I understand how it looks on the surface, but her silence in Episode 28 isn't a lack of courtesy—it is a moment…
@Armaniiie All these things happened. I really don't understand how you are making and an analogy about trauma, depression and small pox.
People were dying because their Master said so. The End. People were fighting battles and died. Women were lost while bearing children. People were dying because they didn't have food or water. In other places of the world, some women died because they accused them to be witches. All those things happened.
I can agree with you and at the same time disagree with the fact that the scriptwriter chose a poor way for Lan Xiang to stand her ground after that slap to JQ.
Yes, she bowtowed. Yes, she could have stayed silent in the beginning and feel all those things you said above.
At the same time, she could have responded once to the Old Master when they brought the soup to them. She is smart, that is what we have seen in the first of the story, she had a whole month to decide what she could have said to him. Instead she didn't. I continue to believe that it was inconsistent based on the historical times the story is. :-)
This is valuable. In fact, I think you have nailed it completely.We are products of our time, class, gender, upbringing,…
@grapejuice I feel the scriptwriter in the middle part of the story is using cheap tricks. She shouldn't have to make JQ drugged her in episode 29. I didn't like this option. LX could have talked to him instead and said that she changed her mind because of Ji Er. I
Also, both are products of their circumstances. I don't like the analogy the "perfect "Lan Xiang vs Jin Qi who has all the flaws. Every human being is imperfectly perfect.
Lan Xiang has knowledge about being a slave because she was one. I really enjoyed what you have written in another thread about the Shen Patriarch. Lan Xiang doesn't know who they were.
I wrote a comment last night, that I didn't like the fact that she didn't answered back to the Old Master when they visited to pay their respects. She could have responded only once, in order to stand her ground in their house and their game.
I think there are some inconsistencies with the character's development.
She was totally absent minded infront of them. Atleast she bent and bowed. I was afraid she Won't even do that.…
@Hikikomori Scholar Han said by himself that he knew that he is the only one who had feeling for Lan Xiang. Also, she was accepting the marriage proposal because of filial piety towards her parents.
Both men did wrong, but historically that was happening back then. Parents decided for your marriage and you coudn't say anything.
Scholar Han knew that Commander Lin had feelings for Lan Xiang. That's why he said half truths after she was saved by Ji Er. Lan Xiang wouldn't accept Lin Qin Ji's proposal because they are in different classes. He doesn't know about her past and how she feels about the Lin family.
I understand how it looks on the surface, but her silence in Episode 28 isn't a lack of courtesy—it is a moment…
I know what trauma is and thank you for writing these things for me to see.
The thing is the story is in middle ages. They didn't know anything about trauma back then. Life and death just happened. You were lucky to live well or not...
You are explaining to me, her reaction based on our knowledge of today. And I agree with you. This is our insight today about her life in the past. Yes, she is a survivor. Yes, she is clever, stubborn and has pride. She is also traumatize by what happened in the Musical Bureau. She could use all her sassiness to answer in their game. Once. Not to be the obedient wife. That is all I am writing to everyone who is writing to me about it.
She was totally absent minded infront of them. Atleast she bent and bowed. I was afraid she Won't even do that.…
Yes, she was. But she had a month to gather up her thoughts.
Her parents' wishes was to respect her elders. So, yes the trauma talked, but also she missed a chance to confront them in their game. That is what I am saying.
I understand how it looks on the surface, but her silence in Episode 28 isn't a lack of courtesy—it is a moment…
I don't disagree with you in what you are saying to me. We the viewers know about her identity, while they don't.
Still, Jin Qi's mom is a good woman but also very bad in judging people. From the Dus to Man Yi, she made one mistake after another...
Lan Xiang may not have a back up in the Capital any more. But Jinqi is a major player and he has offended a clique. They need to work together to overcome all those things.
I understand how it looks on the surface, but her silence in Episode 28 isn't a lack of courtesy—it is a moment…
They don't know WHY she behaved that way. Only the viewers do. Being stubborn is not a good trait. At times, you need your cleverness to change the game. Hopefully, she will learn to do that.
I know exactly why she did what she did. I agree with you about the trauma and her pride. But she need to level up her game. She doesn't know how to play in their court and she will find out about it when she goes to the Capital.
I am not talking about a "stubborn bride" here. Also, we have two clans who chose different things. The Lin Patriarch chose to abandon his values, flee the capital and save his clan, while the Shen Patriarch chose to live by his values and had his clan annihilated.So, the Lin's saved themselves and didn't say anything to the Shen's because the Zhaos offered them as a scapegoat. That's why in the first episode, when LJQ asked his grandfather to inform them, he answered no.
Her mother's words came back because she saw them for who they are. The dynamics are there. Are they hypocrites? Of course they are. They didn't even said anything about the traitor Duke and his daughter that they wanted to bring to the family.
I understand how it looks on the surface, but her silence in Episode 28 isn't a lack of courtesy—it is a moment…
I know all the things you have written. I watched them as well.
Still, she could answer only once to the Old Master when they offered the soup and not beforehand. It is not about the household etiquette. It is standing on your ground on your own terms and showing them you can play the game too.
Unpopular opinion : I didn't like that Lan Xiang didn't speak at all at the Elders. Basic Courtesy. She can be mad at Lin Jin Qi for what he did. She may be mad for the past at them, but now she is not Shen Jian Lan. She is the Young Madam of the Lin Clan. (Episode 28)
This is valuable. In fact, I think you have nailed it completely.We are products of our time, class, gender, upbringing,…
@grapejuice I am behind on Viki, but the spoilers are everywhere! I hope that LX learns from Ji Er today, who was frantically trying to find her as well...
People were dying because their Master said so. The End.
People were fighting battles and died.
Women were lost while bearing children.
People were dying because they didn't have food or water.
In other places of the world, some women died because they accused them to be witches. All those things happened.
I can agree with you and at the same time disagree with the fact that the scriptwriter chose a poor way for Lan Xiang to stand her ground after that slap to JQ.
Yes, she bowtowed. Yes, she could have stayed silent in the beginning and feel all those things you said above.
At the same time, she could have responded once to the Old Master when they brought the soup to them. She is smart, that is what we have seen in the first of the story, she had a whole month to decide what she could have said to him. Instead she didn't. I continue to believe that it was inconsistent based on the historical times the story is. :-)
Also, both are products of their circumstances. I don't like the analogy the "perfect "Lan Xiang vs Jin Qi who has all the flaws. Every human being is imperfectly perfect.
Lan Xiang has knowledge about being a slave because she was one. I really enjoyed what you have written in another thread about the Shen Patriarch. Lan Xiang doesn't know who they were.
I wrote a comment last night, that I didn't like the fact that she didn't answered back to the Old Master when they visited to pay their respects. She could have responded only once, in order to stand her ground in their house and their game.
I think there are some inconsistencies with the character's development.
Both men did wrong, but historically that was happening back then. Parents decided for your marriage and you coudn't say anything.
Scholar Han knew that Commander Lin had feelings for Lan Xiang. That's why he said half truths after she was saved by Ji Er. Lan Xiang wouldn't accept Lin Qin Ji's proposal because they are in different classes. He doesn't know about her past and how she feels about the Lin family.
The thing is the story is in middle ages. They didn't know anything about trauma back then. Life and death just happened. You were lucky to live well or not...
You are explaining to me, her reaction based on our knowledge of today. And I agree with you. This is our insight today about her life in the past. Yes, she is a survivor. Yes, she is clever, stubborn and has pride. She is also traumatize by what happened in the Musical Bureau. She could use all her sassiness to answer in their game. Once. Not to be the obedient wife. That is all I am writing to everyone who is writing to me about it.
Her parents' wishes was to respect her elders. So, yes the trauma talked, but also she missed a chance to confront them in their game. That is what I am saying.
Still, Jin Qi's mom is a good woman but also very bad in judging people. From the Dus to Man Yi, she made one mistake after another...
Lan Xiang may not have a back up in the Capital any more. But Jinqi is a major player and he has offended a clique. They need to work together to overcome all those things.
I know exactly why she did what she did. I agree with you about the trauma and her pride. But she need to level up her game. She doesn't know how to play in their court and she will find out about it when she goes to the Capital.
Her mother's words came back because she saw them for who they are. The dynamics are there. Are they hypocrites? Of course they are. They didn't even said anything about the traitor Duke and his daughter that they wanted to bring to the family.
Still, she could answer only once to the Old Master when they offered the soup and not beforehand. It is not about the household etiquette. It is standing on your ground on your own terms and showing them you can play the game too.
She is the Young Madam of the Lin Clan. (Episode 28)