Alchemy of Souls Season 2: Light and Shadow

I really did not like the plot of season 1, but did not really have anything better lined up, so against my better judgement decided to pick this up. The previous season's final 3 episodes were basically trash & I have to give it to the Hong sisters, at least they managed to recover from that quite gracefully in the early episodes, it must have taken quite a bit of creative effort to somewhat -obviously not perfectly- untangle the mess they've made.
I enjoyed watching the first 7 episodes, more so than the first 17 episodes of season 1. The pacing was much better & the new actress did a reasonable job as well.

While I don't regret watching this, it's quite a shame that the final 3 episodes of season 2 are also a jumbled mess with incredible asspulls left and right & that's out of 10 episodes now, as such obviously I'm unable to give this a very good rating.

Read More

**Alchemy of Souls Season 2: A Disappointing Follow-up to a Strong First Season**

*Alchemy of Souls* Season 1 was a thrilling ride filled with rich lore, compelling characters, and an exciting hero’s journey for Jang Uk. It was a show that, for the most part, felt like a breeze to watch. However, Season 2 struggled to maintain the same momentum, and by the halfway point, it became more of a chore than an engaging experience.

### Strengths of the Show

One of the biggest strengths of Season 2 was the performances of Lee Jae-wook (Jang Uk) and Shin Seung-ho (Crown Prince). Lee Jae-wook was convincing as the brooding, all-powerful mage weighed down by his burdens, and Shin Seung-ho was thoroughly entertaining as the Crown Prince, bringing charm and humor to the screen. Their interactions remained a highlight, with their dynamic being just as amusing as in the first season.

Another enjoyable aspect was the side romance between Park Jin and Maidservant Kim. Their story provided some lighthearted and touching moments, making them one of the more entertaining older couples in the series.

### Weaknesses and Disappointments

Despite these strong performances, the overall narrative of Season 2 felt lackluster. One of the most significant disappointments was the handling of the central romance. The chemistry between Jang Uk and Jin Bu-yeon (who has Naksu’s body but no memories) never felt organic. Their relationship felt rushed—kissing as early as Episode 2—making it difficult to invest in their bond. Unlike the deep, slow-burn relationship between Jang Uk and Mu-deok in Season 1, this pairing lacked emotional weight.

Additionally, the show’s pacing felt uneven. The first five episodes were tolerable, but after that, it became tedious to watch. Perhaps binging both seasons back-to-back contributed to the fatigue, but by the latter half, the story lost its grip, and watching felt more like an obligation than a pleasure.

Jin Mu’s continued presence as the main villain was another source of frustration. He felt like an overused antagonist, and the negative characters in general became tiresome to watch. The stakes never felt truly engaging, and the soul shifters, which initially seemed like they would be a massive threat (almost zombie-like in the first episode), never really played out in that way.

### The Lingering Absence of Mu-deok

The biggest blow to Season 2 was the absence of Jung So-min as Mu-deok. While the show initially made minimal effort to acknowledge her presence, later episodes did include some flashback scenes featuring the original actress. However, these moments were not enough to fully recapture the emotional depth of Season 1. The connection between Jang Uk and Mu-deok was so compelling that it was difficult to accept a new female lead, and that disappointment never truly faded throughout the season.

### Final Thoughts

While Season 1 had a devastating yet powerful ending that left a strong impact, Season 2 failed to evoke the same emotions. The overall storytelling lacked the depth and engagement that made the first season so enjoyable.

In the end, *Alchemy of Souls* Season 2 felt like an underwhelming follow-up. It had its moments—strong performances, fun character interactions—but it was ultimately weighed down by a lackluster romance, sluggish pacing, and a story that felt like it had run its course. While Season 1 was a delight, Season 2 overstayed its welcome.

Read More

I'm angry that they made a second season!

I loved AOS #1 up through episode 19. Then they had to go the historic tragedy cliffhanger route to justify another season. So, I'll admit my review is based upon my feelings. PLUS, I felt the script really diminished Uk's love to "love the one you're with" and that irritated me no end.

As with #1, AOS#2 was well-filmed, though granted, a lot darker than the first one. Great CGI, beautiful music.

STORY: Repetitive, with more of the same from #1. How the evil guy, that everyone KNEW was evil, continued to get away with his evilness was just frustrating. My biggest beef was the way the romance was written. Uk fell in love with Cho Yeong before knowing that she was Naksu. That might have been fine if we had some sense that he was struggling with his feelings, considering that he was supposedly so in love with Naksu. I didn't get that impression at all, though. Also, I didn't particularly care for the way that Cho Yeong/Naksu was written. Her personality was just so completely different than Naksu, I didn't get a feeling for Naksu's strength at all. She just seemed clingy to me, coming up with excuses to be with and touch Uk.

ACTING: So good.
Lee Jae Wook as Uk. I was believing his mourning until he met Cho Yeong and then that went out the window. I don't know if he lost weight since the first season or if it was makeup, but his jawline was so sharp it could have cut glass. It was a good look for him. I also liked him wearing black throughout the drama. It was like he had "graduated" from colors to being serious in black.
Go Youn Jung as Naksu/Cho Yeong. She did a good job with the writing that she was given. She is absolutely gorgeous. I've not seen her in anything else I don't think, I'm going to need to check her filmography and watch her in something else.
Hwang Min as Seol Yul. He, again, was my favorite character in this show. He figured out she was Naksu pretty early on, and you really got the sense that he could just FEEL that it was her. He did such a wonderful job with his longing for her.
Shin Seung Ho as Go Won. We got to see a little more understated comedy from him this time around.

CHEMISTRY: The kisses were so good, but I didn't feel the chemistry between them. How is that possible?

I have to say, I'm not particularly caring for the current trend of making multiple seasons of a show, unless it's an exceptional show like Hospital Playlist. Otherwise, it feels like they are just milking the drama, causing a lot of draggy parts to extend the drama length.

Bottom line: If you like darkly filmed dramas with multiple good fight scenes, good CGI, and you really don't care about the romance anyway, give it a try.

Read More

The world they built was too good for this

The best way I can describe how this drama felt to me is a shoujo reverse harem manga type of thing. I don’t know if that’s explanation enough but that’s the best I can do. I did have a lot of reservations about part 1, some of them carried out to this second part others didn’t but then new issues emerged in this one.
Let me explain, one of my biggest issue with this show (both parts). Whenever you’re watching this sort of stories there are always key scenes that are meant to draw you in and make you root for the Lead/s and make you go “WOW this character is super cool”.
This drama had -IN MY OPINION- too many. It was specially bizarre to me in the first part how Jang Uk was supposedly an underdog but then there was always -insert convenient plot hole here- and it allowed him to show off his out of the ordinary abilities. I get it he was supposed to have super abilities compared to the rest because of his horoscope but sometimes they stretched it too thin for my liking. With this second part I got it the first couple of times. it was needed to understand how powerful Jang Uk had become but then every other scene they are showing off his abilities and it got boring very fast.
Now one thing that I liked about the first part that didn’t carry into the second part was the ensemble cast. I know we only had 10 eps for this part but it amazes me how much talent and chemistry this ensamble cast HAD and they let it GO TO WASTE LIKE THAT. Part 1 & 2 feel WORLDS APART in that sense.
The focus was the main couple and I know this sounds ridiculous but the way it was presented to me in the first part was an ensemble cast rather than just the main leads and the rest acting as background which is what part 2 became (except maybe for Park Jin and his new wife). Why introduce so many characters in the first part that ended up amounting to nothing but a couple of sidelined sub level plot lines at most or not used at all.

One thing I liked about this second part though (even if the story felt a little rushed and nonsensical) was that I could finally root for Naksu and Jang Uk to be together. And that’s mostly because they greatly reduced Seo Yul’s presence here but mostly because Jang Uk had infinite amount of romantic chemistry with THIS actress. I was mostly team Seo Yul in the first part because I felt Minhyun had better romantic chemistry with Mudeok than Jang Uk (Besides Yul was given more of the date like romantic scenes than Uk)
Naksu was done WRONG in so many levels they turned her into nothing more than a damsel in distress for this 2nd part. Jang Uk literally had to rescue her up until the very end. Like yes she learned to rely and depend on someone else which is nice but let’s not pretend Naksu wouldn’t have relied on her strength and ability to fight even more so now that she had someone to protect. The shift was too sudden and in my opinion out of character that it felt like we had an entirely new and different female lead.

Because of the way the characters and this world was richly built and shown to us the ending was a little disappointing because it could’ve delivered something more. The OSTs and the cinematography was top notch and it does feel like I could watch another season of this with the newly appointed King and/or Seo Yul stories as the main focus because they are interesting characters by their own right.

There’s so much more Id like to add like how they made me cry so much for no reason because nobody ended up dying (it would’ve been better if they had it would’ve set how high the stakes were and the severity of the fight at hand) or the way they recycled Jin Mu one too many times BUT overall this was an enjoyable watch though nonsensical at times.

Read More

An otherwise perfect drama that has fallen from grace

I'll keep it short and simple: They should have ended the series in season 1 adding just 2-4 episodes totaling 22/24 episodes.

There were good things in season 2 but there were more things that made the drama bad than good. The direction of the story completely went south and one bad decision led to another. They did a great job with season 1 and should have just kept using the same formula instead of being ambiguous. The writers definitely had a hard time choosing between one or the other, so they decided to create a story of in-betweens. They should have just committed to one direction of a possible story instead of trying to please both sides.

Season 2 kinda felt like a mess and the final scenes were lackluster and unsatisfactory, but I wouldn't say that the drama was completely bad. Ultimately, season 1 was an absolute masterpiece, while season 2 needs to be watched just to achieve closure from the drama -- unfortunately.

Side note: I love the main cast of both seasons to death. I wish nothing more than their success in future dramas <3

Read More

Perfect Part 1 ... fun but confusing Part 2

Part 1 of this drama was one of my favourite things I ever watched. The characters were well-defined, and the story flowed perfectly. Everything made sense and tied well (and very tragically) at the end.
While I still enjoyed part 2, and while I liked the direction of the story in part 2, most of it was really frustrating to watch. Here are some of my reasons:
[SPOILERS WARNING!]

1. Master Lee
His character was absolutely charming in part 1. I loved how he subtly helped Jang UK reach his destiny and always looked after both of them. But in part 2, his character only seemed to exist just to confuse us and throw us off, so when the real predictable plot happens, we'd be surprised.
In one episode, he says that Bu Yeon is dead, only to reveal two episodes later that, nope! she was actually alive all along...
And then he tells Yul about this big hard choice that UK will have to make between saving Naksu with Hwansu or doing the right thing, but we never saw UK make this choice or even consider it ever?!
Don't get me wrong, it would've hurt to see him make this choice and I'm glad he didn't, but why foreshadow something that was never relevant?

2. Jin seol ran
The whole "She was actually Jin seol ran all along" seemed irrelevant to the plot. She didn't help them like...at all?
Except at the end with the basin but that was after the bird was free and the world was already on fire?
But even then, if the writers went with her being Jin Bu Yeon it would've still made sense. It seemed like an unnecessary added layer of confusion.
If she foresaw all of this, then why didn't she give them a warning? why did she hide in Sari village all this time?

3. Naksu
The memory loss plot realllllyyy dragged. Jang UK seemed to be made slow this season just to stretch the plot. He was really smart in the first part, and I refuse to believe that it took him this long to connect the dots!
Part of why we fell in love with Mudeok was her ruthless, fearless character who had a warm side to her, but she found it hard to show. I didn't feel those characteristics in the second part. Regardless, I think Go Yoon Jung did a great job, and at times I felt like they really were the same person, but those times were rare.
Stretching the memory loss plot robbed us of seeing the Naksu we knew because everything that happened after her regaining her memories felt really rushed. It felt like Mudeok completely disappeared once part 1 ended.
The final scene when she was telling UK that she doesn't want to train anymore felt so detached and out of character from the Naksu we knew and loved...

4. The time jumps
I would have loved to see a little bit of the aftermath of what happened at the end of part 1. 3 years gap was a bit long.
And then again in the last episode, they had a 1 year jump out of nowhere.
One minute we were fighting the firebird the next, we were babysitting Dang-gu and Cho-yeon's babies. From a super intense scene to a super colourful scene. In fact, most episodes had this sharp transition between the scenes. Similar to how 3 main characters died in one scene and were brought back literally 30 seconds later. It felt like a lot of the plot this season was done and then undone over and over again.

Overall, I still loved and enjoyed this drama, and I will dearly miss it. My favourite thing about part 2 was the cute romance since we didn't get to see much of that in the first part. The actors/actresses were great, and the soundtrack was amazing. Weekends will truly feel empty now that this drama is over.

Read More

Started great, ended like a joke

Yeah it's plot went smoothly on season 1 and half of season 2. Until a little turtle suddenly become a big hero, haha

Not clearly where is it from, and suddenly its a hero that solve big things. Then why kim dong ju can't go out from jinyowon cave? Why every great magicians suddenly become villains and don't matter to ruin the world?
Why su yon where jinmu switch the body just startled and not even try to move or run?
The fight with dwajo (fire bird) also done poorly.
Etc.

The 2-3 last episodes like a mess and joke + ruined everything. No logic at all. It could have been better easily with just a few tweaks and explanations.

Anyway since half of it still good and we have to have s2 for their happy ending, I still give 7/10 for this.

Read More

Overrated for people looking for something else in kdrama nowadays

I cannot say anything about cgi, music or performances. Even tho, no music was good enough for me to remember over the time. And some performances could have been way better but the directing allow them to act « not that well ».

But what I regret is that drama starts off with a very interesting plot and cool special effect we rarely see in dramas. The cinematography is beautiful too.

And then, little by little, we fall in the trap of a standard k-drama plot, which, nowadays especially, is only for fan services for idols and nice looking actors rather than a real plot, complexity, suspense, or without being complexe, something opposed to what we are used to. I mean if you look at it has nothing surprising to offer. Nor great plot or message to tell.

But I guess we call kdramas for a reason and kdrama fans for a reason too as I see the ratings.

I already said something about the acting. If you remove the cool stuffs and beauty… it looks very much like an amateur series in terms of performances.

People are going to say that of course the performances are not perfect since we have rookies. But this is the point… if you can clearly see it, how can you give 10/10 to performances ? Also I am not giving a bad rating because the director knew what he was doing and what kind of public he was aiming at. In that sense, performances are very okay.

Should you give it a go ? In order to support CGI yes but other than that, you can live very well without seeing it.

Read More

There really was no need for part 2

Okay so I know I’m super late to the party but I’ve only just finished AOS today and I have so much to say.
I can’t even describe to you how much I loved the first part, I literally gave it a 10/10 rating. It was everything I’d want in a romance drama (a story that has more to it than just romance). The chemistry between Mu-deok and Uk was the best thing ever OMG. I really didn’t expect how the first part would end tbh and I was so sad but I ASSUMED that everything could only get better right….. WRONG. Bro I felt like I was forcing myself to watch part 2. I hated seeing Uk pursue a relationship with a different FL it just looked and felt so wrong to me. Like even though I knew she was still Naksu it didn’t feel right at all. Also I just felt like the plot fell off so much. Part 2 only got good for me in the last 3 eps, everything else felt so slow and uninteresting. In my opinion, at most maybe there should’ve only been 20-25 eps in total and the plot of part two could’ve easily been shortened down and rewritten with less ‘flatness’. I mean don’t get me wrong I still love this drama and I’m so glad they ended up with eachother at the end but I was so hyped for the second part and I was very disappointed by the way it was written and how it felt like it was dragging at times :((

Read More

Nothing good came out of this season

The difference in rating and popularity between Season 1 and Season 2 isn't surprising at all. After watching both, it's pretty easy to see why.

While Season 2 is a continuation of the same story, it feels like a poorly written version of it. The world suddenly feels smaller. Everything revolves around the Fire Bird & FLs amnesia , while Songrim; once the heart of the story feels deserted. Most of the mages have disappeared, and the concept of Alchemy of Souls itself is barely relevant anymore. For a show named after it, that's a pretty big problem. The pacing doesn't help either; the story drags for long stretches and rarely feels exciting.

Jang Uk's character takes a strange turn. He's supposed to be a darker, more broken version of himself, but instead he often comes across as inconsistent. One moment he says something with absolute conviction, and the next he's doing the complete opposite. Rather than feeling complex, his behavior often feels confusing.

The biggest disappointment, however, is the female lead. Even accounting for the amnesia plot, she feels like an entirely different person. The sharp-tongued, fearless, and clever woman from Season 1 is nowhere to be found. Instead, we're given someone who spends most of the season being passive and dependent on others. The writers keep telling us she's Naksu, but they rarely show us anything that actually makes us believe it. For someone with such an important identity and immense power, she contributes surprisingly little beyond looking beautiful on screen.

The writing itself often feels frustrating. The show builds emotional moments only to immediately undo them. Maidservant Kim and Lady Jin's "deaths" are a perfect example. The drama expects viewers to be devastated, only to reveal they're alive almost instantly. It completely kills the emotional impact and makes the whole scene feel pointless.

Then there's Assistant Gwanju, who somehow spends most of the season moving around freely despite being one of the key reasons everything went wrong in the first place. Instead of focusing on the real mastermind, Uk spends episode after episode hunting soul shifters. It eventually gets addressed, but by then the payoff feels underwhelming.

The Yul and female lead scenes were another source of frustration. The show invests so much time creating romantic tension between them, even though everyone watching knows it isn't going anywhere. Rather than adding depth, it often feels like unnecessary filler.

Oddly enough, So-i ended up being one of the few characters who genuinely impressed me. She showed more courage, determination, and personality than many of the main characters. Meanwhile, the Four Seasons barely function as a group anymore. Aside from Uk and occasionally Yul, the others are practically invisible and contribute very little to the overall story.

By the second half of the season, I found myself skipping scenes just to get to the ending. Not because I was excited to see how it all wrapped up, but because I wanted it to be over. What made it even more disappointing was constantly remembering how much I loved Season 1. Instead of building on that foundation, Season 2 felt like a watered-down version of everything that came before it.

Read More