Dana

I finished this drama a week ago and cant stop thinking about it, especially that ending! Came back and re-rated 9.5/10.

Damn it! Back again after 3 weeks and I can not stop thinking about this drama! Please watch it, the black/white vs grey is epic and is unlike any other drama. 10/10

The chemistry was great!! The bittersweet ending was just too much. 7.5/10

I struggled with the first 2 episodes. I am so glad i continued because this dram was great. It is so absurd that it's hilarious! 9/10

Afrer episode 8-9 the plot got a little repetitive . This drama is still worth it because when Rowoon is on screen I sit and watch. Always. That man is fine. 8.5/10

The ML & FL had a very sweet relationship. I really liked the couple and I think Min Hyun did a good job with his first ML. I even watched this on my lunch breaks because it was so adorable and easy to watch. 8.5/10

100% binge worthy but also a little confusing towards then end. As someone who never watched the original, this remake was very entertaining 8.5/10

Baek Kyueng was almost too horrible to watch. Im so glad this wasnt my first Jae Wook drama or i wouldve permanently hated him. He was still incredibly handsome while being such a jerk

The ML finally got me! He was great with Yoo In Na in Bo Ra! Deborah. Highly recommend that drama

I would have liked this more if the 2ML wasnt so good. This is my first drama with second lead syndrome. What makes it even worse is the 1ML was also amazing! Even with the struggle it's a great light hearted watch and solid 8.5/10.

No actresses?? I'm very disappointed the main cast are male leads...the ladies were the more interesting characters in S1.

I loved this drama but there were some problems. Wished they had made the ML learn to repect women in general and not just the FL. Even so their chemistry was insanse! Best ive seen in a long time so that easily made it a 9/10.

This is an adorable, light hearted and cheesy fantasy rom com. Not a true fantasy kdrama like Alchemy of Souls.
That being said, I loved Heavenly Idol. The story was cute, the romance was cute and most importantly Kim Min Gue was extra cute! 9/10 even with plot holes

I loved this drama. The last 3 episodes were very touching

The cast, outfits and settings were all so pretty and very easy to watch. But that was basically it. Romcom is my favorite genre and this was kinda dull. I love LSG and KSY but not together in this drama....it wasnt bad just average chemistry from 2 top tier actors. Still give this an 8/10 for the look of the drama and ML and FL.

This was cheesy and cliche but in all the best ways! I was entertained the entire drama

I love the Hong sisters! This drama is perfect

I think a lot of viewers these days hate on dramas that aren't "intellectual". I really don't care as long as it's entertaining and this drama was really good.

I don't think it's on Netlix in the US. But I was able to find this drama on Kocowa app after paying another subscription fee

This drama just disappeared off Viki last night. I was half way through and now I cant find it anywhere...

I've never been a fan of Park Hae Jin but I love fantasy so I started this drama a little skeptical. I was completely surprised by the entire cast! Everyone did a great job and the script/ comedy were spot on. This drama is a must watch!