Celebrity This review may contain spoilers
Being Called China's 50 Shades of Grey Is Not a Compliment
This is going to ruffle feathers, but 50 Shades idealizes toxic, controlling relationships. The Early Spring being called China's version of it is in no way a compliment.
Don't get me wrong. Jing Bo Ran is a hottie and was fantastic at his role. Sun Qian and the rest of the cast also were great, but I just have a hard time with the script. Workplace romances always run the risk of being shady especially when it's between a boss and subordinate. The power dynamic makes it hard for both to be consenting adults (even if they were initially willing) because it's always in the background. We actually see this becoming a plot point and the impetus for why they broke up the second time. Obviously, the issue is far deeper than just fearing others' misunderstanding and having your achievements being downplayed because you're in a relationship with your boss. If FL wanted to end the relationship or refuses to sleep with her boss, it would have been difficult to refuse out of fear of retaliation or losing her job. We see bits of that play out when FL breaks up with him during the time that he was away because she knew he wouldn't have signed her resignation request had he been present. It's even worse when you think about how young and impressionable FL is. In the first episode, we learn that she's a new grad interviewing for her first job after college. At max, she's 21-23 years old when she first starts working for ML who has already established himself in the field. If you stop superimposing JBR and SQ's faces onto the FL and ML, this story is basically fresh-new-grad-in-her-twenties x midlevel-manager-in-his-thirties. From the start, the premise was already raising plenty of red flags.
When we get into the nitty gritty of the characters and the character development of FL and ML, there's still not much redemption. ML is callous, curt, and honestly intolerable even outside of work. His arrogance stems from his abilities but it's made him rather detestable as a person. During the relationship, he crosses FL's boundaries multiple times, calls her a variation of stupid or timid, and is just so condescending. Even when they're having sex, he's condescending with her. When his feelings towards her changes and he wants her to take him seriously, he doesn't tell her outright that he loves her and instead is passive aggressive and controls who she meets. In every sense, this is a toxic relationship. ML does have his arc where he's tormented and has to chase after FL, but it's not done very well. It was rather short of a redemption arc (3-5 episodes max after 15+ episodes of mistreating her) and his way of winning her back is stalkerish and crosses boundary after boundary. In real life, this is when you call the police and file a restraining order. ML also never really gets off his high horse when he's trying to win her back. In the last episode, he says something along the lines of "If it wasn't because I wanted to prove that I wanted to be with you forever, I'd already made you pay for it today" after pulling away and not forcing a kiss like he would have. While I understand that it was supposed to be a sign of growth or something for us to swoon over, it didn't hit the mark for me especially since he's already crossed so many lines. A strategic retreat is common for domestic abusers and him saying this makes it sound like he's threatening (sexual) violence.
FL is the complete opposite of ML. She's young, impressionable, timid, and really has no ability (which is normal because this is her first job and she's supposed to be entry-level). She is initially drawn to ML because of his looks and ability, but she's not without common sense. She's made it clear that she needs to draw a boundary and that she's not allowed to date ML (which of course ML crosses the line and the first time they slept together is debatable consent). I do give her flowers for acknowledging this which makes it harder to accept ML crossing the line to be with her anyways. He knows better than anyone how detrimental it could be for her and she's refused, but he continues to chase after her until he gets what he wants. Again, returning to the power dynamic of a boss-subordinate relationship. My only gripe with FL (because she honestly did the best that she could in that situation and relationship) was that in the end, she wasn't able to prove herself without ML. She still ends up needing to rely on ML in the end which I think means that there's still a sense of inequality to their relationship. Because one of the reasons they broke up was because FL feels that ML doesn't view her as an equal or as capable and ML also has a habit of interfering with things then lording it over her, I feel that getting back together and then getting engaged soon afterwards is a mistake.
TDLR: If Jing Boran didn't look the way that he did, none of you would be ok with this situation. It's a glorified, toxic relationship between a boss and subordinate. Even though it's easy to get lost with all the kiss scenes, that's all their relationship ended up being (FWB) and they had little in common.
Don't get me wrong. Jing Bo Ran is a hottie and was fantastic at his role. Sun Qian and the rest of the cast also were great, but I just have a hard time with the script. Workplace romances always run the risk of being shady especially when it's between a boss and subordinate. The power dynamic makes it hard for both to be consenting adults (even if they were initially willing) because it's always in the background. We actually see this becoming a plot point and the impetus for why they broke up the second time. Obviously, the issue is far deeper than just fearing others' misunderstanding and having your achievements being downplayed because you're in a relationship with your boss. If FL wanted to end the relationship or refuses to sleep with her boss, it would have been difficult to refuse out of fear of retaliation or losing her job. We see bits of that play out when FL breaks up with him during the time that he was away because she knew he wouldn't have signed her resignation request had he been present. It's even worse when you think about how young and impressionable FL is. In the first episode, we learn that she's a new grad interviewing for her first job after college. At max, she's 21-23 years old when she first starts working for ML who has already established himself in the field. If you stop superimposing JBR and SQ's faces onto the FL and ML, this story is basically fresh-new-grad-in-her-twenties x midlevel-manager-in-his-thirties. From the start, the premise was already raising plenty of red flags.
When we get into the nitty gritty of the characters and the character development of FL and ML, there's still not much redemption. ML is callous, curt, and honestly intolerable even outside of work. His arrogance stems from his abilities but it's made him rather detestable as a person. During the relationship, he crosses FL's boundaries multiple times, calls her a variation of stupid or timid, and is just so condescending. Even when they're having sex, he's condescending with her. When his feelings towards her changes and he wants her to take him seriously, he doesn't tell her outright that he loves her and instead is passive aggressive and controls who she meets. In every sense, this is a toxic relationship. ML does have his arc where he's tormented and has to chase after FL, but it's not done very well. It was rather short of a redemption arc (3-5 episodes max after 15+ episodes of mistreating her) and his way of winning her back is stalkerish and crosses boundary after boundary. In real life, this is when you call the police and file a restraining order. ML also never really gets off his high horse when he's trying to win her back. In the last episode, he says something along the lines of "If it wasn't because I wanted to prove that I wanted to be with you forever, I'd already made you pay for it today" after pulling away and not forcing a kiss like he would have. While I understand that it was supposed to be a sign of growth or something for us to swoon over, it didn't hit the mark for me especially since he's already crossed so many lines. A strategic retreat is common for domestic abusers and him saying this makes it sound like he's threatening (sexual) violence.
FL is the complete opposite of ML. She's young, impressionable, timid, and really has no ability (which is normal because this is her first job and she's supposed to be entry-level). She is initially drawn to ML because of his looks and ability, but she's not without common sense. She's made it clear that she needs to draw a boundary and that she's not allowed to date ML (which of course ML crosses the line and the first time they slept together is debatable consent). I do give her flowers for acknowledging this which makes it harder to accept ML crossing the line to be with her anyways. He knows better than anyone how detrimental it could be for her and she's refused, but he continues to chase after her until he gets what he wants. Again, returning to the power dynamic of a boss-subordinate relationship. My only gripe with FL (because she honestly did the best that she could in that situation and relationship) was that in the end, she wasn't able to prove herself without ML. She still ends up needing to rely on ML in the end which I think means that there's still a sense of inequality to their relationship. Because one of the reasons they broke up was because FL feels that ML doesn't view her as an equal or as capable and ML also has a habit of interfering with things then lording it over her, I feel that getting back together and then getting engaged soon afterwards is a mistake.
TDLR: If Jing Boran didn't look the way that he did, none of you would be ok with this situation. It's a glorified, toxic relationship between a boss and subordinate. Even though it's easy to get lost with all the kiss scenes, that's all their relationship ended up being (FWB) and they had little in common.
Was this review helpful to you?

1