PinaRudolf

Idol I is an entertaining romantic drama without being overly cheesy (although I did have to roll my eyes a few times). The character development is believable and authentic.

SPOILER!!
For me personally, the murder case could have been a little darker, and I ultimately found the resolution a bit shallow and simplistic. There was no real confrontation in court, and I didn't feel that Do Ra Ik was ever really in danger. The obsession with the fans could have been more intense as well.
The supporting character Park Chung Jae as the “unrequited love of the childhood friend” was unnecessary in my opinion. I would have liked it if he had been given a real backstory and more screen time, maybe even as a second romantic storyline. We didn't really learn anything about him, except that he had a difficult childhood and that his mother and grandmother are dead. His character was only meant to be a rival to Ra Ik and show how fixated Maeng Se Na is on Ra Ik. I found the placement of the character in the case very shallow, quite predictable, and clichéd.