Hana Kimi Remake

wrote: I agree. If they just attempt to re-make the same story I thik it will be a fail. So am hoping for a new storyline.

yeah.

wrote: I've never read the manga. Is there another story line? I'm just not sure how they'll write another story about a girl who sneaks into an all boys high school without it being too much like the original. Then we'd end up with a situation like Gokusen.

i also haven't read manga but from what i've heard taiwanese hana kimi went more like manga. and i liked the comedy & acting a bit better in it but JPN had better ending.

wrote: But isn't Miura Shohei playing Kamiya in Gokusen? Then I'm happy

yeah. that's why I'm gonna watch this remake. I don't like the main guy so much D:

ShineeGirl wrote: I've never read the manga. Is there another story line? I'm just not sure how they'll write another story about a girl who sneaks into an all boys high school without it being too much like the original. Then we'd end up with a situation like Gokusen.

The manga is longer and has more detail, also some of the reasons in the drama were changed (I think to make it more dramatic) so it doesn't really follow the manga well other than some scenes (such as the ending when everyone wishes her farewell and such was similar in the manga). The drama I thought they made it more random and funny. The taiwan version is closer to the manga until the ending.

http://www.jpopasia.com/news/akb48s-kashiwagi-yuki-joins-hana-kimi-cast::7598.html

"Kashiwagi Yuki will be playing the role of Kishinosato Juri, a rich girl who attends the all-girls high school St. Blossoms. She will later become Ashiya Mizukiâ??s (played by Maeda Atsuko) rival for the affection of Sano Izumi (Nakamura Aoi)."

So I guess it's safe to say that this is going to be a complete new version, and not like the manga

As i can understand, they are changing the plot...and I thought they were going to make it closer to manga.
The Japanese version was not like the mange, except for the characters and the MAIN scenes, for example the way Sano found out Mizuki was a girl, the Taiwanese version has it right... though I'm not the fan of the TW version...
Now I'm skeptical about the remake...I'm going to watch it whatever, though I'm so not into the main characters' appearance...

Cymntenny wrote: As i can understand, they are changing the plot...and I thought they were going to make it closer to manga.
The Japanese version was not like the mange, except for the characters and the MAIN scenes, for example the way Sano found out Mizuki was a girl, the Taiwanese version has it right... though I'm not the fan of the TW version...
Now I'm skeptical about the remake...I'm going to watch it whatever, though I'm so not into the main characters' appearance...

That's what I originally thought, too, but it's going to be a completely new storyline. I wish they'd made the japanese version a little more like the Taiwan version because it was closer to the manga. I'm skeptical about watching it, too, still going to watch it. I just hope they don't ruin it.

hana kimi isn't even that old!!! why would they make a new version??
that's what i am wondering. . .

because in the earlier j-version the charas name was Hanayashiki Hibari

also, according to the pick on drama wiki, they seem to have a really good time slot. It should get pretty decent ratings.