This review may contain spoilers
Far-fetched Love Story with no Story and no Love-making
To be clear: when one decides to watch a Xuanhuan romance, it is in search of escapism, not because one expects a realistic depiction of events, people and their relationships. Nonetheless, for the make-believe world to be engaging, it must have an inner logic of its own and at least some kind of plot allowing the characters to develop.Love Beyond the Grave has neither. For the first time since I started watching C-drama, I found myself fast-forwarding intimate moments between the leads. For a romance, this is a sign of utter failure.
I am reluctant to put the blame for it on the most obvious suspects, i.e. the cast. Dilraba Dilmurat is stunning beautiful as usual and, as usual, she is reasonably convincing in portraying her character. Then again, at least she is given a character of some substance to work with: a 400 years old queen who governs the unruly world of spirits with an iron fist in order to preserve the legacy of law and order left by her loving but early departed parents. Her subjects, spirits, are by their nature volatile and obsessive. Thus, to be able to effectively control them, she herself is deprived of all sensual enjoyment susceptible to make her temperamental or biased.
How then is this woman, who can never know even the simplest and most innocent of sensual joys, supposed to fall in love with anyone? Not to worry. There is a rumor saying that she might be able to "borrow" human senses from an individual mystically chosen to become the owner of a magical sword. In comes a young, ambitious general with a gruesome backstory which makes him wise beyond his years. He fights fearlessly and plots strategically; he makes smart alliances, earns the loyalty of his subordinates and seems unstoppable in his ambition to reclaim lost lands for his nation and ensure good governance for people. His appearance is dashing, his aspirations noble and he has a magic sword. What's not to like?
This is the starting point of the plot. It is also the ending point of the plot, because there is simply no plot to speak of. The moment our young hero realizes, fairly early on, that the beautiful woman following him around with a suspicious interest in his magical sword is not a mortal, but a powerful otherworldly queen free of all human passions, he abruptly and inexplicably becomes determined to seduce her. In pursuit of this goal, and in order to give her the possibility of temporarily experiencing the mortal world through his sense, he progressively sacrifices his family, his friends, his allies, his subordinates, his martial skills and therefore his military ambitions - in short, his entire existence.
The premise of self-sacrificing, self-annihilating love could, of course, be the making of a great tragedy. However, the tragic love story never materializes because, implausibly, incredibly and even callously, our male lead engages in self-destruction casually, cheerfully, with all the charm, energy and easy forgetfulness of a playful young puppy. Whatever happens, whatever losses he suffers, he doesn't seem to take it very seriously. He may shed a few tears here and there, but as soon as he receives a tender hug from his lady love - who hugs him for unclear reasons seeing that she can feel neither the warmth nor the pressure of human touch - he regains his flirtatious smile and keeps happily trotting down the road of self-annihilation. All this in stark contrast with everything we have initially learnt about his tenacious, calculating, survive-at-all-costs personnality.
It is a small surprise, then, if Arthur Chen constantly looks like he came to the studio to shoot a teen comedy, then mistakenly blundered into the wrong set and is now clueless as to what role he is supposed to be playing. To begin with, his look is that of a mischievous sweet 16, as opposed to Dilraba who presents exactly as she should, i.e. an immortal beauty. More disturbingly, not only does his character look like a pubescent boy but, as soon as he falls in love, he starts acting like a 6-year-old, blissfully oblivious to anything other than the object of his childish fascination. Watching a presumably grown man - an army general, no loss, responsible for thousands of lives - behave with such immaturity and recklessness is not romantic. It is awkward, mildly distasteful and, ultimately, boring.
Nor do I see how the asexual relationship between the leads could have ever been turned into an epic love story. The couple's asexuality is never openly discussed, or even suggested. Yet it is the inevitable implication of her crippled sensuality and his sacrifice of his own to make her momentarily happy. To put it bluntly, either he can't perform, or she can't enjoy it. A situation more conducive to marital counselling and couples' therapy than to a sweeping love story.
Certainly, it is possible to create a sizzling romance with no sexual content; C-drama in general excels at it. But you can't simply put two famous actors together, make them play characters who have absolutely nothing in common, have them go through the motions of a plot where they don't fully engage in each other's separate worlds or undergo any pivotal experiences together, and still have the viewers believe that they are somehow irresistibly attracted to each other even though, on top of everything else, there is no hope of their ever sharing any physical joy in each other.
Only a very innocent young heart, who lacks a hands-on understanding of human physiology and tends to confuse idolatry with physical chemistry, can be swept away by such sloppy far-fetched approach to star-crossed lovers trope.
The lazy storytelling would have probably been better served if the producers had opted for a modern romance, with the female lead an ice-cold CEO and the male lead a young enthusiastic intern. It might have been equally boring, but at least it could have made some kind of sense. Moreover, the outstanding work done by various crew members to create a visually sumptuous fantasy world would not have gone to waste. As it is, all the eye-candy trimmings of an enchanting fairytale only exacerbate the hollow absurdity of a love story with no story and no love-making.
To honor the efforts of the crew and of the supporting cast, some of whom offered notable performances, I will give this drama a generous overall rating of 7.5. As for the leads, their star power might have been better used had they insisted on a less nonsensical and self-defeating script.
Was this review helpful to you?
Authentic, concise and compelling
I am relatively new to Chinese drama and completely new to Chinese film industry, so maybe that's the reason why I am surprised by the relatively low score of this movie.The story is authentic and interesting, with emotionally compelling characters convincingly portrayed by a strong cast. It is executed neatly, effectively and concisely.
There are only two somewhat weaker points I can think of. First, the self-congratulatory moral of the story; but this is typical for most dramas centered around the justice system everywhere in the world. Second, I would have liked to know more about what happens with the protagonists later on; but as the story is inspired by real facts, it was obviously impossible for the film-makers to improvise much further.
Overall, a good way to spend an evening, both educational and enjoyable.
Was this review helpful to you?
