Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Dumb Female Lead
Lucky I watched The Rise of Ning—otherwise, I probably would have banned all RenMin dramas!The storyline was so-so, and the plot moved slowly.
The entire cast was good except RenMin—seriously, her acting was so lousy.
The female lead’s character was just too ridiculous as a princess.
Was this review helpful to you?
Longest promise " literally "
YGY is funally here!!! im so happy.😍😍🥰🥰🥰i cant even remember when was the last time since i've watched a drama with Great CGI and good visuals ( magestic costumes and beautiful scenic building clusters etc.)
the plot of the drama is catchy and i can't wait for the next episodes.
the actors are also very professional i can't find the words to describe my feelings towards xiao zhan, his acting is non comparable, he's got more and more profound understanding of each character he plays, such a great person ❤
overall, the waiting all this time hasn't been wasted and im very satisfied.
Was this review helpful to you?
Xiao zhan
sooooo I guess I can say that this serie is good because of xiao zhan. The female lead is annoying(not the actress), she interferes in someone’s business when it has nothing to do with her. The plot is okayish, it’s just that when I started this show I was hoping for a strong female lead like in who rules the world, but after becoming the disciple she still had to rely on others to protect her. I think I can say that I am continuing this serie for xiao zhan, because his acting is really good as always.Was this review helpful to you?
o melhor drama que assisti no último ano
A história é incrível e a construção dos personagens é bem feita, amei acompanhar a evolução da Zhu Yan e como ela se tornou forte no desenrolar da história.Sua relação com Shi Ying se desenvolveu lindamente, demonstrando que o amor pode superar todas as dificuldades.
A relação com Zhi Yuan se mostrou bonita, mas nos mostrou que a obsessão é perigosa.
Nos capítulos finais fiquei angustiada com o desenrolar dos acontecimentos, e ainda vou demorar a superar, mas isso faz desse drama um excelente drama!
Was this review helpful to you?
I hope they come out with a season 2
I don't usually watch movies i have to read, but this movie was not only addictive, but beautifully outstanding . The storyline,was awesome and creative not to mention the acting was so moving. And it is so refreashing to watch a movie that is so beautifully intimate. American movies are so sexualized. And lack depth. I dont mind reading movies anymore and i do hope and pray they do another season. I will definately watch this again, i think i may even see if i can buy it. I dont mind reading movies anymore when it has this much quality to it.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Shi Ying wasn't just a character—he became one of the reasons I fell in love with C-dramas again.
Some dramas entertain you for a few weeks.Some leave you with beautiful memories.
And then there are rare dramas that quietly become part of your journey as a viewer.
For me, The Longest Promise was one of those dramas.
After finishing The Untamed, I honestly wondered if I would ever become that emotionally attached to another Chinese drama again.
Then Shi Ying happened.
And little by little...
I found myself emotionally invested all over again.
Looking back now, after watching more than fifty historical and xianxia dramas, I can confidently say that The Longest Promise remains one of the stories that shaped my standards for this genre.
Not because it was perfect.
But because it made me care.
Deeply.
At first glance, it seems like another xianxia built around destiny, forbidden love, and cultivation.
But beneath its fantasy setting lies a story about responsibility, sacrifice, restraint, and unconditional love.
Those themes stayed with me long after the final episode.
The heart of this drama is undoubtedly Shi Ying.
I've seen countless male leads who are powerful, intelligent, or emotionally distant.
Shi Ying is different.
He never tried to become the strongest person in the room.
He never sought recognition.
He never fought for glory.
Instead, he carried responsibilities that most people would never willingly accept.
Again and again, he chose duty over personal happiness.
Again and again, he sacrificed his own desires to protect the people around him.
What made those sacrifices even more painful was that he never expected anything in return.
He simply believed it was the right thing to do.
That quiet selflessness broke my heart far more than dramatic emotional scenes ever could.
And I think that's exactly why I became so attached to him.
Not because he was powerful.
But because he remained kind despite carrying unbearable burdens.
This is also where Xiao Zhan completely amazed me.
Of course, I've always known he is handsome.
But The Longest Promise reminded me that true acting goes far beyond appearance.
He didn't simply wear Shi Ying's robes.
He became Shi Ying.
His posture.
His calm voice.
His restrained expressions.
The elegance in the way he walked.
Even the silence between his lines carried emotion.
There were moments when he said almost nothing, yet his eyes expressed heartbreak, conflict, compassion, and loneliness all at once.
That's incredibly difficult to achieve as an actor.
Watching him, I eventually stopped seeing Xiao Zhan.
I only saw Shi Ying.
And to me, that's one of the greatest compliments an actor can receive.
As for Zhu Yan...
I have to admit she frustrated me during the first half of the drama.
Her impulsiveness.
Her recklessness.
The way she often acted before thinking.
There were many moments when I wanted to tell her to simply stop and listen.
But looking back, I realized those flaws were intentional.
She wasn't meant to begin the story as the perfect heroine.
She was meant to grow.
And she did.
Her development became one of the most satisfying parts of the drama.
The same impulsive girl slowly matured into someone capable of carrying responsibilities, understanding sacrifice, and making difficult choices.
By the end, she had earned my respect.
The romance itself is another reason this drama stayed with me.
It wasn't loud.
It wasn't built on endless flirting.
It wasn't driven by physical affection.
Instead, it grew through restraint.
Distance.
Silent longing.
Unspoken feelings.
Forbidden love has always been one of my favorite tropes when it's written well, and The
Longest Promise captured both its beauty and its heartbreak.
Some of the most emotional scenes weren't confessions.
They were moments when both characters chose each other's happiness over their own.
That kind of love always hurts the most.
The xianxia world also deserves praise.
Rather than relying on constant magical battles or flashy visual effects, the drama embraced a more spiritual and philosophical atmosphere.
Cultivation wasn't simply about becoming stronger.
It reflected discipline.
Balance.
Responsibility.
And understanding the consequences of one's choices.
That slower, more contemplative approach made the world feel elegant rather than overwhelming.
Visually, this remains one of the most beautiful xianxia dramas I've watched.
The white robes.
The snowy landscapes.
The temples.
The lighting.
Every frame looked almost ethereal.
Shi Ying himself often felt less like a prince and more like an immortal who had quietly descended into the mortal world.
The cinematography complemented that feeling perfectly.
The soundtrack also deserves recognition.
It never tried to overpower the scenes.
Instead, it quietly amplified every emotional moment.
Even now, hearing certain pieces immediately brings back memories of Shi Ying's journey.
The supporting cast added depth to the story as well.
Every important relationship helped shape the emotional weight of the narrative instead of existing solely to support the romance.
Family expectations.
Master-disciple relationships.
Political responsibilities.
Friendships.
Every connection mattered.
If I had one criticism, it would be that the pacing occasionally slowed during the middle portion of the drama, and Zhu Yan's early immaturity sometimes became frustrating before her eventual growth.
Still, those moments became easier to appreciate once I saw how much both characters evolved by the end.
Looking back...
I don't think I remember The Longest Promise because of a single unforgettable battle.
Or one spectacular plot twist.
I remember it because of one man who spent almost the entire story sacrificing pieces of himself for others without asking for recognition.
Shi Ying taught me that strength isn't always measured by power.
Sometimes, true strength is choosing kindness when life continuously asks you to suffer.
Out of all the historical and xianxia dramas I've watched, very few male leads have left such a lasting impression on me.
Shi Ying is one of them.
And perhaps that's why, even after watching more than fifty historical dramas, he still remains one of the characters I find myself thinking about long after the story has ended.
The Longest Promise wasn't simply another xianxia that I enjoyed.
It became one of the dramas that reminded me why I fell in love with Chinese dramas in the first place.
It made me believe that quiet love can be stronger than grand romance.
That sacrifice can speak louder than words.
And that some characters never truly leave your heart.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Cada episódio é um show de confusão.
Bom, eu sou uma amante desse tipo de drama e já assisti dezenas de dramas desse gênero.Eu geralmente consigo esperar três, quatro, até dez episódios até o drama ficar bom, mas esse daqui é impossível. Logo nos primeiros episódios é impossível realmente entender o que está acontecendo, e então você pensa, no próximo episódio irão explicar, e não, não explicam. Não explicam nada o drama inteiro, você praticamente tem que decorar maioria dos cargos, tribos e princesas e príncipes desde o começo, e tem uma baixa porcentagem deles voltarem a ser citados, afinal, depois de cinco episódios maioria dos personagens e tribos citados no primeiro episódio, nem sequer aparecem nos episódios seguintes.
Eu não ligo muito para a personalidade das protagonistas, não me importo se são avoadas, fofas, fortes, burras ou dependente, mas essa protagonista é sem noção mesmo. Logo nos primeiros episódios uma das amigas dela tem um vestido lindo e a irmã mais velha dessa amiga quer vestir, mas a protagonista faz uma picuinha para ela não vestir e diz que ninguém além da amiga dela deve vestir. E então, essa irmã joga o vestido em um penhasco; Depois de mais ou menos 9 episódios de enrolação, a protagonista resgata o vestido e o usa. Ou seja, desde o início ela podia resgatar o vestido, e todo aquele discurso não serviu de nada.
O Xiao Zhan desde o início foi um bom ator, mas o personagem dele é um personagem além de entediante, é confuso.
É isso, o drama é muito bem feito, com efeitos incríveis, mas a história deixa e muito a desejar.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The acting is not bad. But every episode Yan was crying was so annoying. there is way too much screen time of the support character, it kinda feels like I am watching multiple dramas at once. and Zhan and Min are the third lead couple (they just happen to be a part of the plot) I am honestly skipping the support role screen and going to Zhan and Min. It's not a bad show it is just wayyyyyyyyyyy too much of the second and third-lead couplesThe romance it so SLOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW.. omg I swear for like 12 episodes he was trying to tell her he liked her.
what saves this drama is the acting and the theme song.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Was kind of okay. The romance in it wasn't my cup of tea.
In the beginning, I had high hopes from the drama. The visuals were pleasing and I was hoping that the leads would impress me. For a while, the story seemed to be going in a good direction, but even I a watcher go tired of the ML's constant rejections. The FL was someone who just couldn't take a no and kept on annoying him to no ends. She just put him on a pedestal and decided to worship him, accepted all his decisions were right and made up excuses for the way she was treated. This is what happened between them for the first 35 episodes. They finally got together in the final 5 episodes for a short-lived romance. It was an open ending, thankfully I got to read the novel ending, where they get married become the Emperor & Empress. When they die they are buried next to each other.The drama ending reminded me a lot of Love between fairy & Devil. They should have done a better job.
Bai Xue Lu was the most frustrating character to watch. The way she just shamelessly tried to pursue people would have been okay if both of them didn't love other women, who cared for them in return. She didn't even care about her own sister and would have tried to break apart her relationship because she wanted to be empress. The sad part is she did not even want the men, and treated the one man who wanted her shabbily. She liked him but chose ambition over him. Then suddenly she had a change of mind, maybe had a epiphany and decided to become a decent person. Both the Bai sisters got their happy ending.
Was this review helpful to you?
Love the main ML, disappointing FL!!
I don’t usually write reviews… but omg I’m so disappointed in the casting for the female FL :/I have been looking forward to this costume drama since it was announced and with all the delay in airing… I was so happy to finally be able to see as I enjoy a good costume drama especially with actor Xiao Zhan, he is not only a good actor, his role is clearly depicted in his acting. On the other hand we have the main FL I dunno what they were thinking but acting skills is on a total different level - she acts like a B-rated actress, like i those cheesy dramas. I just find her acting annoying, it doesn’t flow, sounds more like a spoiled brat in her lines.
I will watch further to see if her acting improves but I’m not crossing my fingers….uuugh
Was this review helpful to you?
Unquestionably bad Chemistry
The storyline with the first 20 episodes is ok, but the most debilitating aspect to this show is the Chemistry.The main actress is cute in the first few episodes and when she supposedly matured in some scenes, she still has a tendency to look down the ground like a waif.
The main guy is supposedly her master but he doesn’t seem to have ‘that’ presence. Chemistry is hard to manufacture. The screen may show if there is chemistry in the characters.
Cinematography is cool. Acting is plain so-so.
Was this review helpful to you?



