Scattered, Shallow, and Disappointing — Genie: Make a Wish Misses Its Mark
As a long-time admirer of Bae Suzy's work, I went into Genie, Make a Wish with high expectations, trusting that her presence would, at minimum, guarantee a watchable drama. Sadly, this fantasy-rom-com turned out to be a profound disappointment - so much so that I couldn't bring myself to finish it.
The premise - a charismatic, satanic Genie meets a psychopathic, rule-following master - is intriguing, and Bae Suzy's portrayal of the emotionless Ka-young, who lives strictly by her grandmother's moral code to prevent a serial murder spree, is commendably precise. The core character concept is one of the drama's few strengths.
However, the execution falters dramatically. The visual effects (VFX) are noticeably poor, cheapening the overall fantasy aesthetic. Furthermore, the acting from a number of the supporting cast is disappointingly irritating, distracting from the central conflict. The introduction and handling of key side characters, such as the Jaguar (Sayyid) feel incredibly weak and poorly developed, and their convoluted backstories make very little sense in the larger narrative.
The drama suffers from a severe case of "a lot happening, but nothing happening". It introduces numerous plot points without proper extrapolation or meaningful exploration. For example, Ka-young's sudden wealth is never convincingly established or explained. Instead of feeling like a complex story, the pacing is a chaotic, frustrating mess that merely 'goes through the motions.' The characters, rather than being complex or nuanced, are often reduced to cartoonish caricatures, making it impossible to emotionally invest in their fates.
In the end, despite the magnetic presence of Bae Suzy, Genie, Make a Wish fails to coalesce into a coherent or compelling narrative. The combination of irritating performances, poor special effects, and a sprawling, underdeveloped plot made the viewing experience unbearable. It is a frustrating misfire that misses the point of its own unique premise.
The premise - a charismatic, satanic Genie meets a psychopathic, rule-following master - is intriguing, and Bae Suzy's portrayal of the emotionless Ka-young, who lives strictly by her grandmother's moral code to prevent a serial murder spree, is commendably precise. The core character concept is one of the drama's few strengths.
However, the execution falters dramatically. The visual effects (VFX) are noticeably poor, cheapening the overall fantasy aesthetic. Furthermore, the acting from a number of the supporting cast is disappointingly irritating, distracting from the central conflict. The introduction and handling of key side characters, such as the Jaguar (Sayyid) feel incredibly weak and poorly developed, and their convoluted backstories make very little sense in the larger narrative.
The drama suffers from a severe case of "a lot happening, but nothing happening". It introduces numerous plot points without proper extrapolation or meaningful exploration. For example, Ka-young's sudden wealth is never convincingly established or explained. Instead of feeling like a complex story, the pacing is a chaotic, frustrating mess that merely 'goes through the motions.' The characters, rather than being complex or nuanced, are often reduced to cartoonish caricatures, making it impossible to emotionally invest in their fates.
In the end, despite the magnetic presence of Bae Suzy, Genie, Make a Wish fails to coalesce into a coherent or compelling narrative. The combination of irritating performances, poor special effects, and a sprawling, underdeveloped plot made the viewing experience unbearable. It is a frustrating misfire that misses the point of its own unique premise.
Was this review helpful to you?
