Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: October 8, 2019
Idol I korean drama review
Completed
Idol I
2 people found this review helpful
by ltspada
10 days ago
12 of 12 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 10
Story 10.0
Acting/Cast 10.0
Music 10.0
Rewatch Value 10.0
This review may contain spoilers

From the Filming, to the Writing, to the characters to the story - Perfect!

My Rating: 10/10

I haven’t enjoyed a drama this much in a long time.

What really stood out is how unique the overall blend of genres is. It’s not just a romance or an idol drama — it seamlessly weaves together mystery, crime, legal elements, and a grounded look at idol life. That combination alone makes it feel fresh, but what elevates it even further is the execution.

The filming was absolutely stunning. I even looked up who the director was, Lee Gwang Young, the acting and filming were top level. I will be excited to see her other works. There’s a clear artistic vision behind how this drama was shot. Certain scenes — like the nature shots or even simple moments inside Maeng Se-na’s home — felt intentionally composed in a way that made everything look elevated without feeling artificial. It never felt overly filtered or unrealistic, just… expertly captured. Like a photographer who knows exactly how to frame a subject to make it look its best.

It’s the kind of cinematography that makes you notice the direction, not just the story. I actually found myself wanting to look up the director afterward just to see what else they’ve done — and that doesn’t happen often.

I also really appreciated the more grounded portrayal of the industry. Through Do Ra-ik’s experience, the drama doesn’t just show the glamorous side of fame, but also the pressure, lack of privacy, and emotional toll that comes with it. If you’ve seen other works in this space, you can tell there’s a clear interest in showing the reality behind celebrity life rather than just the fantasy. It has elements that reminded me of the Indie film "Time to Be Strong" which I saw on a Delta flight and wish was widely available. These types of films, that show the less glamorous aspects of fame, are important to validate the experience many that choose these paths go through.

On top of that, the pacing and storytelling keep you engaged the entire time. There’s always something unfolding — whether it’s the legal case, the mystery, or the developing relationship — so it never feels slow or dragged out. Kim Da Rin, the screenwriter did an amazing job and I also looked up her other works. If what I saw was accurate this may be her first but I will be paying attention if she does more, because this was an amazing show with great writing.

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this and would absolutely watch it again. I’d recommend it to anyone who enjoys:


Romance
Idol dramas
Mystery/crime
Or especially a strong blend of all of the above

⚠️ Spoilers

This drama did an incredible job keeping me guessing.

From the beginning, I was sure Do Ra-ik wasn’t actually guilty. But beyond that, it constantly shifted where suspicion landed. At first, it really seemed like Choi Jae-hee (the bandmate who was always angry with him and had just fought with him) could be responsible. For a good portion of the show, that felt like the most obvious answer.

Then after Jae-hee's accident, that theory started to fall apart, and attention shifted elsewhere. For a while, it really felt like the truth might lie with someone closer to the situation — possibly even someone unexpected like a female character involved in the case.

At one point, it even made you question whether someone like Lee Young-bin could be behind it all, or if there would be a twist involving someone who seemed neutral — like the “peacemaker” type within the group. That constant shifting is what made the mystery so engaging. It never felt predictable.

Another standout element was how the show handled fan culture.

The obsessive fans around Do Ra-ik were uncomfortable to watch — but in a very real way. The lack of boundaries, the constant surveillance, the physical closeness without consent… it all felt grounded in reality. Anyone who has dealt with that kind of behavior (even on a smaller scale) would recognize how unsettling it is.

One particular fan’s behavior bordered on cringe, Se-na, but it also made more sense once her backstory was revealed — especially the fact that Do Ra-ik had played a role in saving her life. That added a layer of understanding without excusing the behavior.

The relationship between Maeng Se-na and Do Ra-ik was something I really loved. There is a slight gray area with professional ethics early on, since she is initially connected to him in a professional capacity, but the dynamic shifts naturally over time. Much of the emotional progression comes after that boundary is no longer in place, which makes it feel more acceptable and organic.

I also really enjoyed the subplot involving Maeng Se-na’s tenant/friend. His investigative skills were impressive, and the backstory of how she helped pull him out of a life of crime was genuinely heartwarming. It added another layer to her character and showed her impact on others beyond the main storyline.

Now… Do Ra-ik’s mother.

She was honestly a difficult character to watch. The idea that she essentially pushed him into the industry at a young age and shaped his entire life around that choice is hard to ignore. The drama does attempt to frame it later in a more positive light — suggesting recognition of his talent — but it definitely takes some narrative stretching to make her actions feel justified. That’s something I’ve noticed comes up often in Korean dramas, but here it stood out more.

Also — the hairstyles in the early days 😄I understand they were trying to make the group look younger, and early K-pop styles were definitely… a choice. It worked for the timeline, but it was still noticeable.

As for the romance — I loved them. Completely.

The only very minor disappointment for me was the ending. While we clearly see that Maeng Se-na and Do Ra-ik are together and happy, I would have loved to see a proposal. It felt like the story was right there, ready for that final step, and it just stopped short.

It’s a small thing, but I really wanted to see how he would ask — what that moment would look like. Ending without it felt just slightly incomplete for such a strong relationship.

Was this review helpful to you?