Problematic But Brave
As other reviews attest, it is far too easy to "punch down" in reviewing this series: its flaws are many and criticism is warranted. And yet, I didn't give up and actually looked forward to each week's episode release.The script chose to tackle and address issues that many stories (BL or not) pretend don't exist: mental health, therapy, institutional/authority figure predation (and the willful ignorance around these predators), and forced prostitution and victim-shaming. I think art, even flawed art, that chooses to speak to power should be praised for what it gets right as well as criticized when part of the execution falls short.
The early episodes did a tremendously deft job in taking us on Ice's journey as he continued to heal. Some of the most outstanding scenes during the characters' workshop sessions were understated and they let the subtext speak volumes that the script did not. Their workshop scenes were heartbreaking and hopeful, and watching two fractured people attempt to create connection (while one is still reeling from the trauma of sexual exploitation) was masterfully done. In fact, I might go out on a ledge and say those scenes in particular are some of my most memorable from the 2025 season and the best acting executed by the leads.
Yes, the second and third acts piled trauma on top of trauma, trope on top of trope, to the detriment of the story that was offered in act one. To me, it felt like the production team had tremendous courage to tell a unique story as they started, but got scared and retreated into genre semantics and syntax as the story progressed. If they had had the courage to keep the story smaller, the plot contrivances fewer, they had a chance to tell a very aching redemption story for our two leads.
And the reviews citing Ice's toxic boyfriend as an unnecessary element, in my opinion, miss the point of that subplot. Ice still feels unworthy and "tainted" when he chooses that relationship- there is a part of him that wants to wallow there as those feelings are at least familiar. He specifically chose a partner that would create the feelings in him he felt he deserved. Moving past Warm was a sign of growth and healing for Ice. Too often, survivors feel unworthy of real, sustained happiness and will continue in relationships that keep them in their "normal" state of stress, self-loathing, and self-doubt. Did the writers take that arc too far? Absolutely. This is just one example of courage in act one that retreated into trope by the end of the series.
Overall, this definitely is not a "seek it out" kind of show. But if you're in a generous mood and looking to watch a flawed but brave series, indulge your curiosity.
Was this review helpful to you?
Not For Everyone
The best and most inappropriate way I can describe this is imagine if Dario Argento (Italian film maker known for Suspiria) and Orson Welles (of Citizen Kane fame) got really drunk and decided to have a threesome with The Manchurian Candidate- Black Stage might be the head scratcher, imaginary love child of that drunken encounter.If that sounds intriguing, this second season of Enigma is for you. I thoroughly enjoyed the fusion of old world belief with contemporary celebrity culture, although the execution was a little clunky.
I truly wish they had done two or three more episodes to really explore some of the post-modernist, Marxist, and capitalist social indictments that seemed too tacked on to really make for cohesive themes. This is a series that suffered from brevity- a more expansive third act might have made this a real contender for classic status.
It feels incomplete and my high rating is more of an appreciation for what was there instead of what was missing.
Season one started by sowing chaos on a small scale while season two attempted to bring that chaos to a national stage. Again, the brevity of the story, the lack of revealing the impact on the watching audience, and a budget that couldn’t allow for a more expansive story really makes the narrative they were attempting to tell feel incomplete. Ironically, a character speaks at length about what happens to understanding when chapters in a book are missing or skipped. This season feels like some of the best chapters were referenced instead of given to the audience.
But I enjoyed it. It was different (which is becoming increasingly rare) and if you are a true fan of horror that attempts to hold a mirror up to society, give it a shot. Even imperfect horror is better than no horror at all!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Master Class in Acting
What could have been a banal, enjoyable watch is elevated tremendously by the sheer will and force of Fujibayashi Yasunari's (Enaga/Ae) performance. I noted that this review contains spoilers and it's a rather minor spoiler considering that all the characterization, conflict, and themes rest on what happens after the "big reveal" very early in the show's run.Yasunari has created two distinct characters in his performance: Enaga and Ai. He has accomplished this on a genetic level. Each "character" he plays has a distinct walk, posture, line delivery, and even gaze. In the hands of a lesser actor, this role could have merely let the piece be what it's script delivered- a "mistaken identity" romantic comedy that bordered on farcical. But the subtlety of what Yasunari has accomplished is what elevates the show above it's material- it is completely believable that Nagano Ryota's character (Chiaki) is entirely oblivious as the "two" men he is spending so much time with are so disparate and even unrecognizable to each other in juxtaposition. The amount of commitment to craft is obvious and it is a shame that this genius performance will go under-recognized simply because of the genre in which it was delivered.
But this praise of performance does not end with Yasunari; after all, he needs a scene partner and this is where Ryota's choices really shine. It is tremendously challenging to play the "straight man" to an "over-the-top" character and Ryota delivers the foundation on which Yasunari builds his performance. Ryota is tasked with delivering "unbridled admiration" for his bias in their "AE" scenes and what could have very easily been "cringe" or scene chewing is given such a sweet, hot, shyness: a sense of being slightly overwhelmed by the brilliance yet basking in the warmth of his personal sun in such a way that his growth and comfort feel organic. There were times I felt a phantom blush and reddening of my own ears watching this dynamic and this attests to Ryota's talent.
Kudos to the director for trusting the subtlety of what his actors were doing and just letting them deliver. The performances are what really elevate this material to the position of noteworthy.
You've seen this type of story play out one hundred times if you are a BL fan. But you've never seen it played out in the hands of two master craftsmen like Yasunari and Ryota. One caveat though- Ryota's character is slightly underwritten so his performance pales slightly in comparison to Yasunari's.
Was this review helpful to you?
The Story of Bi Hyeong: Enchanted Master of the Goblin
2 people found this review helpful
Whimsical & Lighthearted
A truly whimsical tale done with love and executed well. Animations provide backstory and they are illustrated with a classic timelessness that truly sets the mood for the early episodes.It is a fairytale plopped right into the contemporary world and much like Secret Vampire, offers a humorous glimpse into how otherworldly creatures acclimate to being a part of- yet apart from- the human world.
The acting stays solidly grounded in realistic performance, ensuring the fantasy tone and story elements also stay grounded.
This is a lovely piece to watch on a cold night with your favorite blanket and a cup of cocoa with marshmallows.
It was delightful.
While it does complete the narrative arc, the slight open ended final moments leave the door open for a second season or a few special episodes.
Fresh characters, fresh folk tale presentation and some adherence to trope and genre does make it a little predictable, but the cast is so likable, you won't mind that you know where it's going.
Was this review helpful to you?
The Actors Slayed
I am not really a fan of the vertical drama format, but I have to give respect to this production team- they knew the format and told a really well-executed story in it. As a former film teacher, I recognize the talent and technical know-how to pull off as tightly crafted a story as this in this format. I truly respect the craft that is evident here, even if this mode of storytelling isn't my cup of tea.But what truly shines here is the acting. it's natural, understated, and despite a script that missed important story beats, the actors' performances somehow provided those beats. There were scenes and arcs that seemed alluded to and not explored, and yet the actors' tight performances made me feel like I had witnessed those scenes.
Overall, it had the warmth and naturalness of Thamepo with a slightly more mature couple. Highly recommend.
Was this review helpful to you?
More Authentic Than Rumored
Notice the wide range of reviews for this follow-up series- ignore the vague reviews and zero in on specific criticisms.I watched season one (Kiseki Chapter 2) owing to its infamy- and in many ways, that infamy is earned.
Both season one and two do something most casual BL watchers don’t see too often- slice of life very much from the male perspective. Most BL is written by women for women and (especially season two) I feel Kiseki Chapter 2 and Shimane are written from the male perspective, which is what makes it a unique BL entry.
The interplay amongst the male characters runs the spectrum from awkward to vulnerable not the way women imagine men to be, but more how men are. Male bonding and friendship is written realistically here and it happens over fart jokes, homoerotic drinking games, and a slow slip of their masks to reveal more authentic feelings.
Shimane definitely has the more traditional story map of conflicts and resolutions, but for me, that isn’t the strength of this series. The strength of the series is in the quiet moments between characters who are unsure if feelings are enough to overcome problems. The quiet and tender moments in bed, the more realistic visual of men enjoying each other’s bodies without all the female-written romanticizing.
Was this review helpful to you?
Bittersweet &Funny Coming of Age
I truly respect fans of the source material and it’s always difficult to watch your beloved source material be adapted to the screen: which is why I think the ratings here don’t reflect the work as its own independent story.While superficially the narrative seems like pretty well-worn territory (first crushes- both same and opposite sex) what this drama is doing beautifully is simply reflecting life the way it is: some kids in class are straight, some are gay, some aren’t even sure yet, but at the end of the day, there is both a common humanity in the first love “rite of passage”, as well as differences unique to your sexual orientation. While there is a commonality of emotional experience, respect is given with regards to the intersectionality of sexual identity and how that identity may make the rite of passage a much different journey than the journey of your straight counterparts.
The acting is not always subtle which is fine- these are high school kids and teenagers tend to react with much broader strokes than adults.
The drama explores an interesting romantic quadrangle and gives equal weight and respect to the varying combinations. The effect on the MLs’ friendship is quiet and understated (although at some point, I am anticipating a direct confrontation).
I can’t give a complete review as episodes are still dropping. But seeing the “front-facing” reviews, I felt compelled to throw an initial review together- it would be a shame to miss such a mature and honest look at the rite of passage known as your first crush- especially since it honors the reality that is often underrepresented in drama, or represented in a very narrow definition. I truly appreciate that both gay and straight identities are given space to coexist in one drama.
Was this review helpful to you?
Quiet, Heartfelt, Amazing Chemistry
There is nothing achingly original about the story line- a well-traveled BL fan has seen this sweet story of childhood friends turned awkward lovers countless times, but there is a freshness in the way the story unfolds. The use of flashback enhances the emotion of the present day story and it’s through those flashbacks, so well integrated into the present day story, that really brings the depth of the love story to your heart.And the chemistry between the male leads is a perfect balance of sweet, tender, romantic love, and a more primal, fierce, I need to possess you intensity.
now that the series has finished, I can see this becoming a comfort watch that I come back to time and time again, not unlike Time of Fever.
both actors bring such earnestness to their portrays of their characters that you are immediately enamored with them as individuals and as a couple.
Was this review helpful to you?
Earnest, Honest, Understated Tale
Such an earnest, honest, and understated tale. A simple, quirky little story that seemed bigger than the sum of its wonderful parts. Kudos to the actors for their sincerity and to the entire team that clearly made this with a great deal of love for the script. It shined through.An interesting spin on vampire lore, but the vampiric element is truly incidental, I honestly felt like this tale was more of a "Coming of Age" or "coming to terms" metaphor for what happens when you cut people off from the shared history, cultural identity, and necessary information to navigate their burgeoning queerness. These vampires don't know what it means to be a vampire. An early running joke has them doing "research" about what it means- the physicality, the actuality, and the practicality- all of which they have been denied. Devouring books, films, and "urban legends" around vampirism was intelligently humorous and what led me to the conclusion that this is really a metaphor for the challenges queer youth have in coming to terms with themselves when they are bereft of reliable information and community. Left to muddle through with what scant information is available has a psychological and emotional toll and I think this series- through humor and monster archetype- illustrated this struggle with a light touch and in a non-preachy way. Even the emotional fall-out of said isolation was dealt with lightly, though sincerely, by the script and the performances.
But fundamentally, it is a simple love story and the actors' performances invest you in that story. The chemistry amongst the entire cast is palpable and the chemistry between the obvious pairings is sizzling underneath the words and actions.
As others lamented during the show's run, the episodes are short and there are only eight, and we all wanted more.
Tuck this title away for a time when you need a short story arc to soothe your weary soul. The actors, the script, and the production values are all on point. This one may not change the genre, but sometimes that's okay too. Sometimes well-done familiarity offered with sincerity and love is just what you need.
Was this review helpful to you?
It Shouldn’t Hit Like This
I remember seeing the trailer for this and thinking to myself, “well this is straight up porn”. I figured it would be a passable titillating and forgettable watch- and I am thrilled to admit how wrong I was.THE GOOD/GREAT:
1- Boat and Oat are a part of the wave that is redefining boundaries in Thai BL (think SmartBoom). They rise above what’s written on the page to give more dimension and depth than what I believe the script demands. Their chemistry is not only undeniable, but it has layers. Yes, they are trending for the NC scenes (which are fire) but it’s the super subtle chemistry in the forehead kiss, the carnival, the way in which right under all that fierce passion is an emotional connection that feels so tenuous yet so strong (because of each character) that you are transfixed when they are on screen together. It feels like you are watching two people whose absolute trust in each other allows them the safety net needed to act a difficult relationship that should not have us rooting for a happy ending. GMMTv better pay attention and take notes or they are going to be left in the dust.
2- They lean heavily into one theme for character growth (you don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone) which serves the story and character arc well. Loss usually is a great motivator for change, and it’s a solid theme on which to build character growth.
Was this review helpful to you?
Worthy Entry Into the Genre
It was fantastic.The joy (at least for me) in teaching Monster Archetype theory has always been about the evolution of the genre.
Monster Archetype theory is predicated upon this idea: the monster and its stories that a culture creates gives you tremendous insight into the sociopolitical reality of that culture. To watch what the culture does over time with its monster stories allows you to understand what fears and ideology the "common man" has in any given time period. It's a Common Man approach to history (instead of the traditional Great Man Approach).
The writer's nailed the social commentary. This incarnation speaks directly to power with its full chest: economic power, patriarchal power, and legacy of power.
The script was brilliant (although I'm sure some things were lost in translation).
A powerful statement deeply rooted in global fears and anxiety about the control the ultra wealthy have been able to wrest from our democracies.
Highly recommend
Was this review helpful to you?
A Worthwhile Story
It is the rare BL (although I'm not sure this could be called a BL drama) that tackles head-on serious issues and then doesn't resolve them neatly at the end of the show's run.This show hits hard with its subject matter and the camera does not flinch for a moment in capturing the physical, emotional, and psychological pain these characters experience. There are some very bold choices made by the director, and those choices may not be safe or comfortable for all viewers.
What begins as (what we assume ) will be another trope-filled college drama actually drops very subtle hints that all is not what it appears. It would be very difficult to say more without giving spoilers so I will leave it at this. A devastating and traumatizing incident and the emotional and psychological aftermath of this incident are handled with maturity, honesty, and an unflinching camera. This is not a "comfort watch" but a watch that will take you down a very raw path.
It is absolutely worth watching once but is not a journey I would take again- not because it is not done well, but precisely because it is done very well.
Was this review helpful to you?
Scream+The Glory+Incidental BL
Headline says it all. If you took the movie Scream, added The Glory with a peppering of Thai BL, DFF would be the result.what starts as a love letter to American 90s slasher films quickly plants its roots in Thai culture. The result might have been messier in less capable hands (definitely not perfect by any stretch of the imagination). The director was able to get some really decent performances from a very young and inexperienced cast (Jin, Phee, Non, Tee) and there was nothing gratuitous about the NCs- in fact, I felt they served narrative purpose you don’t often find in Thai BLs.
For fans of smartish slasher films, I strongly recommend. For fans looking for a morally ambiguous romp, I highly recommend.
Was this review helpful to you?
Honest and Authentic
I have yet to see a narrative that so respectfully and lovingly expresses the joys, pain, longing, and frustration of queer and queer questioning youth finding their way in an unforgiving and unknowable world.This narrative serves as a prequel to Unintentional Love Story and frankly, it is the far superior and genuine story. You do not necessarily need to watch the first to appreciate this story, but if you do, you will notice the stark difference in the two tales.
The acting is sublime and each of the leads offers such warmth to their respective roles that you will long to spend more time with them.
Was this review helpful to you?
Plot Is Sometimes Bonkers But Performances On Point
There are many warranted and unwarranted criticisms here on Reloved's MDL page and if you're looking to figure out whether or not to watch, hopefully the preponderance of the evidence will help you decide. I truly enjoyed the small story they told, even if the narrative itself was sometimes outlandish and uneven. I would highly recommend it for its performances and its commitment to showing a segment of queer life not often represented on screen.First and foremost, kudos to the writers and production team for giving a glimpse of queer love that mirrors more the daily lived experience of many queer men outside of the falling in love arc. We rarely if ever see gay men raising children, trying and sometimes failing to "launch" adult lives, all while the giant roulette wheel of life throws unexpected triumphs and tragedies in willy nilly. We sometimes forget that life truly is luck- both good and bad- and life will throw both at us whether we deserve the type we get or not.
Far too often queer representation wallows in the (very real) tragedies and neglects to tell other stories. P'Than has loving, solidly middle-class parents who embrace the totality of who he is, as well as embracing (without forced villainy for conflict's sake) the truth of people and their situations. They respond to life and their children's lives as thinking, rational adults and are supportive. These are not parents who neglect grandchildren simply because they are unhappy about the choices and mistakes the adult's who made them have committed. They reflect the kind of parent I hope I am to my queer child.
I will thoroughly concede that the "mystery" behind why our MLs broke up in the past drags on for far too many episodes. However, I understand Akin's commitment to that secret. He is not keeping this secret simply for himself or to exacerbate the story's conflict. In fact, to break the promise he made to Meya and reveal the secret would have long-lasting and potentially detrimental consequences for not only Meya, but for Mawin as well. He is silent because he has chosen to be a father. Though not explicitly stated in the script, the performance attests to the internal conflict Akin feels. He wants to be done with the secrecy for his own selfish reason, but that is balanced heavily by the commitment he made to be in Mawin's life. To reveal the mystery is to potentially put Mawin at risk emotionally and psychologically. Perhaps this was too underwritten to be made clear to the audience, but I certainly saw that tension in his arc. As a single mother I may have overly-identified with the need to put your own wants and desires on the back burner and make choices for your child that protect his emotional and psychological well-being. But the production team certainly laid out that internal conflict within the five axis of film, whether it was in the juxtaposition of scene and flashback, or the way the camera stayed with Akin as the conflict played out on his face when looking at Mawin and P'Than.
And the Don situation. While others find it a weakness of the series, I find it is one of its strengths and reinforces the team's commitment to tell a "real story." Sometimes, no matter how hard we commit to growth and understanding, the aforementioned roulette wheel lands on a number you didn't deserve. You can do everything right- every choice, every introspection, grab every opportunity to be a better version of yourself- and still be dealt an illogical and cruel blow by life. This isn't just reflected in Don's arc, but in the gym's struggle are as well. This too is often neglected on screen and is a shame. Sometimes I'm tired of the happy ending because who hasn't at some point sat at night and lamented, "I've done everything right- so why does so much of my life feel unfair?".
So with all of its weaknesses, why did I love it? Authenticity. In the midst of the sometimes outlandish script, the actors made me care deeply about the characters and forgive the plot's shortcomings. The authenticity of performance, the glimpse into a segment of the queer community not often represented, and the obvious love of the production staff to tell this story won out over the flaws. Yes, so many of us turn to dramas for escapism, but sometimes that escapism- ironically- has the opposite effect; it makes us lament the unfairness that life sometimes throws our way. In its bid for authenticity, this drama dared to show that we are not always in control of the outcomes in our lives. Sometimes there is a car accident. Sometimes one success doesn't automatically breed another and we fail even though we did everything "right." Sometimes we have to make choices against our own self-interest because the roles we chose to assume have to take precedence. It was very comforting to see a drama that dared to say, "the happy ending doesn't always come in the package you expect or even at all- and it's not always your fault."
Was this review helpful to you?
