Quantcast

I recently came across a comment saying that people who dislike dark themes such as rape/SA, abuse, violence, etc. should simply avoid watching that particular drama. It got me thinking about how some people genuinely believe certain pieces of media should not be critiqued because they contain these themes.

Personally, I don’t think fiction exists in a vacuum. Media has societal impact. Just as good representation of sensitive topics can positively affect the real world, poor representation can negatively affect it too.

Does this mean you cannot enjoy dark romance or darker media? No. It just means people should not be surprised or upset when those works are critiqued.

It would be to see other people's opinions, even if you think the opposite.

What a coincidence, just yesterday I came across an article about what if a teenager watch a vertical drama where family members hurt each others. Those kind of things happen in real life indeed. There's news about a younger brother reported being sexually and physically assaulted by his older brother on Thailand and there's an older brother kidnapped his younger brother in inheritance dispute in China iirc. There's also a father killing his son over monthly allowance in Korea like last year. A father even collaborated with his daughter and son in-law to rob a comedian's decade earning in Korea. And younger sisters have affairs their older sisters' husbands in Malaysia and Indonesia. I think both news and entertainment need to have age restriction.

But there's some problem with age restriction too. I once read a novel and the only protection was a question, "are you over 18?," which will block no one. And with how accessible internet to everyone, there really no way to prevent children to be overexposed to cruelty, violence, and sexual ehm things. So it's indeed true the one that could protect oneself from watching such things is only himself. And for children, their elders.

Because people making money from writing news, novels, and scripts. And people making money producing music videos, movies, dramas, music videos, variety shows, contents. And all genres attracting their own viewers/readers. Where there's money, there's people. There's no way to make them not making things that earning money, right? There's so many Chinese danmei novel writers got arrested, did Chinese writers stop writing danmei novels? No, even when there's jail time and financial penalty waiting for them. Just don't watch them.

Wow so many cases, I had no clue about.

I mean, there is truth in the fact that whether you watch it or don’t, the world will keep spinning and they will keep producing it. But people should not stop critiquing something just because nothing changes.

I see people use examples like not liking a particular food, so they avoid that food, or not liking gore in horror movies, so they avoid horror movies. But does that mean they can’t critique that food or critique horror movies? No, they can, because everything in this world can be critiqued.

I think the central point is: fiction is not exempt from discussion just because it’s fictional.