This review may contain spoilers
This is not your typical horror series.
It doesn’t rely on cheap jump scares or random twists. What makes it stand out is its consistency. The story builds a system with clear rules — and actually respects them. Every decision has consequences, and the tension comes from watching characters navigate a game designed for them to fail.There are echoes of franchises like A Nightmare on Elm Street or Saw, where the “evil” doesn’t disappear, it just moves on. But this series doesn’t copy — it builds its own identity by mixing folklore with modern elements in a way that feels both grounded and unsettling.
The pacing is excellent. I didn’t skip a single scene — and that says a lot. In fact, I found myself rewatching moments just to feel the tension again.
And the ending? It’s not the one you expect — it’s the one the story needed. It closes the main conflict while making it clear that the system is still active.
They survived… but the game didn’t end.
Was this review helpful to you?
Too Much Gore, Not Enough Story
This story seemed kind of intriguing at the beginning. I love a good horror series. It seemed to have a blend of shamanism with a touch of "The Ring" horror movie blended together. A count down of 24 hours instead of seven days ....However, there was real difficulty for me getting pulled into this story. At times it was a bit confusing and a little mixed up with the direction of the plot. It seemed to be focused on blood and gore. I mean, I get it, it's a horror theme, so naturally you need the blood and cutting flesh and all the good stuff that goes with it ... but it just seemed to be excessive, showing the same scenes over and over again.
It wasn't until episode 5 that the series started to redeem itself. I'm kind of glad I was able to stick it out that long, because there were a few times I just about gave up on it. From episode 5 through the final episode, it was a much more enjoyable watch. The characters become more in focus, as does the story, too ... all except the ending.
Not exactly sure what the ending is trying to suggest or hint at maybe a sequel?? but it really didn't work for me.
Overall, not a bad series, but could have been so much better!!!!!
Was this review helpful to you?
MASTERPIECE
I tuned in to the drama not expecting much but this was mind blowing I ended up binge watching everything in a day. The plot was fantastic and made so much sense no dragging, the drama was well done and the scenes look so realistic. it got me stressed out man, but I think the love triangle with the FL was kinda forced and unnecessary even though SML was so cute. I really wished dramas like this can just have a perfect ending without hinging on a season 2 cause they end up taking ages to drop a new season. I’m really impressed I need more people to discover this.Was this review helpful to you?
or more like "if friendship could kill"
Human beings are the only creatures that have the ability to speak, but they can't communicate. As long as human beings' selfish desires exist, no one can break the curse.I am not into these horror , mystery thriller, and gruesome shows, but people on Reddit said it's kinda similar to "Night Has Come", so I picked it up. I went with fewer expectations, but the acting amazed me.
Honestly, there are a lot of loopholes in the plot; I can't even fathom whether it is an open ending or a season 2 teaser .
The cast gave their everything , it felt realistic with their acting. *clap clap*
Maybe it could be better if we could get 12 episodes to show some character story and about their friendship; it passed too fast, even though I was rooting for the second main lead and the female lead, but we needed more of their parts.
The story was jumping back and forth with the storyline, so it was kinda confusing
If season 2 gets announced, then of course I will watch it because I watched season 1 and want answers to my questions, but I do think the plot could be better.
Avoid if you can't watch blood and gore, and please check trigger warnings.
Was this review helpful to you?
need season 2 asap
I you loved watching like night has come you will definitely loved this one with a twist a bit dark and ready yourself ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………Was this review helpful to you?
A Suspenseful Drama with Great Twists but a Confusing Story
I really enjoyed If wishes could kill and I ended up giving it an 8.5/10. I really liked the characters of Ha Joon and Se Ah, and I got attached to the whole friend group as well as Ha Joon’s brothers-in-law. One thing I especially loved was the plot twist where the drama makes us believe one specific person created the app, when actually that wasn’t the case at all. That reveal genuinely surprised me.I also really liked the atmosphere of the drama. For something involving deaths and a supernatural app, I thought the mood and tension were handled pretty well overall. Even though some of the special effects looked a little awkward at times, it didn’t completely ruin the experience for me.
However, I do have to admit that the story became a bit messy toward the end. Sometimes it felt like the plot didn’t fully know where it wanted to go, and I found it complicated to understand why the app suddenly became “alive” and how everything actually worked. Some explanations felt confusing or underdeveloped, which made certain moments harder to follow.
Still, despite those flaws, I found the drama entertaining, suspenseful, and emotionally engaging because of the characters and relationships.
Was this review helpful to you?
thrilling
i think y'all should stop going too much into the technical aspect and start enjoying the drama for what is it and take it as a entertainment. As for as the reviews i have seen for this drama they are mostly questioning only the technical aspects like what did the school authorities do, why did they not wish for the app to stop. I think taking the drama for what it is and enjoying it doesn't reveal much of the shortcomings. Only when you view the drama to keep questioning and finding fault those thing come into play therefore just watch the drama without thinking too much and enjoy it. It is a thoroughly well made drama for me. It made me really get curious about shamanism also. overall a great watch.Was this review helpful to you?
fresh and Unique concept
I actually like the way presents! and the character development emotion collection also very good’’ and the horror Quite little bit, I also like the first way Show are going on it is actually good and good show in my opinion ‘’maybe there is show basis on the same story, but I actually like this one’
yesterday, I started watching and I can’t stop myself Watch and I finished it was a few hours cause it was a fast engaging that every episode ending Is make you to watch next episode it is a good series
Was this review helpful to you?
An Exciting Watch
this show is the definition of a show that is 100% exhilarating while you’re watching it, but the second it ends, you start realizing not much makes sense.it’s not exactly scary (i’m usually terrified of anything horror, but this didn't scare me.. at all), but it keeps you on your toes. the pacing is fast, they use blood in every scene, its a lil exhausting but also exciting. the acting was also really great for a cast of mostly fresh faces. i especially loved the main couple and really wish we got more scenes of them just being together.
but here is where it falls apart: kwon siwon. i have zero sympathy for her. hyeryoung was literally the only person who cared about her and was trying to protect her with that talisman, and how does siwon repay her? by outing her crush and letting her get physically assaulted in front of the whole class.
the whole curse continuation felt so petty and illogical. siwon dying and wishing for the cycle to continue just to make hyeryoung "pay" is the definition of being a hater. i dont understand her intentions behind torturing everyone who uses the app. there was no depth to it just spite against the only person who was actually kind to her. i really wanted some kind of justice for hyeryoung in the finale but alas.
anddd the most annoying thing — the season 2 bait. i am so tired of shows leaving things open just in case they get a season 2. not every show needs a sequel. why can't we just get a closed, satisfying ending? leaving nari’s phone like that and not solving haetsol's issue of not being able to leave her house just felt lazy. it leaves so many unanswered questions that could’ve been fixed with like... 20 more mins of writing.
its a solid 8/10 for the adrenaline but 6.5 plotwise
Was this review helpful to you?
Killer App
I watched If Wishes Could Kill and honestly it’s really interesting but kinda dark. The idea is super cool—like people getting their wishes but with bad consequences—and it keeps you thinking “is this even worth it?” The story pulls you in quickly and some moments are actually intense.The characters aren’t perfect at all, which makes it more realistic, but also a bit frustrating sometimes. I liked how it shows that getting what you want isn’t always a good thing. It’s not a super light or fun drama, it’s more the type that makes you think.
Overall, I’d say it’s worth watching if you like darker, suspenseful stories 👍
Was this review helpful to you?
A fun watch for horror fans, but content warnings for suicide and self-harm intrinsic to the story
I'm a huge fan of any death game-esque type of horror, and while this isn't really that it is close enough that I decided to give it a watch. I'm happy that I did. I found the writing to be pretty solid; the characters were consistent (and clever!), the balance of humour and horror was good, the pacing didn't drag, and the worldbuilding/explanation for the horror felt pretty well thought out. The soundtrack was simple and beautiful, doing a great job of creating an atmosphere without being too distracting. The acting was 10/10 (to me), and the visual effects were excellent. The story overall felt more character-driven than "get us to the next scare/gross out" driven.It occasionally verged a bit too close to feeling like it might go into fantasy-adventure territory for my taste, but that's more of a matter of preference and really wasn't so bad until after the plot had been essentially wrapped up. There might be some confusion around the fate of one character, but I think that may be intentional as it seems like they may have been trying to set up a second season without leaving the show on a cliffhanger. I'm not giving a perfect score mostly because I feel like for a horror show, it wasn't especially creepy or scary. It was suspenseful, and got intense at times, but to me it is missing a bit of that sense of fear and consistent heightened emotions that I usually go to horror for. However I did enjoy the relationships between characters being such a big focus.
Overall I enjoyed it, I would say that this is more of an easy/light watch for a horror fan who's okay with a bit of gore (so long as scenes of suicide and self-harm are not a trigger for you, if they are then I would say you should avoid this show). It's not too intense, but it also isn't boring. If you don't like horror, you won't like this (because it's horror). But if you're horror-neutral you should be fine.
Was this review helpful to you?
Must watch for Horror/Mystery lover
I love this type of twisted plot shows which have a strong back story and reasoning to why whatever was happening were happening which is people dying through a mobile wish granting app.You can easily watch this show in one sitting because of the cliff hanger they leave at the end of every episode. It is very enjoyable and gripping. TW it contains gore though.
The acting of young adults was quite good and the one funny character of 'Bangwool' was the perfect touch of comedy to the serious plot.
Was this review helpful to you?



