The cast is good, But the character they potray is not good enough to warrant and show their acting skill more.
Rewatch Value? You should just rewatch for some good scene. There is quite some good moment which is for me quite touching. Especially a scene between a mother and both of her son
Was this review helpful to you?
A really overall Good movie with passionate acting
It's been already two years ago I watched a movie in Theaters This movie is the first movie I watched after hiatus watching a movie in theaters. Very pleasing experience. I really didn't expected I would be understand it more than When I read the novel which very boring and totally confusing for me. The storeytelling is being presentQuite well by the director. They present it well about the world building which conveyed by the male lead who drive the story . Despite stereotype storyline, I enjoy it alot. Really passionate performances by the actor especially Ahn Hyo Seop. His character drive the story. Without his acting performances and his versatility, this movie won't be as enjoyable and work for me. I really appreciate his performances here which is one of his best. Yet. Imo
I'm glad I don't listen to the haters. This is peak cinema based how much I enjoy the acting. The plot want to showing it too much at times just for 2 hours. The character other than dokja is just not being well present because this is too focus on the mc. For an ensemble cast this huge, it's pretty surprising. But nevertheless, i enjot it alot.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Embrace the complexity
It seems almost anyone on mdl doesn't like it. It's a mainstream drama. But it's just too heavy to be a mainstream drama. It has too much politics, which for me is engaging because not only protagonist, but each supporting who contribute to the narrative getting flash out. They look like human being who is blind by power and start panic wanting to keep their throne which start shaking, instead of mere plot device for our hero to shine. They are still useful to the plot in later episode to make thing interesting.The baddy is blind by desire cover up their scheme, Also the tragedy that happpened 10 years ago. It's not The scheming that is interesting, it's how each of them react. Even the victim like " fake diziyuan", the writers not throw her under the bus and flash out her feeling after being used by Anle for her freedom.
I enjoy it alot. The plot is cohesive. I have no idea where mess up comes from? Might be we have different taste not because this drama is bad. Or novel reader just want to copy paste everything from the novel. It has it's flaws like many convenient plot and gimmick. But it's embrace human emotion and it's complexity yet it's never too convoluted or confusing.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A good movie with so much heart
This movie is quite typical love triangle - quadrapple trope. But they nail with the good storytelling by the director and writers which make us hooked with twist and turn plus Kim Yoo Jung give her character so much heart and the biggest impact to the storytelling being successfully told. So even with two green acting from her leading man doesn't affected the movie to be mediocre. Though, quite underwhelming with the ending execution.It teach us not something sacrifice for people we love benefit them.
Was this review helpful to you?
This drama remind me of Class of Lies, setting in school with adding politics and melodrama element to add spice. I'm watching it the second time after I finished it, and still feels compelling and I got a new perspective, because the main addiction of this drama is the way the story told, the environment, and each character perspective, and Some of good performances. After I finished it, I think alot of it and the question of "what could have been" always ring in my mind. ANd that's an achievement.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
One of the best of this year and I'm not exagerate.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
It's trying to depict many issue in High School environment, from bully, unfair treatment of student based on their social standing, the stress of to get the best score, etc, but they are just fail miserably. There is the tenstion for the sake of tension, at times preachy, but it's just a bunch collection of problem throw it you down of your own throat. The writers certainly doesn't has talent to match between romance, bromance and realistic conflict they arise. But the good news is, This cast is the best casting compare to among other previous cast in school series in recent memory (well, compare to School 2013 and Schcool 2015). School 2013 and School 2015 has the same fail attempt to depict teenage environment in high school. But this School series has one advantage, is the cast and make the show become bearable.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
ENjoy it because the romance lead journey.
I really love it, Mainly for the main leads romance and the problem surrounding them. I really though it will be just another shallow gender reversal who want to talk deep but end up being pretender. But There are so many RAW moment that I love, mainly the romance of the main leads and the circumstance which connecting them. Two character opposite personality who seems like strong female lead with her status and male lead who seems a very nice person, But actually they are just a flawed human being which face ups and down about their relationship due to their background and personality different. I enjoy it alot. I laughed and cryed along with them. . They growth and learn as the show progress and the writers given their story so much depth which I enjoy alot. I don't enjoy much about the corporate stuff but I know it need to be brought up to make some conflict to our leads . There is also some flaws in this drama which I'm not enjoying which is the villain arc (though the actor Shawn Zhang is doing a great job) which for me unreasonable and some fluff subplot 2nd lead and other character supporting character relationship which take too much screen time and honestly I don't enjoy them much . But I think they need to shoot them because they need other character surrounding our leads.I will definitely will rewatch it mostly just for the leads.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I Watched for Ahn Hyo Seop, And I find myself enjoy the drama, despite my allergic to Medical Drama. Yo In Shik is doing a good work here everything in the operation table feels real that at times I can't stomach the scene. Ass usual this writers has a skill and tendency with dramatic setup. That I sometimes giggles because at times it's abit OTT.. But she success to bring out the best in Lee Sung Kyung and AHn Hyo Seop Performances. their background and arc here is really engaging, I wish this drama emphasis more about their story and arc. and less about politic. Back then, I was skeptical about Yo In Shik casting choice. WHo knows Both of these combo hit the jackpot, that I find both of them have so much potential, both of these actor already look passionate in acting here. Give so much nuance and passion to character, that I enjoying this drama thanks to them. Contrary to so many people who want season 3. If you need season 3, then it's more like fan service to satisfy the fans. I don't think this drama need for that. The entire story basically Kim Sabu is like God. It's like the show credit all the good think in him, and everyone around him is flaws and all. Like basically that's the entire story of this drama is all about his greatness and how it affect people around him and look out of him heck even the villain. And This hospital is the ideal dream about what is the hospital should be, to a pure form .The drama for me is already complete and there is no need to explore more.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
complete darkness
this is depiction of how jail time, no matter how short or long, will left a negative impact on pure souls. Eiher you wrongly accused or you are just accidentally kill a person without actually mean it, that experience will left a trauma and you might be never recover. This depiction is more about contrast to the police, they want the obvious suspect become a real suspect, because they think this is savest bet to level up. but they never know what they done to a suspect is evil and cruel.either he is really a real culprit or innocent person, his view to the world during those experiience is total darkness and feels helpless.
this depiction is wonderfully convey in this little drama.
and this is after a very long time one of the best Kim Soo Hyun performances. which unfortunately not even given a nomination in baeksang. he should be doing this kind of performances more often.
Was this review helpful to you?
It lacks something than it will be better if the writers want to convey something more than what it seems.
After all I come to think that's the power of good PD. Elevated the script, and alot of performances and scene really well executed . SO I can see why people rate it high. I give this drama a good rating for those two alone.
Was this review helpful to you?
GOOD DIRECTOR AND GOOD PERFORMANCES MAKE THE DRAMA WATCHABLE
EDIT 16 JAN 26 : I already watching the fully. This drama is saved by good directing and and some good performances from the actor.This drama is too centered around romances and multiples misunderstanding about female lead identity so they abandoned some plot point that more interesting. Political family conflict they arise might be more interesting and engaging if handled by more competent writing, but here we are. Even enemy to lovers trope because different realms handled haphazardly with chip tricks. While some character has layer (mostly thanks the actor interpreting the roles whith more depth), there is nothing special in the writing. I enjoyed it due to performances and how the director told the story. It's obvious they run out of budget at the third of the drama, but it's always solid in terms of acting and how the director handled the scene and performances
Overall despite trust conflict they arise in romances departement, it's just has this undercurrent romances touched from the director like passionated eyes, intimacy, and romance scene handled just give warm and passionated feeling between the character, despite many misunderstanding conflict, I still swepted by the romances.
Was this review helpful to you?

