Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 days ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location:
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: October 8, 2019
A Bona Fide Killer korean drama review
Completed
A Bona Fide Killer
0 people found this review helpful
by ltspada
2 days ago
14 of 14 episodes seen
Completed
Overall 8.5
Story 9.0
Acting/Cast 9.5
Music 7.5
Rewatch Value 7.5
This review may contain spoilers

Never convinced me what she was doing was ok

Rating: 8.5/10

I really enjoyed this one! It had a unique premise that immediately made it stand out, and I thought the series did a good job keeping things interesting without letting the story drag. The darker tone worked well, and I liked that it wasn't afraid to explore a subject that isn't exactly black and white.

The acting was good across the board, and I especially enjoyed the chemistry between the leads. Their interactions added another layer to the story, and I found myself invested in watching their relationship develop alongside everything else going on.

The pacing was another plus for me. It kept moving, held my attention, and didn't feel like it was stretching the story just to fill episodes. I enjoyed watching it from beginning to end.

Would I watch it again? Absolutely, especially if someone else wanted to watch it with me. It's not necessarily something I'd immediately start over on my own, but I enjoyed it enough that I'd happily revisit it. I'd also recommend it to anyone who enjoys darker plots, morally complicated situations, and something a little different from the usual drama.

Spoilers

My biggest issue with this series was that I never really felt it resolved the question of whether Bo-na (Yoo Bo-na) was any different from a serial killer herself.

I understand the background behind her actions. She experienced horrific things during her childhood, found a group of people who shared similar experiences, and believed that the people they were targeting were dangerous and likely to repeat their offenses. I can understand the anger, the desire for justice, and even the frustration with a system that might not keep these people locked up for long enough.

But there's a pretty big difference between believing someone deserves a longer prison sentence and deciding that person deserves to be executed. They weren't necessarily waiting to see whether these people would reoffend. They were making that determination themselves and acting as judge, jury, and executioner. These people might have been terrible, but that doesn't automatically make a private organization the authority to decide who lives and dies.

I actually thought the series might eventually reveal that the organization had some legitimate connection to official judicial channels. Maybe there were people within the system who knew how corrupt it was, knew that the worst offenders were getting away with things, and had some unofficial way of dealing with cases that the courts failed to handle. That might not have made the organization morally right, but it would at least have given it a little more structure and background.

Instead, it seemed to be a completely independent organization that simply decided who needed to die, when it would happen, and how it would be carried out. We never really got the full backstory. There seemed to be a lot of money and resources behind it, and the members appeared to be paid, but who established it? Who funded it? Who was actually running the whole operation? What was the larger purpose, and how did it get to operate so extensively without more explanation?

Even the cover story raised questions. Who set up the electronics sales team, and why that particular business? We got very little background on the team leader (Kim Bong-pal), why he was involved, or what brought the different members together. I wanted more of that. The organization itself was one of the most interesting parts of the premise, but the show never gave us enough to really understand it.

Another thing I couldn't reconcile was the choice of methods. If they had someone like the medical specialist (Go Young-gap) who could make a death look like a medical accident, why would they need to use a sniper in so many situations? Why not make more deaths look accidental? The series never really explained why sniping was the preferred approach in certain cases, or why Bo-na was put in a position where she was so exposed that she ended up on a police watch list. It seemed unnecessarily risky when they supposedly had other ways of getting the job done.

And realistically, with the way Bo-na carried out these missions, I would think it would only be a matter of time before she was caught. It's not infinite space/infinite locations there are obvious choices for each snipe. So they can quickly narrow where they think the shots came from. And, there are not unlimited people being released who fit the profile. It was and would continue to be easy to narrow down who they might go for. She goes into a building looking like an ordinary person and leaves the same way. There's no elaborate escape or quick extraction to get her away from the scene. She just seems to walk away and return to normal life. I had a hard time believing that someone who was supposedly such an experienced and highly skilled sniper could keep operating that way without eventually being identified.

There was also a storyline involving the task-force investigator and the mothers' group that I thought was going somewhere. Bo-na meets this very capable, almost super-solver type of investigator as another mother, and seems drawn to her. I assumed there would be some interesting cat-and-mouse moments as the two became better acquainted, especially with Bo-na having no idea how close she might be getting to someone who could expose her. But that never really developed. So why set up that connection in the first place? It felt like a missed opportunity for some really good tension.

I also wondered about the direction they were taking with Tae-seong's sister (Kwon Se-ah) becoming a police officer. That seemed like another setup for future conflict. Now you have another person in the family who believes in the law and could potentially become morally conflicted if she discovers what Bo-na has been doing. It could have added another interesting layer to the story, but it felt like another thread that wasn't fully explored.

And then there's Bo-na herself. What bothered me most was how coldly she could kill someone and then carry on with her day, even making it to dinner as if nothing had happened. Yes, the people she was killing were bad people, but she was still taking lives. Her past helps explain how she became the person she is, but it doesn't erase what she's doing. I kept waiting for the series to dig deeper into that contradiction.

There were also moments when her behavior went beyond the actual missions and made her seem downright dangerous. The incident with the man who was having his daughter hold onto a ledge really bothered me. Yes, he was in the process of doing something absolutely horrific, and I understand why Bo-na reacted so strongly. But she completely lost control and beat the living daylights out of him. It took someone else pulling her off to stop her. The child was right there, and even if she didn't actually see what was happening, she certainly would have heard it.

I understand the instinct to protect that little girl, but Bo-na seemed ready to beat the man to death. If no one had intervened, I honestly think it could have ended very badly. That moment further reinforced my problem with her. She wasn't simply someone carrying out calculated assignments against people she believed deserved punishment. She had a frightening level of violence in her, and she didn't always seem capable of controlling it.

The way she threatened Serge (Sergey) bothered me for a similar reason. It wasn't because he had gone after someone she considered a terrible criminal. His sniping was simply taking care of people she was already planning to kill. What really set her off was that he had gone around her husband and child. Her response made it seem as though she would genuinely kill him over it. Again, it showed just how easily she could cross that line. Between that and the incident with the father, I found it increasingly difficult to excuse her behavior as some kind of misguided attempt at justice.

I also had a hard time with how everything played out between Bo-na and her husband, Tae-seong (Kwon Tae-seong). Of course he was devastated when he discovered the truth about his wife. Imagine finding out that the person you love and have built a life with has been secretly murdering people. That's not a little secret you can just shrug off. It's an enormous revelation that would change how you see your spouse.

I thought his moral struggle was understandable, and honestly, I expected it to be a much bigger obstacle for them. Tae-seong is a genuinely good person with a strong sense of right and wrong. I couldn't see how he would eventually move from being horrified by what she had done to accepting it and even helping her. Loving someone doesn't automatically make you okay with discovering they're a killer. It just didn't feel consistent with the person the series had shown us.

And Bo-na's reaction to his struggle bothered me, too. At times, it almost seemed as though she resented that he couldn't immediately accept her and treat her the same way. But she had deliberately hidden the biggest secret of her life from him. She let him marry her without knowing who she really was or what she had been doing. He had every right to struggle with that. I couldn't understand why the series sometimes seemed to frame his reaction as something she shouldn't have to deal with.

I also don't see how Tae-seong is supposed to be okay with this long-term. He never really seemed to believe that what she was doing was right or good. He was conflicted because he loved her, not because his moral beliefs had suddenly changed. So what happens now? Bo-na tells him she's going to be late, and he has to sit there wondering whether she's off killing someone? How is he supposed to live with that? I can't imagine the anxiety of knowing your wife is going out to murder someone and having no idea whether she'll come home safely or what she's doing. I just don't see how that becomes a sustainable marriage.

The detective (Lee Dong-jin) was another character whose position I had mixed feelings about. I understood his belief that murder was wrong, regardless of who was doing it. But I didn't necessarily agree with the idea that the answer was simply to keep putting these people back in prison whenever they committed another crime. Yes, some of them got out early or received lighter punishments than they deserved, but they still have to commit another crime before the police can put them away again. That doesn't necessarily protect the people who might become their next victims. I understand the frustration with the justice system, but I wanted the series to explore that problem more thoughtfully rather than making it seem as though there were only two choices: keep putting them back in jail or murder them.

What I especially didn't buy was how the detective eventually handled his suspicions about Bo-na. He was so firm in his belief that murder was wrong, even when he suspected someone close to him. Then, once he became more certain of her identity, it seemed that hearing how much his friend loved her was enough to make him back off. He was suddenly willing to take a demotion and essentially look the other way. That was a huge shift for someone who had been so unwavering. I didn't feel the series did enough to make that change believable.

And what about Serge? Why was he so willing to snipe people? Why was he so ruthless? Was he simply a psychopath, or was there more to his history and motivation? We never really got enough to understand him.

The same goes for Mama (the Russian operative). Why was she so invested in Korean criminals and this particular organization? What was her connection to all of it? I wanted more background on her and the people behind the operation. There were so many interesting questions that the series raised but never really answered.

And then we get to the ending, which was probably my biggest disappointment.

I thought perhaps everything that had happened would finally make Bo-na reconsider what she was doing. She had devastated her husband and his friend, and both men had made enormous compromises to allow her to move forward. I thought that might be the point where she decided she couldn't continue living this way.

But no. She sees someone on television whom she thinks deserves to be eliminated, and she simply calls it in. So now she's directly deciding who should die? That actually made the whole situation worse for me.

At least when the organization was involved, there was some semblance of a process, even if I didn't agree with it. Other people were involved in deciding who the targets were, and then the assignments were given out. It was still vigilante justice, but Bo-na personally choosing someone she thinks needs to be killed takes it another step further. She's no longer just carrying out an assignment. She's making the decision herself.

And what was the point of having another woman essentially take the fall for being the sniper if Bo-na was just going to start doing it again? What exactly has changed? What happens next? Are we supposed to believe that she has learned something, or is this simply going to continue?

I really wish the series had given us a more meaningful conclusion to that part of her story. I didn't need everything to be wrapped up neatly, but I wanted some indication that she had actually considered the consequences of what she was doing.

Despite all of these complaints, I still enjoyed the series quite a bit. The premise was interesting, the acting was strong, the chemistry between the leads worked, and the pacing kept me entertained. I just think the story had the potential to be even better if it had spent more time developing the organization and giving its characters motivations and decisions that felt consistent.

It's an 8.5/10 for me. I enjoyed watching it, would happily rewatch it with someone else, and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys darker, action-oriented stories. I just have quite a few questions about the choices the writers made!
Was this review helpful to you?