Hi !Funny enough I just wrote a comment above reflecting yours. I also wrote the comment about the first kiss…
Thank you sweetheart, and you are absolutely right ! I did not take much heart to it actually , I think I'm just tired of this kind of people, and as a French my writing exced my actual vision and feeling towards their comment. And loved your review on the kiss and agree !!!
Before you take this person’s episode-by-episode rants as gospel, maybe pause and reconsider twice.
This series isn’t perfect (none are), but it is good. Dismissing Inthu simply because he’s emotional, sarcastic, or sensitive says more about your own discomfort with male vulnerability than it does about the writing. You’re watching a BL, yet complaining about one of the few characters who dares to show feelings beyond the “cool stoic top / cute blushing bottom” cliché. That’s not a flaw: that’s progress.
And about the “bad kiss”? Interesting take coming from someone who gave 8/10 to My Stubborn, a series infamous for cardboard plots and some of the most lifeless kiss/NC scenes out there. (Yes, I said it. And I say it as a queer experimented person who actually knows the difference between authentic intimacy and fanfiction-for-straight-women staging.)
Here’s the thing: BL isn’t just about serving you fantasy hookups and soft-focus kisses on demand. My Magical Prophecy tries to give space for queer characters to exist in messy, sensitive, and sometimes frustrating ways. Don’t watch queer series only for the BL fantasy, watch them also to learn. Watch them to also recognize when a show is reaching for representation instead of repackaging tropes written by hetero women for hetero audiences who fetishize us.
Finally, insulting other fans while demanding the right to be “unfiltered” isn’t bravery, it’s immaturity. You’re allowed your opinion. But don’t expect everyone to nod politely when your opinion drips with bias, contradictions, and a lack of basic respect.
In short: You don’t have to like My Magical Prophecy. But maybe next time, try reviewing the show instead of exposing your hang-ups.
Best regards,
Someone who survived your review without crying unlike Inthu, apparently.
Before you take this person’s episode-by-episode rants as gospel, maybe pause and reconsider twice.
This series isn’t perfect (none are), but it is good. Dismissing Inthu simply because he’s emotional, sarcastic, or sensitive says more about your own discomfort with male vulnerability than it does about the writing. You’re watching a BL, yet complaining about one of the few characters who dares to show feelings beyond the “cool stoic top / cute blushing bottom” cliché. That’s not a flaw: that’s progress.
And about the “bad kiss”? Interesting take coming from someone who gave 8/10 to My Stubborn, a series infamous for cardboard plots and some of the most lifeless kiss/NC scenes out there. (Yes, I said it. And I say it as a queer experimented person who actually knows the difference between authentic intimacy and fanfiction-for-straight-women staging.)
Here’s the thing: BL isn’t just about serving you fantasy hookups and soft-focus kisses on demand. My Magical Prophecy tries to give space for queer characters to exist in messy, sensitive, and sometimes frustrating ways. Don’t watch queer series only for the BL fantasy, watch them also to learn. Watch them to also recognize when a show is reaching for representation instead of repackaging tropes written by hetero women for hetero audiences who fetishize us.
Finally, insulting other fans while demanding the right to be “unfiltered” isn’t bravery, it’s immaturity. You’re allowed your opinion. But don’t expect everyone to nod politely when your opinion drips with bias, contradictions, and a lack of basic respect.
In short: You don’t have to like My Magical Prophecy. But maybe next time, try reviewing the show instead of exposing your hang-ups.
Best regards,
Someone who survived your review without crying unlike Inthu, apparently.