News This review may contain spoilers
contract-produced TV series
Hello,
I have finally finished a series that I had long heard highly praised. It is a fantasy series set in a utopian world, featuring a complex web of clans, a vast array of characters, terminology drawn from Chinese mythology, and extensive flashback sequences—and I absolutely hated it. I only forced myself to finish it so that I could write this review.
Despite completing the series, I couldn't form any connection to it. The confusion surrounding names and clans, the excessive use of flashbacks, and the return of a character who had died in a nonsensical way—all of these were clear signs of how poor the series was. Flashbacks took up nearly half of the runtime; if you were to remove those thirty episodes, only twenty would remain, which is far from satisfying.
Looking at the series as a whole, it feels like a "patchwork quilt." Although it is adapted from a book—where the core narrative should have revolved around the love between two men—this aspect could not be adapted due to censorship in China. The book, and the series based on it, essentially cobbles together elements from various films that became cult classics worldwide. If you look at the examples below—and consider the plots of those cult films—you will understand why this series feels like such a patchwork quilt:
1. *Brokeback Mountain* (starring Heath Ledger)
2. II. Aragorn (Elessar) / The Lord of the Rings (Aragorn summoning the Army of the Dead)
Furthermore, these clans resembled those in *The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Five Armies*:
* The Lan Clan is like the Elves.
* The Wen Clan is like the Orcs—allies of Mordor.
* The Nie, Jiang, and Jin Clans are like the Humans and Dwarves.
3- Anakin Skywalker - Darth Vader / Star Wars (Anakin’s transition to the dark side to become Darth Vader)
4- Victor Frankenstein / *Frankenstein* (Wen Ning becoming a "ghost general")
As for the actors, this series clearly stems from their early, inexperienced days; there is no soul, no facial expression—they are as rigid as a wall of ice.
It is a shoddy production riddled with logical flaws. They took thirty episodes' worth of content, crammed it into twenty, and then tried to market and polish it as if they had created an epic, seamless masterpiece.
Given that so much time, effort, and money were poured into this nonsensical series—which relies on motifs borrowed from cult classics and features a cast with wooden, expressionless acting—it was impossible for it to culminate in a satisfying or intelligent finale.
I have finally finished a series that I had long heard highly praised. It is a fantasy series set in a utopian world, featuring a complex web of clans, a vast array of characters, terminology drawn from Chinese mythology, and extensive flashback sequences—and I absolutely hated it. I only forced myself to finish it so that I could write this review.
Despite completing the series, I couldn't form any connection to it. The confusion surrounding names and clans, the excessive use of flashbacks, and the return of a character who had died in a nonsensical way—all of these were clear signs of how poor the series was. Flashbacks took up nearly half of the runtime; if you were to remove those thirty episodes, only twenty would remain, which is far from satisfying.
Looking at the series as a whole, it feels like a "patchwork quilt." Although it is adapted from a book—where the core narrative should have revolved around the love between two men—this aspect could not be adapted due to censorship in China. The book, and the series based on it, essentially cobbles together elements from various films that became cult classics worldwide. If you look at the examples below—and consider the plots of those cult films—you will understand why this series feels like such a patchwork quilt:
1. *Brokeback Mountain* (starring Heath Ledger)
2. II. Aragorn (Elessar) / The Lord of the Rings (Aragorn summoning the Army of the Dead)
Furthermore, these clans resembled those in *The Lord of the Rings: The Battle of the Five Armies*:
* The Lan Clan is like the Elves.
* The Wen Clan is like the Orcs—allies of Mordor.
* The Nie, Jiang, and Jin Clans are like the Humans and Dwarves.
3- Anakin Skywalker - Darth Vader / Star Wars (Anakin’s transition to the dark side to become Darth Vader)
4- Victor Frankenstein / *Frankenstein* (Wen Ning becoming a "ghost general")
As for the actors, this series clearly stems from their early, inexperienced days; there is no soul, no facial expression—they are as rigid as a wall of ice.
It is a shoddy production riddled with logical flaws. They took thirty episodes' worth of content, crammed it into twenty, and then tried to market and polish it as if they had created an epic, seamless masterpiece.
Given that so much time, effort, and money were poured into this nonsensical series—which relies on motifs borrowed from cult classics and features a cast with wooden, expressionless acting—it was impossible for it to culminate in a satisfying or intelligent finale.
Was this review helpful to you?
