News
This review may contain spoilers
Not the best, but still good
You know that thing that kinda annoys you at first, but you find yourself going back? Like it just grates at you, but for whatever reason, you keep going back coz something about it calls to you? That was this show to me. Maybe I'm subconsiously a masochist.☀️What I Liked🌑
1. The acting - There are parts that I for sure did not like. However, when the gimmicky parts of the plots are drawn back, you get to see just how well these guys act. Especially TeeTee, who plays Duang. When they stop making him play a literal dog, you can see the immediate change in his face and aura.
That man can act. A good example is in the finale, after their conversation with Jamie on the phone, and Qin tells Duang that they can sleep together. You can see the immediate switch on this face. I wish we saw more of that serious/toned-down side of him
Por, his smile is absolutely beautiful. In terms of acting, I think he was OK. I didn't cringe at it. However, it is harder to critique him as his character, Qin, doesn't have that much of an emotional range, meaning Por doesn't use his facial muscles much. Likely since Qin's supposed to be more reserved.
He could do better with his crying scenes, but overall, based on the little we got from what he had to work with, I think it was OK. Hopefully, we get to see him as a more expressive character in the future. I think I'd like that.
As for the wider cast, some were cringe, most were average. No one quite stood out for me.
2. The Production Value - Based on my experiences with Dumondi through 'Khemjira', 'Love Upon a Time', 'Zomvivor', and now 'Duang with You', the company has some incredible people behind their cameras. Their cinematography is top-notch. Up there with (dare I say) a company like BOC. They know what works and what to do with the camera and the lighting.
Lemme gush about lighting for a second, the blue light on Qin in episode 6. Holy shit. I know that scene was supposed to be hot, but that light on him. Oh, it framed him beautifully. The NC scenes in episodes 9 and 12 are also filmed so beautifully. I know the actors have to do their job to sell these scenes to the audience, but the people on the lights and cameras have to be recognized for how well they highlight the actors and their actions in said scenes
3. The chemistry - What I keep thinking is, 'if these characters can give us this much chemistry in a fluffy, college show, what do you think they can do with a more mature, perhaps even darker show?' I think I would spontaneously combust.
PS. I know most people loved their 1st kiss in episode 4. I didn't like it. It wasn't reciprocal enough for me. But the kisses in episodes 9 and 12... That's where it's at. That's where they actually and equally shine
4. The communication - They are surprisingly mature in how they communicate and refuse to let things fester. This show isn't driven by miscommunication, and I love that. And this isn't just with the main characters, even within the wider friend groups. They argue, yes, but take the time to talk things over and fix them.
🚨What I Didn't Like/Could've Been Better🚨
1. It can be overly comedic - This is an ongoing issue for me. Oftentimes, Thai BLs do this kind of humor that doesn't quite land for me. It's over the top, a bit forced, and just so confusing. I remember being thoroughly annoyed by the comedy that I had to note down my feelings after episode 4. Good thing they toned it down as the show proceeded. Or maybe I tuned it out...? IDK. But I think it's the former.
2. Duang's characterization - He is very childish, especially in the 1st half. I think it's meant to be cute, but it comes off as immature, taking you out of the headspace where you're supposed to view him as a potential love interest. And for the love of Christ, why did he have to act like an actual dog for most, if not all, of the 1st half of this?
I think the makers of this show wanted to portray him as this sunshine golden retriever, which, cool, no problem. But why make him mimic an actual dog? Why was he panting on my screen? You can 100% do a golden retriever character without the dog traits. It's been done before. I'm still unsure why they insisted on it.
3. The 2nd couple - With how the streets were excited about the introduction of Marvis, I thought the 2nd couple would have a bigger role to play in the overall story. Only, no, that wasn't to be the case. So much could have been done with a story about 2 playboys falling for each other, but they just let that drown. Then, they only let the combined friend group meet Marvis for 2.5 seconds in the finale. Tsk, tsk.
4. The performances - I mean all the singing and dancing. So during the course of watching this drama, I learnt that the 2 main characters are part of a Tpop band under Domondi. Which could explain why I had to spend about 20+ minutes or so (divided btwn 2 episodes) watching them perform full songs and dance routines.
However, I shouldn't have had to sit through all that. Christina Aguilera and Cher singing and dancing in the 2010 movie 'Burlesque' makes sense coz that is a musical film. Duang with You isn't a musical, so none of that extended singing and dancing made sense to me
5. The situation with Qin's parents - It should've been handled better. The resolution was too quick and too shallow, especially after that long flashback to Qin's childhood. The child actor and the woman who played the nanny should be commended for their acting, though. I was simultaneously heartbroken and pissed off to the high heavens
Would I rewatch this? Absolutely not. I cannot handle a 2nd round of Duang
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Hilarious Watch that Unfortunately Falters Towards the End
Starting with the good❄️The Acting - I truly do think that everyone did a good job, but I think my standouts were Im Ji Yeon, Heo Nam Jun, and Yoon Byung Hee.
Despite Byung Hee being a supporting character in every show I've seen him in, I always know that his acting will be good and I will very likely be laughing my behind off. He truly never disappoints
Im Ji Yeon - The last time I saw her was in The Glory (OK, so, truthfully, it was in 'The Killing Vote,' but I dropped that shit so quick I couldn't even tell you what her character was like). Now back to The Glory. I think all, if not the majority of us, can agree that she straight-up traumatized us there. Her character was to be feared, loathed, and hated. That is (fortunately or unfortunately) a character that stays with the audience. From that to this is such a 180, and a glorious one. She played the unhinged Sin Seo Ri beautifully. And I think that proves what an amazing actress she is.
Heo Nam Jun - If you'd have asked me b4 the Twitter thirst traps, I'd have told you that I'd never seen this man in any show. Come to find out he was in both seasons 2 and 3 of 'Sweet Home'. Girl, I never clocked him them😭. I am glad that he got his chance to shine in this drama, though. This is a man who KNOWS how to use his facial muscles. I do not think the romance would have worked as well as it did if his microexpressions weren't as good as they were.
❄️ The Comedy - I have had so much fun with this show the past 7(?) weeks. Anytime Friday would come around, I just knew that I was in for some foolishness. This cast has made me laugh so much over the past few weeks, and I thank them for it. I think the drama deserves recognition for its hilarity (alongside the acting, of course). They stuck the landing on that romantic comedy tag.
❄️The romance - They both might have been crazy, but they communicated. Even in the midst of all that was going on, they always found their way back to each other. Cha Segye fell fast and fell harder than anyone else, and Seori is a bit prickly, but they were both into each other. You see that their love is mature and reciprocal. They never lingered in misunderstandings
Now let's talk about the bits that had me feeling dissatisfied
🌠Inconsistent characterization - Cha Segye & Sin Seori
👩🏻Seori is shown to have a 6th sense for danger in the 1st ep or so, but that wholly disappears by the time the show hits ep 11 or so. The show starts setting up situations for Se Gye to save her. Situations that do not make sense if you recall the woman we started the show with.
For example, that incident with the water. Ep 1 Seori would have started seeking help the minute she felt weird. Actually, she'd have never stayed in that isolated room till late at night. She'd have started asking questions when she saw that these wardrobe pple were taking too long to find her
👨🏻On the other hand, Cha Segye started off being very bullheaded, smart, and cunning. He doesn't let anyone (aside from Seori, that is) lead him on like a fool or take advantage of him. However, when the show requires it, suddenly his cunning and smarts go out the window. He constantly underestimates Mun do allowing him to one-up him.
I'm still so mad at the writer(s) for making this man legit beg Mun Do not to destroy Seori's house. I think he even got on his knees (don't quote me on this, though). The point is, the businessman Cha Segye, the man who built a business despite Mundo, his useless aunts, and his grandfather, would've never done that. I hate that they made him do that.
On to other cast members
🌠Choi Mundo - Why was this man so horrid? You could say that he was made like that. Like, he was horrible in the Joseon era, so he's bound to be horrible too in the modern day. However, I feel like this explanation is a little lazy. While his actions in the Joseon era were very much on the extreme side, he had a reason.
Watching palace dramas is knowing that court politics and accession to the throne is a cutthroat game (quite literally, as they will behead you). So in Joseon, he was horribly protecting his seat.
But what is the explanation in the modern day? Jealousy? Coz he was born poor, and Cha Se Gye has a proverbial silver spoon? That's it? A jealous kid became a jealous (I'm assuming) 40-yr-old who wanted to usurp a conglomerate seat that was never his to begin with? Ai🤦🏾♀️
🌠Mo Tae Hui - How did she go from obsessing about getting married to Cha Se Gye and using her economic power to put him back in his 'rightful seat' to besties doing dealings together? That was quite the sudden and weird switch. We should have seen her come to terms with the fact that Se Gye would never be hers, no matter how much she tried. I think they tried showing that to us in the scene where she was speaking to the foreigner at the museum, but based on the fact that she never knew about what happened in the past btwn them, it doesn't make sense
🌠Grandfather - How did this man rise to being the head of this conglomerate? How did he manage to work out the politics of business and grow his company when he couldn't see the evil that was Mun Do all along? Mun Do was right for telling him that he was always a horrible grandfather to Cha Segye. And grandpa was dead wrong in calling Mun Do a burden. Yes, Mun Do was awful, but he cannot just spew those words after using him for all those years.
🌠The aunties - I felt like they never used them enough. They could've been a hilarious duo had they been better utilized.
🌠Ji Hyo - By the time the show was hitting ep 15, she had become one of my favourite characters. However, I cannot help but lament at who she could have been. The weird romance they were pushing btwn her and Baek Gwang Nam was honestly... weird. Funny, but weird. I'd have preferred that they had instead made her story more of a true rival to Sin Seori.
In one of the episodes, Ji Hyo had said that she hated Seori when she was younger, as Seori was better than her. And that once Seori disappeared, she always lived with some kind of anxiety regarding her career. Ji Hyo grows as a character during the course of the show. She's not just a mean character but a complicated, nuanced one. So, rather than the romance, I'd have preferred if she were shown to be using the now 'old but new' Seori as a tool to improve herself.
🌠That one random extra actress - Why on earth was she being mean to Seori? At 1st I thought the Mun Do had bought her off, but the show ends with us never knowing why she suddenly turned evil. Weird
🌠 Other Questions
a. What was the point of Mun Do's kid?
b. Why and how did Mun Do's assistant turn coats? He was never painted as a spy, so... why the change of heart?
c. Back in Joseon, why did Mun Do marry Dansim? He'd already achieved his goal, so what was the point of having her in his bed and elevating her status?
d. Did we really need all the drama and anxiety between eps 11 and 16? I cannot even count the number of times I repeated the line, 'They better not give me another 'Mr. Queen' ending in this one. I do not think the drama about her maybe going, maybe not going, then actually going back to Joseon was necessary. Even Segye's stabbing, what was that about? Did I miss the reason behind why he was stabbed and by who, or was that just the writer's way of forcing Seori to go back to Joseon🤔?
🌠Final Thoughts🌠
Would I recommend this? Honestly, yes. It wasn't perfect. Okay? It wasn't. However, despite the unnecessary drama that the writer(s) added from ep 11 to 16 and unanswered questions, I think this is a solid romcom.
The acting is incredible, the comedy lands, the villain is an actual true villain, and the plot is actually good. I truly believe that this show is actually worth investing your time in (esp those 1st 10 episodes)
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
No, It's Not About the Romance: It's About the Women
I started this drama with one question: 'How in the hell would she end up married to a man who abandoned her and then made her a servant in the house she was to become a young madam?' I assumed they'd make him save her, then give him some dumbass sob story that she would accept, forgive him, and they'd live happily ever after. I was ready to hate it.But boy was I wrong. The blame is on me since my assumptions were made from reading the synopsis here and seeing the one trailer where she and her adoptive parents talked about saving enough money to save themselves.
After a whopping 47 episodes - the longest Cdrama I have watched thus far - I feel with everything in me that we need more stories like this. Stories that center around the plight of women and what it actually means to live and survive in a world that restrains you. A world that sees you as nothing but a tool, a nuisance, a burden, and, according to the Lin sisters' mother, 'spilled water'.
LanXiang: The 'Cameraman of the Era
Lan Xiang reminds me a lot of ManMan from 'The Prisoner of Beauty '. They are both quick-witted, possess a quiet strength, and the ability to adapt to any circumstance. I love a vengeful, cunning, sword-wielding woman as much as the next babe, but sometimes, It's good to see how the average woman would have survived in such times. LanXiang and ManMan are far from the average historical Chinese woman due to the fact that they are educated and braver than most. IMO, that (the education really) is what helps them accomplish much of what they do.
In one of her plays, Lan Xiang talks about a woman who turns into an eagle to escape her ungrateful, murderous family. Throughout the story, I saw Lan Xiang as that eagle—or rather, a vessel whose eyes I used to view the atrocities women faced. In meme language, she is the cameraman: she sees everything and never dies.
I feel like the aim of this drama was not to portray how one woman beat the odds, making her better than all those around her. But rather, to walk the audience through this time period, showing them, through Lan Xiang, all the atrocities that women had to live through. Lan Xiang is rather modern and forward-thinking for her time, which is why I see her as I, the audience, dumped into this time period. Her desires and thoughts mirror what liberated women in 2026 want and think. She forces us to ponder: "If this were happening to you with your 2026 brain and sensibilities, how would you feel?"
Through her, we see the systemic traps that women faced
• A woman gets kidnapped, yet she has to lie about her whereabouts lest the family decides she was defiled and throw her out to the wolves - Remember the women in 'The Prisoner of Beauty' who were SA'd, and their Lord forced them to go to the frontlines because the loss of their purity meant they were shameful and no longer useful to society?
• Women raised to believe that marriage is all that matters. A good man is all there is to their world. They are less than if a man doesn't want them and if unmarried by a certain age. And once married, they are shamed and hated within the household for earning an honest living, regardless of whether the man earns enough or not. Starve if you must, but do not show your face in public trying to make money
• Women are forced to stay in not only unhappy but physically and financially violent households because leaving is seen as shameful. And let's not forget that seeking a divorce requires the woman to be punished for shaming the husband, but also, divorce is only granted if the man agrees. If he says no, you are forced to stay. If he says no and claims he 'only beat you a little,' you stay
Crucially, the drama shines a light on women as complex human beings. They aren't evil for the sake of it; they have layers and distinct motivations. We see:
• The Jealous Sister: She rejoices at her older sister’s ruined prospects (possible loss of virginity before marriage), only to save her upon realizing the scandal would not just ruin her older sister but tarnish her reputation as well as that of her family at large
• The Toxic Wife: She treats her husband with disdain, cheats on him, and mistreats the maids from his side of the union — until you learn about the abusive family she came from.
• The Social Climber: A maid who bullies the girl she grew up with and tries to gain favor with the young master of the household, but she later proves to be more than just a surface-level bully.
These women aren't sanitized, and they aren't demonized. As a woman living with the narrative that women are each other's biggest enemies, I love how human this show treats them. I don't agree with all their actions, but I understand them.
Lin Jin Qi: The Patriarchal Cage
I think he was a good portrayal of a patriarchal, classist man. Before he falls for Lan Xiang, he forces her to spy on his wife so he can find a way to break off the marriage. I wonder if, at the time, he thought of the other servant girl that was beaten and sold off. The one he'd bribed to tell him about that book (was it a scripture book?) I forget. I assume he did not, since he went to the brothel she'd been sold to -to save the 'love of his life' - and never recognized her.
Once he falls for her, he does not treat her with the same respect he would women of his standing. He starts touching her and even drinks from the same cup as her. This would have never happened had she been of the same class. Then he uses the emperor's decree to marry her. Does he care how she feels about returning as a wife to the house where she used to empty chamber pots? Doubtful.
He likely believes that she and her family will be elated. A man of his standing found her smart and beautiful enough to deign to marry her. How wonderful! He elevated them!! Then he drugs and drags her to the capital. He assumes that her desire to stay in Jingling must be about another man. He cannot comprehend that she has independent desires outside of romance.
He believes that if he's patient enough, acts cute enough, and takes off his clothes to show off those sexy abs, she'll like him and give him a chance. Thinking about him just pisses me off.
I never understood the viewers begging Lan Xiang to forgive him so the romance could start. Every woman in this story is trying to escape a cage. Lan Xiang finally escaped and built an easy life, and he caged her again! We're supposed to gloss over that for "romance"? Hell no. Her restraint and silent treatment were much kinder than what I would've given him.
He does eventually become a man who deserves her, giving her more freedom than most within the marriage, and he's a great father, so... he wasn't a total lost cause.
The Romance or Lack Thereof
When they finally consummated their marriage - many years later - I didn't know how to feel about it. I hated the thought that she loved him. Not because she's undeserving of love, but because, in my eyes, he'd never deserve her love. However, the more I think about it, the more I feel like she ended up like many women of her time - those who never truly loved their husbands, not in the 2026 sense of all-consuming love, but found ways to care for them.
During those unconsummated years, shared hardships and conversations likely allowed her to trust him. Like water (another Prisoner of Beauty parallel), she learned to adapt to her circumstances and find happiness where she could. I believe that, till his death, he definitely loved her more than she loved him.
The Downsides
Despite everything I loved, 47 episodes were too many. The pacing after episode 38 went straight to the gutters. The resurgence of old enemies and mundane daily life wasn't interesting, and the time jumps didn't help. I fear they cut out most of what the audience needed to see these two, but especially her, bond enough to build trust and a family.
Final Thoughts
As I close the book to this drama, I wonder sadly if Lan Xiang was ever truly happy. Some part of me thinks that some small part of her never learned to be happy. She lived because her mother's dying wish was for her to do so. But can you ever be truly happy after seeing all the women in your life take their lives to escape state-sanctioned sexual slavery? Then later in life have to live in the house that belonged to said deceased family and with the family that played a part in this tragedy? She kept it all a secret and never used her name again. I think this is too much to ask for one person
Ultimately, this is exactly what I look for in stories about women and their struggles. It doesn't sugarcoat the past. Instead, it serves as a powerful reminder to be grateful for—and to protect—everything the women before us fought and suffered for. Things today could certainly be better, but we are living in their wildest dreams. We must never forget that or take it for granted.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The Potential Was There
I won't discuss the AI usage or the actors' looks, as the former has been discussed extensively here and the latter adds zero value to the plot. As my title suggests, this show had immense potential that went unrealized by the finale.The series has two interesting elements going for it:
👮🏻 The Tumultuous Romance 🧑🏻💼
This dynamic involves two key players:
• Fei Foon: A brilliant undercover cop taking on dangerous missions.
• Hui Leuk To (Vincent): A wealthy, closeted young CEO with appearances to keep up. He hooks up with Fei Foon (initially mistaking him for a criminal) and eventually falls in love with him, while simultaneously battling severe internalized homophobia.
IMO, this show would have benefited greatly from diving deeper into these two characters, their romance, and their psyches. I wanted to see how Fei Foon dealt with his feelings every time Vincent hurt him. Vincent was physically violent toward Fei Foon twice when threatened with exposure. The struggle of loving a man who refuses to be seen with you due to internalized homophobia deserved more screen time.
Furthermore, we missed seeing how Vincent dealt with his feelings—not just toward Fei Foon, but also regarding the burden of his family’s underworld ties. That said, his internalized homophobia and selfishness were the most interesting parts of the show for me. He loves and cares for his boyfriend but dares not be seen with him. He sees no issue with marrying a woman for appearances while keeping Fei Foon a secret. Let's also not forget his violent tendencies when backed into a corner about their relationship. Vincent consistently puts himself first until Fei Foon finally leaves without a word, forcing him to realize his mistakes.
Unfortunately, the drama’s frequent time jumps do a disservice to the romance. Because many major milestones and emotional turning points happen off-screen, the emotional beats feel shallow. I will not deny that these two had some really cute moments when they were happy. It just felt a little empty when I remembered all the things that'd been glossed over
🔫 The Organized Crime Aspect 🔫
This plotline had so many layers: Fei Foon's undercover assignment, Vincent's family mafia history, and the Eastern Hall + Shwan counterfeit money business. Done well, it could have been an engaging blend of crime, thriller, and romance. Yet, the show somehow managed to make it incredibly boring. Whether it was the script, the acting, the odd makeup, or a combination of all three, the crime elements failed to hold my attention. It is incredibly disappointing because I could feel the potential just out of reach—blocked by poor execution.
Final Thoughts
Would I recommend this...? Truthfully, I don't know. I left a note for myself at the end of episode 7 stating, "The last two episodes have been such a bore. And I'm really not warming up to Vincent. He's like a possessive child who doesn't like the word no." Looking back, the story started going downhill for me after episode 5. Between the boring crime plot and a romance I couldn't connect with, the whole thing just left me disappointed in what it could have been. I'll likely never rewatch this
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Is this how sports fans usually feel? I hate it
If the title wasn't clear enough, my faves didn't win.💪🏾Next time, contestants from all the countries should be chosen fairly. Some countries were very obviously more stacked than others. It's like they were setting some of them up to fail. I mean, I know you have to fill the numbers, but the differences in strength were so glaring
🇹🇭Thailand & 🇵🇭Philippines - I rooted for them since they had black contestants. Namely, James & Robyn. Did I think these teams would win? No. But as Issa Rae said, 'I'm rooting for everybody black. '
PS. I wanna add a note here that representation truly matters - I'm speaking about James. I've been watching Thai BLs for about 3 years now, and in all this time, I've only seen 2 black characters in these shows.
The first time was in 'Triage', and the other time was in 'I Will Knock You'. Seeing James on such a huge show -and killing it btw, heels and all - felt so good. I hope all the black and dark-skinned Thai pple out there saw themselves in him. I mean, I think he's a pretty big deal over there already, but he deserves this, too
💪🏾Australia - I liked them coz they were strong. I've seen pple hating on them, saying they were loud and rude coz of all the cheering and cursing, but to me, they looked like any other Westerners. I'm not a sports person, but they acted like what regular sports pple that I'm exposed to act like. They fumbled really badly in that rope game - I think that they should've replaced Eddie with Katelin. Had they strategized better, I genuinely think they'd have been in the final match. N probably would've won. Also, Dom, my favorite of all the Aussies. I need him to give me just 5% of his positivity
💪🏾Mongolia - Before this, I knew very little about this country and its people. Truthfully, I still don't. However, I started rooting for them after perhaps ep 2(?). They are definitely the opposite of Australia, but that quietness hid such strength. They were reserved and respectful, and so incredibly smart and strong. Their sportsmanship is truly one to be admired. While some teams ( I won't be mentioning names👀) were busy posturing and being rude to other contestants in the name of the game, they largely minded their own and stayed real nice throughout. I hope to see them again in the future. where they'll win. I'm genuinely so sad that they didn't win😭
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Unfulfilled Promises - I Wish They Kept the OG Dynamic
There is such power and expectation in a title such as 'The Servant Prince'. Even the synopsis itself puts weight on the master-servant dynamic introduced in the 1st episode.Takaaki is rather interesting. While it looked like he was being bullied by Naoya back in high school, it is revealed (pretty quickly at that) that he enjoys this dynamic. He loves being at Naoya's feet, looking up at him. He enjoys this dynamic so much so that when their outward power balance shifts, i.e Naoya falls to the bottom of the social ladder, losing his standing and money, and Takaaki makes it big, becoming nouveau riche, he still wants to be at the bottom of his 'boyfriend's-but not really boyfriend's' feet. Taking orders and serving him when told to. The man literally tells us that he believes he was born to serve Naoya. It's an intrinsic part of him.
That was such a good setup to me. I wanted to see how they'd navigate learning and understanding each other, growing and building a stronger relationship with better communication, while balancing this delicate dom-sub dynamic that one of them is said to crave and thrive in. Unfortunately, this dynamic is kicked to the curb by the end of the 1st episode.
From there onwards, they become just a normal couple. We watch them struggle to better understand each other, grow closer (past just hooking up), navigate Naoya's atrocious father, Takaaki's insecurities, and Naoya getting out of his shell and choosing how to live his life despite his past and his father. It's nice, but it's not quite what I was promised, now is it?
I remember watching Takaaki confronting Naoya's father in ep 8, and thinking to myself, 'Can you imagine if the drama showed us the contrast between this commanding Takaaki and the version that took joy, pride, and satisfaction in worshipping and serving Naoya? Being at his beck and call? How fucking hot and interesting could that have been?'
Sigh. I cannot help but lament my expectations of what this drama could have been.
Final Thoughts
The JBLs 'My Beautiful Man' and 'My Personal Weatherman' appear in the recommendations section for a reason. This drama promised us something similar to what is seen in those dramas - and eventually failed to deliver on it. Had this promise not been made, had this dynamic not been introduced, I think I'd have had a decent time watching this. Sadly, while the show has some positives, I spent most of my watch time feeling frustrated because of the broken promise.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
I Should've Watched This Sooner
Were it not for those last 2 episodes, I think I'd have rated this higher.I think if someone went into this hoping for a lot of romance, they'd be disappointed. Most of this story is spent navigating the issues the characters face to find their way to the love (and lives) they want/deserve, rather than on their romance.
Watching them navigate those issues is what made me binge the first 9 episodes. Only to be disappointed by the 3rd-act breakup scene. I say this about both romance books and romantic movies & TV shows, we don't always need the 3rd-act breakup. More often than not, like in this case, it disrupts the fantastic momentum of a story that the reader/viewer is invested in.
The Characters
👩🏻🏫Manami - I saw her jump into the sea in the 1st like 2 minutes of the show and got immediately invested. I thoroughly enjoyed her growth throughout the series. She starts very timid, passive, and clumsy — I'm still confused by why she was constantly stumbling on air — and slowly grows into a more confident version of herself. Able to make her own decisions and mistakes and own them. In the latter episodes, she rarely stumbles, so perhaps that was to signify a growth in her confidence? Or maybe I'm just reading too much into things🤔
Her personality is largely shaped by her upbringing. On one hand, her mother is passive and suffers in silence. On the other hand, her dad is a very sexist, misogynistic, and controlling father, who constantly speaks down to her mother both in private and in front of others. I hated that man.
Manami is the good girl. Never stepping a toe out of line (you know, aside from the whole stalking her ex and yeeting herself into the sea thing). She does everything right and is soft spoken, kinda like her mother. But she's clearly bursting at the seams, and the chance meeting with Kaoru slowly helps her break out of her shell.
Had Kaoru not come into her life, I think she'd have become another version of her mother — angrily chewing basil leaves at the sink whenever her overbearing husband did or said anything hurtful.
🕺🏻Kaoru - I knew he was the main lead, but I did not like him for perhaps 6 or 7 episodes. During this time, he remains very much a 'host' and doesn't show any prospects as a love interest. At least not one that Manami deserved. However, his backstory shows you how life has shaped him into the smooth-talking asshole that he is.
His dyslexia has crippled his life outside the club, and his mother is — as Kaoru calls her— a tick who's constantly sucking him dry to feed her 2nd deadbeat baby daddy. His insecurity over the fact that he can neither read nor write, coupled with the need to make money to feed the never ending blackhole that is his mother, pushes him to ignore what he and Manami could be.
Luckily, as the story progresses, Manami's steadfast belief in him and her assurance that he is not stupid help him try to see himself as more than. More than just a host with nothing else to give to the world. More than the dumb kid that everyone, including his mother, insulted and were frustared by. More than a pretty face. His character growth was beautiful to watch, especially once we started spending less time at the host club. He is truly a pure soul who wants someone to see him, value him, and be more.
Unfortunately, this is tainted by the 3rd act break-up. I know he was frustrated by the exam, but him bodily throwing Manami and her bag out of his house left a bad taste in my mouth. It reminded me too much of how Manami's father treated her mother, and that's just.... Ew.
The two also get back together at the very end of the show, without a proper conversation or anything. I'd have loved to have spent more time with them as a couple rather than those scenes of them away from each other.
🌸🌸PS. Something that made me uncomfortable(?) with Manami and Kaoru's relationship is how she reacted when teaching him. She used this baby voice and reacted like one would when teaching a baby. Like I expect that behaviour when teaching someone like Yuki, Kaoru's brother. He's a literal child, unlike Kaoru.
I understand that there's a 12-year age difference between the two, and that Kaoru was rather insecure about his inability to read. Kaouru is also a golden retriever personality who thrives under praise. However, he's an adult. The baby voice and overthe top rections when he got something right were not needed IMO. It made things weird.
🧑🏻🏫Sakura - I wish the story gave us more about his life and experience with love in Japanese society. He mentions to Manami that he's gay and that's why he has a lens into society's view of 'forbidden/taboo relationships'. This story focuses on the 'taboo' of Manami and Kaoru's relationship, which has to overcome their age-gap, social standing and financial differences, as well as the fact that Kaoru works as a host. However, I wish we had gotten a mini side story or something about him.
👴🏻Manami's father - He got a sort of redemption arc. I didn't think he deserved one. That's all I have to say about that
🪴Manami's mother - When she smacked her husband with a ladle on the back of his head, I stood and clapped. I'm happy that she eventually got a life outside the house (coz of the new job). I'm sad that she never went through with the divorce.
💼Kawahara - The story tells us that he eventually fell for her, and that's why he let her go. I, unfortunately, did not see this love they tried telling us about. When exactly did this love bloom? In the middle of all the stalking and the telling on her to her father? Let's not forget that he only wanted her because of who her dad was and what the union could do for his career. Plus, the cheating in the beginning. The man was literally planning to keep his side chick after the two were married! I just....🤦🏾♀️
🏫The School - I was flabbergasted by how this school was run. Maybe it's a difference between Japan and my country, but...
1. How is it a teacher's responsibility to go fetch a girl from the red light district? Isn't that the parents' job? Or at least people in the parents' direct employ? Like a domestic worker or a driver, perhaps?
2. When that one girl made Manami fall and hurt her head, and then everyone laughed, I was just...*mouth to the floor*. They would have murdered us if we ever did that. Maybe not the school, but a combination of the school and parents. We don't act like that where I'm from
3. Why does a school dictate a teacher's love life? I think, unless the situation directly affects the running of classes or the school in general, I've never heard of principals or parents telling a teacher who they can or cannot date or interact with. And I say this as someone who went to an all-girls Catholic high school where we had mass EVERY Thursday.
4. I also fail to understand the need to call Manami back to the school—after they forced her to resign—, only to have the girls insult her
All in all, I think it was a rather well-paced story that unfortunately faltered in the end. I am a fan of noona dramas, so this was a delight to watch. Despite the few issues pointed out, I enjoyed the progression of the story, the characters, and the relationship between Manami and Kaoru. It was a nice slow burn that tackles societal issues that many age-gap romances face
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Watch It For What It Is & You'll Likely Enjoy It
Aka, manage your expectations.The best advice I got before starting this drama was (and I'm paraphrasing here) 'This drama does not care about politics. Do not expect a story that cares about political intrigue or machinations. The story knows that its idol drama audience is here to simply look at good-looking people being good-looking and falling in love.'
That helped me better manage my expectations. I knew that:
1. We had a smart ML and FL. They would win against their adverserives but we would not see the process. A bad guy appears, the FL and ML quickly find out about it, and 3 days later, the bad guy has been apprehended, exposed, and confessed. They win, and we move. No long explanations on what happened. We don't even see the bad guy getting apprehended or investigations happening. Everything just falls into place as needed, and the main characters come out of it unscathed and victorious. Overpowered final bosses, these ones.
2. A cold FL, a harem of sorts, and a puppy ML - Everybody wants her, and she couldn't care less. The ML *really* wants her; they are best suited for each other, but she would make him WORK for it. This is my favourite trope, so I had a lot of fun with it. It reminded me of the drama 'Glory' that I watched earlier this year. That too had a harem, a cold FL, and a puppy ML. Gimme 15 dramas with this trope and I'll eat them all up.
Knowing these two factors, especially point number 1, allowed me to enjoy the drama a lot more than I would have otherwise.
Side note: I know we are supposed to love Hua Yong and Xi He the most. They are our main characters after all. However, I will say that the couple that stole the show for me was Cui Jin Bai and Bu Shu Lin. I found myself smiling every time they were on my screen. Their dynamic was so good (and hilarious) that they overshadowed the main couple. I wish we had had more time with them.
Ps. The fact that they did it once and ended up with twins?!?!?! What kind of fertility rates are these? Bu Shu Lin needs to make her man wrap it up, or she'll end up with a litter, and then her civil service dreams will be dashed. Now that I think of it, what did they use for condoms way back when🤔? Lemme go google
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
An Unfortunate Case of Wasted Potential
It took me 10 weeks to watch this drama. It'll likely take less time than that to forget it. IMO, I believe the filming style was bad, and the script was worse. Here me outIn terms of script, this drama had 2 and a half excellent topics to work on, but failed them all
1. Classism
As Thai-speaking viewers online pointed out, the title is a literal metaphor: Toto is the dog barking at Kanit, the airplane. It's even shown in the credits where a simple ambulance chases a plane. Toto is reaching for a world completely out of his league.
The drama briefly touches on the stark differences in their lives, careers, and families, but it refuses to linger there. Instead of letting the audience sit in the uncomfortable reality of classism, the show immediately undercuts the tension with cheap comedy, a cute romantic moment, or some dirty jokes.
Throughout the drama, Kanit's and Toto's relationship is constantly fraught with the issues of money and class. However, because the series insists on staying happy and bubbly, it never gives the weight that this heavy topic deserved.
2. Lookism
This concerns Akki and Veha. The latter, after being ignored in school because of his looks, ventures into the real world, hits the gym for the gains and the plastic surgeon's table for the looks.
When he meets his former high school crush, he is plagued by insecurity: 'Does he only like me now because I'm hot? Why did the ugly duckling that I was back in high school not deserve the same attention and love that he's so willing to give now?'
If done right, this could have been a deeply profound exploration of insecurity, as well as the superficiality and shallow-mindedness of humanity.
Instead, the impact was ruined by Veha repetitively asking the same question 'do you only like me now coz I'm hot? 'aloud.
Also, rather than exploring both perspectives -i.e, Veha learning how to accept love as this new self (or something like that) and Akki confronting his own superficiality- the writers took the shallow way out. They tried to convince us that Akki never actually ignored Veha in high school. That kept his bracelet the whole time. *🙄🤦🏾♀️*
2a. Veha's Character Growth
This should've been handled better. He started as a side piece who didn't know his place. Rather than the audience walking with him through his journey of atonement and growth, we
⁕1st have to watch him be sorry for himself (back to the badly handled lookism topic above)
⁕2nd suddenly contend with the idea that he's a good guy now. He's changed and gets along with Kanit, the innocent party that he not only helped get cheated on, but also antagonized
The drama tells us that he's grown and changed. But it all happens off-screen. This, quite honestly, does not help his case whatsoever. Because his growth was completely invisible, I felt zero emotional connection to this second couple. Their conversations were repetitive and a total snoozefest.
There's also that sudden switch up by Akki; from calling Veha trash for his side-piece actions to caring for and falling in love with him.... *sense, out the window*
Final Thoughts
Had the creators fixed the script and used a moodier, darker cinematographic vibe—think Burnout Syndrome or Moonlight Chicken—A Dog and a Plane could have been a standout BL.
Instead, it reeks of wasted potential. The romantic comedy is cute, but the story as a whole is utterly forgettable.
But hey, I finally managed to finish a TayNew show (this is after dropping the Cherry Magic remake 3 episodes to the finale), so yaay me🥳🙌🏾
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Their Friendship was the Best Part
If this drama has taught me anything, it's that when my dream of living and working in a different country materialises, the 1st thing I'll do is enroll in a language school.What I Liked
🥙The highlight given to all the food. You can make me watch almost anything as long as you mention that they will be talking about food from different cultures. I liked how Mari was curious and willing to try different foods. If she were real, I know that we'd go on so many food adventures together.
🌸Mari & Arikino's Friendship - Sure, it starts with Mari basically bulldozing into Arikino's life and dragging him along her adventures - his opinion be damned - but Arikino needed it. He needed someone to pull him out of that solitude and loneliness that had become his life. Someone to add some colour, taste, love (albeit platonic) into his life, and show him that not all humans are all bad. I love how he, over time, came to not only respect our lovely lettuce head, but also go out of his way to protect her against even his superiors
🚔A cold look at (some) foreigner experience in Japan - The world, at least today, loves Japan. There is a reason why the term 'Japan glazers' exists. I love how this show highlights how not every foreigner's experience is all cherry blossoms, mochi, matcha, and roses. I appreciate how they highlighted matters like xenophobia, racism, disregard from police forces, how language barrier affects daily life, etc., all things you never hear about unless you do a rather deep (and possibly depressive) dive into Japan - or any other country for that matter
PS. I also recently learned about a thing called 'hostage justice,' and Lord, was I traumatized. The thought of being a foreigner, getting arrested over there, having no language to explain yourself, and being saddled with legal enforcement that doesn't give 2 shits about you gives me shivers
💕How much respect and care Mari gave to Arikino & Oda's r/ship - She didn't make a big deal out of it, just simply approached the matter with care, and when Arikino finally opened up to her, lent a listening and understanding ear. She is such a good friend. We all need such friends in our lives (we should also strive to be such friends too)
🎶I did enjoy the OST by Balming Tiger. It's a fun little tune. But no other songs stood out
What Could've Been Done Better
🚨The police cases (and volunteer) - I would've liked it if we dove deeper into them. I wanted the show to dig just a bit deeper into the accused persons and the cases. But I suppose that wasn't the intention
🚨Mari's hair - It was distracting. Not the colour, but the roots and the intensity of the colour. I know TV shows/dramas are rarely shot chronologically. That is likely why her hair colour and roots growth differed so much. But, seeing her hair be bright green in one shot and a faded green with roots showing in another scene, and these scenes are supposed to be in one day or wto consecutive days takes you out of the story. They shold've gotten her a good wig or something
🚨The Villains - Mr. Volunteer guy played a much smaller role than I expected. He shpwed up in all white looking pretty but menacing and I thought he had a much bigger role. He doesn't. It felt like a waste.
Agawa did not get what he deserved. Yeah he got his throat slashed and might never wake up. Boohoo🙄. The man sold people to human traffickers, let murders slide, got that one witness murdered, threatened to out Arikino & Oda (leading to Oda's death) jeered at Arikino that one time they met at the station, and if left alone, would've gotten Mari killed too.
Being in a coma was too good for him. IMO, he deserved a worse fate
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
It's Interesting Enough...
IMO, I think anyone asking fans/viewers not to compare this show to the 1st installment is calling for a tall order. You cannot have a predecessor like the OG Only Friends and expect people to scrub it off their minds to watch this. Like it never happened. That makes no sense. Not only do they share a name, but it's set in the same universe, and the OG cast keep popping in. Come on now.The OG show was also messy, daring, and different. Far from anything we'd seen b4 in the Thai BL space. Of course, it's going to leave a mark that many will remember. Also, I don't expect a show like Only Friends to be relatable. If they were, I'd be seeking therapy and a new friend group, not sitting in my bed on a Friday to watch a TV show. I'm here to be entertained (and lowkey stressed out), not to find something relatable.
🎭Ok, now for my actual thoughts on this show, the couples, & plot.🎭
1. Jack & Dean
Their start was interesting enough. When Dean seduced Jack in the 1st episode, then Mix proceeded to break the 4th wall and stare deep into my soul, I was sat. I was ready for the mess, to learn what this unforgivable thing Dean had done to lead to the breakup, and to hate him. Turns out, I wouldn't hate Dean at all. In fact, I ended up disliking Jack instead.
God forbid, but if I had a partner like Jack... Bruh, I'd walk straight into Nairobi traffic. Just take me out, man. That man is so fucking petulant. Holy shit! When he got punched in ep 10, I stood up and clapped. A whole standing ovation in the living room. He'd had it coming for so long.
Now, I don't think the reason for their breakup was handled very well in this story. They broke up because Jack found out that Dean was side hustling as a host. And so he drank himself into addiction, hated Dean, and spent the rest of the show punishing him coz he could no longer trust him.
I have beef with that. I think that sex work or sex adjacent work should be handled very carefully, especially in this case, where familial circumstances and poverty led Dean to start hosting. And correct me if I'm wrong, but Dean never slept with any of the clients, did he?
He wasn't in love with any of them either. The man was poor, had to support his mother, was dealing with a sister who had an abusive bf, and didn't want to ask for money from his bf because, well, pride is a thing. Plus, moneyXromatic relationships are always a slippery slope.
Based on that, I'll say that the plot tried to be deep, but failed as they mishandled the topics at hand. Dean's poverty and family situation are only used to show that he's maybe untrustworthy, shame him into everyone thinking that he can be bought for sexual favours, and thus, hard to love. Like Jack was trying soo hard to love him. despite it all. Boo hoo, poor Jack *insert hard eye roll🙄*. Come on, man.
I wish that he'd actually cheated. Then all the drama, the name-calling, the mistrust, and the guilt that Jack (and others) kept throwing at and piling on him could make sense.
Side note 1. I need someone from the GMMTV screenwriters' room to sit me down and explain to me how alcoholism works. In the 1st installment, Ray was back to drinking after ditching rehab coz Sand's love and care made him all better. In this one, Jack, who went to rehab for drinking because he was oh so heartbroken, is back to clubbing and drinking with friends with zero repercussions. What...? How..? Fuck the science of addiction, I guess
2. Arnold & Tua
I don't have much to say about them. Friends-to-lovers has never been the genre for me, so I never have much to say about it. There was a lot of yearning and very cute, heartwarming moments with them. Definitely a change of pace from the mess that was the other couples.
I will, however, thank this show for introducing me to the ship that is JossGawin. I hadn't seen Joss b4 and the last time I saw Gawin was in 2023 in 'Be My Favourite.' I enjoyed their chemistry and acting, and cannot wait to see them in the just announced 'Round One.' I've seen parts of the trailer on Twitter, and it looks interesting. A little different. My interest has been piqued. Thank the gods I have a chance to see them in something since 'Replay' was cancelled.
Side note 2: I need to have a serious talk with whoever was in charge of styling Tua for this show. Y'all put Jack in those absolutely delicious fitted crop tops and put that on Tua?? What in the...🙆🏾♀️🤦🏾♀️. What were you trying to accomplish? What was the vision here?
3. Rome & Raffy
Now, if trophies were to be handed out to the couple with the most memorable NC scenes, they'd be taking them home. No questions asked. AouBoom is another new ship that this show introduced me to. Such incredible chemistry and good acting. Outside of their chemistry, their overall storyline was weak, though.
Rome was the good, long-suffering one, while Raffy was out there chasing and appreciating anything and everyone apart from the one person who showed him care. Yes, they got back together, but it felt a little rushed. Rome was really the 2nd option😭. Everyone left, and Raffy had no one, so he picked him. Tsk tsk.
I wanna see their future projects, but I'm weary of the upcoming 'Billionaire Biker.' I watched the trailer, and something about it gave me the vibes of 'A Boss and A Babe,' a show I could not complete. It's one of those GMMTV 'idol dramas', where the ship, their visuals, and their chemistry carry the show on their backs, while the actual plot limps and gasps for breath in the background.
🎭Other Thoughts🎭
a. The cameos from the OG cast were so much fun. I thought Sand & Ray cameos would be my highlight, only for Boston & Nick's conversation to come outta nowhere and take the cup. That was perhaps the best conversation in this whole installment. So heartfelt
b. Speaking of Boston, they used that man as bait. Had me all stressed out, only for him to work to push the couples together. Zero mess from him *sigh*. And then he had the most random 'come to Jesus' moment outta nowhere
c. What happened to the 100k that Pete stole? Yeah, he got exposed for the scheming, thieving, lying little shit that he was, but did he give back the money?
d. I wish they hadn't quickly dropped with that on-screen ship vs r/ship side plot that they started with DeanxArnoldxJack. I think that could have made a very interesting social commentary on the behind-the-scenes lives in the BL (and more recently GL) world
e. How did poor boy Dean end up in a high-rise with floor-to-ceiling windows? Did the pple behind the story forget that bro was poor? Or does rent in Thailand work differently than where I'm from?
f. Dean & Raffy's catty cutting fights were so fun to watch. Raffy was certainly in over his head trying to take on Dean.
g. Not enough 'cross kissing' for my liking
h. We saw Great in the 2nd-to-last scene. Does that mean we'll be getting a 3rd installment? If so, please, please bring back the mess - and tighten the plot
🎭Final Remarks🎭
Overall, the show is good. You can watch it, but perhaps lower your expectations on the messiness. It's nowhere near the levels of greatness set by its predecessor. The actors were good. The plot wasn't. It played it too safe and left many glaring plot holes.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
*taps chin contemplatively* Hmmmm...
This is yet another show that took over my Twitter feed for weeks and has (as of now) very high ratings, but I just seem to be on the other side of the majority.👻Let's start with the good👻
1. Arthit's r/ship with Direk - If there's one thing that Thai BLs will give you, it's a shitty dad. They are a dime a dozen. Out here, like they are trying to win 'worst BL dad of the genre' or something. That's why it was so refreshing to see how healthy and utterly unserious the relationship between this father and son was. Please, can we get more of this? I'm tired of all the a-holes.
2. This gave me 'Semantic Error' vibes in a couple of ways
a. Daotok reminds me of Chu Sang U. He is very robotic, especially in those beginning episodes. He seems to have a bit of a hard time peopling and a harder one understanding Arthit
b. How Arthit pursues Daotok. He lowkey basically annoys him into liking him. Which is what Jae Yeong did to bag Sang U. It wasn't on the same level, of course, but Arthit took a page from Jae Yeong's book. I like this version of pursuing what is basically a spicy street cat in human form. You have to be willing to annoy them and push boundaries (knowing that it will earn you some scratches) if you want them to notice and keep noticing you.
3. The relationship development in episodes 4-6 - This is where their relationship, the slowburn as it is, shines the best.
4. That NC scene - Who directed that shit? And can we have them coordinate more scenes in the future? Coz Holy Shit... Lemme not say more on this very public platform.
5. Solid friend groups for both characters
👻What Could've Been Done Better👻
1. The 1st 3 episodes - The pacing is off, and overall, doesn't add much to the plot or the overall plot. Perhaps, you could argue that it helps introduce us to Daotok's powers and helps with forced proximity between the characters. I'll agree with you that it's true.
But the fact that each episode is about an hour long, and we don't really get to see much of Daotok's power after ep 3 (I think), and the girl from jail ups and disappears until she's needed for some sleuthing later, it overall feels like a waste of time.
Maybe they didn't have enough material to fill 8 episodes and chose to drag this out. Or maybe they did, but chose the wrong thing. IDK, I haven't read the novel.
2. Arthit's behaviour in that living room scene in Ep 6 - I have no idea where that behaviour change came from. He'd been such a respectful green flag in the r/ship, then all over sudden.... TF? That kiss and the reasoning behind it weren't it. It reminded me of those Korean manhwas that start so healthy, genuine, and respectful, then, for some unknown hellish reason, the author decides that s*xual assault is what the story needs. Their makeup after that was really cute, but I'm sure they could have done quite literally anything else to bring them closer. Not this predatory act
3. Ep 7 & 8 - More pacing issues. And the absurdity of the choice to include a random shooting? It reminded me of those useless 3rd act break-up scenes. Where the author or screenwriter is like, 'Ah, they are doing too good and too happy right now. Let's include some drama.' And now, as the reader/viewer, I'm stuck wondering where all the unnecessary drama came from.
The shooting incident didn't even add anything to any relationship. Daotok had already accepted being with Arthit. He didn't need this random occurrence to make him 'realize' his feelings for the man, or whatever point they were trying to make
Overall, I'd say that this is fine. While the pair is cute together (I really enjoyed how cute n needy Arthit became once he started pursuing Dao), the overarching story itself leaves much to be desired. What had the potential to be good is ruined by pacing issues and side quests that could have been done and over within 2 episodes, tops.
Random (unrelated) thoughts
i. I could not help but wow at how beautifully their skintones contrasted. Generally, BLs love that (slightly) tan topXpale bottom thing. I usually notice it as like a footnote in my head, but it doesn't stand out to me. Maybe this time it stood out coz of how deeply(?) tan Ngern is. I pray that that man never touches skin-lightening products
ii. If Ngern and Joss Way-ar ever took a gym pic together while flexing those biceps, shoulders, and thighs, I would potentially, spontaneously combust. May the gyms in Thailand remain open, and may these two never stop going
Was this review helpful to you?
Goddammit! They made me (sit through &) enjoy fluff
I go into every fluffy drama with a dramatic side eye. IDK what it is about them, but more often than not, the acting is usually average at best, the comedy is overdone (or doesn't land), the pacing is horrendous, or the story is overly simplistic or nonsensical. And if I'm particularly unlucky, I am assaulted with the deadly combination of 3 or all the above factors.If you cannot tell, I do not generally enjoy fluff shows - I mean, my favourite BL stories include "My Beautiful Man", "Love Mechanics", "My Stand-In", "The End of the World with You", "KinnPorsche", "Moonlight Chicken", and most recently "Revenged Love". Clearly, I have a flair for the dramatic. I like a complicated story with characters who live in the grey areas of life, rather than in clear-cut blacks and whites. Fluff doesn't cut it in my house. Which is why my enjoyment of this drama comes as such a surprise to me.
Despite liking FirstKhao's acting chops, I was convinced I'd hate it. But week after week, I found myself coming back. The plot is simple but not nonsensical. It has heart, specifically in regards to Khaotung's character dealing with his mom's death (the guilt and regrets surrounding that), the aftermath and picking up the pieces, as well as learning to open himself up to love. The comedy also wasn't overdone. All in all, it was a good, low-stress way to pass the time on a Tuesday night.
Now, would I rewatch this? Honestly, no. Just because I like FirstKhao as an acting ship doesn't suddenly make me a changed woman. I am set in my ways. I am more likely to rewatch their scenes in Only Friends or The Heart Killers than I am this. I think I was able to enjoy this as much as I did because I only had to watch one episode a week. Everything was spaced out. If I had to binge it, I'd have likely dropped it. Or it'd have taken me a lot longer to complete it. But for those who love fluffy shows and like this ship, yeah, I believe your rewatch value/likelihood will be much higher than mine
PS. High school BLs (with age-appropriate actors) are the only exception to my dramatic side eye. They are 1000% allowed to be fluffy and cute. I will eat the shit up every time.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Tries to be realistic, passes in some parts but fails in others
The Wins1. I think their attempt to highlight the harm caused by obsessive fans is great. As someone who's been in the K-pop space for about 4 years now, I'm genuinely shocked and scared every time I see just how much people are invested in idol off screen lives. Actually, even their onscreen lives too.
2. The burden of being a celebrity in an image-obsessed society. At some point in the earlier episodes, it is pointed out that Laik is a brand, not a person. He's only allowed to be one way and can never be human. That's honestly such a sad existence.
3. The murder mystery aspect - This is like half a win. It was really interesting in those 1st 6/7 episodes. I was hella invested in the whodunnit of it all. However, somewhere around the 7th/8th episodes, everything went downhill. The plot stalled and started going round and round in circles with no end in sight. We also veered off, paying more attention to the romance, rather than the fact that a high-profile celebrity is accused of murdering his equally high-profile bandmate.
4. The reveal - They win on who the murderer was. I would not have guessed it
The Misses
1. Se Na - I think making her his fan was the wrong thing to do. I feel like it contradicts the initial message they were trying to make, especially with those fans who broke into his house and somehow found his number. If the point of the show was to stop fan delusion, they failed when they made his fan 'win' by having him fall in love with her.
IMO, it perpetuates the delusion that 'if only I get to meet my idol, then he'd fall for me', which is harmful for the levels of delusion seen in such fandoms. I think it'd have been best had she not been a fan of him at the beginning, but had become one in the process. Or if she were to remain a fan, she'd have been a more casual one, and he shouldn't have been her main bias.
2. The legal perspective - I speak on this as someone with a legal background. Her unshakeable belief in him was utterly unbelievable. It is human to be doubtful. Hell we are faced with doubt in relation to those closest to us (family & friends), how can you be so trusting of a celebrity? Just coz you are his fan and he saved you once way back when?
Again, the show worked hard to show us that fans don't really know what goes on behind the scenes of celebrity lives. We can speculate, choose sides when information is lacking, even when some information is revealed. But at the end of the day, we still don't know these people. This messaging is unfortunately undermined by the whole 'I'm his fan, I even met him once by chance, so clearly I know him. He'd never do that', undertone of the plot/romantic situation.
Also, lawyering is a job. You don't always trust your client. Sometimes you do, but as the case goes on or as more facts come to light, doubt can set in. That whole thing of 'I'll only pick a lawyer who 100% believes in my innocence' is dumb. And a privilege not afforded to many IRL. Heck, if lawyers only worked with people they wholeheartedly believed, the whole industry would collapse. And if accused persons only looked for legal representatives who believed in them 100%...., Bruh, everybody's going to jail.
3. Her dad's case - Why set up her background, show us the very reasons she is who she is today, the reason why she (partly) chooses to represent Laik only for you to not show us what happened with the dad's case?
Final Thoughts
a. Had they not sacrificed the idol life reality plot for the romance, I think this story would've been more impactful. But maybe they were afraid of the netizens and didn't wanna ruffle too many feathers.
b. They propped up the prosecutor in the beginning, but didn't use him to the fullest. His whole story of 'former high school bully turning a new leaf and leaving his terrible/corrupt father's shadow' would have been interesting to watch if further explored.
c. I don't think this was the intention of anyone in that writer's room, but I finally grasp (really well at that) why some idols have said that they wouldn't want to date their fans. Like, I always had an idea why, but watching this had me sitting on my couch and nodding like 'aaaah, I see it now. It makes so much sense!'
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Perhaps I should stop trusting recs on social media
I've been dropping a lot of Cdramas lately, so I wanted to push myself to complete this. But I cannot stop thinking about how much I DON'T WANT to keep watching it (seeing as I chose to drop this show and write this review at 1:30 am).If you were to ask me why I feel dissatisfied with this drama, I'd tell you that 'they' sold this drama wrongly to me. I couldn't tell you how many times I've seen this recommended as
1. An epic romance - Que that one scene with our FL and ML kissing while ML is on a horse and the military is walking in slow mo on either side of them
2. A show with a cruel, fierce white-haired general - *insert - multiple tweets, fan edits, and Reddit posts about Song Mo being one of the coolest white-haired generals out there, with apparently one of the best snowy entrances - here*
I went into this expecting a few things
i. A cool, ruthless, sensible, white-haired general
ii. Based on the happenings in ep 1, a collaboration of brains and brawn from the FL and ML — both working together to evade the terrible fates in their 1st lives.
iii. A love story that defied all odds through the sheer will, stubbornness, and cleverness of the main characters
Instead, what I got was
a. Some odd reincarnation (can we even call it that?) plot - So 3 people got a chance at a 2nd life - not 2 as I'd initially thought. Not bad. But, rather than me getting a version of 'The Princess Royal' where both the ML and FL find out about this 2nd life and work together, it turns out that he thinks it's a dream.
And the other person who knows the truth is a male character who rarely pops into this story.
He could be a random sage from the ages, a part-time narrator, or maybe a random magical being from how little he shows up and influences the plot. He randomly shows up, has a short convo with our FL (they are reincarnation besties after all), explains some things, then poof! He's gone. Eh??? Why's he even here?
b. The ML & FL don't work together - Until she decides to marry him, she spends her time saving him in secret, avoiding him where possible, lying to him, and trying her best to ignore his existence the rest of the time.
He, on the other hand, uses her largely as his moral compass/sounding board. At times when he has to make a decision, he or someone close to him goes ' What would Dou Zhao do?', and then they go from there
c. Zero presence of the cool, ruthless, sensible, white-haired general I was promised - The white hair, this white hair that I kept seeing over and over and fucking over my feed showed up in episode one and never again! *insert gif of me falling dramatically to the ground in tears and despair*
Like Y'ALL TOLD ME, YOU PROMISED ME that I was going to witness the coolest, hottest white-haired general, only for that to last for 1 episode???? Then, THEN!!! This so-called white hair shows up in some later episode as a random little strand coz he was stressed, as his father is an ass. But she saved him, so.... that was the end of that. I just... Liars. All of you!
Let's not even talk about how rash he is. The man doesn't even stop to think. Just rushes everywhere, sword and anger first, thoughts and consequences later. Because of his thoughtlessness, he even becomes a sort of pawn in Dao Zhou's hands
d. Inconsistent characterisation - This is largely about Duo Zhao. For most of the story, she is portrayed as a rebellious yet purposeful young lady. She learned her mistakes from her 1st life, so when given a chance to redo her life, she takes destiny into her own hands and defies what is expected of her as a motherless noble daughter with a spineless father.
She chooses to forge her own path, learning not only business but also how to stand up for herself and deal with crafty people.
So, with all that in mind, can anyone explain to me why, when she went back to her father's house, she sat back and let her horrendous stepmother basically dog-walk her? Let the terrible, power-hungry uncle continue pulling strings in the household?
The young lady we were introduced to before could have run laps around her stepmother and uncle. Could have found 15000 ways to prevent her marriage to Wei Ting Yu. She had the smarts, money, and connections to do it. But no. It took her younger sister daring to plot against her for her to evade that marriage. Girl... WTF?
e. Their romance is just, meh - They didn't sell it to me. Rather than it feel like 2 people mutually liking and falling for each other, it feels like her constantly avoiding him as he follows and badgers her like a lost puppy, hoping to be loved. She's closed off, and usually, this characterisation can work if it comes off as the character being careful. Here, instead, it comes off as cold. They didn't convince me of this epic love between them.
Like, that episode where she wants some, was it tofu pudding🤔? and he hears about it, so he has his men buy multiple tofu puddings from the capital and have them taken to her grandmother's estate in the countryside. That should've made me go 'aaaww. What a thoughtful, caring man.' Instead, all that rang in my brain at that scene was, 'Is this how he's spending military personnel and funds? Wow, what a waste'😭
Perhaps if I had gone into this without the set expectations, I'd have enjoyed this better. But seeing as I can't help thinking 'this is not how it was supposed to be' every time I watch the story unfold, I believe it's time to let go.
PS. A character I was rather invested in, in a way I didn't expect, was Ming'er. I feel bad for her. She might have been terrible in the 1st life, but I think that was her mother's influence. She is such a sweetheart in this life. I'd hoped that she and Dou Zhao would form a nice sisterly bond in this life. That both their fates would be better as in truth, they are innocent victims of their cirucmstances. Of the mistakes of their parents.
But seeing how she's still under her mother's thumb and ended up married to that useless man, I don't think that's happening. She's also being bullied by the useless man's money-hungry sister, and the husband, in his glorious uselessness, hides behind his very young wife's skirts and does nothing about it. Leaving her to fend for herself. Sigh, the poor girl.
Was this review helpful to you?

1
1
1