I've been loving reading all the responses.
Going to do expectation vs. reality for the list:
War of Y: Expected 7, Actual -3 : I forced myself to watch a lot of it and regret it
Check out: Expected 7, Actual -50 - one of the very few shows I actually dropped
Kissable Lips: Expected 9, Actual 6 - like how do you make this bad when you have the most perfect casting?! Kim Ji Woong and Bright basically LOOK like (super hot) vampires in real life! SMH
PS: they should be MLs in ALL vampire BLs in Korea and Thailand :D
Byo No Hosoku: Expected 7, Actual 2 - basically lather, rinse, repeat - I think my expectation was too high based on all the great BLs japan gave us this year
Unforgotten Night, Big Dragon, Fahlanruk, In Your Heart were all TERRIBLE - but I'm not spending time rating because expectations were low to begin with.
Also, while they weren't bad per say but To my Star 2 and Papa & Daddy 2 were less than expected because I loved their S1 so much the storyline for S2 just didn't hold up for me. Also, couldn't get past change in ML in P&D 2 - kept missing Jerry OG :(