This review may contain spoilers
Regal romance, dignified sorrow—The Red Sleeve leaves a lasting impression
I have been hesitating to watch this drama as I already knew from the get-go how this will end. But, despite my concerns, I’m glad that I gave this a try.Since most of the reviews here have provided the gist of what happened in this drama, I will spare the regurgitation and get straight to what I deemed are the strengths and the weaknesses of this drama.
As most have most have pointed out, the acting of both leads stood out and I completely agree. I have watched both Lee Jun Ho and Lee Se Young before in their much newer works, and I am amazed that Lee Jun Ho is even the same person as acting as Gu Won in King the Land. Not to say, that his performance in King the Land was shabby, it’s just his acting here was so much better. I probably could say the same of Se Young in TSPMC, and perhaps it’s the testament more of the directors and writers of The Red Sleeve, who gave them both a worthy vehicle to showcase their full range of talents.
The rest of the cast also benefited from the strength of the script, and the guidance from those at the helm. Supporting characters are as complex and vital to the plot as the main characters, with no one feeling unnecessary. Everyone had their own role to play in the bigger picture. I especially loved the character of King Yeongjo, and the actor that brought His Majesty to life.
Speaking of plot, it’s intricate without being confusing, and I loved how the team handled the political intrigues without putting the romance on the back-burner. Also prominent in this drama is how friendships are being portrayed. In spite Deok Im’s rise in status, she still held the friends she grew up with, in high regard. They worked together despite their conflicting views and lay their grievances aside to support each other.
I have a few reservations though, that prevented me from giving this a full mark.
Firstly, I am wondering why they showed the funeral procession of the late Royal Noble Consort Yeong, and the Head Court Lady Jo’s heavy emphasis to Deok Im, on how it was an honor to die within the palace, if this was not to be reframed in the last episode. After not-so-subtle hints about this importance, I would have expected a similar procession to be shown at the finale.
Secondly, if the drama were to base a lot of the events on Korean History, despite some liberties they have taken to embellish on the romance, I didn’t see why they would omit one of the most important tidbit that actually happened upon Lady Seong’s death: the 26,000 trees that King Jeongjo planted in her graveyard that later became a well-known park in modern day Korea.
Thirdly, I’m not sure whether it’s heavily influenced by historical facts but the “forgiveness” of Hong Deok Ro, didn’t sit well with me. Granted that Yi San thought it was Deok Ro who saved him once when they were children, but that favor has been long repaid throughout the course of the drama, and is not a “hall-pass” to commit numerous atrocities. Many people have died for less serious crimes, and this guy just gets away with it and even be roaming the streets to live out the rest of his life.
Other than these small shortcomings, the Red Sleeve is a beautiful tale of perseverance in the face of adversity, and a love that spans decades, regardless of social class.
Was this review helpful to you?
this nearly destroyed my mental health ?
In Korea during the second half of the 1700s, Yi San is an aloof and perfection-loving young prince. His father’s killing haunts him, although it leaves him in the position to take the throne once his grandfather – the cruel and ruthless current king responsible for Yi San’s father’s death – dies. He has resolved to become a benevolent monarch who will reform the law when he eventually takes the throne, but the way his father was killed has scarred him emotionally.
At court, he meets a young woman named Sung Deok Im. Yi San falls in love with her and tries to convince her to become his official concubine. But Sung Deok Im is strong-willed and free-spirited. She is also intelligent enough to understand that becoming a royal consort to the future king is a prestigious role, but one that would restrict her freedom and likely bring her little in the way of joy. But Yi San’s love for Sung Deok Im is true, and she starts to understand that forming a union with him could ultimately benefit his troubled realm.
(Source: Viki)
Was this review helpful to you?
Whoa
First drama I fell into that wasn't a full romantic story. I have to say the ML was arrogant, obsessive, an overall a hole at times with the FL. I hated that he did not have any personal growth. But then, this is very realistic, this is how it is in real life. The FL was great but she also had her flaws so many misunderstandings that could have been resolved by just speaking up when needed and explaining to the ML her thoughts, he gave her many chances too. I didn't like her ending it was depressing but again this was more realistic. overall the story and actors were great. the Supporting Male was also an a hole completely, he should have been punished more severely. And let's not talk about the Grandfather king smh what a character. I give this drama a high rating because besides it not being what I thought it was good, everyone's acting was on point. it keeps you going despite the frustration, had me in tears towards the end.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
My Biggest Heartbreaking ?
Sebelum gue bisa move on, gue akan ngomongin drama ini keseluruh penjuru dunia ??? Coz i do really LOVE this drama, the acting and chemistry is amazing, and each episodes always keeps you anticipating karena dari posternya udah keliatan cuy mc nya kaga tatap-tatapan???? LIKE CMON, btw I love how they focused on the patriarchal society that existed in the time rather than focusing solely in the romance aspect. The characters are so well written ❣️this is my biggest heartbreaking kdrama setelah Moon Lover 💔 The soundtracks are beautiful to hear, salah satu favku Duk-im Bubbly Girl and im still listening to it now ☺️🤍 i hate to say it but i dont recommend to rewatch this bcause, THIS IS HURTING ME A LOTWas this review helpful to you?
I'm not a fan of historical dramas and I watch this just because of Junho BUT...
Yeah... I'm a Hottest (a fan of 2PM) and I started watching this just because of Junho without expecting much. I know it's too early to write a review when just 2 episodes were aired but I want to express that those 2 episodes preceeded my expectations. Firstly, I was amazed by the cinematography in episode 1 where the two child actors walking through a stream and a road lit by a series of laterns on the way to the house of the noble court lady. Those two child actors did great jobs. I'm glad that their childhood scenes are shown at a fast pace without much complications and cruelty. The acting of Lee Junho and Lee Se Young and their chemistry is great. I definitely didn't expect comedy in this drama but the two leads are effortlessly funny and adorable. I feel episode 2 is at a little bit slow pace but still I enjoyed it. The storyline itself is interesting so I hope more interesting plots in coming episodes.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The first 9 episodes are worthy of a 10!
The first 9 episodes are worthy of a 10! However, starting with episode 10, the story becomes unrealistic and starts to drag.What I do like, is the first 9 episodes of this drama; the female lead is not a damsel in distress, but is rather quick-witted, outgoing, and smart. I like the chemistry between the male lead and female lead characters. I also, think the supporting actors and actresses did an outstanding job acting.
I'm currently watching episode 11 (the 50 minute mark), and I'm debating whether or not, I want to continue to watch this drama. What were the writers thinking, when they wrote episode 11?
Was this review helpful to you?
Emotions: Anger
I was going to give this a low rating when I became angry with the writers in the last two episodes. I mean crap, you have me focused for 16 episodes with everything that was good, loving, fighting, protection of others... and you do a left turn into traffic run a red light hit pedestrians. The Pedestrians would be those who are watching this KDrama. I mean WHYYYY??? WRITERS... why did you have to go there? I'm in tears not because of the Drama... I'm crying because you left me out in the rain with no jacket on and it's freezing. The two main leads who played the palace maid and the Crown Prince... Lee Jun Ho OMG, he is fine as he wanna be... them muscles, those abs... He was so convincing in this drama, a very skilled actor. Lee Se Young who played Sung Deok Im was also convincing when she was in her role. Right now, I am mad at the writers because I was going to give this a 10 just for keeping my focus, and you kicked my focused self to the curb.Was this review helpful to you?
TASTELESS
Everything that I will write here is only based on my personal and unpopular Opinion. I have no time to argue with you on comment section as I will not change my opinion about this Tedious Drama.The Red Sleeve is your typical Historical K-drama about FL who doesn't know that ML is the Crown Prince. Damn I'm just so done with this. Writer, Can you give me something new?!
It's not that because of the Story I can honestly watch those stuff but God! It was so boring. I can't watch it in Normal Speed and I can't watch it without skipping.
Overall This Drama is tasteless The Poster, The Environment, The Editing and Everything. 3 Episodes is enough to drop this as I found it so boring. And also I think I'm just wasting my precious time and it's not worth it. Drop it like it's hot
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
LE drama de l'année
Ce drama, tiré d'un roman et surtout relatant une histoire vraie, marquera longtemps mon esprit.Tout était à la perfection, à mes yeux : déroulé, costumes, décors, extérieurs..
Et un jeu d'acteurs absolument merveilleux, pour tous.
Lee Jun Ho et Lee Se Young étaient hors concours, tellement ils se sont approprié leur rôle.
Je suis sûre que Yi San et Deok Im les marqueront longtemps; on ne sort pas indemne de tant d'émotions.
La première partie de l'histoire, racontant la rencontre de nos deux héros, enfants puis adultes, était émaillée de moments légers et drôles.
La forte personnalité de Deok Im nous est révélée très tôt, alors qu'elle n'est qu'une toute jeune court lady.
Yi San est encore un petit garçon sensible, bien que déjà très courageux.
La deuxième partie, plus tendue, m'a fait traverser toutes les émotions possibles et inimaginables.
Je me suis posée tant de questions, fait tant de réflexions...
Bien sûr, j'avais fait quelques recherches et connaissais, dans les grandes lignes, la vraie histoire. Je savais donc quelle tournure allaient prendre les évènements.
Mais il n'empêche...
J'ai compris les hésitations de Deok Im, son besoin de garder un semblant de contrôle sur sa vie , mais à un certain point, je me disais que finalement, même après qu'elle ait accepté d'être la concubine royale, ni elle, ni le roi, n'ont été véritablement heureux; elle, parce qu'elle se sentait piégée dans ce rôle; lui, parce qu'il souffrait de ne pas savoir si elle l'aimait vraiment... même un peu.
Par dessus tout cela, la mort du petit prince héritier a ouvert le bal, de chagrin en chagrin.
Ce n'est qu'au moment de s'éteindre que Deok Im dit enfin à son roi, qui lui demande encore une fois "m'as tu aimé, au moins un peu", que oui, elle l'aime ("pensez-vous que j'aurais accepté d'être avec vous si je ne vous aimais pas?")
J'avoue que, même en étant préparée, imaginer la solitude et la souffrance du roi après la mort de son seul amour, ma foi, c'était dur.
D'autant qu'elle venait de lui demander de l'ignorer et de lui laisser vivre sa vie s'ils se rencontraient dans une vie future. Avec ça, c'est le pompon.
Un autre grand moment qui mord le coeur, c'est lorsque le roi décide d'oublier Deok Im, pour pouvoir avancer.
On sait, bien sûr, qu'elle est toujours là, blottie au fond de lui, mais tout de même.
Etre le père d'une nation, ce n'est pas chose simple : à peine sa bien-aimée a t-elle disparue que le voilà tenu d'accepter une nouvelle concubine, raison d'état oblige.
La fin, que j'ai trouvée bien amenée, m'a cependant laissé un goût doux amer... il est évident que nos coeurs souhaitent les voir réunis dans l'après vie, mais je ne me sens pas sereine pour autant.
Avez-vous remarqué le rappel de ce moment où, alors qu'ils étaient au début de leur "relation de couple", il se réveille d'un somme qu'il a fait sur les genoux de Deok Im, avec une expression tourmentée, comme les prémices de ce qui arriverait par la suite ? On retrouve cette scène dans l'épisode final.
Je sais que beaucoup ont trouvé le roi égoïste; il le dit lui-même quand il est sur le point de perdre la femme qui a marqué sa vie, il regrette de l'avoir poursuivie et d'être la cause de son malheur; mais je préfère m'attarder sur le fait qu'il a fait d'elle son centre absolu et que elle seule pouvait se permettre de contester ses décisions.
J'ai, en outre, adoré le lien fort de Deok Im avec ses trois amies, toutes les quatre se protégeant et se soutenant, quoiqu'il arrive.
Le sort de l'une d'elle, mise à mort parce qu'elle avait eu une relation avec un homme dépeint bien cette merveilleuse époque (!), et surtout cet enfer que devait être le palais, avec ses règles rigides.
La reine douairière Kim exprime d'ailleurs ce sentiment d'extrême solitude, dans ce palais désagréable. Quel destin fut le sien, mariée à 15 ans à un homme beaucoup plus âgé qu'elle.
"Vous qui entrez ici, abandonnez toute espérance" (l'Enfer, de Dante Alighieri)
Pour moi, c'est la note maximale de 10, sans aucun doute, pour ce drama et ce, même si nous n'avons eu droit qu'à peu de moments heureux, le décès du prince héritier arrivant tellement vite, sans qu'on l'ait vu grandir. Mais je suppose que c'était une décision réfléchie, le drama se concentrant sur les étapes les plus marquantes de la vie du couple principal.
Au final, si la réincarnation existe, et bien que la Deok Im de la fiction ait souhaité le contraire, j'espère que les vrais personnages de cette histoire ont pu se retrouver et vivre une belle vie heureuse... ("Si je n'étais pas une dame de la cour et si vous n'étiez pas roi ?...)
Was this review helpful to you?
Una bellissima storia d'amore ispirata ad una storia vera
Una bellissima storia d'amore ispirata ad una storia veraLee Se-young è magnifico come Sung Deok-im, una figura ispirata e complessa. Deok-im è una donna che desidera vivere una vita semplice, indipendente e dignitosa, ma è inevitabilmente attratta da Yi San. Il dramma costruisce la sua personalità in modo che il pubblico possa apprezzarne la forza interiore, l'intelligenza e il coraggio. La sua relazione con Yi San è tormentata e struggente perché, nonostante l'amore, entrambi comprendono i rischi e le limitazioni del loro legame, soprattutto per lei.
L'accuratezza storica e culturale è un altro pregio del dramma. I costumi, l'ambientazione ei rituali della corte Joseon sono rappresentati con un'attenzione ai dettagli straordinaria, trasportando lo spettatore in un'epoca lontana con grande autenticità. Gli intrighi di palazzo e le dinamiche di potere si intrecciano alla storia d'amore, arricchendo la trama e offrendo uno sguardo profondo sulla complessità del potere e delle responsabilità re
La regia è elegante e rispettosa, e crea momenti di grande impatto visivo ed emotivo. La colonna sonora, con le sue melodie delicate e malinconiche, accompagna alla perfezione i momenti più toccanti, amplificando l'intensità del racconto e rimanendo impressa nella memoria dello spettatore
La storia d'amore tra Yi San, futuro re Jeongjo, e Sung Deok-im è ispirata a fatti storici. Il re Jeongjo fu davvero innamorato di una dama di corte chiamata Sung Deok-im, che, secondo le fonti storiche, fu una figura importante nella sua vita. Nella realtà, Yi San desiderava sinceramente che Deok-im diventasse una delle sue consorti, ma lei esitò a lungo, rifiutando per quanto possibile per via della sua indipendenza. Alla fine, tuttavia, accettò e divenne una delle sue concubine, ma il loro rapporto non fu facile e comportò numerosi sacrifici per lei.
Storicamente, il re Jeongjo fu un sovrano molto apprezzato per il suo tentativo di riformare la Corea e per il suo forte senso del dovere. Questo aspetto è stato ben rispettato nel dramma, che lo mostra come un uomo diviso tra le responsabilità di un monarca e il desiderio personale di una relazione sincera
Tuttavia, come in molti drammi storici, alcuni dettagli sono stati romanzati per rendere la storia più appassionante e coinvolgente. Ad esempio, alcuni aspetti della loro relazione e delle dinamiche di corte potrebbero essere stati enfatizzati per aggiungere intensità drammatica e profondità emotiva, rendendo il loro legame più intenso e contrastato rispetto alla realtà. Anche intrighi di corte e conflitti sono stati probabilmente amplificati per mantenere alta la tensione narrativa e offrire allo spettatore un'esperienza
Was this review helpful to you?
Desempenho impressionante de Lee Jun Ho como o Príncipe Herdeiro Yi San
Como pode essa história mexer tanto com meu pobre coração!? Os dois últimos episódios são teste para cardíaco, me levaram a uma montanha-russa de emoções. Ri, chorei, senti frio na barriga, foi como se realmente eu sentisse todas as emoções do personagem. Até precisei assistir uma comédia em seguida para aliviar meu coraçãozinho que está descompensado até agora. Mas vamos ao que interessa...Se você é fã de dramas de época que exploram as complexidades das relações humanas em um cenário histórico, essa série certamente merece atenção. A atuação talentosa do elenco, aliada à rica ambientação e à narrativa envolvente, torna esta trama uma escolha perfeita e ainda traz uma performance memorável de Lee Jun Ho. O desempenho impressionante dele como o príncipe herdeiro Yi San e, posteriormente como um imperador compassivo, é verdadeiramente envolvente. Sua interpretação magistral captura a angústia, o amor e o desamparo de seu personagem. Sério, deu vontade de colocar esse menino no colo de tanto sofrimento que seu personagem passou através de sua interpretação.
O drama foca no romance real entre Yi San (Lee Jun Ho), um príncipe herdeiro que se esforça constantemente para se tornar um rei benevolente que sempre coloca o dever acima do amor e que vive a sombra da morte de seu pai e da personagem Seong Deok Im (Lee SeYoung), uma jovem dama da corte que quer viver a vida de sua escolha, ao invés de uma das numerosas damas da corte chamadas apenas de mulheres do rei. Acho que um dos destaques desta série é ver o quanto Yi San está apaixonado por Deok Im. É historicamente conhecido que ele não amava nenhuma outra mulher tanto quanto a amava, e Lee Jun Ho foi capaz de transmitir perfeitamente essas fortes emoções.
A trama traz muitos detalhes e como que precisam ser vivenciados no drama já que não tenho intenção de spoilers. Com o passar dos episódios é perceptível que esta série tem muito a ensinar quando nos diz em voz alta que a felicidade está nas nossas próprias decisões, mesmo quando estas parecem ser feitas sobre coisas triviais. A trama traz muitos detalhes que precisam ser assistidos e sentidos já que não tenho intenção de spoiler. Apenas vejam e se deliciem com a perfeição deste drama e não esqueçam o lencinho.
Was this review helpful to you?
