
This review may contain spoilers
What a dissapointment
What a disappointment this turned out to be. As someone who has read countless mangas and novels dealing with reincarnation and time travel, I went in expecting at least a fresh twist or a tightly written plot. Instead, I got one of the weakest executions of the genre I’ve ever seen — a complete waste of Pond’s potential.I’ll be honest: I was here only for Pond, hoping his talent would be paired with a compelling story. But, as I’ve said before, Thailand desperately needs to invest in good scriptwriters. The narrative was a mess from start to finish — riddled with loopholes, tonal inconsistencies, and logic so flimsy it collapsed under the lightest scrutiny.
Armin, the protagonist, was perhaps the most baffling reincarnation lead I’ve ever encountered. In most stories, when someone gets a second chance at life, they’re laser-focused on avoiding their past mistakes or preventing their tragic fate. Not Armin. He seemed determined to antagonize everyone around him, almost inviting death. Then, in episode three, he meets the so-called “love of his life” — and suddenly nothing else matters. Any idea of revenge, personal growth, or strategic planning evaporated into thin air.
The reincarnation premise was completely wasted, shoved aside for a generic romance that felt rushed and forced. If you’re here hoping for a smart, satisfying revenge plot, you’ll be just as let down as I was. Armin’s attempts at changing the lives of his aunt and friend were minimal at best — blink and you’d miss them. Instead, he was almost entirely dependent on TD, letting the story drag him along rather than driving it himself.
And don’t even get me started on the ending. Out of nowhere, TD’s stepbrother is revealed as the villain, with a last-minute motive that he was in love with TD. This plot twist came out of absolutely nowhere, with zero build-up in previous episodes. It felt like the writers were scrambling to wrap things up and reached for the most random idea available.
Honestly, if you remove Pond from the equation and replace him with any other actor, the flaws become even more glaring. The reincarnation element might as well not have existed — this could have been any typical Thai BL with nothing to set it apart. The romance angle came too soon, too shallow, and too conveniently, leaving the rest of the narrative hollow.
In the end, this was several hours of my life wasted on a show that had the premise to be great but chose to squander it at every turn.
Was this review helpful to you?

Most spectacular bl of 2024
So I am here after finishing this beautiful show. First I was a bit doubtful about this show and Collab due to only 12 episodes. But my god they presented the story do beautifully and it makes a lot of sense. Personally for me this was better than the novel. The casting was on point btw. Every character felt like they came straight out of novel. All of them were cuteness maximised. I loved the story character and the actors, and along with that I loved the Ost this beautiful series has. For me this show is the best Bl of 2024 along with Century of love. Loved this loved this. Want more collabs like this....❤️❤️🤍🤍🤍Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Honest opinion
Honestly, this drama had a lot of potential — in its world-building, its characters, and in the foundations of its story — but all of it was barely explored. I came in hoping it would get better, and kept watching… and watching… and waiting. But for me, it just didn’t deliver.The biggest problem? The entire focus is on the ML and only the ML. His ambitions, his growth, his story. That’s it. And somewhere along the way, he becomes arrogant, detached, and — let’s be real — a little frustrating. One thing I usually love about Wuxia/Xianxia is how these dramas explore the journeys of all characters — their growth, pain, power, relationships — not just one person. But here, it was Xiao Yan supremacy and nothing else.
Let’s talk about Xun’er. First of all, can we just ignore the fact that she’s the ML’s first cousin and in love with him? 😬 But even if we do — their so-called “love story” had zero chemistry. Completely flat. Meanwhile, he had way better chemistry with his teacher, the poison girl, and even Medusa, who literally appeared like 3–4 times in total.
What annoyed me more was that all the women in the series just fall for him without any actual reason — it’s that classic harem setup, and I’m not a fan. Even the strong female characters were reduced to background noise. Medusa, Xun’er, Yafei, the poison girl, and even Nalan Yanran — so much potential, so little screentime.
Honestly, Nalan Yanran was the only one who seemed like a full-fledged person. She had her own motives, goals, and wasn’t constantly chasing after the ML. I wish we got more of her.
And then there’s the Medicine Elder — probably the only character I truly enjoyed watching. The Xiao Zhan cameo was nice, but let’s be real, he wasn’t even in half the series. Their friendship was okay, but even that dynamic faded under all the ML-worship.
And please — that whole “everyone just waits for Xiao Yan to save them” thing? So unrealistic, especially in a world where everyone else is also a cultivator. Why is everyone, including his seniors, so helpless without him?
And the music? Meh. Not memorable.
Final thoughts:
2/10. I finished it because I started it — but compared to the other Wuxia/Xianxia dramas I’ve loved, this one felt like a boring, uneven, and forced story that wasted the potential of its world and characters. Will I watch the donghua? Probably not anymore.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
One the best Cdrama
Let me just say it: Mysterious Lotus Casebook is easily one of the best C-dramas I’ve watched in recent years. From the very first episode, it had that rare spark—the kind that pulls you in and doesn’t let go. The execution, the storytelling, the characters—everything was just so tightly crafted and emotionally rich.The plot was layered, full of mystery and clever twists, but it never became too heavy or complicated. It was always grounded in relationships, loyalty, and inner conflict. The balance of investigation, martial arts, emotional depth, and camaraderie was perfect.
Let’s talk about the three male leads—what a treat! Their chemistry, banter, and loyalty were honestly heartwarming to watch. The dynamic between them was one of the best parts of the show. They felt like real people with real burdens, yet their connection made it all feel lighter. I only recognized the actor who played Fang Duobing from Ultimate Note (and yes, he’s still such a cutie and super talented). But the other two leads? Absolutely nailed it. Their performances were full of quiet strength and emotion.
Now, I HAVE to mention the two female characters—Jiao Liqiao and the ML’s love interest. Both of them were written so well. No side-lining, no reduction to just love angles. These women had purpose, spine, presence—and the actresses gave such mature, nuanced performances. Loved them both.
The fight scenes were beautifully choreographed—clean, elegant, and emotionally loaded. And the way each case was handled made me excited for every next episode. It gave me that Sherlock Holmes meets Wuxia feel, but softer, richer, and more heartfelt.
Verdict: Mysterious Lotus Casebook is a must-watch. It’s thrilling, tender, smart, and full of beautiful relationships. Whether it’s the mystery, the brotherhood, or the quiet emotional punches—you’ll find something to fall in love with. 10/10 without hesitation.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
So I watched this drama in continuation to other voice series. As much as I loved thriller genre, I must say this was not as good as other seasons. Especially after Do kand Woo death. His death in previous season was highly disappointing. His character was so good and complex that I loved watching him. One thing that I found absurd in Voice seasons was that nobody shot the actual criminal in the series but they shot a police officer in the head with the intention of killing him. His mental state was not good, but it was not taken into account. Now coming to this season there were so many stupid mistakes in first few episodes tht I was literally banging my head on the wall. Ths mute sister of the ML made so many stupid mistakes in order to get killed. The main villain and the concept behind it was good but somehow I was not that impressed with the story line as there was no mystery in it to solve. It became repetitive and boring after a point of time. I didn't like the male lead much but let's hope they come up with a better storyline in Voice 5.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Wasted potential
I would have rated this even lower had I watched the final two episodes. I went in with such high hopes after watching the trailer—visually grand, high production budget—but the execution was simply not it. It baffles me how Mandi channel consistently refuses to invest in good screenwriters.The show started off promising, even compelling up to episode 7. But once we reached episode 8, the storyline began to stagnate. Dragging things out for no reason, stalling progress—it was a frustrating watch. And then Chakrii got shot… and somehow everything fell apart even further.
I didn’t even bother with episode 13 after reading the wave of disappointment on Twitter. But what crushed me most was Ava leaving the competition—the very cause she was passionately fighting for, thrown away just like that. It screamed internalised misogyny. Why would a woman who stood so strongly for women’s rights suddenly back down? It felt like a betrayal of everything her arc was building toward.
And don’t get me started on Ramilpaytai. The chemistry? Electric. The potential? Immense. But the writers simply refused to explore their backstories, motivations, or even deepen their relationship. What a waste.
NetJJ had almost no screentime—again, wasted potential. ZeeNunew’s dynamic, while cute in the beginning, became repetitive and flat as the story progressed.
Also, why do Thai BLs keep glossing over major political and emotional issues like they’re nothing? The king was clearly a tyrant, and yet Khanin forgives him in the end? Why? What was the point of the rebellion? The prince who actually fought for justice died without fanfare, without purpose. It felt hollow.
A visually rich show that had all the right ingredients but lacked the one thing that truly matters: a strong, coherent script.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Enjoyed it
I was obviously here for Xiao Zhan, and as expected, he never disappoints. I mean never. The man has a gift — he takes any role and breathes life into it, and his portrayal of Zhang Hai was nothing short of phenomenal. The story, at its heart, is a revenge saga, but what makes it truly stand out is the heavy dose of political scheming, strategy, and power games. Normally, I am not the biggest fan of political dramas, but this one grabbed me right from the first episode and held me tight. Every little move, every word, every subtle look was part of a grand plan, meticulously crafted and slowly unfolding before our eyes.And the ending — it was exactly the kind of payoff I crave. Everything came together like puzzle pieces snapping into place, revealing the grand design behind all the chaos. I’ll admit, as someone who prides herself on sharp instincts, I had already guessed most of the twists very early on. But that didn’t lessen the enjoyment — instead, it made me appreciate the craft even more, because seeing my predictions come true still gave me a rush.
Now, let’s talk about the female lead. What a badass. I adored her. Strong-willed, clever, and independent — she wasn’t just a side character, she was a force in her own right. Watching her maneuver through this dark world was so satisfying.
That being said, here’s my one tiny gripe: I just couldn’t feel the chemistry between Xiao Zhan and the FL. It’s not that they acted badly or lacked intensity in their performances — not at all. But something about their dynamic felt… detached. Maybe it’s because the revenge plot overshadowed the romance, or maybe because I was so laser-focused on Zhang Hai’s journey that the love line didn’t land with me. Whatever the reason, the emotional pull I usually look for in couples wasn’t there. And honestly? I didn’t mind too much, because the political intrigue and revenge narrative were so gripping that romance almost felt secondary.
Still, overall, this series is absolutely worth it. A thrilling mix of strategy, betrayal, and poetic justice — carried on the shoulders of Xiao Zhan’s brilliance and supported by a fearless female lead.
Final Verdict: Sharp, intelligent, and unexpectedly addictive.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
This drama was an absolute masterpiece. I genuinely can’t find a single fault in it. Everything—from the acting to the story to the cinematography—felt intentional, nuanced, and deeply moving.Tontae was my main reason for watching, having adored him in Venus in the Sky. And my god, he did not disappoint. His performance here was raw, layered, and heartbreakingly believable. Every glance, every pause, every emotional beat landed perfectly.
The story itself was rich with symbolism, each visual and dialogue choice adding deeper meaning to the central romance. And then there’s the most special part for me—the Hsia twins. I’ve known them since HIStory 3: Make Our Days Count, and seeing them here alongside Tontae felt like such a gift.
The slow burn romance was immaculate. It didn’t feel staged or exaggerated—it was like watching two real people slowly, quietly, inevitably fall for each other. The chemistry was understated yet magnetic, pulling you in without fanfare.
And then… the ending. I had a feeling it was coming, but when it hit, it still gutted me. I am a shameless sucker for sad endings, and this one was bittersweet perfection—lingering in my mind long after the credits rolled.
A rare BL that manages to be both poetic and emotionally devastating in the best way possible.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Absolute bullshit
Six hours of my life gone, and for what? A storyline so thin it could disappear if you blink. The concept was interesting—on paper. But the way they butchered the script? Painful. By Episode 3, it slid straight into mind-numbing boredom. The soul-switch plot should have been exciting, but it was handled so poorly that half the time I couldn’t even tell who was supposed to be who. It didn’t look like a soul swap, it looked like bad acting direction—and it left me confused more often than intrigued.Max and Nat actually did a decent job in the romance department in the beginning, but even that spark fizzled out as the plot dragged on. The emotional tension just couldn’t survive under the weight of such a messy storyline.
And yet—Earth. Earth single-handedly saved this from being a complete dumpster fire. His acting? Natural. His presence? Magnetic. His beauty? Unquestionable. He’s the only one who actually looked alive in this entire mess. Without him, I’d have dropped this faster than you can say “why was this even made?”
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Peraya Nation, how are we? I missed Krist and Singto so much that seeing them together again felt like being reunited with old friends. Honestly, I never thought I’d get to watch them in their full glory again—but here we are. And my god, it was beautiful.Krist and Singto are not just another BL pairing—they are the pioneers of the genre for so many of us. They helped shape the BL landscape, and without them, I’m certain half of us wouldn’t even be here as devoted fans (or fujoshis). Their on-screen presence is magnetic, their chemistry timeless.
The story in The Ex Morning was solid and engaging, giving just the right amount of romance, nostalgia, and emotional pull. It didn’t feel like a forced reunion—it felt like a natural continuation of what made them special in the first place.
I truly enjoyed every second of it. For long-time BL fans, this was more than just a drama—it was a heartfelt reminder of where it all began.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Some stories don’t just end when the credits roll—they stay with you, haunting the quiet corners of your heart. The Sparkle in Your Eyes is one of those stories.It is proof that CBL knows how to speak in silences, in glances, in the weight of unspoken words. Without the heavy hand of censorship, I can only imagine the magnitude of what China could do in the BL space. And yet, even here—uncensored—it shines like a rare gem.
It’s not just a romance. It’s a study of humanity—its fragility, its persistence, the quiet dignity of love that survives storms. Every issue they touched felt real, like they had lived it themselves. I didn’t just watch the characters; I felt them.
And then came the hospital scene. My heart shattered—not in one clean break, but in a thousand tiny fractures that ached long after. There was nothing melodramatic about it. It was simply truth, delivered with such tenderness that it hurt.
The episodes may be only half an hour each, but the scriptwriting cuts deeper than most full-length series. Every scene is purposeful, every line intentional. This is why I keep coming back to CBL—because when it’s good, it’s not just entertainment. It’s art.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Beautiful drama with beautiful visuals
As a fan of Xiao Zhan it is my duty to watch him in Wuxia/Xianxia dramas. This drama was visually spectacular. The CGI and the characters were beautifully weaved in a good storyline. What surprised me was the female lead was cute and her acting. She did a really great job in portraying the character. Xiao Zhan as always was top notch in his acting. He never disappoints.Strong female characters and their dynamics with each other also with the male characters was portrayed really well in this drama. I am a sucker for sad endings and I loved this drama . The female lead was strong improved herself through sheer hardwork, she had a spine always stands for what is right. I truly loved her character.
ALso this drama has some really good ost.
Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Let me just say I was in love with Do Kang Woo's character. It was so complex but at the same time it gives you plenty of time to relate with him. I love the way he portrayed this character. The story line was great. The only point at which i was disappointed was that there were few stupid things in that drama. Such as what's with leaving an important witness alone and taking a phone call in different room. Like you know they can be killed why are you leaving them alone time after time. This pissed me off so much. Overall a good drama. Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Strong female lead is love
Though i started this drama for Yibo and a the given strong female lead. I sticked to it because it is well made. I haven't read the novel but I heard it is not as good as the novel. However i loved this drama. Priest as novel writer rocks. I loved the execution of the story and how it explores the dynamics of every character. Also i loved the fact that Zhao li Ying is a veteran in industry and is playing a character opposite Yibo. There is only one annoying character Li Yan. Other than that i loved how it explores different stories of different characters. I loved Duan Jiu Niang, too bad she died early wanted to see her more. The fact that physical strength is not everything is shown in the way how the characters explore their strength during the show time. The character of ChuChu her development was phenomenal. I loved her character development. The chemistry between Yibo and Zhao li Ying is good. I loved how they go through thick and thin together and romance is not central to the story.Was this review helpful to you?

This review may contain spoilers
Really good drama
So I watched this drama for Xiao Zhan and got impressed but Darren Wang. The range he possesses my goodness i loved the way he portrayed innocence then hatred then menacing and then in love. The music is beautiful the acting of the whole cast is just awesome. I loved the transition of FL. How she learnt fighting different skills and the ending it was heart breaking but beautiful. The character of Ji Chong was damn sexy every time he came on screen i literally slowed the video to get a good look on him. Li Qin did a fantastic job in this and loved her emotion portrayal in different situations. The story always keeps you on edge of the seat and it is so interesting so painfully good. Beautiful creation by everyone. Also i loved the ways the two ml support and teaches the FL to fight on her own. That was darn good. A special thanks to costume department especially for Ji Chong loved them all. The music, acting, cinematography everything.Was this review helpful to you?