_Rosie

I couldn't agree with you more dapinamrs. I liked it & scored it accordingly I didn't check where it was on the chart and mark it up or down accordingly that is just childish. I rarely give out 10's actually I have only given 4 dramas 10, Bridal Mask & Reply 1997 being two of those. They are totally different dramas.

But in my opinion Reply deserves a 10 the writing alone justifies it, and its about teenagers but its not your typical fluff teen drama. This has heart and soul and I think thats why so many people were moved by it to give it a high score. Whether it is #1 or not is immaterial this drama moved me and that is what matters to me not points!

Same here I found it so different from the usual will they wont they scenarios with evil ex'es or parents getting in the way this was just a simple yet extremely moving story.

Theres some glitch in the system cos a bunch of us wanted to make it our top 5 drama on our profile page but it wont let us lol

Thats good I appreciate you will be busier with college & stuff but Im glad you are coming out of your drama funk now

High 5!!! Lis is upset that its taken the #1 spot from Bridal Mask ...she doesnt get why we love it so much lol

Nice to see you back don't disappear on us :)

Happy Birthday to my favourite actress!!!!

I dont give out 10s very often. The only 10s i have given to dramas are to Bridal Mask, The Princess Man, IRIS & now to Reply :)

Its very good totally different from Reply. Its more serious a period piece set in 1930s Korea when its occupied by Japan. The action is great so if thats your cup of tea you will like it & the 2 lead guys are gorgeous & play their roles really well. It took me a couple of eps to get into it but when I did I was hooked!

BTW as of right now Reply is ranked #2 in all dramas on MDL :D

buhahahahhaha

oh my list isnt in numerical order i just put them in randomly lol

Yeah I like that they didn't make it a sugary sweet ending for JH & left it open ended...I hope for his sake whoever was in the sporty red car was GAWJUSSS cos he so deserves it lol

i know i tried too & it wont let me I reported in bugs thread lets hope they get it fixed soon. I want to add it to my top 5 list lol

yep everything about this drama was so natural & uncontrived. I like how they showed their relationship bickering and all lol thats realistic rather than them just kissing and walking off into the sunset & we never see what happens....i like how this drama showed us life after the declaration of love & then life after marriage.

what mark did you give it?? its a 10 for me :D

I know!! I knew he couldn't hurt Yoon Jae he practically raised him after their parents died.

I like the way they replayed that earlier scene at the restaurant reunion this time filling in the blanks so we knew that Shi Won & YJ were married and expecting a 2nd baby :D

mmmmm loving the latest Joo Won avi...& glad to see you are also a Reply 1997 fan :D

I still have a big smile on my face :D

same here tried to add to my top 5 dramas & it wont let me!