BlackKitKat

Hmm I am.wondering what I will like the best in this case between the series or the book :) I'll let you know ^^
Oh ... FYI Isaac is an original character he doesn't exists in the books ^^ There there is Aled but where I am (book3) he is gay not asexual. I guess they made the change in the series to talk about more kind of sexualities. Also Imogen doesn't zxist in the book I guess in her case ot was to talk about heterosexuality.
I know in book 4 they will dwelve in Charlie's eating issues that they started to show in book3/s2 but I don't think it will turn too dark bcz the series is light not very dark as you said.

I went to MEB website and it was in Thai when I switched to english not everything was traduced 😅 so I think I'll try kindle I am just trying to see if it will be readable with my phone.
Yeah I was surprised with the acting not only the mains but I think the whole cast did a good job. For the leads, they had chemistry from the 1st time we see them on screen I really could believed they loved each other and were destined to meet. They didn't looked embarassed or uncomfortable in the intimates scenes either that can turn cringe and weird depending of the actors.
It will be great of they find budget to adapt the 2nd part ! let's hope for it.

yeah usually books tends to have better descriptions and also most important the characters emotions are sometime easier to get since its all said textually. But I don't know I guess I am just loving much watching it in a screen. I don't the fact that we see it coming to life I just feel it more you see I guess that's why I usually tend to prefer the show even though I buy the books ahah. But at least the books gives usually more insight or bztter understanding. Sometimes some scenes are completely different so I always feel like knowing the book when it exists is somehow important.
It makes me think of Hunger Games I really prefered the book because it has way more depth and you could understand better the emotions the characters were going through specially in the end. But for example I prefered Shadowhunters series compared to The Mortal Instruments books bcz in the books it focused so much on the 2 mains characters I was so sad. yet I still try to see the adaptions and the original support as 2 different things it makes it more enjoyable to think they have the right to change things its the purpose of "adaptation" ahah
Heartstopper is a graphic novel so you read it very very fast it feels a bit rushed compared to the series and there is not much scenes for the secondary characters but in the show they corrected it enough to make you love all the characters not only the mains one.
Just my thoughts they are not always the popular ones ahah

omg you are right I just saw they say "deliver to your kindle library" I don't even understand how it works 😭 I'll search a bit to see if any account needs to be created but I think I saw it on google books too well I'll manage in a way I guess ahah.
oooh okay got it 👌🏼 in this case it makes more sense I guess ahah.
You should sell things ahah you hyped me to buy this novel ahah ! I am not the kind to cry while reading I feel like in difference with a show you have the time to control your emotions since you read at your own pace hmm so yeah I don't get overly emotional with a book even when major characters death ahahah but I love trying to picture it in my head even more when it has a live adaption it makes it more easy since you have the actors on your mind (it just dont works sometime when they cast physically different actors it happens sometimes and I am like what? so hard to imagine them as this character ahah)

ooh also last question I swear ahah
since you read the novel, for you is it a read and watch or watch and read ?
For example I bought heartstopper books after having watch the 2 seasons and I felt like the book would have been more enjiyable if I had read it first since the series follows it a lot and I find it better in the end (thought I loved the books anyway ahha I will just have enjiyed it more I guess)

Thank you so much for the details !!
I would have loved it so much to be able to read it but I am not a social med person ahah -.-' sry I just have an instagram account to follow a bit Bl actors only (shame on me 🤣) but I guess we cant exchange anything through that.
I'll try to buy it through Amazon in this case :/ seems the price is okay I'll just double check the shipping part.
Also I was wondering why is Yai always "Yai" lol? the others always change names so its a bit disturbing no?
I am a big fan of historical K drama costumes and all the setting I will hope for a s2 I rly think it could be soooo damn good >.<
Also warriors with tender heart always are my favs 🤣

OMG thank you so much
just reading your comments gives me so much wanting of a season2 >.< Yet I am skeptical for a BL to have enough budget to pull a story in this kind of era bcz he says in the series moustache Yai is a warrior and as you call him "commander" I guess there must be wars to show and also the scenery in this era must be much more complicated to set. Lets be honnest the actual series was filmed mainly in the house other than that they did a little market and found an old bar that's all so it was easier for budget purposes I guess to only do 1920's era and not the other era. Yet with your explanation I want to know more about this Commander Yai >.< I feel like I may love him even more than Khun Yai ^^

OMG honestly what would make the most sense I guess is for Busabong (I think I got the name right? the one he should have married in 1920's) or his father Brother Perch? Perck? to be the one that cursed him. Maybe bcz he should have married her in the commander Yai era?
What would be a total surprise would be if its the sister :o I would be like 😱
But another possible guessing is Fong Kaew bcz she seems to have a bad karma so maybe its because she has done something bad in a previous life ?
I would have love to see James in this era but I guess there was no white people at this era what a shame :( I got invested in him I rly liked him ^^
OMG please spoil me. I saw I could buy the novel in Amazon but some people say english traduction is less good than thai version bcz of the wording use its hard to get understanding it >.<

Spoil me I will love it since I think there is very few chances for a season2 🤣

Thank you very much for the detailled answer!
I have another question in this case :) Yai have several reincarnations (at least 3) but his love story is always with Jom 2023 ?
Why? I don't understand why there is no other version of Jom? Is it explained?
I am so sad Yai 1928 stays alone. Why he doesn't meet a Jom from his era ? Same for moustache Yai ?
Why are they cursed in the first place?

Thx for your reply it clarifies some points. I am so so sad about Yai in 1928 😭 I would have liked he met his era Jom. It feels like only 1 Jom exists althought there are several reincarnations of Yai I am so sad :(
Also I hope we could have seen the other Yai thought I guess the budget must not be the same, should be more complicated to portray wars (as he says the moustache man is a warrior) and life in this era

PLEASE SOMEONE SPOIL ME THE NOVEL.
I just ended in 2 days this uncut version of this series and I don't get the ending scenes.
please tell me if i m right or wrong
before the generic : the Yai we see in 2023 is the reincarnation of the 1928 Yai (means our Yai is dead) For whatever reason he remembers his past life and so Jom. How on hell? did he experienced any thing like Jom? please explain to me if there is more info on the novel 🙏🏼
then I was completely lost with the post generic scene and the Yai from ???? 1700? 1800? I don't know at all. Well it's the Yai that saves him in the river and give him the ring right ?
Q1 : I guess this Yai version is the starting point of there love. What I don't get is why its still with the 2023 Jom ? Is he condaimned to time travel and meet all the versions of his Yai to finally never be with any?
Q2 : Related to last question. If Jom finally found is own version from the same era in 2023 at the end WHY ON HELL IS HE DRAGGED AGAIN IN THE PAST? Or was Yai 2023 the ghost of our 1928 Yai? And he was able to send him back on time with a kiss (as the water Yai) but not into the good era?
Q3: Is Jom happy in the end with any version of Yai ? 😭 If he can time travel I would have liked he went back to Yai 1928 but judging by the letter he read that didn't happened right ....
Please help me if you have any answer. A link to read the novel in english. ANYTHING PLEASE I AM OBSESSED TO UNDERSTAND THIS ENDING 😭

Thx for your reply I have give it a try directly to the uncut version! I found ep1 so boring (dragging too much on some scenes) I thought I will drop but I continued and I am happy I am at ep 6 now and I slowly got into it :) Thought I rly don't like so many things happening in the drama but its normal since its historical drama >.< I feel its going to be a sad ending at least in 1920's. Maybe he will meet Yai reincarnation in 2020's when he will be back. I'll cross fingers 🤞🏼

Thx for your reply I have give it a try directly to the uncut version! I found ep1 so boring (dragging to much on some scenes) I thought I will drop but I continued and I am happy I am at ep 6 now and I slowly got into it :) Thought I rly don't like so many things happening in the drama but its normal since its historical drama >.< I feel its going to be a sad ending at least in 1920's. Maybe he will me Yai reincarnation in 2020's when he will be back. I'll cross fingers 🤞🏼

Hello ! I want to give a try to this story but as I don't know a single thing about Thailand History I was wondering if I will feel lost or if it's still possible to follow anyway ?
Thx in advance!

you're welcome ;)

Just FYI this is an original story. The novel was adapted from the script, not the other way around ^^

thanks for this info !
I am from European country and I had a friend you got cornea transplant when she was still seing very clearly. she didn't had to wait long. lots of donors I guess

Actually I'll say him having just 2 in this much time seems very unrealistic. Its pretty "easy" compared to other transplants to have a cornea transplant. But maybe its different in Thailand ...

Did I found the end good ? Yes. Did I found it bad ? Yes. There was good and bad and I will not rant here about what could have been different because some people will not understand we can dislike things in a show we actually like overall.
I will keep the positive of this show and there was actually a lot ! It's definetly one of the best BL produced to date and a real must watch for every BL lover. For me from ep 1 to 9 there are no debates everything is just perfection from writing choices to script to acting to cinematography. Then they lost me a bit with the 3 last episodes with their writing choices but MhokDay will forever remain in my heart ❤
It's a strong 9 for me and a must rewatch at least till ep9.
Hope it gets even more recognition and people watching now that it has ended bcz damn Jimmy Sea deserve better! There are some ship in GMMTV so popular but with just acceptable acting skills when these 2 guys have proved they can act like REALLY act.
If you want to know if you should give this show a chance : don't wait anymore and throw yourself into Last Twilight without second thought ;)

Don't get me wrong : I am team Day gets back his sight by the end of the series ^^
I know donation exists. One of my friend had a cornea donation she as now a black/blue eye so I think its realist to be able to have a donation.
No my problem was the cliché that its christmas like he got "a miracle" "a gift" thx to this day it's just that. If it was a normal day I think I will not have disliked it

Thanks for the clarification on the timeline I got your explanation better I guess you are right it was morning and then the night okay.
Yeah I got it but either this forgiveness is too soon or they pushed to much of Day's angryness in the earlier episodes because it didn't gave the feeling he could come to terms with it in a single day. I would have prefered okay he talk back to Night but "forgives" him later after having give more than a second thought (this how I felt for me it was sooo rushed with how much anger Day had in himself towards Night ..)
For the glove someone else mentionned it I didn't noticed at all I was wondering if he was talking about the blue color of the glove 😅