I can't comment on the novel, although it's not possible to adapt everything exactly as it is, this is why it's…
We could ignore it but it does affect their work, the director had a plan for season 2 but he will only do it if the audience receives this show well and right now it's a disaster because the rating is insanely low which takes away our chance of seeing them on our screens again š on top of that, I don't even want to imagine the state of their mental health after hearing so many malicious comments about how they look
I mean if people are attracted to the mains that's subjective. I personally think both look really good so I don't…
I understand that, it's not like everyone has to like their appearance but their faces shouldn't determinate how good the show is, that makes the rating invalid for me. As for the intimacy, they only got into that when they were officially together in the book, I am guessing the show will take a similar approach
I really donāt understand the low ratings on Douban, especially since theyāre not even critiquing the plot. The negative feedback seems to be focused on two things: 1) the actors not fitting certain beauty standards, and 2) complaints from book readers claiming it doesnāt do the source material justice, which, as someone whoās read the book, I can confidently say isnāt true. Theyāve followed the storyline very closely, with only one significant adjustment so far. Itās frustrating that instead of engaging with the actual story, people are hung up on superficial things like appearances and strict book-to-screen comparisons.
A Stebrothers romance of course it has very high ratings lol
Iām responding here to both this comment and the one under my post because, Iām not wasting time on two separate replies.
First, regarding the comment on my postācalling something a masterpiece is *subjective*, not some universal declaration. Itās my perspective, plain and simple. Iām allowed to feel that way without needing to convince anyone. How exactly does my ābiasā affect you? Why are you so invested in discrediting my opinion? If you disagree, thatās fine, but you wonāt see me tracking down your comments to dismantle your views. Thereās space for different opinions without turning it into a personal mission to undermine someone else's take.
Now, onto this commentāyouāre spending a lot of time and energy trying to figure out why people love the show, as if you need to crack the code. But maybe instead of speculating about everyoneās motives, consider that people can enjoy things without needing to meet some specific criteria or explanation. The show isnāt loved because of some shallow stepbrother trope; itās the storytelling that resonates. And newsflash: no one owes you a justification for why they connect with it. Audiences aren't required to validate their reasons for liking something to anyone, least of all to someone whoās more focused on critiquing others than engaging with the material. Leave your own review, cool, but stop acting like this is a psychological evaluation of peopleās reasons for enjoying content.
At the end of the day, everyoneās entitled to their own thoughts, but you donāt get to police how people relate to or appreciate a show.
There are many ways to interpret that moment, but to me, itās clear that Tian saw the hint of pain in Wangās…
Haha, honestly, the amount of wasted food is kind of hilarious! š¤£āWang was definitely stalling. He was still feeling all shy and awkward after what went down the night before, trying to find any excuse to avoid going with Tian. But the moment he realized Tian was actually waiting for him, he couldnāt help but give in and follow him out, so naturally, the food was forgotten.
can some1 explain the eye communication between tian and sheng during Bernoulli's law?
There are many ways to interpret that moment, but to me, itās clear that Tian saw the hint of pain in Wangās eyes when the Bernoulli law was mentioned. Itās as if Tianās gaze gently asked, āWhatās troubling you?ā and in response, Wangās eyes turned more vulnerable.
I think Wangās disdain for the Bernoulli principle might be personal. Throughout his life, heās yearned for someone to genuinely care for him, even if heās never voiced it. He might feel that the "wind"āthe force that draws people togetherārepresents his longing for connection. Yet, when that wind dies down, heās left isolated again, mirroring his strained relationship with his father. As a child, he was close to him, but as he grew older, the distance between them widened, as if the wind had carried him away.
So I guess Wang identifies too closely with the Bernoulli law, seeing it as a symbol of his own broken life and Tian saw right through him.
You really found wonderful words to describe the complexity and feelings that the series conveys. Thank you! šEven…
Thank you! š I'm so glad you felt that way. I totally agreeāno matter how many times you revisit it, the emotions stay just as intense. Itās the kind of series that keeps its impact every time.
It flew by for me, but thatās probably because I was busy reading and watching " the on1y one". Still, the wait…
You should start it. Honestly, Iāve been struggling to get into any BL ever since "4 Mins" dropped, but *The On1y One* has been such a pleasant surpriseāitās really pulling me in and helping me stay somewhat distracted from the agonizing wait for this show.
AND SAME, today when Bible said he *dislikes* the ending of 4 minutes and then Jes was like, āI love it,ā I seriously almost had a heart attack. WHO AM I SUPPOSED TO TRUST HERE? Itās messing with my head! Iām so stressed about how itās going to end because if itās anything close to a sad or open ending, I honestly donāt think I can handle it. I *need* closureālike, desperately. No heartbreak, no unresolved tension, just a satisfying, wrapped-up ending, please. š
I just binged all five episodes, and honestly, Iām not okay. Iāve read the book before, so I thought I knew what was coming, but this show just hit different. They managed to translate everything from the original materialāthe slow burn, the layered emotions, all of itāinto something so visually stunning and emotionally raw. I feel like my heart is both aching and rooting for these characters at the same time, and itās tearing at me in the best way possible.
I donāt want to give away too much (no spoilers, donāt worry), but if you really get Tianās backstory, you feel the weight of all the pain heās been carrying around for so long, and then thereās this glimmer of light that starts breaking through. Itās honestly heart-shattering. The way this show handles his trauma and how love slowly, almost reluctantly, starts to heal himāitās *chefās kiss* perfection.
Episode 5? Whew, that one took me out. Starting the episode with Bernoulliās principle? Absolute genius move. Talking about two objects colliding because of the wind sets up the whole episode in this breathtakingly poetic way. From the very first scene, you can feel this undercurrent of bittersweetness, like everything is both falling apart and coming together at the same time. The hopelessness and the hope, itās all there, right from the start.
Sheng Wangās sense of deep, bone-deep loneliness and Jiang Tianās constant hesitation, that push-pull between them, itās so powerful. All those emotions just swirling together like some kind of chaotic storm, and itās like you can see them both trying to figure out whether to embrace it or run from it. Theyāre stuck in this emotional turbulence, not sure if they want to stop the wind from pushing them together, but also terrified of what happens if they donāt.
And letās talk about *that* scene. Sheng Wang asking Jiang Tian to carry him? It absolutely wrecked me. Like, you know in that moment, itās not really about being carried. What Sheng Wang really wanted was just...to feel close to him. To feel connected in any way possible. He wanted so much from Tian, and itās almost like he didnāt know how to ask for it. So he wraps it in this tiny request, hoping Tian would say yes.
This show is something special. Itās not flashy, itās not fast-paced, but itās mesmerizing in its slowness. The burn is so gradual, but it pulls you in deeper and deeper until youāre completely lost in the little detailsāthe stolen glances, the unspoken words, the layers of meaning behind every gesture. Itās the kind of show that consumes you, where you feel every breath, every touch, every bit of tension between them. Itās a masterpiece in its own way, and honestly, if you let yourself get wrapped up in it, you wonāt be able to look away.
Donāt trust Bibleābro said he likes Spaceless' ending and probably wanted Vegas six feet under. If heās mad about the ending, thatās a W for us. Praise be! š
I don't know if y'all saw, but Jes and Bible reacted to their NC scene in episode 6 (full reaction), and they were so proud of it š. There was zero hiding or shynessāthey were watching so intently! Bible even mentioned how much he loved that scene.
Itās so slay of them because Iād be squealing if that were me!
First, regarding the comment on my postācalling something a masterpiece is *subjective*, not some universal declaration. Itās my perspective, plain and simple. Iām allowed to feel that way without needing to convince anyone. How exactly does my ābiasā affect you? Why are you so invested in discrediting my opinion? If you disagree, thatās fine, but you wonāt see me tracking down your comments to dismantle your views. Thereās space for different opinions without turning it into a personal mission to undermine someone else's take.
Now, onto this commentāyouāre spending a lot of time and energy trying to figure out why people love the show, as if you need to crack the code. But maybe instead of speculating about everyoneās motives, consider that people can enjoy things without needing to meet some specific criteria or explanation. The show isnāt loved because of some shallow stepbrother trope; itās the storytelling that resonates. And newsflash: no one owes you a justification for why they connect with it. Audiences aren't required to validate their reasons for liking something to anyone, least of all to someone whoās more focused on critiquing others than engaging with the material. Leave your own review, cool, but stop acting like this is a psychological evaluation of peopleās reasons for enjoying content.
At the end of the day, everyoneās entitled to their own thoughts, but you donāt get to police how people relate to or appreciate a show.
Anyway, that's all. š
https://x.com/juexias/status/1484064097000116224
I think Wangās disdain for the Bernoulli principle might be personal. Throughout his life, heās yearned for someone to genuinely care for him, even if heās never voiced it. He might feel that the "wind"āthe force that draws people togetherārepresents his longing for connection. Yet, when that wind dies down, heās left isolated again, mirroring his strained relationship with his father. As a child, he was close to him, but as he grew older, the distance between them widened, as if the wind had carried him away.
So I guess Wang identifies too closely with the Bernoulli law, seeing it as a symbol of his own broken life and Tian saw right through him.
AND SAME, today when Bible said he *dislikes* the ending of 4 minutes and then Jes was like, āI love it,ā I seriously almost had a heart attack. WHO AM I SUPPOSED TO TRUST HERE? Itās messing with my head! Iām so stressed about how itās going to end because if itās anything close to a sad or open ending, I honestly donāt think I can handle it. I *need* closureālike, desperately. No heartbreak, no unresolved tension, just a satisfying, wrapped-up ending, please. š
I donāt want to give away too much (no spoilers, donāt worry), but if you really get Tianās backstory, you feel the weight of all the pain heās been carrying around for so long, and then thereās this glimmer of light that starts breaking through. Itās honestly heart-shattering. The way this show handles his trauma and how love slowly, almost reluctantly, starts to heal himāitās *chefās kiss* perfection.
Episode 5? Whew, that one took me out. Starting the episode with Bernoulliās principle? Absolute genius move. Talking about two objects colliding because of the wind sets up the whole episode in this breathtakingly poetic way. From the very first scene, you can feel this undercurrent of bittersweetness, like everything is both falling apart and coming together at the same time. The hopelessness and the hope, itās all there, right from the start.
Sheng Wangās sense of deep, bone-deep loneliness and Jiang Tianās constant hesitation, that push-pull between them, itās so powerful. All those emotions just swirling together like some kind of chaotic storm, and itās like you can see them both trying to figure out whether to embrace it or run from it. Theyāre stuck in this emotional turbulence, not sure if they want to stop the wind from pushing them together, but also terrified of what happens if they donāt.
And letās talk about *that* scene. Sheng Wang asking Jiang Tian to carry him? It absolutely wrecked me. Like, you know in that moment, itās not really about being carried. What Sheng Wang really wanted was just...to feel close to him. To feel connected in any way possible. He wanted so much from Tian, and itās almost like he didnāt know how to ask for it. So he wraps it in this tiny request, hoping Tian would say yes.
This show is something special. Itās not flashy, itās not fast-paced, but itās mesmerizing in its slowness. The burn is so gradual, but it pulls you in deeper and deeper until youāre completely lost in the little detailsāthe stolen glances, the unspoken words, the layers of meaning behind every gesture. Itās the kind of show that consumes you, where you feel every breath, every touch, every bit of tension between them. Itās a masterpiece in its own way, and honestly, if you let yourself get wrapped up in it, you wonāt be able to look away.
Itās so slay of them because Iād be squealing if that were me!