My Stand-In

No I desagree

First this is a very good serie, and Actors, directors writers who worked on turning it anto a drama(the story is based on novel ) did amazing Job.
I recommend to watch it .
BUUUT, hear me out: for those who say My sweet Joe was naive and stupid to be given a chance of life and go back, he actually in the second time had more guts and a bit confidence ,listen this time he managed to give Ming a bit taste of his own medicine,by just saying, this time my dignity comes with a price tag, five million ,a house and a music Carrier .
Yes you all say that's a nice way of saying he sold himself, but i think he understood that Ming will always be a narcissistic as×××!@ ,and he could not stop his feelings for him.
Like one wrote in comments, they are relationships who are more toxic in real life than ,Joe and Ming.
The only thing whic bothered me a lot ,my Baby Joe ,why do you want to go and save Tong( could you have found a better Name mybe you would be likeble 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣)
And Ming (in the whole country of 71,7 million, you chose that ... Man ,to fell in love with ????🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 not only you are a Narcissistist but blind as well , i can hate you and feel sorry for you.
Im talking about characters, Actors are amezing they really did amezing Job.

Read More

ANNOYED TO MING AND TONG AND JOE IS A FOOL

This review is only my opinion, so pls don't hate me,
This drama is annoying, it was confusing from the start, Up was so annoying here I do not like his character, his role is to hurt Joe by keep on saying to him he is just a stand in, it was annoying the situation itself and his character but him acting it is not convincing for me , in some circumstances I cannot really tell if he was joking or serious for real, and Him liking the boyfriend of his sister ?? and then seems flirting with that flirty Tong , I am not into this kind of story.
I could've continued watching it for Poom or Joe because I liked his acting and I am so convinced with his facial expressions, but I cannot take the drama itself I cannot absorb it and Joe is such a fool to accept that kind of man , I cannot take that kind of character who doesn't value and see their worth , I have my own stress in my life and this drama adds on it AHHAH I am so sorry this drama is not for me , not a fan of Up now, I even liked him at lovely writer , but now I don't know , And poom I think I can just watch him on his next drama if there will be

Read More

Overall best series of this year

story line is very interesting and both characters performed every emotion perfectly, although it's very hard to wait for next friday. Ming is rich and crazy while Joe is soft and caring. Their chemistry has lots of up's and down. In starting when they get to know eachother Joe put lot's of effort in their relationship but Ming only treat him asI replacement of Tong and always make him feel uncomfortable. But later when Joe reborn in another Joe body after 3 years in this mean time Ming realised Joe importance and care towards him, this whole time Ming suffers a lot. when somehow they get together again Ming put lot's of effort in their relationship. I hope this drama will get happy ending.

Read More

I just finished the last episode, and in my opinion, the ending is too "joyful" for certain characters. I won’t spoil anything, but those who have seen the drama will understand who I’m referring to.

Ming's character stood out to me. Although I wouldn’t have enjoyed the novel due to many extra scenes, the drama's version made it more enjoyable. Up's performance was excellent. His naturally cold expression suited Ming, a character who openly admits he doesn't like people. Ming's honesty about his feelings was refreshing; he doesn’t pretend. If he doesn’t like you, you’ll know it, if he loves you, you’ll know it too, and if he’s indifferent, it’s the same.

Ming's journey is compelling as he evolves in showing his love while staying true to himself. Despite his mistakes, which in real life would be unacceptable for most, there are still those who would give him a second chance. Here, Joe was one of them. I only wish there had been more emotional scenes to reflect this growth.

Joe, on the other hand, remains consistent throughout. He is sweet, kind, and somewhat naive. While he isn’t the smartest, his natural gentleness wins over the audience. The actor playing Joe did an impeccable job; he embodied the character perfectly.

Tong, however, was a character I disliked from beginning to end. The actor did a fantastic job in portraying him, but the character's actions were hard to swallow.

The series excels in music and cinematography, with roles and actors perfectly cast. However, I felt it lacked an I love you at the end, which I was eagerly awaiting.

Read More

Final Review of *My Stand-In*:

I just finished the last episode, and in my opinion, it's too "joyful" for certain characters. I won’t spoil anything, but those who have seen the drama will understand who I’m referring to.

Regarding Ming, I really liked his character even though I would never have been able to read the novel due to numerous additional scenes that, thankfully, were removed from the drama, making it more enjoyable. Up did an excellent job. The actor has a rather cold expression when he doesn’t smile, making him perfect for playing Ming, who, in his own words, doesn't like people. I found it brilliant that they had Ming say, "I don't like people very much," because Ming will never be the type to smile and be friendly with everyone. He doesn’t pretend; if he doesn’t like you, you’ll know it, if he loves you, you’ll know it too, and if he’s indifferent, it’s the same!

From start to finish, Ming retains his personality while evolving in how he shows his love. Yes, the character made mistakes that, in real life, would be intolerable for 90% of the population, but there are 10% who would be willing to give a second chance. 5% would be right, 5% wrong. Here, Joe was right. I just regret the lack of tears, but I think that fits the character.

Regarding Joe, he remains the same from beginning to end. He is a sweet, kind, and somewhat simple character. Let’s be honest, Joe isn’t very clever, but he has a natural gentleness that attracts the audience. The actor played his role very well; it’s flawless. He was perfect; Joe was Poom and no one else!

As for Tong, I hated his character from start to finish. Kudos to the actor, nothing more to add without spoiling.

The music is very well managed, the series is beautifully shot, and the roles and actors are perfectly executed. However, it lacks an "I love you" at the end. I was waiting for it...

I know they both show their love through their actions, but I would have still liked a little "I love you" to wrap things up nicely.

It’s an 8.5/10 for me. My highest rating of the year so far!

Why not a 10? Because I found some moments a bit slow, long, and uninteresting, and others too rushed and illogical.

Thank you to all the actors. Plus, I discovered a lovely YouTube channel. The actor who plays Ming (Up) has a YouTube channel if you want to check it out.

Read More

¡Qué tres meses este viaje!

Aunque llevo tiempo viendo BL, es la primera vez que una serie me hace querer leer el material inicial y vaya si me lo introduje por el orificio anal con fuerza, que me leí las 1000 páginas en menos de 4 días. Eso habla mucho de la adaptación.

Y, aunque habiendo leído la novela, siento que tengo una opinión distinta de la que habría tenido sin haberlo hecho, no me arrepiento, porque llegué a comprender mucho mejor la psicología de los personajes que no llega a desarrollarse todo lo que me gustaría en la serie. Creo que la mayoría de los cambios realizados aportan bastante a la trama y, por mucho que la gente diga, yo no siento que hayan endulzado el personaje de Ming. Sinceramente, me lo imaginaba bastante como lo he visto en la serie. Más joven, claramente, pero igual de guapo, malo y ajusticiado por el karma.

Volveré a verla, lo tengo claro.

Read More

Incomparável!! Um trabalho absurdamente bem feito.

Sinceramente, gente, essa série é uma das melhores da Tailândia. Se não for a melhor. Só poderei dizer, de fato, se é, ou não, quando assistir o final. Sim, o relacionamento deles é tóxico, mas não é tóxico como em TharnType ou KinnPorsche. A série deixa bem claro que o Ming é um lixo e que o Joe não tem amor próprio. É romântico, mas não é romantizado. Tá tudo bem claro ali. Além de roteiro, diálogos, fotografia e trilha sonora absolutamente maravilhosos. Não tem aqueles clichês horrorosos, que tem em todas da GMM. Os protagonistas atuam super bem. O elenco todo é muito bom!

Quem deixou de assistir porque tem drama ou sofrimento demais, está perdendo uma história maravilhosa, muito bem contada, cheia de altos e baixos, que te prende. Vai ser um marco na produção de BLs na Tailândia. Elevou DEMAIS o nível. E que cada vez venham mais BL's como tão bons, ou melhores, do que este

Read More

BL tipicamente Thai, con scene di sesso esplicite (in questo caso anche riferimenti verbali a ruoli, posizioni, ecc.) e molto incentrata sui protagonisti, dove la storia tra i due è di fatto la storia del drama e non è prevista quindi una trama più ampia a parte.

Punti a favore:
- la recitazione - soprattutto quella dei protagonisti - più convincente rispetto alla media degli attori tailandesi
- l'attore che interpreta Joe: espressivo e affascinante
- la caratterizzazione dei personaggi: Ming è una figura sicuramente e volutamente non positiva, narcisistica ed egoista fino al midollo in tutta la prima parte. Il suo è un vero e proprio opportunismo, Joe è di fatto il rimpiazzo di Tong e la gelosia che lo coglie all'entrata in scena di Sol non è da correlare a un inaspettato innamoramento bensì a una mera possessività. La nota positiva è che la scomparsa di Joe promuove in lui un lento ma radicale cambiamento, senza però snaturare nel complesso i suoi tratti caratteriali. Migliora, notevolmente, pur rimanendo sempre Ming. Joe al contrario è colui che inizialmente è disposto a cedere su tutti i fronti, praticamente senza mai lo sforzo di un compromesso da parte di Ming. Anche lui evolve, per certi aspetti più di Ming, nel corso della storia: diventa meno arrendevole, scopre nuove priorità e, soprattutto, si ritrova di fronte all'ardua sfida di vivere la sua vecchia vita in modo nuovo e dentro un corpo diverso. Per quanto cambino, però, restano coerenti ai tratti base della loro caratterizzazione iniziale (nessuna snaturazione insensata e assurda alla Kinn/Porsche, per intenderci).

Punti a sfavore:
- il tema della reincarnazione, o meglio del trasferimento dell'anima del vecchio Joe nel corpo dell'altro Joe: non è un meccanismo che mi entusiasma particolarmente e l'idea del diverso aspetto nemmeno. Fortunatamente hanno ben pensato di mantenere, per lo spettatore, il Joe originale (quasi quasi avrei eliminato anche i pochi frangenti che mostravano come in realtà appariva agli occhi degli altri). Gli avrei almeno concesso la possibilità di riprendere possesso del proprio corpo verso la fine (niente di impossibile, bastava inventarsi che l'incidente era accaduto in una zona remota ed era stato soccorso da qualcuno della zona, rimasto in coma per tot tempo, la volontà della troupe di non creare scalpore in seguito alla sua scomparsa avrebbe giustificato anche delle ricerche brevi e approssimative).
- L'infatuazione vecchia di anni per il fidanzato della sorella è credibile, ma che poi si riveli essere tutta legata alla scena di un film in cui il presunto Tong si vede solo di spalle...anche no.
- Sol: la sua ricomparsa, anni dopo essersene andato, perchè tutto a un tratto nei suoi pensieri c'è Joe...Davvero senza senso. Serve farlo tornare? Ci si inventa una qualsiasi altra motivazione, anche professionale, dopodichè la vicinanza con Joe può anche portare alla nascita - o al rispolvero - di un interesse nei suoi confronti. Non serve uno sforzo megagalattico per rendere un passaggio coerente, ma a volte davvero la credibilità sembra proprio avere zero importanza e meritare zero investimento.
- I drammi familiari: dopo aver dedicato i tre quarti del drama al rapporto tra i due, alla questione della "controfigura" di Tong, al cambio di corpo di Joe... Ha davvero senso introdurre l'apparentemente insormontabile scoglio dell'opposizione dei genitori di Ming? Il tempo rimasto è poco, la risoluzione deve quindi essere forzatamente rapida e di conseguenza ancora una volta poco sensata: la madre passa dalla modalità "squalo" a quella "agnellino" alla velocità di un cambio d'abiti e il padre sostanzialmente disereda il figlio con l'obiettivo di minare il suo rapporto con Joe per evitare che possa soffrire di nuovo se lasciato solo. Logico, no?

In conclusione, un drama che - col metro delle BL thailandesi - si aggiudica una valutazione buona, per certi versi - cast e rceitazione - sopra la media. Spunti di miglioramento potevano essere la credibilità di alcuni passaggi, lo sviluppo di una trama più ampia e complessa e un maggior coinvolgimento emotivo (personalmente nessun batticuore, nessuna lacrimuccia di commozione, nessuna risata).

Read More