i think it was never relevant as this isn't a birth-secret show. them being fatherless is a detail for us to understand…
yeah this is how I read it. It was just part of the backstory that made them and also another mirroring of their lives. in many ways they were "orphans" b/c the parents they had left weren't good ones.
We saw a pic of Lee Jun Young wearing the priest outfit
Sigh.
I guess this would likely require a time jump (which I heard the screenwriter did in her other series, so it is definitely plausible). JY goes off and becomes a priest for a few years. Time jumps ahead to some sort of ending scene. If JY doesn't stay that way and reunites with Pio in the end, I may be okay with it, depending on how it is handled. But JY permanently giving up music for the priesthood, for whatever salvation he believes he gets in that act, would be so disappointing to me.
And also, just on them being of one soul -- two halves of one. Separating them permanently is cruel. The story needs to end with them being united again and playing as one. No matter how they've been torn apart, it only makes sense if they can find their way back to each other.
u havent watched it? i probably cant do this sorry bc ive been watching since it started airing so i barely remember…
The homophobic comments have gone quiet fortunately, and also the screenwriter based the couple on a famous romance story, so the subtext is very THERE. people can still claim it's friendship, but for those who see the love story tropes, it clearly is more.
Jaein is more of supporting character her purpose was to support pio in every thing against eevryone because pio…
I love how brave she was, she took on the bullies when they were teasing Pio when they were teens, she took on JY when she saw him hurting Pio, and she even took on her mother when she threatened to fire Pio. This girl is the biggest Pio defender lol. So she definitely played her role. People may be upset she was so Pio-centric and had no other development, and I get that. But in many ways, wasn't Jeognyo equally obsessed with Pio? Also Pio's personality is one that tries best to take on everything himself, he closes himself off, and Jaein even points this out. Without Jaein fighting in his corner or forcing him to actually eat and get up (like when he was grieving JY's death), I think he would have suffered so much more.
I didnt like that Pi O chose to falsely confess that too in the concert itself. I wish they hadnt shown the truth…
Pio thought he was making the right decision, the one that would free JY from his revenge. But of course Pio didn't realize what JY wanted was not this sort of freedom from him. 😭
It ended up being a much "softer" reveal than the action-packed fan theories about guns, and shootouts or big public reveals via the recorded audio by JY's friend. Pio taking it on himself to publicly take the fall surprised me, because he basically gave up his career and freedom, but then again, this was very in character given his sacrificial history. Also, in many ways, as I saw said on twitter, in the epic Pio/Piano/Jeongyo love triangle, Jeongyo won. Pio gave up piano for JY.
Jaein is more of supporting character her purpose was to support pio in every thing against eevryone because pio…
You know what's interesting and I didn't really realize it until I read this, but Jaein in her own way is as Pio-obsessed as Jeongyo is his way. It's not a triangle b/c Pio only has his eyes on JY, but Jaein was able to fulfill a role as a support system for Pio when he had no one else.
In Wuthering Heights, Catherine's husband was actually kind, devoted, and loved her deeply; a big contrast to the abusive men in her life, but he could never understand her or truly see her for who she was and what she wanted, nor could he survive Catherine's intense and destructive love for Heathcliff.
Jaein in many ways mirrors him I think (although without being another casualty of the revenge).
I agree w the Pio's mom part, but I feel as frustrating as this was Pio doing was the only way this cycle of revenge…
Yet Pio did turn himself in for JY's sake. He gave us his career and the piano so JY could move on with his life and stop the revenge that was killing him.
I just did a rewatch as well in its entirety (the first time I kept pausing and stopping). I'm not sure how I'm…
Yes, and considering this series was more about the emotional arcs of the characters (and not a "revenge" series in its typical form where you see the harmed character meticulously enacting their revenge plan every episode). So I'd have hoped by this episode to have seen a lot more headway in terms of the emotional turns for the characters. But in this episode there was a lot of retreading over familiar ground. And Mama and Gramps getting redemption were't what I had in mind in terms of character growth, lol, when the focus should have been on Pio and JY's relationship. Oh, and I just saw the preview clip with Pio at the press conference, and we still see Pio in the same headspace with blaming himself. I really didn't want to see this still happening in Ep12 😭
So, I watched episode 11 in its entirety, not in chunks, and I'm afraid that, unfortunately, my hopes for this…
I just did a rewatch as well in its entirety (the first time I kept pausing and stopping). I'm not sure how I'm feeling right now. I'm actually afraid the finale won't do what we'd hope in terms of character development.
people are scared of suicide and here i am terrified he might become a priest lol
yeah I remember the pics of the actor in a priest outfit. omg. Also, let's not forget JY was with monks for 9 years?! And those first 5 years with them he had amnesia, was he just studying the bible and sweeping the steps? we have no idea lol.
Like I said, for me, if we're getting a suicide or death, they both need to die together. We go full Wuthering Heights, or nothing.
For me, worst ending: JY becomes a priest, Pio marries Jaein. It's not as bad as "bury your gays," but it still feels homophobic 😭
i'm not sure what the detailed plan was but what i know is that it involved keeping pio close and at his command.…
Right exactly! I kind of wish he'd flipped the table lol. They are talking at cross hairs all the time. Also, I know I saw people going into Pio analysis about how he is so disordered he can't even see why or how JY would see any value in him; Pio sees himself as disposable, thus the constant self-sacrificing (again, cue low self-worth). And you have JY on the other side not being able to take his eyes off Pio lol (and not able to understand why Pio would sacrifice himself...something he even said during their rain fight). But JY is also hungry for Pio to see JY and his needs outside of the guilt/sacrifice frame, and to just tell him the truth. Pio's explanations, his "whys" for his actions are never completely honest, not even when they were teens. He was always apologizing and telling only a slice of the story when JY demanded an explanation. He stuck to the easiest answers and didn't allow true vulnerability. Like you said in a post earlier, he needs to just finally tell the truth. Break the wall, and like, FEEL. JY needs to hear that level of truth from him too.
they become each other's family in terms of caretaking, as neither had family that cared about their wellbeing.
I guess this would likely require a time jump (which I heard the screenwriter did in her other series, so it is definitely plausible). JY goes off and becomes a priest for a few years. Time jumps ahead to some sort of ending scene. If JY doesn't stay that way and reunites with Pio in the end, I may be okay with it, depending on how it is handled. But JY permanently giving up music for the priesthood, for whatever salvation he believes he gets in that act, would be so disappointing to me.
And also, just on them being of one soul -- two halves of one. Separating them permanently is cruel. The story needs to end with them being united again and playing as one. No matter how they've been torn apart, it only makes sense if they can find their way back to each other.
It ended up being a much "softer" reveal than the action-packed fan theories about guns, and shootouts or big public reveals via the recorded audio by JY's friend. Pio taking it on himself to publicly take the fall surprised me, because he basically gave up his career and freedom, but then again, this was very in character given his sacrificial history. Also, in many ways, as I saw said on twitter, in the epic Pio/Piano/Jeongyo love triangle, Jeongyo won. Pio gave up piano for JY.
In Wuthering Heights, Catherine's husband was actually kind, devoted, and loved her deeply; a big contrast to the abusive men in her life, but he could never understand her or truly see her for who she was and what she wanted, nor could he survive Catherine's intense and destructive love for Heathcliff.
Jaein in many ways mirrors him I think (although without being another casualty of the revenge).
If there's no HEA where they drive off into the sunset together, I feel like there are four bromance possibilities left it could end like:
- Sakamichi no Apollon
- Banana Fish
- The Untamed
- My Country: The New Age.
All of these have different endings ranging from tragic to bittersweet to ambiguous/open.
Like I said, for me, if we're getting a suicide or death, they both need to die together. We go full Wuthering Heights, or nothing.
For me, worst ending: JY becomes a priest, Pio marries Jaein. It's not as bad as "bury your gays," but it still feels homophobic 😭