This review may contain spoilers
Not Poor but Weirdly Lacking
With two well known actors as the main couple, it's expected that this drama be one that outshines some of its peers with smaller budgets, cast, and production. Surprisingly (or not), it felt like this drama was lacking something and it just didn't measure up.
First of all, like many of the dramas in recent years, Fight for Love draws inspiration from a CNovel. One of the biggest pitfalls of these sorts of adaptations is shrinking these novels while preserving iconic scenes and arcs as some of these novels are hundreds of chapters long. This particular novel was 174 chapters long which is pretty average as other novels like Rebirth of a Star General (which Legend of the Female General was adapted from) came in at 272 chapters. I found that there was nothing wrong with the way that the script was adapted. No particularly iconic scenes or arcs were cut and there weren't awful time-skips or jumps in the story, yet it still felt like there were too many side characters and too many things going on at the same time. The multitude of side characters which seemingly insignificant roles made it difficult to remember all of them and understand where the plot was trying to go.
Since the end of this drama, there were many articles talking about the lack of chemistry between the FL and ML (which I confess, I agree with) but I think there were a number of issues that contributed to this drama feeling a little lukewarm. Aside from the main couple, the major issue really was the fact that there wasn't a single scene stealer. To put it nicely, everyone on the cast is about the same level when it comes to acting. To be a little more blunt, no one on the cast was particularly good at acting and so there weren't scene stealer moments. You would expect that there would be at least one breakout star in such a big team, but it just felt like they shooed in a bunch of unknown actors to fill roles. (Edit: Joe Chen as the Eldest Princess and her yandere man was actually pretty good)
Ok, so here's the (potentially) controversial part. Many people said that Victoria and Ding YuXi just had too big of an age gap which is why there was no chemistry. but I find that to be only part of the problem. The FL in the novel is supposed to be older than the ML and Victoria has done 'noona' style dramas in the past, but the chemistry is lacking here for a couple reasons. The FL as a character doesn't feel like she's older than ML, whether it was due to the adaptation of the script or due to Victoria's acting. Similarly, ML has moments were he feels younger (more inexperienced) but also too young and naive for someone who is supposed to be from a military family. The fact that Ding YuXi also could pass for a 20 year old also doesn't help in this case. In essence, neither seem like the adult in the relationship so it becomes a bit of a mess seeing them go back and forth.
Production-wise, the budget is large enough that the costumes looked well-made and not too tacky. The music wasn't really highlighted too much but it got us through. There were, however, jarring moments of CG use which made me question the artistic sense of the director and the purpose.
So in summary, a drag-y Sparks Note version of a script, a humongous cast with no real breakout stars, and a main couple with no chemistry really made FFL tank pretty hard especially airing after similar, but far more outstanding dramas in the same year like Legend of the Female General, Dream within a Dream, Legend of Zang Hai, etc.
To be completely fair, looking at the roles by themselves, Victoria Song and Ding YuXi are good fits for the roles. Victoria really stood out in martial arts sequences due to her background in dance and did not waver when performing moves (even with a sword) which is quite rare. Her expression of her character and how her state of mind changes could use work, but visually she fits the role. Ding YuXi also was a good fit for the role, but potentially he could have toned down how young his portrayal of ML was (but that also was partly due to the script) which could have helped make the main couple look more like a couple and not like big sister and little brother (who is way to young for her).
First of all, like many of the dramas in recent years, Fight for Love draws inspiration from a CNovel. One of the biggest pitfalls of these sorts of adaptations is shrinking these novels while preserving iconic scenes and arcs as some of these novels are hundreds of chapters long. This particular novel was 174 chapters long which is pretty average as other novels like Rebirth of a Star General (which Legend of the Female General was adapted from) came in at 272 chapters. I found that there was nothing wrong with the way that the script was adapted. No particularly iconic scenes or arcs were cut and there weren't awful time-skips or jumps in the story, yet it still felt like there were too many side characters and too many things going on at the same time. The multitude of side characters which seemingly insignificant roles made it difficult to remember all of them and understand where the plot was trying to go.
Since the end of this drama, there were many articles talking about the lack of chemistry between the FL and ML (which I confess, I agree with) but I think there were a number of issues that contributed to this drama feeling a little lukewarm. Aside from the main couple, the major issue really was the fact that there wasn't a single scene stealer. To put it nicely, everyone on the cast is about the same level when it comes to acting. To be a little more blunt, no one on the cast was particularly good at acting and so there weren't scene stealer moments. You would expect that there would be at least one breakout star in such a big team, but it just felt like they shooed in a bunch of unknown actors to fill roles. (Edit: Joe Chen as the Eldest Princess and her yandere man was actually pretty good)
Ok, so here's the (potentially) controversial part. Many people said that Victoria and Ding YuXi just had too big of an age gap which is why there was no chemistry. but I find that to be only part of the problem. The FL in the novel is supposed to be older than the ML and Victoria has done 'noona' style dramas in the past, but the chemistry is lacking here for a couple reasons. The FL as a character doesn't feel like she's older than ML, whether it was due to the adaptation of the script or due to Victoria's acting. Similarly, ML has moments were he feels younger (more inexperienced) but also too young and naive for someone who is supposed to be from a military family. The fact that Ding YuXi also could pass for a 20 year old also doesn't help in this case. In essence, neither seem like the adult in the relationship so it becomes a bit of a mess seeing them go back and forth.
Production-wise, the budget is large enough that the costumes looked well-made and not too tacky. The music wasn't really highlighted too much but it got us through. There were, however, jarring moments of CG use which made me question the artistic sense of the director and the purpose.
So in summary, a drag-y Sparks Note version of a script, a humongous cast with no real breakout stars, and a main couple with no chemistry really made FFL tank pretty hard especially airing after similar, but far more outstanding dramas in the same year like Legend of the Female General, Dream within a Dream, Legend of Zang Hai, etc.
To be completely fair, looking at the roles by themselves, Victoria Song and Ding YuXi are good fits for the roles. Victoria really stood out in martial arts sequences due to her background in dance and did not waver when performing moves (even with a sword) which is quite rare. Her expression of her character and how her state of mind changes could use work, but visually she fits the role. Ding YuXi also was a good fit for the role, but potentially he could have toned down how young his portrayal of ML was (but that also was partly due to the script) which could have helped make the main couple look more like a couple and not like big sister and little brother (who is way to young for her).
Was this review helpful to you?
