Upstream (2024)

Fun Dramedy with a Strange Message

(I'll warn you when I spoil, which is basically the end of the story.)

I Middle-aged dude software engineer in corporate China loses job and scrambles to find employment to take care of his family and keep their home. Jobs are so hard to find he ends up becoming a delivery 'boy' and perhaps he's too old for the job. But he perseveres to admirable yet mixed results.

The story stars writer/director/actor Xu Zheng -- and he's absolutely great. What brought me eyes to this film was starlet Xin Zhi Lei, but she did her job as a bait and switch actress. Don't see this film to see her -- she's barely in it. And any number of actresses could have played this role. I think Xu Zheng wanted a hottie by his side, and with Xin Zhi Lei -- who can blame him.

The big star of this story is the pacing. Despite being two hours long it's pacing makes it feel much faster. Although this piece has a low budget feel, the sheer number of locations will blow your mind. This delivery company, like the film crew, are all over this city.

My problem with this film was its ultimate point. What exactly was the Xu Zheng trying to say?

One the one hand there was a rather kind message: don't look down on those people delivering your food, you privileged bastards. These delivery people (apparently) work like dogs and are humans too. There's a really nice series of shots at one point where it showed all the delivery people smiling. That they took pride in their work. Teeth and humanity.

My problem was the second message in the story, that was as realistic as it was kind of sad.

(SPOILERS)

Our hero literally risks his life doing as many deliveries as possible to keep his home and family safe. He eventually loses his home and ends up in a smaller place, presumably an apartment. His wife says it's okay because it reminds her of her childhood. The message here is the cliche that we grew up poor but were happier when we were poor. This message is repeated when our hero goes to the home of one of his co-workers and it's basically a narrow shack in an unpleasant area.

The story is saying family is more important than financial security. Hmm. Really? America right now is going thru an affordability crisis and most of us believe financial security is the best way to taking care of your family. I presumed this was a global truth that the Chinese would particularly agree with. But instead this film says "Being fired happens all the time, and beside you're getting old so you kinda should expect this." Hmm...

So the story's message is enjoy what you got instead of what you need, because if you have family you've got all you need. Really? And what if you don't have a family? I guess your co-workers become that? Like I said, strange message.

Despite this major messaging flaw, it's worth seeing if interested. The problem is it's not a strong recommend.

Read More