I would just like to post a comment to say:Regardless of who you prefer (whether as a character or as a couple),…
umm..this is an interesting debate. However, how much of romance feelings she may have for XL is still questionable for me. I can definetly see temptation and chemistry though. I am YaoJing shipper so I maybe a bias (I do have characters actions to prove). But I wanted to focus on XL and his relationship with XY in this reply. Among 4 main characters, I have most difficulty in connection with XL. My first impression on XL is that this is romantizing abuser type (while I have warmed up to other 3 characters already), to me he is fictional of fiction characters . In real life, would a woman fell in love with who throw her off tree suddenly and drown her (to hurt cang xuan). Well, there are women who take risks. I have seen in my surrounding all of those relation are doomed 100%. But this is fiction, bad boys are popular (not all fans will take real life bf who is bad though right). and I also do not get how XL would fall in love with XY that much to sacrifice lives and blood. Don't hate me yet, please read my full long reply. 😅 I come to realize how XY is scared to let XL into her dream. I come to my theory XL come into XY life for temption and to face her fear. On the surface though they do have mutual friendship or platonic one. XL suddenly become her like guardian angel. In here, I take XL as temptation we would like to get yet feel not so real. But on a more practical feel, XL represents soldier and bravery, who has been killing and fighting for long time and feel responsible for it. There is a saying that love can occur quick for soldier. So when he met XY, with certain mutual feels would fall for her quick but would not persue her because he is mature enough to guess they arent meant to be, besides she is also having another guy. So he just act as her guardian but wont not let her know as not feel to any burden as he may have felt to his mentor. I take it as bravery. I know many of XL fans are disappointed how he died. But i think it is honourable because he had fulfilled his mentor wish and as a soldier. His heart is fulfilling too as he had made the woman he loved have the life she yearned for. His life mission is completed. I think he died with no regrets, which makes so memorable about this character. I guess the author purposely make it that way. About how much romance XY feel for him is still vauge for me. But if she did i wont be surprise. She definetly is tempted and he will stay special in her heart (romance or not is up to other viewers / readers. we can fall in love more than once in lifetime). Anyone can see it in different ways of course. Thank you if you read this long reply . 😅❤
Okay, I keep reading some things being written over and over, and I wanted to weigh in. It’s just my opinion,…
Criticizing is fine...as long as it is based on the actions in drama she/he criticizing about (sometimes some facts are not so accurate) it's fine as long as the critics are polite in letting out their thoughts. The thing is that if they slander a lot on a character that there are also viewers liking. Supper annoyance is in the air. Unnecessary words fights can happen which lead to....ummm i don't think is good. And i also find criticizing on actors is bad too. Because it can show that commentor is quite shallow and sounds big headed in not thinking there are people who can see different. Fan wars can happen. That's why I think it's better to just focus on a character you really understand or appreciate about but if one is going comment about a character she/he dislike (but other people like), try to be polite and ask in a more questionable way than do direct insult. Especially those who said they skipped a part of that character but judge that character like he/she knows completely. Sorry i think i used a bit rage word in this reply. But i think debate should be polite.
Just wanted to add as a spoiler that based on the leaked script for Season 2, the plot had some major changes,…
Wow that's interesting🤔...i had been waiting for intense scene ...but i will see how they will change it...CX is my most favorite character , because he gives me most headache. I like analysing his character. (YaoJing is my most comfort)...title is lost you forever. ..so it will be interesting how they will execute it by changing
Though I love both Jing and XL, I am gonna keep them both aside for now coz I haven't showered enough love for…
I really enjoy this character and Wanyi's portrayal is just perfect ❤️. I was attached to him since the beginning. I don't actually hate him like some other do when he can't recognize YX early. This character is so layered. But circumstances make him like that.
ikr !! I agree with you on the aspects that make me unable to support the relationship between TSJ and XY, and…
Also to you is this drama really represent that much ancient culture ? I know it's historical ? Sorry I don't really know Chinese history to watch the drama. I don't think I have to. Because it's for present era people!
ikr !! I agree with you on the aspects that make me unable to support the relationship between TSJ and XY, and…
You have to be specific on which opinion of mine on that comment you think is "MODERN EYES!" I should not see it in that way???? If you think it doesn't make sense, you can explain..😊
ikr !! I agree with you on the aspects that make me unable to support the relationship between TSJ and XY, and…
Hi thanks for the reply. ..but i dont think you get my reply comment for that specific person...im referring to. ..Jing's motives in S1 that person is talking about. I am not talking about any other characters AT ALL! Which I disagree about. .thought she missed something. Do you read it carefully? If you want me discuss about any other character or want me to see in any other perspective, you should have reply me on the comment that Im specifically talking about him/her! And nope I have read the book. The events I am talking about are in S1.
ikr !! I agree with you on the aspects that make me unable to support the relationship between TSJ and XY, and…
well well no hate...😊 I was thinking about this "INDECISIVE" word thingy..... he is decisive in which he is able straight forwardly tell his feelings which is sincere... he uprightly telling it to his family too. (he just got betrayed by his family ..grandma who said..love him)...so when it comes to love and couple union, don't you think it's better tell it straight and get chances from that person? (she's been with partly to get support for CX) But he didn't still pull her to him when he's wronged by his family(drug). And again about suicide thingy.its sudden and crucial ...its not that he's not doing anything, he's transferring all his little power that he had into her body. so that CX and XL can continue to help her later. well ...well I respect your opinion. But sometimes try to see drama in different perspective. So that you may get the drama and its messages more.
One thing I don't like about Jing it's his empty promises , starting from beginning1. He said XY he will take…
I know many are disappointed with Jing's doing in the drama. I just only want to express my own probably defensive opinion on his motives too. It has to be with upbringing too. I do not think he is as pessimistics as CX or XL, therefore he sometimes lookover some bad issues. He does love family and brother although his bro did wrong to him. But at least he's aware that Tusang Hou want to kill him. He protected himself several times if you notice Hou plotted to kill him 2 or 3 times. Tusang Hou is too blinded by his anger and jealousy to his bro love. Jing did not think his grandma would wrong him in such a way too. (letting him had ffyy soup with drug). It is natural that he would go depressing as he even is not sure if he did something to Ffyy when druged. About his suicide with XY. It was very unprepared and sudden heart attack. All he could think of XY at the time I guess. Sometimes human can have weak side a time. crucial time.
I'm a bit confused ,i'm on episode 4 and i still don't know who is the ML, I know there are many but i need to…
there are 3 mls. One ml has most screentime. another ml has straight forward love line. and another had a bit complicated sort of attraction chemistry platonic one. I wish you open up to all 3 mls. ❤
I'm thrilled, at how perfectly you captured the main characters. I completely agree with you. I also enjoyed the…
about scarlet heart, yep ...I dont understand why some people address Wang Wook as charming prince. I means truely mastermind and fraud. Historical dramas are not my fav. But lately chinese production of costume dramas are really beautiful. I think the second season will be very intense. I have read spoilers and summary. I don't think it is as tragic as Scarlet Heart. Because Xiao Yao gets with Jing in the end. They love each other. So yep. It was also very bitter because Cang Xuan plot to kill Jing out of jealousy(also he think Jing is too weak protect XY). XY felt very betrayed by that. But she poisoned him and herself. But little on him and intense on her. She died again and he is cured. But Xiang Liu revived her again. XL has also saved Jing life who was in coma. XL died at war. XY and Jing united and travel around the sea for some reason. And Cang Xuan lost XY forever. 😅 Sorry for the spoiler. I am super excited to see S2. The author is also screenwriter. So should not change much?
News 
Among 4 main characters, I have most difficulty in connection with XL. My first impression on XL is that this is romantizing abuser type (while I have warmed up to other 3 characters already), to me he is fictional of fiction characters . In real life, would a woman fell in love with who throw her off tree suddenly and drown her (to hurt cang xuan). Well, there are women who take risks. I have seen in my surrounding all of those relation are doomed 100%. But this is fiction, bad boys are popular (not all fans will take real life bf who is bad though right). and I also do not get how XL would fall in love with XY that much to sacrifice lives and blood. Don't hate me
yet, please read my full long reply. 😅 I come to realize how XY is scared to let XL into her dream. I come to my theory XL come into XY life for temption and to face her fear. On the surface though they do have
mutual friendship or platonic one. XL suddenly become her like guardian angel. In here, I take XL as temptation we would like to get yet feel not so real. But on a more practical feel, XL represents soldier and bravery, who has been killing and fighting for long time and feel
responsible for it. There is a saying that love can occur quick for soldier. So when he met XY, with certain mutual feels would fall for her quick but would not persue her because he is mature enough to guess they arent meant to be, besides she is also having another guy. So he just act as her guardian but wont not let her know as not feel to any burden as he may have felt to his
mentor. I take it as bravery. I know many of XL fans are disappointed how he died. But i think it is honourable because he had fulfilled his mentor wish and as a soldier. His heart is fulfilling too as he had made the woman he loved have the life she yearned for. His life mission is completed. I think he died with
no regrets, which makes so memorable about this character. I guess the author purposely make it that way.
About how much romance XY feel for him is still vauge for me. But if she did i wont be surprise. She definetly is tempted and he will stay special in her heart
(romance or not is up to other viewers / readers. we can fall in love more than once in lifetime).
Anyone can see it in different ways of course. Thank you if you read this long reply . 😅❤
(sometimes some facts are not so accurate) it's fine as long as the critics are polite in letting out their thoughts. The thing is that if they slander a lot on a character that there are also viewers liking. Supper annoyance is in the air. Unnecessary words fights can happen which lead to....ummm i don't think is good. And i also find criticizing on actors is bad too. Because it can show that commentor is quite shallow and sounds big headed in not thinking there are people who can see different. Fan wars can
happen. That's why I think it's
better to just focus on a
character you really understand
or appreciate about but if one is going comment about a character she/he dislike (but other people like), try to be polite and ask in a more questionable way than do direct insult. Especially those who said they skipped a part of that character but judge that character like he/she knows completely.
Sorry i think i used a bit rage word in this reply. But i think debate should be polite.
My take will be...
Xiao Yao: Cheeky, kind-hearted, fierce, lonely
Cang Xuan: Politics-scheming, ruthless, tormented, justice (overall feel)
Tushang Jing: Gentle, artistic, selfless, optimistic, loving
Xiang Liu: Rough, old-soul, warm-hearted(deep inside), responsible edit:bad boy/anti hero
Fenglone: Decent bachelor , optimistic 😅
That's for S1.
I may change my opinion later.
carefully? If you want me discuss about any other character or want me to see in any other perspective, you should have reply me on the comment that Im specifically talking about him/her! And nope I have read the book. The events I am talking about are in S1.
I was thinking about this "INDECISIVE" word thingy..... he is decisive in which he is able straight forwardly tell his feelings which is sincere... he uprightly telling it to his family too. (he just got betrayed by his family ..grandma who said..love him)...so when it comes to love and couple union, don't you think it's better tell it straight and get chances from that person? (she's been with partly to get support for CX) But he didn't still pull her to him when he's
wronged by his family(drug).
And again about suicide thingy.its sudden and crucial ...its not that he's not doing anything, he's transferring all his little power that he had into her body. so that CX and XL can continue to help
her later.
well ...well I respect your opinion. But sometimes try to see drama in different perspective. So that you may get the drama and its messages more.
About his suicide with XY. It was very unprepared and sudden heart attack. All he could think of XY at the time I guess. Sometimes human can have weak side a time. crucial time.
I think the second season will be very intense. I have read spoilers and summary. I don't think it is as tragic as Scarlet Heart. Because Xiao Yao gets with Jing in the end. They love each other. So yep. It was also very bitter
because Cang Xuan plot to kill Jing out of jealousy(also he think Jing is too weak protect XY). XY felt very betrayed by that. But she poisoned him and herself. But little on him and intense on her. She died again and he is cured. But Xiang Liu revived her
again. XL has also saved Jing life who was in coma. XL died at
war. XY and Jing united and travel around the sea for some reason. And Cang Xuan lost XY forever. 😅
Sorry for the spoiler. I am super excited to see S2. The author is also screenwriter. So should not change much?