A textbook case of wasted potential
Idol I started with so much promise. The early episodes did an excellent job building its characters, giving us enough backstory to genuinely connect with their struggles. You understood who these people were and why they mattered, which made the first half of the drama genuinely compelling .
Then came the climax. The main murder motive was incredibly anti-climactic. After all that buildup, the reasoning behind the crime—and committing another to cover it up—felt so stale and underwhelming . It's the kind of reveal that makes you feel hollow rather than shocked.
What makes it worse is how underdeveloped the murder's reasoning felt. We needed more time with the antagonist to understand their descent. Instead, the reveal feels like a last-minute decision from a long brainstorming session . The writers rushed to close doors they spent episodes carefully opening .
The frustrating part? This drama had so much potential. It realistically portrayed the pressures idols face, the blurry line between support and obsession, and how the industry treats artists as products . But by sidelining the murder mystery that drove the plot, it wasted its own foundation.
Then came the climax. The main murder motive was incredibly anti-climactic. After all that buildup, the reasoning behind the crime—and committing another to cover it up—felt so stale and underwhelming . It's the kind of reveal that makes you feel hollow rather than shocked.
What makes it worse is how underdeveloped the murder's reasoning felt. We needed more time with the antagonist to understand their descent. Instead, the reveal feels like a last-minute decision from a long brainstorming session . The writers rushed to close doors they spent episodes carefully opening .
The frustrating part? This drama had so much potential. It realistically portrayed the pressures idols face, the blurry line between support and obsession, and how the industry treats artists as products . But by sidelining the murder mystery that drove the plot, it wasted its own foundation.
Was this review helpful to you?
