This being MDL, if a user liked something, it tends to be a 9 or 10. No-one gives anything less than a 5 unless it was absolutely hated.
But I do believe ratings are based on user votes.
My personal rating system - which I've posted several times (and I really should add to my profile, but I can't see where to alter it) goes something like this:
1: The worst. I probably dropped it but it's an epic failure in either storytelling, technical abilities and/or both. It's worth noting that blatant propaganda might also fall under this figure.
2-3: Various levels of suckiness.
4: Under-par.
5: Middle-of-the-road. Honestly: the majority of stuff released worldwide is this or...
6: Slightly above mediocre; only worth your time if you're a die-hard fan of the genre and/or someone involved in the project.
7: Good. Hell, recommendable even,
8: Very good! Definitely recommended.
9: About the highest rating I can give a title, it hit all the right notes and left me looking for something similar... even though I know there's precious little that can follow it.
10: Perfect. Or, well, about as good as a film/series can be. Almost nothing ever gets this rating.
Oddly enough, people have called me out for rating titles a 6, as if I'm cussing their favourite show and, by extension, them!
People need to grow thicker skins (and be more open than having a dichotomy of either loving or hating something).