A moment but forever (Happy or Sad Ending)

Weibo page: https://m.weibo.cn/search?containerid=100103type%3D1%26q%3D%E5%BF%B5%E6%97%A0%E5%8F%8C
A Moment but Forever (2024) - kisskh
https://kisskh.at/746371-tian-xia-wu-shuang

It's a happy ending (I HOPE THEY DON'T CHANGE THIS). The only thing I want them to change is that he's awake and sees that she's arrived. Because the ending in the book is implied. He's sleeping, resting. She arrives and tells the servant not to wake him up. (This is a happy ending, but it needs to be improved.) Improve (not... make it a sad ending).I think the ending of the drama will be better (that line from the trailer: She says to him: "I am the moon, you are the sun. Forever shining together in the sky."
PS: In the anime, the ending is also implicit (but he is awake). But the scene in the anime does not show the faces of the two. It shows him smiling, and she only shows her feet, as if she was looking at him (in other words, a happy ending, implicit).
PS:
Something I want for this drama, and it seems like it will be like this. Is that Yuan Zhong, Fox Priest, reaches the dimension of a god, and stays with her in the realm of the gods.
And it would be a counterpoint to the character of Liu Xue Yi in another xianxia, which has not yet been broadcast (Love Never Fails), in which the character of Liu Xue Yi was a god, but becomes a mortal in the end for the love of the woman he loves.
Note:
Yuan Zhong, in Ambforever, is an immortal, above a mortal, but below a god. He has the power of a god at times (due to the divine left hand that joined his body).

From IQIYI app: ➡️ Yuan Zhong takes the chance to go down the mountain to remove the seal. But on the way, he is healed by Wu Shuang. The two of them express their feelings to each other and fall in love. But the villain takes advantage of the male lead’s feelings, causing him to break the God’s Hand, and also traps Wu Shuang. In the end, Yuan Zhong rescues Wu Shuang and the two work together to defeat Han Nü, restoring order in the world. This drama will be streaming exclusively on iQIYI

__________________________________________________________________________________________________

JeA  Plot seems quite generic. Like it's been told a hundred times already. Dear Novel readers, is storytelling any good? Like the expansion or plot twists?

eliteles1  The drama is quite interesting. There is adventure, love, emotional conflict. Themes of gods, immortals, and humans, fox tribe. Mortals with powers, the ghosts of war. There is the growth storyline of the main characters. The male protagonist and his good/evil and emotional trauma conflict. There is the conflict between the goddess and her sister, conflict of emotional trauma. From the trailers: There is charm, humor, tragedy, beauty, poetry. It is very interesting and brings a fresh twist to the xianxia genre.
One of the key points is: "For a moment you become a demon. For a moment, you become a God."

• ________________________________________________
• I only watched 2 episodes. Now I'm going to watch episode 3. So far the only recognition between the two is when he was a fox spirit and broke the ice where Tan Yin was trapped. (In the book they know each other from the past, when Yuan Zhong was a teenager and saw the goddess appear at a priest's sacrifice. In the book he falls in love with her at first sight, and never forgets her eyes, but he can't realize that it is Tan Yin, that person. (in the book).
• ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
• 
  

  • LionOfSk  

    What is so original about this drama please elaborate
    eliteles1  VIP
    I perceive a weight and realism in each character. As if each word counts to understand the story. The part about the gods (they seem more realistic. The god represented by Tan Yin: the ability to intervene in human existence). In other stories it is as if these gods (only live in the sky) and can destroy people. But they do not have other subtle powers, we see different powers in this story. Another thing: the issue of craftsmanship. The power of Tan Yin's craftsmanship (I thought the drama could not reproduce all of this well. But it did, and the mechanical birds that fly). Another difference. YZ is not a hero like others, one-dimensional. There are many layers to him. And this character has an ambiguity. Tan Yin fights for the integrity of Yuan Zhong's heart. Another interesting thing is that this story, despite being a fantasy, has several moments of life (joy, sadness, bitterness, hope, tragedy, remorse, resentment, kindness, humor, etc. And we will see that there will be redemption). And another point, they chose a young (but mature) actor, recognizing his beauty and talent. And the main actress was a great asset, this thousand-year-old goddess, is perfect for her. (And the hero Yuan Zhong, is the kind of character who in other stories would be the supporting character of another, with a great story, but who was never developed.) This is his story (but developed, rich, explored for the first time), so he is a multidimensional character.

    ____________________________________________________________________________
  • Drama Tea  

    The ending is a happy one for me 👇

    • Drama Tea  

      Hide Spoiler

      Actually I consider this a happy ending. If they had changed the last few minutes irredeemably probably not but this actually follows the novel!! You should read it. In the novel, Yuanzhong ends up alone for a while like our TV version. Tanyin was formless, basically everywhere and anywhere like the deity said, but always longing to return to him. One day, out of sheer will, she flows back to him. Remember that divine energy she gave Yuanzhong in episode six? That divine energy leapt out of Yuan Zhong's body one day and formed a new body for her from an immortal lotus. (I don't think it's a coincidence at all that her Master gave him a green lotus energy thing back then.) Eventually, Wushuang's spirit, sensing her divine energy, entered her new body and they are finally together. To me the ending is seamless with the novel's, especially with her voice saying at the end, I promise you, I will always be with you.I think the writer chose to end it there because, well, imagine seeing Yuanzhong suffer a bit more after the battle, pining for her. It wouldn't have been as ... satisfying?anyway, read the novel. it will make sense. And the extras are beautiful tee hee (they finally had their wedding night)

    • -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    • 
      

    • Nanadiya  

      does anyone know what flower and what is the meaning of the flower that woke yuanzhong when he wanted to destroy the world in the last minute of episode 26?
      
      eliteles1  VIP
      Hide SpoilerI think that following the meaning of the book and the anime, she left a divine energy in Yuan Zhong. If we combine this with the lotus flower from his master (which he said was a gift), we can imagine the reunion of Yuan Zhong and JTY (with the reconstituted body), due to this force that is in the lotus flower and in Yuan Zhong's body. Because in the anime, it is precisely the lotus flower that brings Tan Yin's life (with TY's life energy in YZ's body).

    • _________________________________________________________________________

    • 
      

    • littlebluemonster  an hour ago

      If you're looking for a mature storyline in a xianxia, this is definitely it. And I mean like, mature thinking, characters, and plot. Not one that's filled with impulsive decisions and young blood. The cast also has solid acting. ML is a little gray, while the FL is such a bad*ss!!!! Kind, but also wise. At first I thought she was too much of a saint and would be naive and gullible. She may be very empathetic but boy can she seriously kick*ss and doesn't put up with bs. She's also really smart and observant! Definitely one of my favorite FLs of all time. Loved the ML's cunningness too. Both leading actors carried their roles so well. It's a slowpaced xianxia, but definitely filled with layers. It's far from boring to me and I enjoyed every episode so much.

    • _____________________________________

    • This drama has a bit of realism. How many "terrible" things happen in this world. Really terrible, because someone was mistreated. The person can turn into something else (which depends on inner strength not to turn to the other side, to evil in fact. We see this every day in this world.). The drama was completely understandable and justifiable in showing this troubled character who was about to lose himself, but didn't. (like the phrase in the trailer: "One thought you become a demon, one thought you become a god").
      "and I hope that the "Left Hand of God" will also bring you sincerity, kindness, and the courage to love and be loved, and the "power of the source" to dare to look directly into the darkness without falling into it.- (Liu Xue Yi- actor)"https://m.weibo.cn/status/5155411955292303 

    • _________________________________________________________________________

    • Liu Xue Yi says goodbye to Yuan Zhong- his character, in "A moment but forever" (Eng Sub)
      https://youtu.be/7WFZjJEr7Hk?si=eAm2rI3ETL-YLuH3
      🎁🎁🎁✨✨✨🎇🎇🎇🎇🎁🎁🎁🎁🔔🔔🔔🔔😊😊😊

 IdealLifeDreamRealm:

Beautiful commentary, beautiful summary

Thank you very much. I'm happy to contribute.😊😊💫

 Lilybilly:

I just read the ending of the novel to check for HE and completely agree with your points. Will be fun to see your posts on the differences between the novel vs the drama for better & worse... 😊 

Thank you! Let's compare together.😎😶‍🌫️

 Lilybilly:

What is the outcome for TangHua and Zhi Dai? Thx!

In the book and in the anime, Tang Hua doesn't appear much. He's just Yuan Zhong's good friend. He always shows up to talk to him, joke around, and warn him. Including Tang Hua's death, which is already shown in the trailer, in Zidhai's arms. In the anime and in the book, he dies to defend his friend Yuan Zhong (when Tang Hua, who had his mind hypnotized and controlled by an evil power, momentarily wakes up from the trance, he tries hard not to kill Yuan Zhong), and he dies like that. In the book and in the anime.

 Lilybilly:

Thx for answering. You never know with Xianxia's. Sometimes when they "die" they are just dead and not dead dead... 🤣 

 Lilybilly:

Got it thx! I’m at the part in ep 7/8 where she keeps repeatedly getting “killed” . They make it quite entertaining 🤣

I'll get to those episodes now. It's in the book and the anime. But in the drama, I'm seeing a lot of praise.

 EmmaBradley:

Such a beautiful, Thanks for sharing!

Welcome !💓💓💓😊😊😊

 Lilybilly:

So is this the end of Pei Ju's romance??? Or do they get a HE at the very end? Thx!

Pei Ju's story only exists in the drama. The book is very short and does not contain this arc, nor does the anime. (But, I have the impression that many of the characters will have their happy endings). In fact, I think this is part of Yuan Zhong's redemption arc (helping "these friends"). I have that impression.