roles. I want to list them all to emphasize this but there's just too many. Instead I'll discuss the only actor that was obviously mediocre, and she happens to be one the series is titled after.
The Dong Yi character stayed relatively flat even when her status changes and although I think this was intentional, it gets old. This may not have been as glaring if the actress was better with micro-expressions or was more versatile with them. She makes the same few expressions ALL the time no matter what the situation is and it becomes more and more noticeable. It didn't help when they used a freeze frame of her with her usual eyes wide opened at the end of most episodes. Why they thought this would be a good cliffhanger is beyond me.
The other aspects that are off is how no one ages appropriately and time skips are pretty abrupt. As an example, one minute someone stated they were pregnant and minutes later, the baby was in their arms. Some portions of the episodes are binge-worthy and sometimes there is a a bit of a drag but it does move along.
Don't let this deter you from giving this one a try though especially if the female lead doesn't bother you as much as it did for me. Although she was a bit mono-toned, she's surrounded by many interesting characters that make up for it.
Was this review helpful to you?
The series was a solid 9.0 until around episode 30. This is when the plot takes a turn down soap opera lane a bit. They tried too hard to link everyone into having some type of familial relationship with one another which made it unrealistic with no added value. The other lesser negative is the unrealistic gun fight scenes and the unnecessary slow-motion effects during the other fight scenes. Otherwise, the action blend could have shone more.
Nevertheless, I was drawn in mainly by our two male leads from the very first episode. The contrast and underlying similarities between them created a chemistry that was addictive and fun. Cheng Feng Tai, is the true star here. He was able to portray the complexity of having to transition into multiple faces very well (and admittedly, his dimpled smile is too good). Shang Xi Rui comes as a close runner-up and I really adore the both of them on screen. There were also plenty of witty supporting characters such as Cao Gui Xiu and Du Qi who only added to the charm of the series.
There is a good surface attempt to explain the life route of opera singers, the royal family having fallen, and when Japan began its invasion. But for me personally, having read and seen many films and books that really dive hard into these events, these are just a backdrop to the ultimate love story in this series. And although I can't forgive the suffering Japan caused (read The Rape of Nanking or watch the documentary), I do appreciate that they didn't portray all the people of Japan as willing enemies.
There are some flaws that can't be overlooked with some parts of the plot and some loose ends that were never explained but everything else was done really well including the design set and outfits for the era and the incorporation of a bit of just everything. If there were some physical touch present between the leads (even if just hand-holding), I think it would have upped it by a notch. Although I took off some points for the mentioned factors, let's just say this is one of the series I made the effort to download for keeps.
Was this review helpful to you?
Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty II To the West
2 people found this review helpful
This review may contain spoilers
Still binge-worthy but...
Very happy to state that season two was done well enough to remain binge-worthy for those who enjoyed season one.However, there are some reductions in quality that I'm hoping doesn't get carried forward into the next season.
- The charisma between the team is starting to lose its appeal. There has been absolutely zero character growth and everyone's personality is growing a little stale. There is also a subtle feeling of trying to force upon the importance of each member in the crew. After so many episodes, I get it already. Pei Xi is great at drawing and Ying Tao is a backup bodyguard who is just average in comparison to Lu Li Feng, and Fei is a miracle healer. How many times does Su Wu Ming need to complement them for doing exactly what they've always done? The worst part is when they tried to suddenly get the whole crew to play detective in the last arc and Ying Tao is hinted at being Su Wu Ming's apprentice? The best character in the series was Su Wu Ming and all of this has really diluted him.
- While the overall mysteries are still quite interesting, the actual investigation and autopsies are no longer given as much detail and emphasis anymore. On multiple occasions, apparently despite Su Wu Ming having conducted his autopsies, he misses relatively key areas for some reason that required multiple additional autopsies. This again, takes a lot away from his character and his character's abilities.
- And while I'm not a big fan of any heavy-handedness on romance, the interactions between the couples (particularly in this season) has no charisma and the occasional reminder of them being a couple really adds no value.
Hoping in the next season, they try to implement more character growth. Also hope they don't continue to try to muddle the dynamic by getting everyone on the team to suddenly become master detectives. It would be like trying to suddenly turn Su Wu Ming into a master swordsman. Nevertheless, season two was still worth the watch despite the slight trailing off near the end.
Was this review helpful to you?
Somehow Captivating
This review comes from a re-watch a couple of years after the first run. As with many of the newer historical dramas, it isn't without its common flaws. So why the higher score despite some shortcomings? Because it was fun to watch the first time and was still fun to watch the second time.- Even if the acting is slightly cringe at times, the chemistry still manages to work and you'll still laugh out loud, then shed a few tears, and go back to laughing again. Xiao Zhan also does a good job in keeping the momentum going.
- Even if there are some plot holes and inconsistencies, the story and twists were well-paced and interesting enough to keep you wanting to get to the next episode even when it's already past midnight.
- Even if the action scenes are flimsy at times, it's too late to care because you're already drawn in to the plot.
- Even if the dramatizations can get a bit much as usual, it actually works well here for the comedy relief which balances out the grimmer undertones.
Despite having dropped other series for less, this one just manages to blend itself well. For a fairly long drama, it surprisingly had minimal draggy moments because the plot usually shifts when it threatens to reach that point. The underlying morals Asian films usually try to incorporate, is actually much more realistically done in this one. And although I don't agree with the romantic censorship, it works out well for me personally because romantic subtleties are usually much more meaningful.
Overall, it is a memorable one and it makes me think the novel must really be great.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
This one is a rough one. I was considering dropping it after the first few episodes because of our leads. This is no fault to the actors themselves but the male lead just didn't quite fit the role he played though it's still passable. The female lead's role was (yet again) written as a cutesy character who's obsessed with the "cold bad boy" but is just incompetent and unprofessional if you pay attention to what value she brings supposedly as a cop of a special team. Sigh to the Asian draw towards having to incorporate the "cute" even when it doesn't work for the genre, but at least she doesn't wear high heels on the job.The blend of the crime and romance aspects of the series feels forced/confused as if they didn't know which one to focus on. Then the humor and lightheartedness that was sprinkled on would have worked if it wasn't sometimes done with bad timing. There also wasn't too much chemistry between the two leads and the number of times they made him lean flirtatiously into her face to apparently make her feel uncomfortable (try counting the times) just became an irritating thing to watch. What is also up with the male lead and his alternating of two hairstyles? At first I thought they were attempting to use it to differentiate between the past and the current, but no. Choosing just one or the other would have worked a lot better for the purpose of the character.
Despite all the above however and while the crime aspect wasn't amazing, there is an interesting overall mystery with the male lead's backstory and where it leads. The rest of the supporting cast did a really good job to keep me focused so I quite enjoyed it while skipping the majority of screen time of the female lead.
The concept of society blaming and looking down on (in hypocrisy) the "monsters" they've created themselves is quite evident here which I love. Nothing to do with the actual plot. but let's say a group of children were raised in an environment where murder was as normal and natural as eating a meal, would it be moral to blame the children for living in the same fashion? Then let's say, a few of those children were fortunate enough to later be placed into a gentler and warmer environment, and learned they can feel and live a different way. Would it be moral to punish them for their past deeds from their prior environment? And then to add to the complexity, what if some of those children were just born and wired a certain way?
The strange empathy you may feel for what should be the "monsters" in this is what hits the spot. Who's the one who's really ignorant? Who's moral and who's self-justifying on their own learned morals?
It is definitely very unfortunate that outside of a great underlying plot, the series couldn't pull it off better.
Was this review helpful to you?
Brotherhoods galore
I had tired of watching overly heavy themes and wanted something for a casual watch -- so what better than a young and good-looking cast that emphasizes on brotherhood to fulfill this? Of course, because of what it is, I also highly expected to drop this relatively quickly. But the fact that while this isn't a particularly sophisticated crew of actors and the dialogue is rudimentary, it still turned out to be unexpectedly entertaining.It truly is a series that revolves around many brotherhoods and thankfully does not include sappy romances. Although the direction of the plot and dialogue were underdeveloped and oversimplified, the plot flow was actually done quite well. Enough to keep me interested in heading toward the next episode, kept me rooting for the different bonds, and even had me shed some tears. Don't be fooled by the initial episodes of charm because it does start to twist into an unexpected and darker direction which gives it more flavor than others of a similar plot base.
While this isn't a masterpiece and there are the usual number of flaws, it still deserves kudos for being able to maintain its direction and for still being able to paint the story well enough. I would recommend for those who particularly enjoy brotherhood bonds and I'm quite surprised that at the time of my review in May 2026, there's only four other reviews. Compared to some other newer series that I've dropped, this would make this one pretty underrated.
Was this review helpful to you?
Addicting
This is one that has felt incredibly satisfying from start to end. An overpowered ML who grants punishment left and right to vicious characters around him. What I love about the ML is his nonchalant personality while maintaining absolute awareness. He isn't one who annoyingly falls in love at first site over a pretty woman nor is he overly righteous as with some other characters. So it's quite refreshing to watch how he wins those around him over and how he metes out retribution. While I'm not always a fan of overpowered characters who have little need for character development, it's not a problem here because he's the trigger for creating character development for everyone around him.The only real drawback for me here was the action scenes and the special effects were pretty lackluster. But the lore was intriguing enough and the plot flow was great. I found myself halfway through the episodes already saddened by how few remaining episodes there were. I even attempted to check out the animation to potentially continue the story but on a side-by-side scene comparison, the live action one was definitely the better of the two for me. So it's really a shame there hasn't been another season yet after three years.
Although the story is incomplete, they ended it well without some crazy cliffhanger - with exception of the last female on scene who might be the only annoying character so far. I highly recommend for those who actually enjoy a good plot rather than just a high-budget production piece with idol actors who can't act at all.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A crime genre overlayed with charm and silliness
This was an entertaining and charming series that encounter multiple crime arcs with our group of feisty individuals. The main character highlight would be Dongbang Yu Bin who really showed great leadership over the team. The pacing was pretty steady with each arc taking up two or three episodes. The crimes themselves were somber but the approach to resolving them included a mixture of over-the-top humor as well as a more intricate analysis from Dongbang. I appreciated how they highlighted the clues to his method allowing the audience to actually think for themselves a little.As for the team, my biggest gripe is how little character development there was with them. It would have been great to have seen a more toned down incompetence with the new leadership. But at the same time, their flaws also makes them quite realistic as it's hard for people to change. The leadership approach from Dongbang is also really well done. He doesn't try to change them and never even really punishes them for their mistakes. Instead, he finds ways to work with their strengths and simply accepts their weaknesses. Nevertheless, it seems the producers just wanted to really emphasize the humorous aspect to it instead of finding a better balance. With this note, they also could have toned down on the bodily function scenes because after the first or second time, it stopped being funny.
Overall, this is a good series to pick up if you want to see a feel-good team bond who tackles multiple crime scenarios and have a few laughs along the way.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Silly, with no other solid categorization
The series started enjoyable with lots of silliness and with an adventure RPG feel. The ML has distinctive eyebrows so I recognize him from the recently watched Moonlit Reunion. He does a much better job in this series and is also much more charming. Not sure why so many reviewers are bashing on the appearance of the FL. I actually think she was a great cast for her role and unlike some other master/disciple romances, this ML/FL pairing made this part of their relationship very believable.Not familiar with the novel but this series is hard to define into any particular category. The clearest part of the plot is the ML growing in his cultivation with the friends he meets along the way. But otherwise, it actually felt more like a slice-of-life than an adventure or typical wuxia story. A lot of it consisted of the characters lifestyles and bantering with one another. There were a decent amount of action scenes but these were pretty poorly done. The underlying story of the sect and the unraveling of the main antagonist moved along in a zigzag manner on a path full of potholes.
Ironically, the best part of this for me was the FL and how her character is the type who hides her grief and pain behind a paradoxical real facade. The subtleties of when the relationship began to change for the FL/ML was good but it wasn't highlighted enough for it to maximize the impact. I sped through a large portion of the series only to finally get a slightly satisfying moment between the two at the end. Would recommend this only to those who are in the mood for mostly humor and the adventure RPG feel, with no expectations of a very in-depth plot. And if you're looking for real action, this one might be too slow paced.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Underrated
After a few episodes, I was so happy to finally find a series that really satisfied a craving that's been ongoing. It started off with such detailed humor and intellectual lightheartedness. The ML is a great cast for his role because he is capable of emoting different characteristics. Then there's the FL with her naivety and sweetness, a character type that I usually do not care for at all but with this one - she was super charming. With the ML's talent that balances on a thin line that can cross from light to dark, she was absolutely needed and perfect for him.I love the uniqueness in how he grew his talents from mingling with prisoners and how he influences those around him. He's not one of those unrealistic and idealistic "always righteous" protagonists who bore you to death. He's someone who lives by his own standards and whims, whether they are always right or not, and someone who cares more about intentions and end goals. He's also capable of real empathy and not the flimsy judgemental type. The supporting cast were also very unique in their own way and they all mesh very well with one another.
The story is also quite unique in how he crosses between two very different cultural and judicial branches within the empire. So while the plot is political heavy, it's not your standard one-note. It's also one where you are constantly in anticipation of how our ML will handle all the crossroads he faces. The series does well in switching between lighthearted to dramatic before it starts to dive into the darker side.
Within the first 15 or so episodes, I was considering giving this a 10. But there are some sections that felt a bit dragged on and a few sections that felt a bit of an overreach, such as the one with the foreign envoys. Nevertheless, despite the 48 episodes, I didn't feel the need to speed up many sections at all. In fact, I wish there were even more episodes so that it can dive deeper into different arcs. As the series ended with what seems to only be halfway into its entirety, it's a shame that a second season hasn't been done... but it's still worth the watch.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Biased Review and Vent
Out of the many series involving legal cases, there isn't anything particularly that makes this one unique with regards to the execution and resolutions of each case. However, it does touch on very real issues we have currently ongoing in our world without the over-dramatization of the actual issues.There is one major overall aspect that I really love about the entire series because it hit a very personal sore spot. Since childhood, my blunt personality and nonchalance of what others thought about me has always been an easy target for others to put blame on for anything or everything. And our male lead in the series experiences this over and over again. Despite having earned his place through hard work and endurance, despite the fact that he knew there can be no resolution in the real world unless you play the game, and despite having proven over and over again his true intent... everyone around him continued to doubt him.
His pro bono team were pretty much useless on actually winning cases which would truly help victims but they judged and continued to judge him harshly on his methods. They celebrated every time there was a win and happily took credit but whenever there was ever the slightest potential shakeup, they would look at him critically again. They lectured him with their own personal idealistic views but can't exact real results without relying on him. They claimed he was arrogant but failed to realize their own deeply embedded egos and inabilities. People who like to think and feel passionately but can't execute any real results, so all they can do is stand on their imaginary pedestal and look down on others.
Even the one female I was rooting for to be his match, ended up betraying him. Despite the "happy" ending, I felt instead heavy sadness for the ML; he has been alone for so long and continues to be utterly alone in the end. He proved time and time again to have done everything with good intentions and overcame his own selfish desires to still choose to be good. But with just a whisper or a slight shift in climate, and the true hypocrites around him immediately casts doubt again. I really wasn't happy about him taking those ignorant dependents under his wing despite this because they are undeserving. Repetitive apologies doesn't take away the wounds from constantly being accused or doubted by the world who can't see outside themselves, much less be someone who can be there for others. At the same time however, I was paradoxically content with the ending because it's a very real depiction on how foolish the world can be. And now I shall go watch something that will throw me into a world further from reality to balance out.
Was this review helpful to you?
