liddi:
GXSH: Think of A Nian. She is the princess of Gao Xin. For me and the Gao Xin people, she would lead the army into battle, even if it was against Cang Xuan. If you were A Nian, would you abandon me and the Gao Xin people?

Xiao Yao shook her head, grief etched on her face.

XY: I would not. I would do as A Nian did.

Is this a joke? Xiao Yao put up a token protest over the whole Cang Xuan taking aimed at Gao Xin before falling in line. I guess she was too busy getting engaged to Jing to care about her adoptive father and country's plight. 


 H19279:
So what is XL's purpose to visit Chi you's house?

I guess they are adding these scenes with Xiang Liu as a way to explain why he and Xiao Yao cannot be together, but they seem redundant considering the drama Xiao Yao barely shows any romantic interest in Xiang Liu, let alone the internal conflict that she had in the novel.

 H19279:
season 2 of LYF is a separate product with borrowing characters' name instead of adapting from the original story.

Can you even call it an adaptation anymore when you have essentially changed the essence of the characters? At best, it's an "inspired by" situation.

 MengXiang:
I hate Jing so happy he doesn't get official mummy approval. Even though it seemed more like mummy asking her daughter 'Are you sure'

Yup. I'd hardly call that exchange "approval". More like Ah Heng was resigned to Xiao Yao's choice because she felt that she had no right to say otherwise given the role that she inadvertently played in Xiao Yao's abandonment issues.

 HeadInTheClouds:

And some of us here will be saying....

Pettiness is my middle name ;-)!

I'm such a villain now. Bring on the pain!! More!!!

 MengXiang:
@liddi, Does this scene happen in leaked script?

There is no attempted assassination with Xiao Yao becoming delirious over hibiscus flowers in the drama, at least not based on the leaked script. What we do have is Cang Xuan put under a hallucination by his grandfather, which had him imagining everything up to Xiao Yao committing suicide (she never even poisoned him because she promised her grandmother and mother that she would protect him).  This is as a warning what would happen had he continued his obsessive behaviour over Xiao Yao.


 blabla100:
As she said in regards to TianEr, the fake gets mixed with the real and thus is becoming difficult to diferentiate between the two. The bugs though are a testimony of her true feelings. Nothing has changed, her heart was still belonging to XL. 

Excellent observation, particularly with the parallels between her situation and Tian Er - thank you.  The significance of the lovers bug is paramount to telling Xiao Yao in the novel, where her heart truly lies. Which is why it is so frustrating that in the drama, she never finds out the true nature of the bugs she planted in Xiang Liu.


 Kokuto:
Ha!  Beloved Ru Shou kicking Feng Long's butt.  WHY must he fight for CX and stand against Xiang Liu??  sob

Xiang Liu's death scene will be tough to watch, with Ru Shou playing such a pivotal role there.


 Kokuto:
But the sense of melancholy for both the Irish Wild Geese and XL, symbolized by migrating geese, feels the same.

Very true. 

 HeadInTheClouds:
I seem to be causing you a fair bit of pain lately, liddi :-). Misery loves company you know? 

Noooo... misery needs to be a distant stranger. It has been 5 months and it still persists on being an unwelcome presence. I have to keep reminding myself that he is not real

 H19279:
Everyone could see that Shen Nong army would eventually lose. which side would practical people choose?

FL was Xiao Zhurong's son. His father was governor of Middle Plains, under Xuan Yuan ruler.


 H19279:
It is always easier and smarter to choose the winning side if you are free to choose. However, both FL and RS had connection with CX before and that was the winning side. No reason to choose Shen Nong army side

It sure is smarter to pick the winning side as Feng Long's family aptly demonstrated (*sarcasm*). They were traitors to the Shen Nong nation centuries ago, there really is no reason for them to side with Shen Nong's Resistance Army now, is there? Why would they give up their wealth and power under CX? Loyalty, honour and love for their country? Of course not, they've given up on those lofty ideas long ago. I used to wonder why Feng Long was friends with Jing, but I think I can see why. Both of these families are about self-interest above all else. Birds of a feather and all.

 liddi:
What happened in Once Promised with regards to the Tushan clan?

My impression of the Tusha clan is that they are merchants through and through  - it's all about self-interest and profits with them. 

It has been a long time since I've read Once Promised, but there are mentions that the Flame Emperor helped the Tushan Clan with some difficulties. However, when Shen Nong and him were in trouble, the Tushan Clan did not want to help as they wanted to stay out of the politic. The Flame Emperor had to ask the matriarch of the clan (Jing's grandma in LYF I believe) for help, only then did she offer help reluctantly. This falls in line with my impression of them.

Considering the Heavenly Mother's relationship with the Flame Emperor, it's possible that she doesn't have the warmest feelings for the Tushan clan.

 HeadInTheClouds:

And some of us here will be saying....

Pettiness is my middle name ;-)!

Petty is one of my favorite colors ❤️

 Elise:

Petty is one of my favorite colors ❤️

It's so refreshing hahah

After Xiang Liu's death, he will not be able to project his Love on the Fox, because only emptiness will remain in her heart

By the way, did I miss the question about the potbellied doll? Please explain to me what this means in the relationship between Xiang Liu and Xiao Yao. 

Why this particular tree? Well, or tell me if I missed a page somewhere =)

 Svetlanchik89:

After Xiang Liu's death, he will not be able to project his Love on the Fox, because only emptiness will remain in her heart

You barely arrived and you are already dropping truths :D

 nathsketch:

I'm such a villain now. Bring on the pain!! More!!!


 Elise:

Petty is one of my favorite colors ❤️

We can revelled in our pettiness together :-).

 Svetlanchik89:

By the way, did I miss the question about the potbellied doll? Please explain to me what this means in the relationship between Xiang Liu and Xiao Yao. 

Why this particular tree? Well, or tell me if I missed a page somewhere =)

Oh, it's such a challenge trying to find things in these forums :(

Ooof, maybe if we try to Google it. All those pages are already indexed.

I found this comment in one of the articles discussing tsj.
he actually wanted Xiaoyao to be captured by CX?


There is an obvious point. When Xiao Liu asked him to help escape, he obviously didn’t have to follow her, but he had to follow her. When Xiaoyao left alone, he said he was Tu Shanjing, but when he walked out, he said I was Ye Shiqi, so he concluded that Xiaoliu would not escape.

The funniest thing here is that if you run away, they dare not touch me. When I go out and say I am Ye Shiqi, if the other party hears that I am Tu Shanjing, who of you dare to touch me. I am Ye Shiqi, that is to say, come on and hit me.