I think they just wanted it "all". Romance for these kinds of topics is always a hard sell. Especially…
They didn't want to do that, they wanted to show us her life. Lin Jin Qi is a part of her life.
For me the problem is that all those things Lan Xiang is saying "history is written by men" or "you took my life (and my choice away) are not historically accurate. Women were not self aware of these notions back then.
Women were supposed to marry whoever her parents wanted them to. So, LX would operate the same way with Scholar Han or whoever else.
I agree with you this is no romance, she is just grateful for him and what he did for her fallen family and friends.
I think they just wanted it "all". Romance for these kinds of topics is always a hard sell. Especially…
@JJJ I haven't read the original, but from what I am watching in the cdrama, the scripwriter made a choice early on. She wanted to write about woman empowerment in that era. Which couldn't have happened in such extend at that period. Hence her decision to make LJQ to drug her in order to bring her to the Capital. I didn't like that choice when I saw that episode and I was pretty certain it would drag on. It did.
Lan Xiang has a modus operandi and she stays in that, without changing at all. Lin Jin Qi was at fault, so he had to change.
He is the one who loves her unconditionally, but LX doesn't. She just feels grateful for what he did for her family. That's it. I haven't seen even admiration from her part, for all that he had done for others during the show. I have written about LJQ's good deeds and who he was as a person, two days ago.
LX is smart and perceptive, but couldn't see the man who was in front of her.
Why should I believe LX changed perspective in Episode 38? I haven't seen her softening towards him. Maybe a glimpse after he was beaten because of his sister's divorce. So, yes for me they shouldn't have ended up together. I agree about what you are saying about the "bad ending".
If he was doing all these, everyone would riot for his indifference.
I really don't understand why the majority of the viewers is pissed off. There was no progression on their romance what so ever. The character development was only for LJQ. Lan Xiang hasn't changed at all. She remained true to her original state. She only witnessed him to change and that was enough. She lived well.
That's why I was debating after coming to the Capital if they should end up together. They shouldn't. The scriptwriter made a choice. The first part was excellent, the second was lacking, the third one, I haven't decided yet.
After episode 34, I kind of lost interest in this drama not because it’s bad, but because the pacing is too…
@Aster the problem starts with Man Yi's subplot. I find the dragging scene unnecessary, in order the story to move in the Capital. The first part is amazing, the second one is lacking and I don't know about the third...
This follows traditional Chinese thinking. First, Lanxiang was jilted, meaning the Lin family betrayed her —…
@Krizklid I am transcribing the scene from Viki. Episode 2, 24:21 mark.
LX : "Heaven above, and Earth below, bear witness. Today, honorable men have recovered the remains of the Shen family and Lan Xiang and laid them all to rest. I owe them a debt beyond measure. I'll never forget what they've done and I swear I"ll repay them one day."
She didn't swear an oath to marry the warrior. She swore an oath to repay them for burying her family.
That's one of my problems. She didn't love him for who JQ was, but for what he did for her clan. Jin Qi was there…
@sevenstar I like talking with people. I enjoyed our conversation as well! You brought something to the table too! Nice to meet you too! I am taking the day off! :-)
That's one of my problems. She didn't love him for who JQ was, but for what he did for her clan. Jin Qi was there…
@sevenstar If we are going to talk about transparency about her identity, the same applies if she married Scholar Han or whoever else she would have married in that case.
Scholar Han was showing himself all along. We cannot say that this applies only to LJQ. Both men showed her who they are.
So, we have transparency from the MLs, but the FL cannot have it, yet, because of her secret identity, which is true. What you are saying is valid.
Everyone can understand something else, because they have a different thinking. We discuss about it and try to find a common ground. :-)
That's one of my problems. She didn't love him for who JQ was, but for what he did for her clan. Jin Qi was there…
@sevenstar She didn't give him benefit of the doubt though. That is what I am talking about. She didn't know what LJQ was doing all along?
He saved YuChan when his Ex First Wife sold her, he brought her back to the estate. Then, he buried Du Chen, even though he tried to kill him. He saved the Deposed Crown Prince, he run to save her as well, even though she didn't know and didn't find out. That's why it was important for the viewers to have Ji Er talking to her about who went to the brothel.
All those little details were there for her to see.
I understand that she was in pain and grieving. I also understand she was furious at him for the Marriage Decree, because they had history together. He was her ex fiance who left her behind.
LJQ always was standing bare in front of her and his deeds were everywhere around her.
He helped his siblings to come in the Capital with him. He saved his 2nd Sister. He even helped Ji Er.
For me all those things were there for her to see, but our smart and perceptive LX didn't.
So, the scriptwriter by choosing a. to make him drag her instead of talking about moving in Capital. b. to make her see who LJQ is and what he was doing all along is LATE!
The trails were always there and 39 episodes laters, LX discovers who LJQ is. Yes, she had a burden in her heart, but Lan Xiang CHOSE not to see WHO her husband truly is.
For all the above, I am not blaming LX per se. It is technical and refers to the scriptwriter. Yes, she did an amazing job weaving the story together, but she missed some details.
So, Lan Xiang was never going to fully accept Jin Qi unless he showed her the grave? 🤔 If he never did that,…
That's one of my problems. She didn't love him for who JQ was, but for what he did for her clan. Jin Qi was there all along and she didn't know him at all... LX was so damn smart, but could not see who was in front of her.
I didn’t get the idea that LX agrees to marry HL. But I see it. Like she didn’t say anything. It was just…
@sachapz I beg to differ. This is double standards. Scholar Han was a talent from the beginning. So, we are treating him as one regardless his position as 2ML.
His character is based on an actual scholar known for his character, I have read in the comment section.
So, he succeeded because he was good at it, not because he lost Lan Xiang.
For me the problem is that all those things Lan Xiang is saying "history is written by men" or "you took my life (and my choice away) are not historically accurate. Women were not self aware of these notions back then.
Women were supposed to marry whoever her parents wanted them to. So, LX would operate the same way with Scholar Han or whoever else.
I agree with you this is no romance, she is just grateful for him and what he did for her fallen family and friends.
Lan Xiang has a modus operandi and she stays in that, without changing at all.
Lin Jin Qi was at fault, so he had to change.
He is the one who loves her unconditionally, but LX doesn't. She just feels grateful for what he did for her family. That's it. I haven't seen even admiration from her part, for all that he had done for others during the show. I have written about LJQ's good deeds and who he was as a person, two days ago.
LX is smart and perceptive, but couldn't see the man who was in front of her.
Why should I believe LX changed perspective in Episode 38? I haven't seen her softening towards him. Maybe a glimpse after he was beaten because of his sister's divorce. So, yes for me they shouldn't have ended up together. I agree about what you are saying about the "bad ending".
If he was doing all these, everyone would riot for his indifference.
That's why I was debating after coming to the Capital if they should end up together. They shouldn't.
The scriptwriter made a choice. The first part was excellent, the second was lacking, the third one, I haven't decided yet.
I haven't proceeded watching after Episode 35.
I am not in that episode yet, but spoilers are everywhere...
I am not speaking Mandarin obviously, but I like to learn things!
LX : "Heaven above, and Earth below, bear witness. Today, honorable men have recovered the remains of the Shen family and Lan Xiang and laid them all to rest. I owe them a debt beyond measure. I'll never forget what they've done and I swear I"ll repay them one day."
She didn't swear an oath to marry the warrior. She swore an oath to repay them for burying her family.
I am taking the day off! :-)
Scholar Han was showing himself all along. We cannot say that this applies only to LJQ. Both men showed her who they are.
So, we have transparency from the MLs, but the FL cannot have it, yet, because of her secret identity, which is true. What you are saying is valid.
Everyone can understand something else, because they have a different thinking. We discuss about it and try to find a common ground. :-)
He saved YuChan when his Ex First Wife sold her, he brought her back to the estate. Then, he buried Du Chen, even though he tried to kill him. He saved the Deposed Crown Prince, he run to save her as well, even though she didn't know and didn't find out. That's why it was important for the viewers to have Ji Er talking to her about who went to the brothel.
All those little details were there for her to see.
I understand that she was in pain and grieving. I also understand she was furious at him for the Marriage Decree, because they had history together. He was her ex fiance who left her behind.
LJQ always was standing bare in front of her and his deeds were everywhere around her.
He helped his siblings to come in the Capital with him. He saved his 2nd Sister. He even helped Ji Er.
For me all those things were there for her to see, but our smart and perceptive LX didn't.
So, the scriptwriter by choosing
a. to make him drag her instead of talking about moving in Capital.
b. to make her see who LJQ is and what he was doing all along is LATE!
The trails were always there and 39 episodes laters, LX discovers who LJQ is.
Yes, she had a burden in her heart, but Lan Xiang CHOSE not to see WHO her husband truly is.
For all the above, I am not blaming LX per se. It is technical and refers to the scriptwriter. Yes, she did an amazing job weaving the story together, but she missed some details.
I don't remember the Scholar's name his character is based on, during Ming Dynasty. He was known for his ethics, kinda like Shen's Patriarch...😳
His character is based on an actual scholar known for his character, I have read in the comment section.
So, he succeeded because he was good at it, not because he lost Lan Xiang.