Quirky and straightforward, but...
It took me a long time to watch this adaptation because I kept expecting it to be the same as the original. Looking back, I probably should have watched it sooner.
In my opinion, this remake is actually a bit better than the Thai version. As the headline suggests, the Korean adaptation is more straightforward and focused, which works to its advantage. I appreciated how the pacing never felt dragging; instead, it reinforced the show's direct approach and allowed the actors' performances to shine more effectively. Furthermore, the division of screen time between the two couples was balanced enough for the audience to understand their individual stories and relationships.
Technically speaking, one of the strongest aspects of this series is the chemistry between the lead actors. They were quirky and charismatic enough to keep my attention and make me eager to click on the next episode. Their interactions establish a strong and believable foundation for the romance. Although the script relies on several familiar romance clichés—particularly the possessive-boyfriend trope of "if I can't have him, then I'll badmouth him"—the actors manage to pull it off without making it feel overly cringeworthy.
The second leads were equally enjoyable to watch, portraying a softer and more vulnerable kind of romance. Yoo Kyeom's golden-retriever energy complemented Sun Woo's personality throughout the series, creating a dynamic that was both charming and engaging. Their relationship added another layer to the story and kept me invested throughout the show's runtime.
The series' biggest strength is undoubtedly its lighthearted nature. With only eight episodes running at approximately thirty minutes each, it is an easy and enjoyable watch that can be finished in a single sitting. However, this short runtime is also one of the drama's greatest weaknesses. Several plot points feel underexplored and underdeveloped, while the relationship-building occasionally feels rushed. Some transitions between scenes are so abrupt that it becomes difficult to tell whether a scene is a flashback or a continuation of the previous one. Important emotional developments happen too quickly, preventing certain storylines from reaching their full potential. In many ways, this adaptation sacrifices depth in favor of pacing.
Nevertheless, this remains the stronger adaptation. It is an enjoyable drama that explores love in a lighthearted and entertaining way while delivering enough charm and chemistry to keep viewers invested. Despite its shortcomings, Why R U? (2023) offers a sweet and refreshing take on the BL genre that is well worth watching.
In my opinion, this remake is actually a bit better than the Thai version. As the headline suggests, the Korean adaptation is more straightforward and focused, which works to its advantage. I appreciated how the pacing never felt dragging; instead, it reinforced the show's direct approach and allowed the actors' performances to shine more effectively. Furthermore, the division of screen time between the two couples was balanced enough for the audience to understand their individual stories and relationships.
Technically speaking, one of the strongest aspects of this series is the chemistry between the lead actors. They were quirky and charismatic enough to keep my attention and make me eager to click on the next episode. Their interactions establish a strong and believable foundation for the romance. Although the script relies on several familiar romance clichés—particularly the possessive-boyfriend trope of "if I can't have him, then I'll badmouth him"—the actors manage to pull it off without making it feel overly cringeworthy.
The second leads were equally enjoyable to watch, portraying a softer and more vulnerable kind of romance. Yoo Kyeom's golden-retriever energy complemented Sun Woo's personality throughout the series, creating a dynamic that was both charming and engaging. Their relationship added another layer to the story and kept me invested throughout the show's runtime.
The series' biggest strength is undoubtedly its lighthearted nature. With only eight episodes running at approximately thirty minutes each, it is an easy and enjoyable watch that can be finished in a single sitting. However, this short runtime is also one of the drama's greatest weaknesses. Several plot points feel underexplored and underdeveloped, while the relationship-building occasionally feels rushed. Some transitions between scenes are so abrupt that it becomes difficult to tell whether a scene is a flashback or a continuation of the previous one. Important emotional developments happen too quickly, preventing certain storylines from reaching their full potential. In many ways, this adaptation sacrifices depth in favor of pacing.
Nevertheless, this remains the stronger adaptation. It is an enjoyable drama that explores love in a lighthearted and entertaining way while delivering enough charm and chemistry to keep viewers invested. Despite its shortcomings, Why R U? (2023) offers a sweet and refreshing take on the BL genre that is well worth watching.
Was this review helpful to you?
