Skye

Initially, this show felt like a solid 9/10 for me, gorgeous cinematography, an array of very attractive leads, and that signature artistic style I’ve come to expect from this director. Visually, it absolutely delivers. But by the time the final episodes rolled around, my rating had slipped to an 8… honestly, closer to a 7.

The problem is that the storytelling just doesn’t hold up under all that beauty. I knew the director’s aesthetic and thematic style going in, and those elements didn’t disappoint. But the narrative itself felt thin, especially in the second half. The female lead, who starts off as a strong, capable, independent woman, slowly drifts into Mary Sue territory and not because she’s powerful, but because the writing stops challenging her in meaningful ways.

And don’t even get me started on the villains’ “deaths.” Plot armour so thick it might as well be bulletproof steel. You cannot convince me that being shot in the chest and falling off a city wall somehow results in… survival? I get that they may be trying to stay faithful to the source material, but at least make it believable.

Overall, it is stunning to look at and has moments of brilliance, but the uneven writing and unbelievable character outcomes hold it back from being truly great.